Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask about civil service working hours and progression?

41 replies

notsallyrooney · 29/11/2023 21:00

Thinking about a CS job at SEO level - don’t want to say much as outing but wonder if any civil servants can help me with the following:

  • What is a “full time” contract? I’ve seen “42 hours including lunch breaks” but that’s not helping me as I don’t know how long a lunch break?! Current employer full time = 36.5hrs (not including lunches)
  • How do you move up within the band? So SEO starts at about 37k which is maybe 2k more than my current salary (where I’m at the top of my grade and have a progression point and am now stuck forever 😂 as I work in HE where nobody ever leaves!)

I’m just not sure if the switch is worth it at the moment if I won’t be able to move up (more than whatever the yearly % rise is?) Especially when I consider the fact that my annual leave is currently 43 days and would go down to 34 days (25+bank hol+kings birthday). I know I could balance out the drop in leave by taking parental leave and potentially buying some more, but both of those options would mean I wouldn’t really be earning any extra in the CS job which I had hoped to do..

Any advice much appreciated. Sorry for posting in aibu for traffic!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Foreverundecided · 26/01/2024 09:32

@Tellmemore16 sorry to hijack this thread but I was wondering if Scotland they are enforcing the 60 percent mandate?
Ive been offered a role however was offered the role just prior to that mandate and believe it'd be two days in the office

Also have a job offer private sector which geniuely is working from home 4 days a week so it's a big factor

TooManyCats88 · 30/11/2023 11:24

notsallyrooney · 29/11/2023 22:15

Current employer contribution is 21% which isn’t quite as good as that but also not so much worse.. seems to me like I would not really be better off by making the move. (And could be a lot of stress for barely any more money!)

Don't compare percentage employer contributions as it has no bearing on the amount of pension you'll receive. CS pension is a career average pension where you receive a certain amount for each year you contribute, part of which can be given up for a lump sum. That's what you need to compare.

As for the other T&Cs it very much depends, the CS is varied and there are many jobs that bear no resemblance to any sort of stereotypical 'civil servant' roles.

But if you'd receive minimal pay rise for a lot fewer holidays, it doesn't seem worth the move right now.

notsallyrooney · 30/11/2023 11:15

tonybennscat · 30/11/2023 11:03

@notsallyrooney I retired!

Ahh, living the dream - enjoy your massive CS pension 😁

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 30/11/2023 11:07

Others have answered but - the contract assumes 1 hour lunch breaks. There’s some reason it has to be phrased like that.

You can’t move up in the bands. Not in any dept I know of. The bands are there to allow for people moving from other departments that pay more (so you don’t lose salary) or for people who’ve been there for ages since a time when you could move ip

tonybennscat · 30/11/2023 11:03

@notsallyrooney I retired!

Haveyouseenthemuffinman · 30/11/2023 08:24

@tonybennscat the implementation of the Sadat pay differs between departments too; we have four bands but only a few DDAT roles are currently covered by the process.

notsallyrooney · 29/11/2023 23:14

tonybennscat · 29/11/2023 23:10

I’ve actually just left but yes, I think it does make a difference

Within each grade eg SEO, on the DDAT pay framework there are 3 levels and three bands within each. You will initially be graded as either Developing, Advanced or Proficient, and each one adds a flat amount to your base pay.

Each job role, eg Business Analyst or Data Engineer will have a long list of skills and you are graded against each annually. Hopefully you will go up at least a step each year. So by the time I left I was at the top of the SEO scale.
There’s potentially also a non pensionable retention allowance.

Oh thank you, this is really interesting. Maybe still worth considering then. (Might not even get the job!!!)

Have you gone to private sector now? Is that a CS red flag I should be bearing in mind?!

OP posts:
tonybennscat · 29/11/2023 23:10

I’ve actually just left but yes, I think it does make a difference

Within each grade eg SEO, on the DDAT pay framework there are 3 levels and three bands within each. You will initially be graded as either Developing, Advanced or Proficient, and each one adds a flat amount to your base pay.

Each job role, eg Business Analyst or Data Engineer will have a long list of skills and you are graded against each annually. Hopefully you will go up at least a step each year. So by the time I left I was at the top of the SEO scale.
There’s potentially also a non pensionable retention allowance.

notsallyrooney · 29/11/2023 22:35

tonybennscat · 29/11/2023 22:23

Rising through pay range can depend on role - eg DDAT scale which has proficiency based uplifts reviewed every year or so - and I went in halfway up the scale.

Edited

Oh here I was completely discounting it - it is a DD&T role within a gov department. Does that make a difference then?

