Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

11 year old DS already suspended from secondary

82 replies

HistoryT · 29/11/2023 22:55

DS has ADHD diagnosed about a year ago. He takes 15mg of meds but I'm really not convinced they help. It's difficult because he only takes them on school days and while I do think that in the beginning they helped him stick at a piece of work for longer, I think they may also make him feel more agressive. I'm completely torn over whether to continue with them or stop.

He was bullied in his primary school. He annoys other kids, is immature and tries to get a reaction or 'stimulation' from interactions with other kids. He can also be kind, sweet, full of love and very thoughtful.

Secondary school was good for the first few weeks and now he seems to have got a reputation for being annoying and a bit of a clown and other children are dismissing him, saying derogatory things, putting him down etc. And so his behaviour has deteriorated, I think because he feels bad inside and it comes out as ager. He's extremely reactive and picks fights, hurts other kids. He crossed the line this week by head locking a girl and received a serious sanction, then he went on to do the same thing again a couple of days later. I don't know how to help him and scared he will have to leave his school. Current appraoch is to wrap him up in support and show him we're on his side, here to support, but at the same time his actions are so entirely unacceptable. He can't seem to take responsbilty or stop himself but is remorseful - but then he'll say things that show he believes the only way for him to respond is by being physical and showing others he is stronger than them. For context, he's average to small and defintely one of the shorter ones in his year.

What do we do to help him? Tried counselling but he tells them everything is fine and says he doesn't want to talk to anyone (he opens up to us a little bit but is mostly a ball of frustration and anger). He doesn't behave violently at home.

OP posts:
FrippEnos · 30/11/2023 14:22

It is worth remembering that these people that he is using violence against are also children and if he is being annoying to them, they will be being annoying back.

It does amaze me that some of the responses are "bless" and knowing that their responses in a few years time will be 'violent man'.

Underthemagnificentbeechtree · 30/11/2023 13:56

I think it’s worth bearing in mind that for your son to be behaving like this and having negative interactions with peers and teachers, he can’t be having a good time.

I think you may need to lean-in to the idea of medication and trialling different ones to get the right meds and dose. That’s not to say medication is everything, but it really sounds like he is very impaired by his need for stimulation and being disruptive as a consequence.

Underthemagnificentbeechtree · 30/11/2023 13:43

Medikinet & Equasym at both forms of methylphenidate - maybe lisdexamphetamine (Elvanse) would be a better option? The different layering the long release meds have also affects how they work for different people.

My son struggled with Concerta but fine on Equasym - he was only on 10mg for a very short time and had always been on at least 30mg as his stable dose - moving up to 40mg this summer after a growth spurt & drop off in function - he’s now functioning pretty optimally on Elvanse 40mg (also 11 and in Y7).

Naptrappedmummy · 30/11/2023 13:37

Nothankyou22 · 29/11/2023 23:05

Ahh bless him, my sons is year 7 and has autism and even his friends take the piss because he’s not doing well or leaves class to sit in the hub all the time because they know it makes him kick off, he’s finally starting to realise and is falling out with them left right and centre. Thankfully though all the asd kids seem to stick together although sometimes they cause havoc.
It sounds like he needs to channel his energy elsewhere so what do the school have in place for that, as others have suggested a med review could be helpful.

Bless him? He put a girl in a headlock?

FlowerBarrow · 30/11/2023 13:27

@HistoryT were his adhd behaviours better controlled on the 20mg?
It’s totally normal to feel horrible as they wear off. What the clinician will normally do is offer a small top up dose eg 5mg/10mg of immediate release methylphenidate to take the edge off as the main meds run out. His conservative approach could be doing more harm than good.

Naptrappedmummy · 30/11/2023 13:06

That poor girl. She must’ve been so frightened. And poor you.

What are the sanctions at home when this happens? Is his dad around?

Ohtobetwentytwo · 30/11/2023 13:05

With love, the reason you probably dont see the aggression at home is because you all love him and make allowances for him. If he annoys the siblings, you probably give him some attention to distract him and interrupt the escalating behaviour. At school, kids are taught to ignore it and there arent enough staff around to give him the alternative timulation. So he continues until he gets a reaction from them.

If he was escalating to physical behaviour at home, how would you handle it? Can that be carried across to the school?

Anisette · 30/11/2023 13:05

It sounds like a full assessment may be helpful, whether it results in an EHCP or not. Write requesting an EHC needs assessment, pointing out the diagnoses and the effects on your son, and the fact that he is in danger of exclusion.

FallingAutumnLeaf · 30/11/2023 12:59

You need to find a way to stop the outbursts at school. I don't know what the answer is, but it sounds like something different is happening at home than school.

But, as the parent of a child who was put on a head lock and wrestled to the ground, it needs to stop. Both kids are failed in this suitation.

I know it is the ND as the cause, but noone deserves to be physically assaulted, so a system to stop it (figit toys, medication, time outs without question, different school..........) needs to be worked out, and quickly.

FriendOfTimo · 30/11/2023 12:25

HistoryT · 30/11/2023 00:06

I’m just so reluctant about trialling different medications . I know how that sounds but it’s so much to put him through, especially if some make him feel worse.

I totally understand. It’s really difficult to know what to do for the best.

My son went through 3 types before we found one that suited (Elvanse, sadly the most expensive one for the NHS to fund! The US now has a cheaper off brand version so hopefully we will get that soon).

My son is now 23 and is a fantastic young adult but the teenage years were super rough. He couldn’t cope with the transition to high school, spent year 8 at a medical PRU due to depression/anxiety and went into a small private mainstream school in year 9, because it was a tenth of the size of the old high school. He was impulsive and prone to taking dares which got him into minor trouble with the police. I did 6 months of Multisystemic Therapy (NHS funded) to pull him back from that brink.

Finally got an EHCP as he started 6th form 😬

Bit of a depressing story but it really does have a happy outcome, he’s now a pleasant and hardworking young man who is living in a shared house and attending uni, whilst working part time shelf stacking.

being neurodiverse in a neurotypical world is always challenging, but the transition to high school and the changes of puberty make it incredibly intense.

All we can do is help them weather the storm as best we can.

The best intervention we got was occupational therapy - they were invaluable for helping pinpoint particular flashpoints for sensory struggles and develop coping (or avoidance) strategies.

Might sound silly but removing all the red from our home (especially a red rug in my son’s room!) and switching all the lightbulbs to warm tone/lower light made massive improvements.
As did chewy jewellery and letting DS clatter about on his skateboard BEFORE homework, rather than expecting him to do homework first.

If you haven’t seen an OT, please do!

NameChange259 · 30/11/2023 11:59

And see another psychiatrist - one who's more sympathetic.

NameChange259 · 30/11/2023 11:58

HistoryT · 30/11/2023 00:06

I’m just so reluctant about trialling different medications . I know how that sounds but it’s so much to put him through, especially if some make him feel worse.

This is a really good guide - especially to explaining why medication can be beneficial.

3 of us medicated for ADHD in this home - 2 on non-stimulant and 1 on stimulant meds.

the non stimulant has caused no side effects for my son. Has no on or off time - he's 'medicated' all the time. It's effects are subtle but long lasting and over time have really helped his behaviours and anxiety. IT's often preferred as a treatment for people with autism and ADHD. We're both on Atomoxetine.

ADD/ADHD | What Is Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder?

Here’s everything you need to know about Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) in children. Thomas E. Brown, PhD, discusses ADHD diagnosis, ADHD sy...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ouZrZa5pLXk

moggiek · 30/11/2023 09:09

usererror99 · 30/11/2023 05:39

What sanctions do you give him for twice putting a young girl in a headlock?

If he only behaves like this at school and not at home then the obvious answer is he shouldn't be in the school. It's unfair on the children he is being violent to to be subjected to him

This ^^

Goatymum · 30/11/2023 08:42

Agree re meds review, see another GP.

And there’s no such thing as ‘some’ autism / he’s either autistic or not!

bakebeans · 30/11/2023 07:07

How do you deal with his behaviour when he steps out of line? Is his phone confiscated, made to increase house duties, grounded etc?

Unabletomitigate · 30/11/2023 06:58

You mentioned that you were reading books on the topic. Can I recommend the books by Georgia Ede and Chris Palmer, too. These go into how nutrition affects the brain, and mental health.
This is a good into to the topic.

How nutrition affects the brain by Georgia Ede

How do your food choices affect your mental health? *Georgia Ede, a Harvard-trained psychiatrist specializing in nutrition science, brain metabolism, and men...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=URwq7Yzf0mY

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 30/11/2023 06:00

My dd became aggressive on equasym, we took her off them in the end. She would say herself they made her feel angry.......he needs an urgent meds review, in the meantime I'd consider keeping himhome until he's on more of an even keel.......a fresh start elsewhere might be just what he needs.

usererror99 · 30/11/2023 05:39

What sanctions do you give him for twice putting a young girl in a headlock?

If he only behaves like this at school and not at home then the obvious answer is he shouldn't be in the school. It's unfair on the children he is being violent to to be subjected to him

Wokkadema · 30/11/2023 05:10

DreamTheMoors · 30/11/2023 04:09

I’m unfamiliar with autism medications, but not medications as a whole.
I’ve never heard of taking a med 5 days a week - is that a new therapy?
It seems logical that for any med to be effective, a therapeutic amount needs to be in your bloodstream 24/7, so you’d take it 7 days per week.
I think you’re smart to give it a try every day.
I take antidepressants - the problem with those is they take forever to work. And then they don’t, so you try another. And another. And another. It’s frustrating & tiresome.
I hope you have good luck with this one, @HistoryT.

