Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if what I said was horribly offensive?

213 replies

Plantain1234 · 29/11/2023 19:59

Me and DD went for breakfast at a restaurant over the weekend. After I ordered Plantain to go with my breakfast, DD told me that her friend (who is mixed heritage) also loves plantain. For a bit of background, DD's friend's Mum was born in the UK to parents who came from the Caribbean in the 1950s.

I asked DD if her friend's liking of plantain came from his Mum's family. I was just meaning that as Plantain is so widely eaten in the Caribbean, that they might have had family recipes passed down through the generations. I feel that plantain is not widely eaten in UK and is not appreciated as much as it could be.

DD looked horrified when I asked the question about whether her friend's liking of plantain came from his Mum. Is what I said racist? I wasn't thinking it was when I said it, but would be grateful for opinions, so I can avoid being unintentionally offensive in future.

OP posts:
TheFormidableMrsC · 29/11/2023 22:34

@Ladybughello

didn’t say I was “offended”. But it’s difficult to understand how you would “struggle” to remember someone’s pronouns, unless you have dementia. Sound more likely to be purposeful fingers in ears

Ok, as this is about my comment. I'm 54 years old. I've seen some stuff in my life. I'm not phobic or racist or anything of the sort BUT when "Bob" you've know for 40 years suddenly announces that he's now "Bernadette" and starts wearing dresses and make up, with no prior warning or indication, it is VERY difficult to suddenly start referring to them as "she". It is indeed a struggle. I don't have dementia, I do have an autistic 12 year old though. He also struggled with calling "Bob" Bernadette. Because Bob is all he's known. It's not "fingers in your ears", it's human error and getting used to a new normal. And we will get used to that new normal but forgive me if I make a mistake after so many years. Your being offended at that is ludicrous.

Cantdoitallperfectly · 29/11/2023 22:31

The younger folks are definitely easily offended and we have a 17yr old (my DSD) who is quick to point out any of our so called of touch view points.

Ironically she will often refer to people as ‘Karen’s’ which I find quite offensive (but say nothing).

Angelsrose · 29/11/2023 22:26

I think your DD was likely winding you up as clearly not offensive in any way. I love plantain and more people should try it!

BlueEyedPeanut · 29/11/2023 22:23

LondonLass91 · 29/11/2023 21:36

Rubbish! People like what they've been brought up on. I like jellied eels because i'm a cockney and it was given to me alot. People eat the food they are accustomed to at a young age.

Well, the OP wasn't brought up eating plantains, and she still likes them right? How do you know this boy didn't have his first when he was 18? You can't just assume because his mum is from Caribbean it means he was raised in the UK eating plantains.

MsRosley · 29/11/2023 22:23

No offence, OP, but your daughter was being idiotic. I love plantain. Would she accuse me of cultural appropriation given I'm not West Indian?

tachetastic · 29/11/2023 22:20

I think your DDs comments come from a well intentioned place and her sensitivity is down to the excellent upbringing you have provided,

The issue of respecting and celebrating differences between people based on race, gender or sexuality is the next step.

This is not easy for adults. Less so for kids and even harder for parents. Good luck!

Sez197 · 29/11/2023 22:16

I didn’t know what plantain was until my husband (from West Africa) introduced me to it. And my MIL taught me how to cook it properly.

He would not be offended and would actually enjoy talking about his favourite recipes with plantain. I’m not saying your DD is one but he also doesn’t appreciate white saviours who are offended on his behalf.

Lifeomars · 29/11/2023 22:16

I am now craving a plantain fritter.

Xmaswomble · 29/11/2023 22:13

Sounds like you don’t h have a great relationship with you’re daughter or else you could have discussed it. Perhaps work on that?

EmmaEmerald · 29/11/2023 22:11

Oncetwicethreetimesalady · 29/11/2023 20:45

Obviously anything and everything a parent says to one of their dc’s friends is going to be embarrassing. I once said hello to one of my dd’s friends and was told “don’t be so cringe!”.
But, on the other hand, I would refrain from asking even remotely personal questions of their friends particularly if it could possibly even in the most vague way be interpreted negatively. Asking about a person’s heritage ie. “does your liking of plantain come from your mum’s family?” I’d think was a bit dodgy because you’re poking around in the “but where do you really come from?” territory which is I guess what your daughter might have been expecting could come next. Your daughter might also be aware that her friend might be carrying bad experiences as baggage and therefore be more sensitive.

Exactly!

As well as the "but where are you really from" comments, it's a bit like being asked "do you think you like plantain because your grandparents probably ate it 70 years ago".

I like your DD! I try not to be perma offended but I really get her thinking in this one. I realise the friend wasn't there, but if you said it to me I'd be groaning inwardly.

WtP · 29/11/2023 22:09

jm9138 · 29/11/2023 21:40

I remember my 16 year old boy being moody all day and then blurting out "I have been wondering why JK Rowling has got me so mad and it is because her comments against trans people are just like homophobic comments in the past". Paraphrasing but words to that effect - it was a while ago. I (calmly) said she has lived as a woman from birth for 50 years and that will give her a different perspective on trans issues to him. And that perhaps he should be more concerned about the fact there are people that live in his own town that from birth have got about 10% the chance of finishing school with 5 GSCEs than he has by virtue of their parents' income. Finally, that he should be aware that by the time he is 50 I can guarantee that 16 year olds will be looking at the views he has as illiberal and bigoted or cruel and selfish.

I suspect we were all a bit dismissive of our parents views when we were younger (I know my dad was really homophobic and casually racist and I would roll my eyes). They do seem to be a bit more in your face about it now though and I think history will not judge well some of the fights they have decided to engage with and the solutions that they want to impose. I could be wrong, but it will be their mess to sort out and I will be too dead to tell them I told you so.

