Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if what I said was horribly offensive?

213 replies

Plantain1234 · 29/11/2023 19:59

Me and DD went for breakfast at a restaurant over the weekend. After I ordered Plantain to go with my breakfast, DD told me that her friend (who is mixed heritage) also loves plantain. For a bit of background, DD's friend's Mum was born in the UK to parents who came from the Caribbean in the 1950s.

I asked DD if her friend's liking of plantain came from his Mum's family. I was just meaning that as Plantain is so widely eaten in the Caribbean, that they might have had family recipes passed down through the generations. I feel that plantain is not widely eaten in UK and is not appreciated as much as it could be.

DD looked horrified when I asked the question about whether her friend's liking of plantain came from his Mum. Is what I said racist? I wasn't thinking it was when I said it, but would be grateful for opinions, so I can avoid being unintentionally offensive in future.

OP posts:
beAsensible1 · 29/11/2023 23:48

its not racist but asking if someone has inherited a liking for plantain is bit weird?

Mummymummy89 · 29/11/2023 23:45

JudgeJ · 29/11/2023 23:27

when an old person mentions someone is "coloured" because that's what the term was and they didn't know any better

That's because the 'acceptable' terms will have changed so often during the 'old person's' lifetime, nothing to do with not knowing any better. Are ageist terms like 'old people' allowed by the way? Can I be offended on their behalf?

This, this is an example of the kind of thing I meant when I talked about being sent the lists of microaggressions.

For those who consider this relevant, I am mixed race and so to my colleague, according to her "glossaries", I and other non-white people must be referred to as a "person of colour, POC". Not "BAME" because, I am told, that was considered too non-specific and grouped too many ethnicities together so got dropped out of parlance. (Are you keeping up? Enjoying the watertight logic?)

Don't get me started on "person of colour", I hate that phrase, it's referring directly to my skin tone as if that's the most relevant thing about my race. The 3-letter acronym always confuses me as I see it as "piece of crap" just as POS is piece of shit.

I would much rather be stereotyped for loving rice (my home country's preferred food, so analogous to the plantain in the op) than labelled as being brown or whatever "colour". People where I'm from DO love rice. Rice is great. We even have a generic word for a-dish-that-goes-with-rice, because we eat rice at every meal.

Op, if you asked me "do you love rice because of where you and your mum are from?" I'd answer with a loud yes and proceed to list the health benefits and favourite methods of cooking.

So, get offended at that if you like. I'm sure I'll get all the offended quote-posts because this isn't how a "POC" is supposed to think. Edit - I'm not addressing @JudgeJ here! More the sanctimonious pp who suggested I ought to quit teaching because I don't deeply appreciate being forced to play this silly game at work [eyeroll]

smilesup · 29/11/2023 23:39

Jewelspun · 29/11/2023 20:06

How old is your daughter? If she is still in education, part of the Lefty curriculum is to brainwash pupils/students to take offence at everything.

What you said was perfectly normal.

Whereas everything you said was laughably sad. Have you got lost and wandered here by mistake? The Daily Mail's comment section for the slightly thick and easily manipulated are over that way.

JudgeJ · 29/11/2023 23:27

when an old person mentions someone is "coloured" because that's what the term was and they didn't know any better

That's because the 'acceptable' terms will have changed so often during the 'old person's' lifetime, nothing to do with not knowing any better. Are ageist terms like 'old people' allowed by the way? Can I be offended on their behalf?

slore · 29/11/2023 23:26

It's not offensive, but I feel for your daughter: young white people are taught that they're irredeemably evil, and the goalposts for what is considered racist or cultural appropriation shift endlessly. They become paranoid about appearing racist and are on guard at all times to avoid being attacked or cancelled. It is second nature to behave like this, even though just you and her together were not at risk of being cancelled.

You might like to have a word with your daughter about being offended on behalf of other people - if you frame it as centering her white voice in other people's concerns, she might understand that she should calm down.

Nospecialcharactersplease · 29/11/2023 23:26

I think young people sometimes have a conceptual understanding of racism without necessarily having the contextual awareness to understand whether it is relevant in a particular scenario.

You were fine.

Plantain1234 · 29/11/2023 23:23

Toohardtofindaproperusername · 29/11/2023 23:16

How old is your daughter? Hell her to "think" for herlsef by,asking,her, not,us, questions about her response. You,seem to have been sent I to place of anxiety when źyljr question is just of curiosity. As an adult, supporting your dc to try to articulate what is in their head can help them, and you. Sorry if already been said I haven't read all responses. Of course, age appropriate conversation. And if she is stoppy teenager, she will just need to think you know nothing and understand nothing. The joy.
But most of all, dont imagine your dc know more than anyone else, and be constantly vigilant for your errors. Talking to them, and asking them, will help you both im sure. And be interesting. Enjoy.

