Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask DH not to go for promotion?

408 replies

NCforthis235 · 29/11/2023 16:13

Sorry for long thread but there is context and don't want to drip feed.

DH is a teacher and has recently had a "tap" to apply for HOD job at his school for next September.

I am the breadwinner (earning c.5x DH's salary) but there are elements of his job which contribute massively in financial and non-financial ways (huge discount on school fees, DH does all childcare during school holidays).

I am pregnant with DC3, due in the spring and have made big sacrifices for him to pursue his teaching career. I went back to work after 3 months with DC1, and 6 weeks after DC2 because he was doing a degree and teacher training so I needed to earn. I have stayed in my current job longer than I would otherwise have done because the flexibility is amazing, but I have to do a night away a week from the kids and a long commute either end. Whenever the kids are sick during term time, it is me who juggles as his job is less flexible.

We are finally settling into a routine but I am stretched/often struggling. I do school drop off and pick up 2x a week on my WFH days (plus on my day off - I work 80%), spend a couple of hours with the kids then finish my work day once DH is home from school. It's working, but it's not easy.

The HOD job would involve him moving from 80% to full time as well as significantly more admin to do before/after school. Which ultimately would involve us needing a nanny for an extra day (which would more than eat up the pay bump for him) and add significantly more strain on me when I already feel like I'm just getting by.

He also wouldn't be able to take shared parental leave as we had planned for Christmas term next year. I've said I think we should just focus on stability during the early years and spending as much time with the kids as possible, and that the HOD is likely to come up again at some point. Once new baby is at pre-school, I am likely to want to look at different job options which would be made a lot easier if DH just stayed where he was for a few years. He's saying that we both worked hard and sacrificed a lot for his career and that he now wants to climb the ladder and start taking some of the financial load off of me. AIBU?

OP posts:
User890976 · 30/11/2023 21:12

MrsAzza · 30/11/2023 20:54

The husband contributes more financially whilst still having school holidays off to look after the children, the husband (and OP if they have serious look at their outgoings to prioritise childcare) have careers that they enjoy which makes them happy people and better parents. Neither of them would resent each other. Surely if OP’s husband gets a promotion then this takes the strain off her having to return to work so quickly? I’m just struggling to understand the negatives other than ‘it’s not what we agreed’. Or maybe I’m just supportive of my husbands career. We both have careers and we both pull our weight when we’re not working and at home with our kids. If he’s not doing that he needs a talking to but it’s not hard. I have friends whose husbands are in the military and are away for months at a time. It’s not ideal but they just get on with it (and still have their own careers)

Edited

I think the problem is that by your own admission you haven’t read the thread as if you had you’d know that OP said it wouldn’t be benefit them financially as the additional money would not even be enough to cover the extra day with the nanny…
plus all the additional stress and load on her from his additional responsibilities

MrsAzza · 30/11/2023 20:54

The husband contributes more financially whilst still having school holidays off to look after the children, the husband (and OP if they have serious look at their outgoings to prioritise childcare) have careers that they enjoy which makes them happy people and better parents. Neither of them would resent each other. Surely if OP’s husband gets a promotion then this takes the strain off her having to return to work so quickly? I’m just struggling to understand the negatives other than ‘it’s not what we agreed’. Or maybe I’m just supportive of my husbands career. We both have careers and we both pull our weight when we’re not working and at home with our kids. If he’s not doing that he needs a talking to but it’s not hard. I have friends whose husbands are in the military and are away for months at a time. It’s not ideal but they just get on with it (and still have their own careers)

sandyhappypeople · 30/11/2023 20:45

MrsAzza · 30/11/2023 20:42

I can’t be bothered to read the whole thread and life isn’t an already written book. Her husband’s had a great opportunity come up that wasn’t planned which will benefit the family in the long term so why would you not try to accommodate that?! If the shoe was on the other foot and it was the woman being presented with this opportunity the views would be different! She can work on her career also - with adequate childcare. This doesn’t sound like a family who would struggle to afford childcare. They’re either career people (and they make sacrifices to do that), or they’re not. OP said she wanted to spend more time with her children then said she wanted a career. Can’t keep up with contradictions!

Edited

What's the benefit to the family in the long run though, I feel like I'm missing something here?

MrsAzza · 30/11/2023 20:42

I can’t be bothered to read the whole thread and life isn’t an already written book. Her husband’s had a great opportunity come up that wasn’t planned which will benefit the family in the long term so why would you not try to accommodate that?! If the shoe was on the other foot and it was the woman being presented with this opportunity the views would be different! She can work on her career also - with adequate childcare. This doesn’t sound like a family who would struggle to afford childcare. They’re either career people (and they make sacrifices to do that), or they’re not. OP said she wanted to spend more time with her children then said she wanted a career. Can’t keep up with contradictions!

