Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if what I said was horribly offensive?

213 replies

Plantain1234 · 29/11/2023 19:59

Me and DD went for breakfast at a restaurant over the weekend. After I ordered Plantain to go with my breakfast, DD told me that her friend (who is mixed heritage) also loves plantain. For a bit of background, DD's friend's Mum was born in the UK to parents who came from the Caribbean in the 1950s.

I asked DD if her friend's liking of plantain came from his Mum's family. I was just meaning that as Plantain is so widely eaten in the Caribbean, that they might have had family recipes passed down through the generations. I feel that plantain is not widely eaten in UK and is not appreciated as much as it could be.

DD looked horrified when I asked the question about whether her friend's liking of plantain came from his Mum. Is what I said racist? I wasn't thinking it was when I said it, but would be grateful for opinions, so I can avoid being unintentionally offensive in future.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SharSharBinks · 02/12/2023 19:36

BombaySamphire · 01/12/2023 18:35

Sweet Jesus! Can you possibly be serious?

Of course not. 😂 The thread is about people taking offence at innocuous comments.

Daddydog · 01/12/2023 20:04

OneTC · 01/12/2023 19:37

It comes from the Tamil word kari

I work a lot from India and the halarious thing is people there will refer to the source part of a 'Curry' as 'Gravy'! Thew me off the first time I ordered dinner, half expected mutton swimming in Bisto!

OneTC · 01/12/2023 19:37

corblimeylove · 30/11/2023 22:39

Nope you are wrong. It was said and actually we had quite a good discussion about it. It is because the term was coined by English/Portuguse colonialists to describe Indian food. My ds has a South Indian friend who told him that the correct term for the dish should be used not a generalised colonial term. I didn't throw my hands up in horror I was educated on the matter. I just find it exhausting. I did argue that using "racist" was too strong a term and my dc did concede that point. But now I know that there are people who find it offensive I can change my terminology just like I educated my parents not to use the term "coloured" to describe black people.

It comes from the Tamil word kari

Daddydog · 01/12/2023 19:15

It's really odd. I've been around people who have been told it's racist to ask an Indian person a question about curry or an Afro-Caribbean person about Plantain/jerk chicken/Jellof rice. Yet, there's never any issue if they ask a Spanish person about Tapas or an Italian about pasta! Never understood that!

JudgeJ · 01/12/2023 18:46

BombaySamphire · 01/12/2023 18:35

Sweet Jesus! Can you possibly be serious?

To be honest I took the comment about my dislike of faggots to be funny, looking at the emoji ! In the UK, where we are, it means odious grotty meatballs or bundles of twigs!

BombaySamphire · 01/12/2023 18:35

SharSharBinks · 01/12/2023 16:16

My late OH loved faggots, I couldn't stand the sight of them!

Reported for homophobia. 😠

Sweet Jesus! Can you possibly be serious?

SharSharBinks · 01/12/2023 16:16

My late OH loved faggots, I couldn't stand the sight of them!

Reported for homophobia. 😠

Panaa · 01/12/2023 15:47

@ChiefWiggumsBoy
I agree.
I'm Irish and the other day an Irish politician said that even when we were being oppressed we still maintained our invisibility cloak of white privilege 🤔🙄
Such an insult to our history and it's being said by white politicians obsessed with self-flagellation to try to be PC.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 01/12/2023 11:57

@cardibach you might think it's ludicrous and not happening that white kids are being taught they are 'irredeemably evil', but unfortunately, there's a lot of stuff coming from black Americans on Tiktok and the like that is doing exactly that. It's really and truly quite upsetting to watch - there's a certain cohort (and I say this because I've literally only seen Americans say it) that hold white people responsible for all the ills that happen in the world.

I'm not saying that's true, but I'm not an impressionable teenager. There are plenty of black creators from many countries that refute this by the way, but unfortunately once the algorithm is attuned to you then you might not see them. Or you might see them, and then read the comments which can be horrible.

On one (what I thought) completely innocuous Tiktok, I personally admitted defeat and said if they think I'm racist for not liking chicken and waffles, then I guess I'm racist. I don't think I am, but there are those out there that believe it.

TheHateIsNotGood · 30/11/2023 23:37

Gotta hand it to the Uni-kids nowadays if all they have to do is "look horrified", whilst at a restaurant, to tie their parents up in knots.