She's 20 and in the second year of uni!

OP posts:
notahappybunny7 · 29/11/2023 23:22

Mariposista · 29/11/2023 23:21

Keep being cheeky!!!! They love it, feeding people is part of their culture and it makes them happy! And they always make too much 🤣🤣

Yeah, makes me happy too!!

Mariposista · 29/11/2023 23:21

notahappybunny7 · 29/11/2023 23:19

My Pakistani neighbours cooking sends me crazy-I’ve had to stop complimenting her as she sends food round and now I feel cheeky like I’m begging! It’s killing me!!

Keep being cheeky!!!! They love it, feeding people is part of their culture and it makes them happy! And they always make too much 🤣🤣

notahappybunny7 · 29/11/2023 23:19

Mariposista · 29/11/2023 20:53

For heaven’s sake! Do young people now take degrees in getting offended???

I have a neighbour (Indian family) whose house always smells fantastic as they drive past with wonderful curry smells. If I mention that am I being racist? I hope not - would like to get invited round for dinner!

My Pakistani neighbours cooking sends me crazy-I’ve had to stop complimenting her as she sends food round and now I feel cheeky like I’m begging! It’s killing me!!

Toohardtofindaproperusername · 29/11/2023 23:16

How old is your daughter? Hell her to "think" for herlsef by,asking,her, not,us, questions about her response. You,seem to have been sent I to place of anxiety when źyljr question is just of curiosity. As an adult, supporting your dc to try to articulate what is in their head can help them, and you. Sorry if already been said I haven't read all responses. Of course, age appropriate conversation. And if she is stoppy teenager, she will just need to think you know nothing and understand nothing. The joy.
But most of all, dont imagine your dc know more than anyone else, and be constantly vigilant for your errors. Talking to them, and asking them, will help you both im sure. And be interesting. Enjoy.

Plantain1234 · 29/11/2023 23:13

Angelsrose · 29/11/2023 22:26

I think your DD was likely winding you up as clearly not offensive in any way. I love plantain and more people should try it!

DD definitely wasn't winding me up. Her mortification at my question was entirely real. I was just genuinely interested in the fact that her friend likes plantain as so few people have tried it. DD and her friend have both grown up in rural Shropshire, so plantain not widely on offer here. The plantain I ate was at a cafe in Camden last weekend (DD now at uni in London) . I think that because in my mind, food types from different cultures are exciting and to be explored, I hadn't thought of my question as seeming as if I was stereotyping her friend.

OP posts:
notahappybunny7 · 29/11/2023 23:11

Plantain1234 · 29/11/2023 19:59

Me and DD went for breakfast at a restaurant over the weekend. After I ordered Plantain to go with my breakfast, DD told me that her friend (who is mixed heritage) also loves plantain. For a bit of background, DD's friend's Mum was born in the UK to parents who came from the Caribbean in the 1950s.

I asked DD if her friend's liking of plantain came from his Mum's family. I was just meaning that as Plantain is so widely eaten in the Caribbean, that they might have had family recipes passed down through the generations. I feel that plantain is not widely eaten in UK and is not appreciated as much as it could be.

DD looked horrified when I asked the question about whether her friend's liking of plantain came from his Mum. Is what I said racist? I wasn't thinking it was when I said it, but would be grateful for opinions, so I can avoid being unintentionally offensive in future.

God imagine having to walk on eggshells around your child like this! Get a grip!

Dobbybigearsdog · 29/11/2023 23:11

wnen I asked my daughter where the ‘vinegar’ was in the cupboard was? I got told at school you can’t say that because people think you’re saying the vile, racist n word - I would never ever say. I had to explain that I was not been a racist nor did I know another way to ask for vinegar. Apparently you can’t say the word vinegar anymore

Sez197 · 29/11/2023 23:08

LoveBluey · 29/11/2023 22:48

It's not racist though. It's a genuine question.

I like plantain but I only discovered I liked it when I went on holiday to the Caribbean. I'd never eaten it in England. So knowing it's a food associated with the Caribbean it would be a perfectly reasonable question to ask.

Just talked to DH about this, after previously commenting. He reminded me my daughter loves fish and chips and that my in-laws say it came from me and not her West African father.

Your daughter will look back on it one day and cringe probably. There are plenty of books out there if she wants to educate herself on the five line between being an ally but not being offended on behalf of others. My husband said that is often what he finds most offensive of all, as if he can’t speak up for himself.

