Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if we are all equal in Heaven

112 replies

Guesswho88 · 29/11/2023 21:15

I was thinking about those that have never found love or who have loved and lost. And those that have lost a spouse who has passed away but have gone on to remarry - what happens when the person who has remarried dies and is reunited with former spouse? And then the other spouse dies as well. How does it go down?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Anonymouseposter · 30/11/2023 09:30

It’s a question no one can answer. Some people don’t believe there’s anything after death at all, some people believe there might be. No one has any idea what form an after life might take. Your idea of heaven is very concrete and you seem to think we will retain the same personality as on earth. It’s quite a childlike way of seeing things. Who knows?

Shortpoet · 30/11/2023 09:28

If you want an interesting read, try Journey of Souls by Michael Newton.

He was a hypnotist who didn’t believe in afterlife, but had a client go back to before they were born under hypnosis and started investigating the concept of before life with clients and documenting what his clients said.

Not sure how much I believe, but I found it very comforting when dealing with grief.

He says we reincarnate with the same souls over and over, so one lifetime you will be partners, another friends, or siblings etc. It depends on what you’ve come to learn in this life together, so you will have many lifetimes to learn.

Cubic · 30/11/2023 09:24

Should read; if we have souls who created them...

SleepingStandingUp · 30/11/2023 09:23

Testina · 29/11/2023 21:32

It’s just that if you believe in NDE’s doesn’t it cancel your belief in heaven - cos none of the NDE’s have any info.

Not necessarily. Nde's are necessarily very short experiences. Nothing to say the second you pass you wake up in heaven. Of it's a transformation of energy then that could take time. People refer to seeing lights etc. maybe if you make it as far as Heaven you've gone too completely to come back, but there's a temporal space between your heart stopping and the gates opening

Cubic · 30/11/2023 09:23

I wish I was religious and had faith but I'm just not.

When my dad died, the circumstances were really bad and then the circumstances that followed were horrific to deal with (fraud, theft, use of his bank cards by someone he trusted within an hour of him going to the funeral home). I had vivid nightmares of him just being in nothing, complete dark. I hope that is just my mind.

I struggle with questions like If we have souls creates them and how does it cope with an increased population if the souls go somewhere after we die or get reused, how are there enough?

Our physical bodies do hold energy which gets reused when we degrade or cremated but what happens to that bit which makes us unique?

jemenfous37 · 30/11/2023 09:12

I find it so odd that they say there is nothing, blackness... and they are ok with that!

But you won't know it's 'blackness'; you are dead. You cannot know if it is blackness or all white and shiny because there is no cognition when you are dead.
When you are dead, you are dead. deceased. Unable to cogitate. No need to worry about bumping into your ex, or the MIL you hated. You are dead.
No need to worry about mowing the lawn, getting on with the neighbours or wondering whether or not to LTB. Because you are dead.

Ploctopus · 30/11/2023 08:35

There isn’t an objective answer to this. Nobody knows. Different religions have different conceptions of the afterlife, and of course atheists tend not to believe in one at all. You can read about different concepts of the afterlife and see if any of them resonate with you, but ultimately there’s simply no way of knowing in any real sense.

MustBeNapTime · 30/11/2023 08:32

RandomButtons · 29/11/2023 23:04

I’m a Christian and this is pretty much closest to my beliefs.

We won’t have earthly bodies or earthly desires, we will be spiritual beings and as the bible says “there will be no marriage”

Also that whole the first will be last and the last will be first thing. So I expect the rich arrogant lot who make it will be in lesser positions, and those who’ve had shit lives and been at the bottom of the pile will be given greater blessing or whatever that looks like.

Genuinely curious... What about those people who worked really hard and became rich but were good, non-arrogant people or those that were poor and had shit lives because they were lazy and couldn't be bothered to try and better themselves? Or those somewhere in the middle...? How would that work? Or is it just about the money, rich, get a shit afterlife, poor, get a good afterlife, in the middle, squeezed in the afterlife so samesame? Seems a bit callous.

That's why this vision of heaven doesn't work for me.

BlackeyedSusan · 30/11/2023 08:16

Depends on your beliefs I suppose.

Calamitousness · 30/11/2023 08:12

Whatever you want it to be. It’s a fantasy and not based in any reality. Which I am sure you know but perhaps find the idea appealing in some way. So make it what you want. It’s your own dream.