Not so long ago parents might get a tad concerned if the banner-waving, demos, the dean called, etc was a regular event.

Quite like a bit of cilantro myself although some might call it coriander but really not keen on yams and sweet potatoes or whatevs they're called by whoevs. Apparently the Nottinham Student Union have voted that the campus should be vegan.

You'd think there might be a few global conflicts and injustice for the students to be horrified about rather than the cultural divisiveness of describing plantain or decreeing that all should eat plant-based food products.

corblimeylove · 30/11/2023 23:18

cardibach · 30/11/2023 22:44

Except the word curry is fine if that’s what you are making. Very little of what we make in this country fits what your child was saying. Meera Sodha has curry recipes 8n her books. So does Nadiya Hussein. And lots of other cooks from other ethnicities. Yes, sometimes it’s particular type of dish, such as dal, that you wouldn’t use the word curry for.
And actually, if you had said what you’ve said in your reply to start with I’d have agreed with you. What you said is it’s exhausting that you aren’t allowed to say curry because it’s racist. That’s utter nonsense. As you know, because you’ve been able to explain what actually happened. So why the ‘permanently offended at being banned for saying stuff’ nonsense?

Not permanently offended just posted on a thread about horrifying our dcs.

I know not all people from SE Asian are offended by the term curry, but I now know some are. Cookbooks marketed to a western audience will use terms that are in use in the west.

Here is a quote by Anita Kummar that give a little insight to how it makes her feel.
"Because, again, “curry” is not a term that most Indians use to describe our food; it is an invention of white people. If we call our foods “curry,” it is to make things easier for the mainstream. I may not remember the names and faces of the white bullies who tormented me as a child anymore, but I do remember the sting of their words. Perhaps that is why when I hear about curry and Indian food being spoken about in such ignorant terms, I feel rage."

cardibach · 30/11/2023 22:44

corblimeylove · 30/11/2023 22:39

Nope you are wrong. It was said and actually we had quite a good discussion about it. It is because the term was coined by English/Portuguse colonialists to describe Indian food. My ds has a South Indian friend who told him that the correct term for the dish should be used not a generalised colonial term. I didn't throw my hands up in horror I was educated on the matter. I just find it exhausting. I did argue that using "racist" was too strong a term and my dc did concede that point. But now I know that there are people who find it offensive I can change my terminology just like I educated my parents not to use the term "coloured" to describe black people.

Except the word curry is fine if that’s what you are making. Very little of what we make in this country fits what your child was saying. Meera Sodha has curry recipes 8n her books. So does Nadiya Hussein. And lots of other cooks from other ethnicities. Yes, sometimes it’s particular type of dish, such as dal, that you wouldn’t use the word curry for.
And actually, if you had said what you’ve said in your reply to start with I’d have agreed with you. What you said is it’s exhausting that you aren’t allowed to say curry because it’s racist. That’s utter nonsense. As you know, because you’ve been able to explain what actually happened. So why the ‘permanently offended at being banned for saying stuff’ nonsense?

corblimeylove · 30/11/2023 22:39

cardibach · 30/11/2023 22:24

Again, utter bollocks.
If your child says this, you simply clear up the misunderstanding and move on, not throw your hands up in horror.
I seriously doubt any child said it though. They have curry for school dinner.

Nope you are wrong. It was said and actually we had quite a good discussion about it. It is because the term was coined by English/Portuguse colonialists to describe Indian food. My ds has a South Indian friend who told him that the correct term for the dish should be used not a generalised colonial term. I didn't throw my hands up in horror I was educated on the matter. I just find it exhausting. I did argue that using "racist" was too strong a term and my dc did concede that point. But now I know that there are people who find it offensive I can change my terminology just like I educated my parents not to use the term "coloured" to describe black people.

1dayatatime · 30/11/2023 22:39

So firstly not in the least racist but secondly and more importantly this post has definitely got me craving fried plantain which at 10.30 at night is just not going to happen.