OP posts:
tonybennscat · 29/11/2023 22:23

Rising through pay range can depend on role - eg DDAT scale which has proficiency based uplifts reviewed every year or so - and I went in halfway up the scale.

MereDintofPandiculation · 29/11/2023 22:20

I don't know why they still advertise it as a range because it is misleading, unless someone was already on the higher band when they removed the increments. Possibly because you can argue your way into being appointed at above the minimum?

Which is why, originally, they sought to reduce the pay ranges - men tend to be more assertive in arguing a higher starting point, and that advantage was then sealed in to their whole career - they moved to a higher point on promotion (because nobody waited till they hit the top of the pay range before trying for promotion) and then retired on a higher pension because it was linked to their final salary.

The big advantage of the Civil Service is being able to move around departments fairly easily, you can have a very varied and interesting career. But in terms of pay and almost everything else, it is nowhere near what it was in the days when one of the stated aims was to be a "good employer".

notsallyrooney · 29/11/2023 22:16

Tellmemore16 · 29/11/2023 22:14

It really depends where you are, I work in Scotland with devolved benefits at SEO level, we are contracted to 37 hours per week but this is dropping to 35 hours in oct 2025 with no drop in pay, you also go up pay points each year and are on your max with 4 years. I previously worked for DWP where the pay progression was awful and the role was gar more intense! Flexi and pension are deffo selling points

Well this sounds amazing but sadly not in Scotland! It’s not in London either and I’m in a more remote part of the country without that many large employers..

OP posts:
notsallyrooney · 29/11/2023 22:15

icebubbles · 29/11/2023 21:07

It will be 37 hrs plus one hr unpaid lunch break a day. Your salary only increases as per whatever the annual pay deal is with the Treasury. Keep in mind the employer pension contributions are 27% though which is way higher than most employers.

Current employer contribution is 21% which isn’t quite as good as that but also not so much worse.. seems to me like I would not really be better off by making the move. (And could be a lot of stress for barely any more money!)

OP posts:
Tellmemore16 · 29/11/2023 22:15

Sorry that should have said oct 2024

Tellmemore16 · 29/11/2023 22:14

It really depends where you are, I work in Scotland with devolved benefits at SEO level, we are contracted to 37 hours per week but this is dropping to 35 hours in oct 2025 with no drop in pay, you also go up pay points each year and are on your max with 4 years. I previously worked for DWP where the pay progression was awful and the role was gar more intense! Flexi and pension are deffo selling points

notsallyrooney · 29/11/2023 22:09

Towerofsong · 29/11/2023 21:26

As far as I am aware there is no progression within the salary bands across the civil service. They got rid of those after the 2008 recession. I don't know why they still advertise it as a range because it is misleading, unless someone was already on the higher band when they removed the increments.

Working hours should be 37 plus lunches.

Ah thanks, I hadn’t realised this at all - I thought the pay range is what I’d move up through (that’s how it works with my current employer.)

OP posts:
notsallyrooney · 29/11/2023 22:07

Stokey · 29/11/2023 21:11

So standard lunch break is an hour. Depending on which part of the civil service though, you normally have flexi time. So you can choose to work 9-5.30 with an hour lunch break for example or 9-5 with a half hour lunch. You could also work some longer days and some shorter days, though generally you have to be there from 10-4 (core hours). And that kind of leads into holiday a bit as you get to take up to 2 days a month flexi in additional to your normal holidays - although depending on workload you may not be able to take them. There's also lots of folk who work compressed hours like 10 days in 9 or 5 days in 4.

Progression is harder at SEO level. You'd be stuck at the same salary for a couple of years and realistically probably need to change jobs to get more, but lots of people change jobs regularly.

Amazed you have 43 days leave at present, that's incredibly unusual. Most jobs start at 25.

Yes very lucky with my leave - also have the option to buy 2 weeks on top of that!! I’m thinking I’d like a change and some more money but actually this leaves thing means i might be wise to just stay put!!!!

OP posts:
notsallyrooney · 29/11/2023 22:05

Dandelionzebra · 29/11/2023 21:54

As others have said in nearly all departments there’s no moving up the paybands based on experience or time in post. But maybe after a few years you could apply for G7 or move sidewise at the same grade level to HMRC or one of the regulators which all see to pay about 10% more than regular civil service for equivalent roles. If you are London based promotion opportunities tend to come around more often simply because there’s a lot more senior jobs and a lot of moving in between departments (in Whitehall it’s normal to move department every few years but if you’re based outside London there might only be one department with an office in your city so it’s harder to build the breadth of experience and it can be a bit dead men’s shoes waiting for more senior roles to come up))

The actual hours depend hugely on the role - if you’re doing anything international or involving primary legislation you’re likely to work significantly more than the official hours sometimes at strange times of day. Parliament doesn’t really get started till about lunchtime and sits into the evening - so if it’s a job that involves a lot of parliamentary work you’ll be working a lot of evenings as well. Some of the more delivery type roles/ support type roles tend to have much more regular hours closer to the actual 37 in the contract.