KimberleyClark · 30/11/2023 08:09

The priest at my MIL’s funeral said that at the moment of your death you become the best person you could possibly be. So yes, if there is a heaven I can imagine earthly stuff becomes irrelevant,but I would still hope to recognise my DH and other loved ones.

SamphireAndSalmon · 30/11/2023 08:08

Dita73 · 29/11/2023 21:16

Nothing happens. They’re dead

🤣

crunchypeanutbutterontoast · 30/11/2023 08:07

In olden times believing in heaven and hell meant ‘consequences’ to how you behaved in life. The church was very powerful - it seems like it would have been a way to control society ‘put the fear of god’ into people. But now we have laws and police! I’m not sure what I believe regarding the afterlife - but heaven and hell are surely man made concepts.

AhhSilence · 30/11/2023 07:44

If you believe in Christian theology, death dissolves the marriage and there is no marriage in heaven anyway.

I'd like to think I'll see dead loved ones again but I suspect once we die, the electrical circuits fade, that's it for consciousness.

Hypothetically, if there is a heaven, I'd like to think we're all equal, though do some people who have been truly evil in life deserve that?

I guess I'll either find out or not (if death is lights out).

Funny, I had no real issue with the concept of heaven when I was Christian. Maybe because I didn't have to think about it too hard. Once someone very close to me died, I realised I don't know what I believe and lost my faith. In some ways it feels like it's still there, I just can't connect with it the same way.

pictoosh · 30/11/2023 06:14

I only believe in Mumsnet Heaven. When you get there your mil is waiting to greet you as your eternal maid and she has to seek your permission to have any sort of relationship with her son.

Why not? It's just as likely as some of these daft scenarios.

sixteenfurryfeet · 30/11/2023 00:04

Guesswho88 · 29/11/2023 21:40

But they still died and came back. What did your dad say? Understandable if you would rather not say. I understand it's very personal.

They didn't die, they almost died.

Sorry, no I'm not going to talk about my dad.

Ohmylovejune · 29/11/2023 23:59

I should add that my brother was in ICU in an induced coma with sepsis when he was looking at a camp fire with dead relatives sat around it and they told him it wasn't time to join them. He believes it was his brain dreaming or hallucinating rather than the other world but he's still a sick guy and chooses to use the experience as a comfort.

Tourmalines · 29/11/2023 23:57

I would say more we are all equal in death .

Ohmylovejune · 29/11/2023 23:54

I don't believe we go anywhere but, like a good book, I sometimes think about "what if".

Such as, if we do go somewhere do we live there forever? What happens with the illnesses we took with us? If our partners join us, how on earth would we ever find them? Do we eat, if so, what and where does it come from?

It does seem such a waste of a special soul for it to just end. It must be of some comfort to truly believe there's a heaven.

SwordToFlamethrower · 29/11/2023 23:48

Heaven for me used to be 3am on the dance floor of gatecrasher 1998-9 but if I were perpetually stuck there forever, it would become hell.

I think maybe if we have souls, we just become pure beings who float among the stars, bumping into other pure souls until we hear a calling to be reborn on earth or wherever.

It's a nice fantasy but I doubt that's true either!

Treaclesandwich · 29/11/2023 23:33

No one can answer this question, unless St Peter is a Mumsnet member.

That said, your question is, in my view, perfunctory, as there is no heaven.

Draoicht · 29/11/2023 23:18

Guesswho88 · 29/11/2023 21:34

Wait, whaaaat?? There are literally testimonies all over the internet, books etc.. of people dying for a few minutes and going to what they consider heaven.

Just for interest sake, do you vote?

MasterBeth · 29/11/2023 23:16

Blazingunicorns · 29/11/2023 21:20

You go back to being a soul and all human aspects of ourselves fall away. So the dynamics of marriage (which is a man made construct) are irrelevant.

You go back to being worm food and all human aspects of ourselves fall away. So the tall tales of religion (which is a man-made construct) are irrelevant.

Wherearemykeysagain · 29/11/2023 23:10

The Christian view is that once there is a new heaven and a new earth we will all be single. This is because (good!) marriage points to the love, joy and being known that is fully realised in relationship with God. In other words we will all be more blissfully happy than those who are married to the love of their life now.