Teenagehorrorbag · 29/11/2023 23:06

Notmetoo · 29/11/2023 20:15

This is ridiculous.

I don't think it's political but schools are very careful to teach children what is not acceptable - and young kids don't always understand the finer nuances (and neither do adults always, tbh). But I think they mean well.

My DTs (15) can sometimes jump to similar assumptions to OPs DD - they are just trying hard to be correct and sometimes go too far the other way. I have had several conversations with DS (who does have ASD so is more black and white than some) - that it is not always wrong to say that someone is black, or gay etc. We can acknowledge facts if not being offensive or making assumptions - but he struggles with that. A more lateral comment such as OPs would probably go unchallenged as he wouldn't make the connection - but DD might have said the same.

They are all learning - and they are trying to get it right.....

Spottyhousecoat · 29/11/2023 23:04

My youngest dd is like this offended for everyone. She was so offended when I said her late gran (dh mum) wasn't very good at making mince and tatties because her mum was English! Apparently that was racist, it was her gran that told me that years ago it just wasn't something her mum made as she didn't grow up with it!

Plantain1234 · 29/11/2023 22:55

User890976 · 29/11/2023 22:39

Surely that’s also an assumption, we don’t know if OP was or was not brought up eating plantain also 🤷🏻‍♀️

No, I definitely wasn't brought up eating plantain. I have lived in culturally diverse areas as an adult, which is where I have discovered it and found it to be truly delicious!

OP posts:
Imperfectp3rf3ction · 29/11/2023 22:54

Try the counter trigger.

You said something harmless genuinely I don't think I know many adults from any cultures old enough to have 'older' kids that would get offended at culture related food questions. We just built different 😁 HOWEVER these young people's reactions may actually be what would make someone feel uncomfortable because then it's just weird. Secondary School age children have a VERY warped sense of what racism is and some children actually use it to their severe advantage and manipulation.

LoveBluey · 29/11/2023 22:48

Alohapotato · 29/11/2023 20:42

I think it's racist , just because the grandparents are from jamaica doesn't mean she likes plantain because of it. You like it and your grandparents are not from Jamaica. Do all the british people like fish and chips?

It's not racist though. It's a genuine question.

I like plantain but I only discovered I liked it when I went on holiday to the Caribbean. I'd never eaten it in England. So knowing it's a food associated with the Caribbean it would be a perfectly reasonable question to ask.

BlueEyedPeanut · 29/11/2023 22:43

User890976 · 29/11/2023 22:37

I definitely like potatoes because I’m Irish 😂

and no I don’t consider that assumption that racist

but note DD was the one who said her friend liked plantain, her mother didn’t assume he would a priori. Why he likes it is irrelevant but not racist

You're right in that why he likes it is irrelevant. Which is why the OP assuming it is because his mum is from the Caribbean is stupid and stereotyping.

User890976 · 29/11/2023 22:39

BlueEyedPeanut · 29/11/2023 22:23

Well, the OP wasn't brought up eating plantains, and she still likes them right? How do you know this boy didn't have his first when he was 18? You can't just assume because his mum is from Caribbean it means he was raised in the UK eating plantains.

Surely that’s also an assumption, we don’t know if OP was or was not brought up eating plantain also 🤷🏻‍♀️

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 29/11/2023 22:37

Ladybughello · 29/11/2023 21:02

I didn’t say I was “offended”. But it’s difficult to understand how you would “struggle” to remember someone’s pronouns, unless you have dementia. Sound more likely to be purposeful fingers in ears.

You can't make people call you what you want them to call you.

I doubt this is what the original poster of the comment intended, but even if it were, you don't have to call any one anything you don't want to. That's coercion.

User890976 · 29/11/2023 22:37

BlueEyedPeanut · 29/11/2023 21:20

I'm guessing it is because it is an assumption based on a stereotype. I'd say it was your use of "from his mum" that annoyed your daughter.

If an Italian likes pasta, it is because he likes pasta. Not because he's Italian.
If an Irish person likes potatoes, it is because she likes potatoes. Not because she's Irish.
If a black boy likes plantains, it is because he likes plantains. Not because his mum is from the Caribbean.

I definitely like potatoes because I’m Irish 😂

and no I don’t consider that assumption that racist

but note DD was the one who said her friend liked plantain, her mother didn’t assume he would a priori. Why he likes it is irrelevant but not racist

TheFormidableMrsC · 29/11/2023 22:36

ManchesterLu · 29/11/2023 21:21

A lot of teens like to sit on their high horses and look down at us uneducated idiots below them.. they think they know it all.. they have a lot to learn.

Quite!