Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Wonder Why Women put up with this?

145 replies

girlfriend44 · 29/11/2023 21:03

Reading a post on a thread about Christmas from the past on tinternet.
Someone had said the men went to the pub Xmas day and the women cooked the dinner. The men came home and ate the dinner and fell asleep.
The post had quite a few likes.
Does anyone else think that's wrong and the woman shouldn't have allowed it?
Why didn't the women go down the pub and the men cook etc?
Better still Why didn't they all make dinner together nd obody went to the pub?

Why do people have to go to the pub Xmas day anyway while dinners cooking?

Should women have made more of a stand and not allowed this?
Does this still happen today?

I think it's really rude to go down the pub Xmas day and leave people at home doing everything?

OP posts:
Davros · 01/12/2023 10:14

I'm 63 and this apparently used to happen, I'd heard of it. Not in my family though. My mum used to get pissed and my Dad, me and my sisters had to rescue the lunch

milveycrohn · 01/12/2023 10:10

My DM did not want anyone else in the kitchen, when I was groing up.
However, neither my DF, DBs or I went to the pub.
Instead we always went to church where we regularly attended and where my DF sang in the choir.

desperatemum24 · 01/12/2023 10:09

Definitely was a thing up north

I have a friend who in-laws still do this. She went to the pub with the men!

muchalover · 01/12/2023 10:07

My dad didn't but he rarely drank and my mum was his whole world.

My exH didn't, he went to the gym instead. We had 4 children.

There is little choice involved when your husband decides this is what they want to do. The children having a lovely Christmas becomes your priority so you don't challenge or your partner will make everyone's day awful.

thebabessavedme · 01/12/2023 10:02

Its quite an interesting topic, I was born early 60s to a large London based family, at that time no one was rich or even well off, the houses were all small victorian terraces, I well remember the men going off to pub for a hour or so, it made room for a meal to be prepared and us kids to play. Even in those days women were very busy and didn't see each other a great deal so getting together was fun, I remember the howls of laughter coming from the the poky kitchens, a long table being set up in the living room, planks and cushions over chairs so everyone had a seat.
The men were merry, never drunk, we had a riotous meal, lots of fun and laughter. Afterwards I strongly remember the men doing the clearing up, all of it. In the evening there would be dancing in the tiny living room. All us kids and women slept in beds, the men were chucked blankets and slept in chairs etc.

Then we all became better off, the houses became bigger, the need for space was not so critical, the men had no need to go to pub. They stayed home and showed off their new cocktail cabinets and stereograms, still great fun.

Now, me and my christmas mad son in law do all the cooking, the houses are large, the gadgets better and take no where need the amount of time it used to take to cook the lunch, we also eat a lot later in the day. WE ALL go to the pub! Grin

Life evolves.

Lostthewilltolive1970 · 01/12/2023 09:21

Why are people so both obsessed with what other people do. What works in one house, won't work in the next house. Live and let live and let people do what the hell they want.

xILikeJamx · 30/11/2023 17:02

The past is the past. Fortunately many things are different now.

I was born in the mid-80s and remember where my uncle lived in Scotland the pub would open from 12-2.30 on Christmas Day - must have been early/mid 90s. The men and kids would go down for an hour or so. I used to like it as I felt like I was being let in to some kind of secret society! 🤓

tolerable · 30/11/2023 16:52

@SwordToFlamethrower .are you calling me an illiterate man? I'm neither.
I think the op post showed an incredible lack of insight yet screamed of condemnation. For no real purpose Highlighting one random (loose)tradition which was non compulsary and subject to personal choice is ridiculous.
As is assuming it was wrong.The notion Woman shouldnt have allowed it is,pretty funny. "made more of a stand" .
I NEVER said "females"were wrong. the suggestion iwas making was -what a load of bollocks.actually

Giggorata · 30/11/2023 16:42

I cook Xmas dinner and dress the table when DH goes to the pub, but he has done all the prep beforehand.
I find the timing easier if I'm on my own in the kitchen, especially when we have family, plus he takes them away for a bit.
He/they do all the washing up and clearing afterwards, too.
I think I get best deal, actually.
I get all the praise for the meal, as I sink gracefully into an armchair and accept a glass of cava.

tolerable · 30/11/2023 16:35

No @SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius I wouldnt. Its a free-for-all forum. My limited grammatical capabilities and your lack of ability to scroll past if you didnt really understand are not a joining prequisite. For the record - there is nothing quite as repulsive as attempting to condescend when you have clearly no grasp of "inclusion" or manners.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 30/11/2023 15:14

tolerable · 29/11/2023 22:55

Actually.? THATS the knowledge you have gained -EVER.?to critiscise and condemn?
how much research you do into the way things were -then.
Drunkish men,do dishes-ANYBODY can fling a dinner together.-would be the easiest road out.
DOES ANYONE else think twas wrong /woman shouldnt have allowed it?
where ya going with that. ? You doing females no favours in suggesting libertys was taken.or joint forces were likely to create a voice.It wasnt enforced.
Also not flattering is presumption this is outrageous.OR that men are\were incapable of independant thoughts and decisions.

Do you want to try that again, @tolerable - only this time with punctuation, proper grammar, and comprehensible sentences.

Aaron95 · 30/11/2023 09:33

dottypotter · 29/11/2023 21:15

You can drink at home if you want, so why do people need to bugger off down the pub?

Difficult to socialise and talk to other people if you stay at home.

Gt86 · 30/11/2023 09:01

One year, my mother and auntie decided to take my grandmother to the pub and left the men in charge of the cooking.

They weren't overly impressed to come back to find the men pissed and trying to barbecue the Christmas Dinner.

SwordToFlamethrower · 30/11/2023 09:00

tolerable · 29/11/2023 22:55

Actually.? THATS the knowledge you have gained -EVER.?to critiscise and condemn?
how much research you do into the way things were -then.
Drunkish men,do dishes-ANYBODY can fling a dinner together.-would be the easiest road out.
DOES ANYONE else think twas wrong /woman shouldnt have allowed it?
where ya going with that. ? You doing females no favours in suggesting libertys was taken.or joint forces were likely to create a voice.It wasnt enforced.
Also not flattering is presumption this is outrageous.OR that men are\were incapable of independant thoughts and decisions.

Here comes the illiterate man to tell "females" are wrong on a forum made predominantly for women

SwordToFlamethrower · 30/11/2023 08:53

Getting the men away from under the women's feet might have been a blessing.

As it happened this was why the men would go to the pub and leave my mum at home with us little kids.

Trouble is they came home drunk and kicked off. Unhappy childhood memories

Valeriekat · 30/11/2023 08:16

Great to get the men out of our way while we have girl time in the kitchen. The guys clear up which is a much bigger and less fun job!

ImustLearn2Cook · 30/11/2023 06:48

Oh forgot to mention that she often looked after her many grandchildren too.

ImustLearn2Cook · 30/11/2023 06:47

@58HappilyRetired women didn’t have it any easier back then either. FWIW my Nana (if alive today would be 100 plus years) worked (employed then ran her own business), looked after 6 kids and looked after her husband (my Pa) who barely survived WW2. She worked bloody hard like many women did from her era.

58HappilyRetired · 30/11/2023 06:16

One grandfather a fisherman out of Yorkshire, the other a miner in Durham. No idea if they went to the pub on Christmas, but just ask yourself if you would like to go out to sea today in a 20 foot boat or down a mine for a long shift. Life wasn't easy for those men.

Lurkingandlearning · 30/11/2023 06:13

The pubs that are open on Christmas Day are open because there’s a demand- the staff are unlikely to want to be there.

Coffeesnob11 · 30/11/2023 06:05

It didn't happen in our household but I know plenty of others where it did. Some were sent off by the women as they would keep asking when lunch would be ready, come in to the kitchen to graze and those women wanted the kitchen to themselves. I think we are also forgetting that way back women weren't allowed in pubs so I can imagine they were expected to stay and cook and look after the children.
My dad was born in 1931 and he was certainly very good with cooking, sharing chores, childcare with me etc.
I am always still amazed at the number of people who don't offer to wash up after someone has cooked for them (friends or family amd not juat christmas) . I am cooking this year and I know that after dinner a couple will be washing up the non dishwasher bits before anyone does anything else.

Elastica23 · 30/11/2023 06:02

No-one went to the pub when I was little, but they were all on the sherry/ginger wine and whisky from early doors, including those helping in the kitchen. This was my grandma, grandad, great aunt & uncle, my mum and dad, most of whom pretty much only had a drink at Christmas! Everyone helped peeling veg and washing up. They really were very Merry Christmases!

I do it this way, everyone mucking in, though I only have a drink when nearly everything is done or it may go awry! My DM (who still hardly drinks) is 84 and is still wanting whisky & ginger wine at 9.30am 😂

GreyhpundGirl · 30/11/2023 06:01

It didn't happen when I was growing up, my parents didn't go to the pub and both did dinner. My husband does all the cooking and we all go to our local for a couple of hours.

MrsTerryPratchett · 30/11/2023 05:52

Have you heard of the patriarchy

Exactly. It's like a post from an alien. or a journalist. And blaming women for men being lazy, drunk plonkers is a stretch.

BarbaraofSeville · 30/11/2023 05:48

For all we know the women told their husbands to bugger off down to the pub so that they can enjoy each other’s company while they cooked. And maybe they actually enjoyed cooking and didn’t want any interference

There certainly could be an element of this. DPs family had this tradition when his grandparents were alive. Family gathered at grandparents house, the men and older boys went to the pub. DC played with their presents, watched TV and ate as much chocolate as they could get away with. Women cooked at a leisurely pace, had a laugh and a few drinks and if the men were lucky, the dinner would actually be ready and not burnt when they came back. Afterwards, the men washed up.