Perfectly put @jm9138
We probably all thought we had all the answers when we were 20!
Now I'm nearly 60 I cringe at some of the shit I said.

MudSandWater · 29/11/2023 22:08

It must be so tiring being so easily offended on behalf of others all the time... she needs to grow a backbone.

Eastie77Returns · 29/11/2023 22:04

Clingfilm · 29/11/2023 21:44

Some people missing the point that plantain is an unusual food item that's not very common in the UK (it really isn't before someone says they can get it in their urban supermarket and eat it 3 times a week) so OPs comment about the friend's familiarity with it is valid.

By the way what does it taste like?! What's the cooked texture like? I've always wanted to try it.

It’s delicious. Quite sweet and best eaten fried (some heathens will say you can boil it). Texture is soft. If you haven’t seen one uncooked, it resembles a large banana.

Every child of West Indian parents will have grown up eating this regularly, usually with Sunday dinner. It was a staple in our house and my DC love it now. They obviously didn’t develop that preference from their dad who is Southern European.

OP - just smile and nod at your child😭

WandaWonder · 29/11/2023 22:01

You know very well it is not racist nice try though

Pinkpinkpink15 · 29/11/2023 22:00

Thinkcentre23 · 29/11/2023 20:19

Solidarity for others navigating life with a ‘permanently offended and triggered on behalf of others’ offspring. Perhaps we should start a support group….

Can it be a side spring? Gid daughter is getting in fucking believable!! She might not see 20!

CornflakesOnTheSolesOfHerShoes · 29/11/2023 22:00

Exactly, @Clingfilm. I’ve only ever come across plantain in West Africa - never cooked or been served it in the UK, or seen it on a menu. So to my mind the only thing wrong with the OP’s comment is that is was too blindingly obvious to be worthy of mention that the friend’s taste for it would have come from his mum’s family heritage.

WilburVonTrap · 29/11/2023 21:51

My daughter was worried about her very curly, dark hair, and whether people would think it was a cultural appropriation.

I had to explain that her hair was growing out of her head, and she didn't need to worry about it. She has high functioning ASD, and was very concerned.

.

Clingfilm · 29/11/2023 21:44

Some people missing the point that plantain is an unusual food item that's not very common in the UK (it really isn't before someone says they can get it in their urban supermarket and eat it 3 times a week) so OPs comment about the friend's familiarity with it is valid.

By the way what does it taste like?! What's the cooked texture like? I've always wanted to try it.

Alalalalalongalalalalalonglonglilong · 29/11/2023 21:40

Never heard of plantain.. just googled it!

Hadjab · 29/11/2023 21:40

It’s definitely not a racist question, but it is a silly one. Would you ask a half Swedish person if their love of IKEA meatballs stems from their father’s side?

jm9138 · 29/11/2023 21:40

I remember my 16 year old boy being moody all day and then blurting out "I have been wondering why JK Rowling has got me so mad and it is because her comments against trans people are just like homophobic comments in the past". Paraphrasing but words to that effect - it was a while ago. I (calmly) said she has lived as a woman from birth for 50 years and that will give her a different perspective on trans issues to him. And that perhaps he should be more concerned about the fact there are people that live in his own town that from birth have got about 10% the chance of finishing school with 5 GSCEs than he has by virtue of their parents' income. Finally, that he should be aware that by the time he is 50 I can guarantee that 16 year olds will be looking at the views he has as illiberal and bigoted or cruel and selfish.

I suspect we were all a bit dismissive of our parents views when we were younger (I know my dad was really homophobic and casually racist and I would roll my eyes). They do seem to be a bit more in your face about it now though and I think history will not judge well some of the fights they have decided to engage with and the solutions that they want to impose. I could be wrong, but it will be their mess to sort out and I will be too dead to tell them I told you so.

IveOnlyEverHeardOutwithONHere · 29/11/2023 21:39

No, of course you weren’t being offensive. God knows how these kids are going to get on in the real world.

all this taking offense at everything on someone else’s behalf is going to have a backlash at some point. People aren’t going to put up with being scolded forever, and it’s going to be the people on whose behalf the offense has been taken that will suffer, the lesbians and gays, the people of color, disabled people. It’s not going to be pretty and I’m not looking forward to it. These poe-faced self-righteous little shits need to wind their necks in and get a life, because somebody is going to pay for their virtue signaling frenzy, and it probably won’t be them.

LondonLass91 · 29/11/2023 21:36

BlueEyedPeanut · 29/11/2023 21:20

I'm guessing it is because it is an assumption based on a stereotype. I'd say it was your use of "from his mum" that annoyed your daughter.

If an Italian likes pasta, it is because he likes pasta. Not because he's Italian.
If an Irish person likes potatoes, it is because she likes potatoes. Not because she's Irish.
If a black boy likes plantains, it is because he likes plantains. Not because his mum is from the Caribbean.

Rubbish! People like what they've been brought up on. I like jellied eels because i'm a cockney and it was given to me alot. People eat the food they are accustomed to at a young age.

ThewaytoAmarula · 29/11/2023 21:36

On TV shows like Masterchef they often have chefs talking about the dishes they're cooking inspired by their heritage, and it's clear they're happy and proud to talk about their cultural and family influences. It's certainly the case in my family (half of which is Asian).

So it could be argued you're being more inclusive and culturally aware than your DD.

BlueGrey1 · 29/11/2023 21:35

Not racist at all, I have to say younger people and all their ‘woke’ nonsense is excruciatingly annoying, how are they going to be tolerated when they go into the workplace, I have to mentor junior staff occasionally at work and I would have no time or patience to put up with this rubbish…..they think they know everything (they don’t at all) are over confident and wickedly irritating

Swipe left for the next trending thread