Up until recently it has been quite good in terms of flexibility - but there’s been a recent 60% time return to the office announcement. It’s not yet clear how much this will actually be enforced especially as they gave up a lot of our office space after the lockdowns- but I don’t think you can bank on being able to mostly work home - so if remote working is important to you bear in mind they’re trying to reduce it.

Thanks for this. I don’t mind attending an office but would rather not if it was going to be 60%!

OP posts:
notsallyrooney · 29/11/2023 22:03

Temporaryname158 · 29/11/2023 21:47

Also working in education with similar benefits to you, I think it really is a balance of what you value more. it sounds like the pension will be a little better but yours is certainly not poor, and only a £2k pay increase but a massive drop in leave. I value my huge amount of annual leave more than money and so it’s the holidays that really keep me!

Yes this is what I keep coming back to!

OP posts:
Dandelionzebra · 29/11/2023 21:54

As others have said in nearly all departments there’s no moving up the paybands based on experience or time in post. But maybe after a few years you could apply for G7 or move sidewise at the same grade level to HMRC or one of the regulators which all see to pay about 10% more than regular civil service for equivalent roles. If you are London based promotion opportunities tend to come around more often simply because there’s a lot more senior jobs and a lot of moving in between departments (in Whitehall it’s normal to move department every few years but if you’re based outside London there might only be one department with an office in your city so it’s harder to build the breadth of experience and it can be a bit dead men’s shoes waiting for more senior roles to come up))

The actual hours depend hugely on the role - if you’re doing anything international or involving primary legislation you’re likely to work significantly more than the official hours sometimes at strange times of day. Parliament doesn’t really get started till about lunchtime and sits into the evening - so if it’s a job that involves a lot of parliamentary work you’ll be working a lot of evenings as well. Some of the more delivery type roles/ support type roles tend to have much more regular hours closer to the actual 37 in the contract.

Up until recently it has been quite good in terms of flexibility - but there’s been a recent 60% time return to the office announcement. It’s not yet clear how much this will actually be enforced especially as they gave up a lot of our office space after the lockdowns- but I don’t think you can bank on being able to mostly work home - so if remote working is important to you bear in mind they’re trying to reduce it.

tommika · 29/11/2023 21:52

To sum up:

37 hours worked, across a 42 hour week with 1 hour lunches. Which with flexi could be half hour lunches making a 39.5 hour week

25+1+8= 34 days leave / bank holidays rising over 5 years to 30+1+8=39 days

Salary expected to rise by a percentage each year, but not guaranteed depending on pay rises.

Promotion is the way to progress - which means applying for subsequent higher grade roles and successful progression - some departments can be easier than others for progression

Subject to the department and specific role there is a lot of flexibility available, with flexi time, adjusting daily hours etc

Pensions aren’t as gold plated as they were with changes to schemes over the years but remain good pensions

Temporaryname158 · 29/11/2023 21:47

Also working in education with similar benefits to you, I think it really is a balance of what you value more. it sounds like the pension will be a little better but yours is certainly not poor, and only a £2k pay increase but a massive drop in leave. I value my huge amount of annual leave more than money and so it’s the holidays that really keep me!

tommika · 29/11/2023 21:41

Historically pay progression rose annually along spine points.
You enter the grade at minimum then expect to increment annually until grade maximum
There would also be a pay rise percentage with each spine point rising by an agreed percentage

Pay scale increments were ceased. So you remain at the scale minimum unless you promote and get to the next grades scale minimum, but whilst at that minimum provided their is a pay agreement a percentage is applied

The pay scale spine points are slowly closing up. The lowest grades have had their minimum rise up to meet their maximum

Ultimately one day every grade will have a single salary for that grade. In the meantime those on the minimum of each scale slowly close the gap between minimum and maximum

notsallyrooney · 29/11/2023 21:40

Yes very lucky with my leave - also have the option to buy 2 weeks on top of that!!

OP posts:
notsallyrooney · 29/11/2023 21:35

Thanks, the pension I had not really considered. My current employer is 21% (HE) so given that plus my lovely annual leave I do think maybe I should just stay put!!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread