Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Nihal Arthanayake is being ridiculous

206 replies

Sausagenbacon · 29/11/2023 21:32

He lives in a country where the majority of the population is white, but says it has mental health problems from a workplace which is mainly, yes, white. However does he deal with everyday life?
https://www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/bbc-diveristy-nihal-arthanayake-radio-5-journalism-diversity-fund-b1123658.html

BBC workplace 'overwhelmingly white', presenter Nihal Arthanayake says

'It's really affecting me that I walk in and all I see is white people,' the Radio 5 presenter told a diversity conference

https://www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/bbc-diveristy-nihal-arthanayake-radio-5-journalism-diversity-fund-b1123658.html

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CurlewKate · 04/12/2023 01:24

@missmollygreen " Reverse the qoute
"It really affects me that I walk in and all I see is black people"

You don't see a problem with that?"

If the person saying it was white in a majority black country with a history of discrimination against white people, then no, I wouldn't see a problem.

AdamRyan · 03/12/2023 20:20

Don't be ridiculous molly
This is a predominantly white country, white people have never been oppressed by black people, it makes absolutely no sense to "reverse the quote".

I did however link upthread to an article about male teachers, where they were saying similar things about being in a minority but noone commented

missmollygreen · 03/12/2023 19:00

Redundantrobin · 30/11/2023 09:21

Really? In what way is he racist towards white people?

I understand where he’s coming from. POC are underrepresented across editorial roles in the media.

Reverse the qoute
"It really affects me that I walk in and all I see is black people"

You don't see a problem with that?

CharlotteRumpling · 03/12/2023 18:52

I just can't be bothered to report lately because there have been so many racist posts on every thread.

HomiesAlone · 03/12/2023 18:40

To be fair @CharlotteRumpling MN removed the 2 Islamophobic posts I reported on this thread. Racism is rife once you open your eyes sadly.

The nonsense about black and brown people taking jobs is miseducation, willful ignorance, racism and fear all muddled up together with a big old dollop of arrogance.

CharlotteRumpling · 03/12/2023 18:15

MN is just one big racist jamboree these days, isn't it? While the mods ignore it all.

Companies gagging to employ brown and black people, my brown arse! The data doesn't support that conclusion.

kirbykirby · 03/12/2023 17:57

CurlewKate · 02/12/2023 08:40

@RosaGallica "
On cultural matters I was born into a country with a completely different culture to that in practice now, one that was aiming towards meritocracy, inclusivity, equality and democracy: one which practised the values of free speech and free flow of information."

When was that? Because I am quite old, and I do not recognise that characterisation of Britain at all. The country I grew up in had a rigid class structure and an education system that reinforced it. Open discrimination against women and minorities, unequal pay structures, freedom to use abusive and offensive language and no mechanism to question authority or to speak truth to power.

I don't recognise your characterisation of Britain either and I agree with @RosaGallica regarding how the country has changed.

CharlotteRumpling · 03/12/2023 17:40

Good to know that this is what some people think of brown or black people in the workplace.

PoC regularly outperform white people in schools and unis on academic performance, but of course they are hired because of PC gone mad and " inconvenient truths". My DH is a brown immigrant with 2 degrees from one of the most difficult to crack unis in the world. He works with people who have passed their A levels..Probably because he has a long and "funny" name, not unlike Nihal.

MN never ceases to surprise me these days, but as I said, good to know.

MasterBeth · 03/12/2023 17:39

TizerorFizz · 03/12/2023 17:25

Why would they always be hired? Employers don’t just look at qualifications so they?

I don't think they are. It was a claim in a previous post which I quoted and you replied to. I thought it was a stupid and substantially racist claim.

TizerorFizz · 03/12/2023 17:25

Why would they always be hired? Employers don’t just look at qualifications so they?

MasterBeth · 03/12/2023 17:02

TizerorFizz · 03/12/2023 15:08

@MasterBeth How do
you, by the same token, know black
peoole had to be more qualified if you don’t know what the qualification is? Who has made this judgement? For talent it’s a portfolio of work. For other jobs it’s not purely degree obtained. It’s lots of things that go into a person spec. Not just a measurable qualification or you would just have firsts from Oxbridge at the BBC. These days you don’t.

It’s also interesting to me that people live here but then complain about us being a majority. How would white person get on saying that in Dubai? Or Pakistan? Surely you accept a country for its ethos and history? We have been wonderfully liberal here and have benefitted from it but listening to privileged people (latest reported earnings circa £160,000 from the bbc) insulting colleagues is a bit rich.

There has been lots of research into this over many years. Here is some:

https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0038038520966947

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5a7f81c6ed915d74e33f6dc4/race-in-workplace-mcgregor-smith-review.pdf

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/17/minority-ethnic-britons-face-shocking-job-discrimination

I know of no research which substantiates the claim that, at the BBC and in the City, where candiadates have the same qualifications, the black or ethnic monority candiadte is always hired. Do you?

Minority ethnic Britons face 'shocking' job discrimination

Exclusive: research finds levels of discrimination unchanged since late 1960s

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/17/minority-ethnic-britons-face-shocking-job-discrimination

AdamRyan · 03/12/2023 15:40

He didn't insult his colleagues.
The fact you and others percieve what he reported as an insult is giving me a very good insight into "white fragility" (I am white).

TizerorFizz · 03/12/2023 15:08

@MasterBeth How do
you, by the same token, know black
peoole had to be more qualified if you don’t know what the qualification is? Who has made this judgement? For talent it’s a portfolio of work. For other jobs it’s not purely degree obtained. It’s lots of things that go into a person spec. Not just a measurable qualification or you would just have firsts from Oxbridge at the BBC. These days you don’t.

It’s also interesting to me that people live here but then complain about us being a majority. How would white person get on saying that in Dubai? Or Pakistan? Surely you accept a country for its ethos and history? We have been wonderfully liberal here and have benefitted from it but listening to privileged people (latest reported earnings circa £160,000 from the bbc) insulting colleagues is a bit rich.

MasterBeth · 03/12/2023 12:14

If there is an equally qualified white and black candidate, especially somewhere in the city, or the BBC, the white person will lose out every time. Inconvenient truth, but truth all the same.

Let's assume this is true. It would actually be an improvement in equality to the historic position where people of colour had to be better qualified than white people to be considered for jobs.

But it's not true. I can't be true, if you think about it for more than a second or two. How would you know? How do you determine "equally qualified"? Are you present at every interview in the city and the BBC to see it happen? How is this policy enacted?

It's a lazy racist stereotype. "You can't even employ white people these days." "There are people of colour on all the TV ads."

Halfemptyhalfling · 03/12/2023 10:48

If all his friends and family and neighbourhood have south Asian heritage working at the BBC will be a shock to the system. The same as black and Asian students who go to university outside the big cities. In the same way those with British heritage can have a shock visiting the big cities and see so few people who look like them.

The BBC are hiring more ethnic groups just adapting to future demographics as the proportion of white British heritage will shrink further as having fewer or no children as can't afford them due to voting in Conservative government who have cut state support. Also white British heritage are more likely to be atheists who have fewer children and less community support (to make up for reduced state support) as don't have social support from religious groups.

As the cities become unaffordable for people without family living there it will become harder for those with white British heritage to access careers in top institutions. But it was the white British who voted in thatcher and praised the right to buy scheme which has made the cities unaffordable to children and grandchildren.

CurlewKate · 03/12/2023 10:12

@DojaPhat I'm waiting for "all lives matter".....

DojaPhat · 03/12/2023 00:19

This thread in a different format would be a fantastic illustration on 'post-race' racism in 2023 and beyond. I wonder if anyone's mentioned they went to the BLM marches but it's all become a bit too much now.

DojaPhat · 03/12/2023 00:15

WomensRightsRenegade · 02/12/2023 20:44

Racial essentialism is so depressing. Where do we go as a society if we all silo off into identity/ colour groups? With the belief that we’re all like different species, in that someone can only be like you, relate to you, if they have the same skin tone?

Seriously depressing. We used to focus on people’s characters and personalities before CRT and identity politics.

Of course no one sensible would deny that racism exists. But as per Heather MacDonald’s latest book, most companies are gagging to employ poc for their diversity quotas. If there is an equally qualified white and black candidate, especially somewhere in the city, or the BBC, the white person will lose out every time. Inconvenient truth, but truth all the same. In the West End nearly every major show has a black star (MASSIVE over-representation), and no one complains about lack of diversity. Same as football and athletics, I guess. It’s all so incoherent.

Classism is the true barrier these days.

Where do you even start with this post!? I really really feel particularly for young PoC because the people that will really have a hand in shaping the course of their lives really do think believe the bile in this post and consider themselves to be 'post race' too. It's staggeringly terrifying.

ilovesooty · 02/12/2023 22:21

This reply has been deleted

We decided to take this down as it is not in the spirit of the site.

I think that's a personal attack on other posters who don't share your point of view.

CurlewKate · 02/12/2023 22:15

Did someone actually say "race card"?🤣🤣🤣

Geeeeeeeeee · 02/12/2023 21:48

This reply has been deleted

We decided to take this down as it is not in the spirit of the site.

C8H10N4O2 · 02/12/2023 20:45

AdamRyan · 02/12/2023 20:11

Also I suggest you read the article because Nihal was not complaining about his colleagues.

Factual accuracy isn't a priority when jumping in to accuse minorities or women of not sufficiently tugging the forlock. We should all bow down to those hard done by UC/MC white men who are are forced to run every major organisation.

WomensRightsRenegade · 02/12/2023 20:44

Racial essentialism is so depressing. Where do we go as a society if we all silo off into identity/ colour groups? With the belief that we’re all like different species, in that someone can only be like you, relate to you, if they have the same skin tone?

Seriously depressing. We used to focus on people’s characters and personalities before CRT and identity politics.

Of course no one sensible would deny that racism exists. But as per Heather MacDonald’s latest book, most companies are gagging to employ poc for their diversity quotas. If there is an equally qualified white and black candidate, especially somewhere in the city, or the BBC, the white person will lose out every time. Inconvenient truth, but truth all the same. In the West End nearly every major show has a black star (MASSIVE over-representation), and no one complains about lack of diversity. Same as football and athletics, I guess. It’s all so incoherent.

Classism is the true barrier these days.

AdamRyan · 02/12/2023 20:14

Here's what the BBC have said in response:

Events like this one are instrumental in bringing new talent in as we work towards making our organisation as inclusive as possible.

“We want everyone who works at the BBC – and those considering a career with us – to know we are focused on creating an inclusive culture where everyone feels they belong.

“We believe we should be setting the highest standards on diversity and we recognise that there is still more we could do, therefore we have clear plans in place to improve the diversity of our workforce.”

Doesn't sound like they have any beef at all with him being at the conference or what he said.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/11/30/bbc-diversity-admission-nihal-arthanayake/

BBC admits it could do more to improve its diversity

Comments follow presenter Nihal Arthanayake’s claims that number of white colleagues has affected his mental health

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/11/30/bbc-diversity-admission-nihal-arthanayake

AdamRyan · 02/12/2023 20:11

Also I suggest you read the article because Nihal was not complaining about his colleagues.

Swipe left for the next trending thread