DD of a friend once objected to their parents serving curry as it was cultural appropriation ( I don't think she liked curry much). Friend said fine in which case that also rules out pizza ice cream, their DD soon backtracked.

cardibach · 30/11/2023 22:24

corblimeylove · 30/11/2023 00:07

oh good god its exhausting isn't it? According to my dc I am not allowed to say "curry" as in "I am cooking curry tonight". As it is racist.😐

Again, utter bollocks.
If your child says this, you simply clear up the misunderstanding and move on, not throw your hands up in horror.
I seriously doubt any child said it though. They have curry for school dinner.

CatMadam · 30/11/2023 22:23

Jewelspun · 29/11/2023 20:06

How old is your daughter? If she is still in education, part of the Lefty curriculum is to brainwash pupils/students to take offence at everything.

What you said was perfectly normal.

Do people actually believe this?

cardibach · 30/11/2023 22:22

slore · 29/11/2023 23:26

It's not offensive, but I feel for your daughter: young white people are taught that they're irredeemably evil, and the goalposts for what is considered racist or cultural appropriation shift endlessly. They become paranoid about appearing racist and are on guard at all times to avoid being attacked or cancelled. It is second nature to behave like this, even though just you and her together were not at risk of being cancelled.

You might like to have a word with your daughter about being offended on behalf of other people - if you frame it as centering her white voice in other people's concerns, she might understand that she should calm down.

Where are young white people taught they are ‘irredeemably evil’ please?
Honestly, the bullshit being spouted in this thread…

cardibach · 30/11/2023 22:19

Dobbybigearsdog · 29/11/2023 23:11

wnen I asked my daughter where the ‘vinegar’ was in the cupboard was? I got told at school you can’t say that because people think you’re saying the vile, racist n word - I would never ever say. I had to explain that I was not been a racist nor did I know another way to ask for vinegar. Apparently you can’t say the word vinegar anymore

No she didn’t. Don’t be silly.
Of course you can say vinegar. If your daughter said anything like that she’s misunderstood - and I’m betting you know very well she has.
I don’t believe anyone thinks you ‘can’t say’ vinegar.

JudgeJ · 30/11/2023 22:02

TheBluestEye2 · 30/11/2023 21:46

I'm not West Indian either but I enjoy plantain and many other Caribbean recipes. I don't think cultural appropriation is about enjoying good from another culture.

Ditto Tunnock's caramel wafers eaten by non-Scots? Will Yorkshire puddings get a protected designation of origin, or whatever?
Life is becoming so bland.

CaptainMyCaptain · 30/11/2023 21:59

Jewelspun · 29/11/2023 20:06

How old is your daughter? If she is still in education, part of the Lefty curriculum is to brainwash pupils/students to take offence at everything.

What you said was perfectly normal.

Don't be ridiculous.
Lefty curriculum ffs.

JudgeJ · 30/11/2023 21:58

Ilovecleaning · 30/11/2023 08:44

Maybe we should start calling them ‘meat testicles’ 🤣

Prairie oysters spring to mind.

My late OH loved faggots, I couldn't stand the sight of them!

cardibach · 30/11/2023 21:54

Mummymummy89 · 29/11/2023 20:34

I'm a secondary school teacher too (though not a subject leader, golly!) and I feel @Jewelspun 's comment deeply.

I'm sure every teacher knows an assistant head who is constantly sending colleagues lists of so-called "microaggressions" to avoid. Giving assemblies and speeches with pointedly awkward turns of phrase to avoid anything "problematic". If you don't know what I mean, you're that assistant head.

Edited

Never been higher than HoD. Never experienced anything like this, no.

cardibach · 30/11/2023 21:50

Jewelspun · 29/11/2023 20:06

How old is your daughter? If she is still in education, part of the Lefty curriculum is to brainwash pupils/students to take offence at everything.

What you said was perfectly normal.

Utter twaddle.
The curriculum was rewritten by Gove and has been added to since by Tories. In what way is it lefty?
I’m a teacher. My aim is the opposite of brainwashing. Education exposes people to a variety of viewpoints and makes offence less likely to be taken.
Where on earth do you get your misinformed ideas from?

TheBluestEye2 · 30/11/2023 21:46

MsRosley · 29/11/2023 22:23

No offence, OP, but your daughter was being idiotic. I love plantain. Would she accuse me of cultural appropriation given I'm not West Indian?

I'm not West Indian either but I enjoy plantain and many other Caribbean recipes. I don't think cultural appropriation is about enjoying good from another culture.

Swipe left for the next trending thread