  1. The medications are for ADHD, not autism. There's no medication for autism.
  2. It's common here in Australia for kids to take ADHD medication just on school days. It depends on the specific medication but many of them half a very short half life in the body... by the next morning it literally does not matter if you took it yesterday or not. Lots of reasons not to on weekends but it's mostly about managing side effects. Important to realise that ADHD is not an illness... it's a different neurology that makes it hard to fit into systems designed for people without ADHD. Medication makes it easier to cope in that environment. But at home on the weekend, we don't have to conform.
InattentiveADHD · 30/11/2023 05:02

Mirrormeback · 30/11/2023 03:34

You can not base your DS medication on your own experience

You are different people

You need to give him 2 - 3 months on his new daily regimen to give him a chance as you would with any medication

This.

There are lots of different types of ADHD meds. Which can be given at different doses and sometimes in combination. Your DS is obviously really struggling. And his lack of control is going to get him in lots of trouble and possibly expelled if he is hurting people. So I wouldn't give up on the meds so easily. If your doctor is not supporting you in trialling the right meds then I would try to change the doctor.

Your DS really sounds like my DS has autism and ADHD. He put himself out there constantly but wasn't liked for all the reasons you have given about your DS. And was bullied because of that and because he would react when bullied so became a target. He was also generally struggling in school with all the planning and organisation. So was constantly getting in trouble for his emotional and sometimes violent reactions and for v planning and organisational fails. The stress he (and your son) was under was enormous so everything just kept escalating and spiralling. Imagine a workplace like that for one moment. We would all be off with stress!!! And obviously as he has ADHD he will less be able to cope and process all these negative and difficult emotions.

What helped was calming everything down. He has a time out card so he could leave a lesson at any point he wasn't coping. He could take 5 mins outside or just go to the SEN room which had a calm space. He could go there any time, so could also go in breaks/lunch if needed. He also had a TA (she was a specific ASC TA, we were v lucky but I suspect most schools don't have them), who supported him with his homework. She would make sure his teachers emailed her with his homework so she could keep a track with him and support him in knowing what he needed to do and when. He also had two "SEN periods" when he met with his TA and complete his homework in school (as that was a major stress for him out of school as couldn't understand why he had to do schoolwork out of school). These periods were another opportunity for a break from the overstimulation of school and the other children.

He has issues with his handwriting which is another barrier that he didn't need the stress of so he was given a keyboard to use in class.

He also attended social skills groups and counselling both in and out of school (just to say about the counselling - my DS found it very helpful as he lives to talk without filter, but he is very prone to forget things and be "in the moment" eg he used to come home from school saying he had a good day and everything was great and then 2 hours later he'd be in floods of tears about a horrible incident that happened at school - if that s applies to your DS reminding him
If things he might want to talk about might be helpful?). My DS found it so helpful to be able to talk through some of his difficult emotions around the bullying.

On top of that the school should be clamping down on any bullying. I would be pushing hard for that. At my DS's school there were lots of instances of my DS being antagonised and wound up until he blew at which point he would get into trouble. It's important to push to ensure that the ones doing the antagonising are also dealt with.

With all of that in place things quickly began to improve, and by year 9 he had a good group of friends and was doing well. He was happier and calmer. I think it's a case of lots of small things to calm things down overall. Each thing may only have a limited benefit but overall they have a bigger impact.

MollyButton · 30/11/2023 04:43

Does he have a EHCP? Is it adequate for his needs?

Skyisbluegrassisgreen · 30/11/2023 04:40

Have you considered that school may not be the right place for him? Have you thought about home educating?

JennyJenny8675309 · 30/11/2023 04:36

When my son was growing up he took ADHD medication. I once discovered a pile of discarded pills he’d been hiding when he was supposed to take them each morning. Make sure he’s actually taking them.

bipbopdo · 30/11/2023 04:35

DreamTheMoors · 30/11/2023 04:09

I’m unfamiliar with autism medications, but not medications as a whole.
I’ve never heard of taking a med 5 days a week - is that a new therapy?
It seems logical that for any med to be effective, a therapeutic amount needs to be in your bloodstream 24/7, so you’d take it 7 days per week.
I think you’re smart to give it a try every day.
I take antidepressants - the problem with those is they take forever to work. And then they don’t, so you try another. And another. And another. It’s frustrating & tiresome.
I hope you have good luck with this one, @HistoryT.

It depends on the medication. With ADHD meds, some are meant to accumulate in your system over time (often non-stimulants) and some are metabolised quickly and clear your system (often stimulants).

This obviously depends on the person, their metabolism and the suitability of the medication for them. Some people have to work with their doctors to find the best dosage pattern for them, but that’s very difficult with children unfortunately

flowerchild2000 · 30/11/2023 04:26

You sound like a very caring, attentive parent, so that's good. You just have to keep advocating for him with his medical professionals. He needs more specific therapy based on his diagnosis. He might need another diagnosis too. His medication needs to be changed for sure. I'm sure he's not responding well to his adult support system because it's his peers he's trying to connect with. That's his world, adults are just peripherals. Keep asking for more help from his doctor and keep doing your own research too. It takes a lot of work sometimes just to get what seems like basic care, unfortunately. I'm drowning in it myself at the moment. I do hope it gets easier for your DS, it does sound like he's trying very hard and just doesn't know what to do. Poor dear! I hope it gets easier for you as well!🌷