ZiriForGood · 30/11/2023 20:36

MrsAzza · 30/11/2023 20:19

Whilst I do sympathise with the situation to some extent, for working families the reality is you don’t really see your children much, except at weekends. That’s just how life is. Doesn’t sound like either of you work weekends so that is your child time? Having a career isn’t really compatible with spending lots of time with your children outside of that. It’s a sacrifice you have to make.
Considering how much you will earn combined if your husband gets this job, I assume it’s more than enough to pay for a nanny? For most working parents the issue is they can’t afford not to work but the childcare pretty much eats up any expendable income. It sounds like you’re in an envious position. Once you’ve sorted your childcare out there’s no reason why you can’t both have a career. Oh and if you can afford it, get a cleaner so you don’t have to worry about keeping your house tidy when you should be spending time with your kids. If you want to spend more time with your kids during the week, it’s you that needs to put your career on hold. But then I say this as a mother of two young children who works four days a week and would love to work five days if I could afford the additional childcare. I am happy the time with my children is at weekends 😂

Edited

If you read the OP's updates, you would know more about their finances and why "just hire a nanny" isn't a good advice.
And you would know, that the OP did put her career on hold for years now and the original agreement was that he would take the time off work and she will be able to work on her career.

sandyhappypeople · 30/11/2023 20:32

I may be missing something here but I don't understand why OP is getting so much flack over this, he agreed to a third child, it was planned for, everything is working fine, they've got a good plan for the future. Why would you want to suddenly work more, and work weekends only for the children to be looked after by nannies? It's not for the money, as the extra pay is wasted on childcare to compensate.

I think he should stick where he is while the kids are so small, for the next 3-4 years, but at that point he should be able to do what he likes in terms of career progression, and OP should fully support it which it sounds like that was the original plan anyway.

OP out-earns him massively, so even if he took the promotion, what is the point putting everyone through all the stress when you don't need to? It will take a toll on DH as a LOT more work, and out of the house a lot more than now, it will take a toll on the children as they aren't seeing their parents as much, and it will take a toll on OP, as she will have to pickup even more of the slack at home, they will all have much less down time if he takes this job. Bottom line is, OP is the one that needs to have a healthy career as she is the one financially shoring up this house of cards. If the sexes were reversed I'd think exactly the same.

At this point in time I think you need to think about what will make your lives better and your children's lives better, unless their is a massive immediate benefit to this HOD job then it can definitely wait for a few years, he wouldn't have any flexibility in the job to adequately support his family so it makes no sense for him to take it at this time.

Carriemac · 30/11/2023 20:20

Codlingmoths · 29/11/2023 22:00

Hmmm. I would be honest and say 1. I have supported your career so much. I have sacrificed leave, flexed my career to be the one carrying the load at home, and I can’t point to anywhere you have done this for me. It is useful to have you home in the holidays , but it isn’t you making a specific sacrifices it’s your job, and I am afraid we won’t even get that with three and you being hod- you will probably tell me you MUST be in school half the holidays and cannot look after our children. I am feeling pretty bitter as I thought it was my turn to get some support.
2.given that, here’s what I cannot do. I cannot cut my maternity leave short, you aren’t supportive enough. I cannot take on more. You have no idea how thinly I’ve been stretched and I have nothing else to give.
3 also, this means we will need more childcare , a nanny probably. If you add in school holiday childcare are we poorer for your promotion? I can’t flex anymore.
4 I am so bitter that you wouldn’t take parental leave if you did this. I really thought our relationship was going to support me for a change. Now I suspect it’s the opposite and you will expect even more from me, and I don’t have it to give it to you.

Well said

niclw · 30/11/2023 20:20

I haven't read all of the posts above but I just wanted to share my opinion as it may allow you both to do what you want.

I work in a school where the leadership team have a belief that family is important too. When I moved to the school my dc was 11 months old and I dropped back down to teaching position. The HOD position came up within 6 months and I applied and got it. I'm a single mum with no family nearby and all of my friends are teachers too. I do everything myself and still manage to do a HOD position. As HOD I get extra free lessons to enable me to complete the extra work. However there are periods of time when the allocated lessons are not enough but there are also times when I don't need to use those free lessons to complete the HOD role so I use them for other things. It is definitely manageable to complete a large proportion of the workload in school hours. Your DH if appointed may have an extra meeting once a half term after school or something similar but he should be able to continue as he currently is working hours wise.

Additionally, if he enjoys his current school, I advise he applies for the HOD job there. I've worked in a few schools where they don't care about staff wellbeing so you wouldn't want him to take a HOD job in one of those schools and then find that he is miserable and overworked because he had to change schools. He should apply while the opportunity is available. I wish him hood luck with his application.

MrsAzza · 30/11/2023 20:19

Whilst I do sympathise with the situation to some extent, for working families the reality is you don’t really see your children much, except at weekends. That’s just how life is. Doesn’t sound like either of you work weekends so that is your child time? Having a career isn’t really compatible with spending lots of time with your children outside of that. It’s a sacrifice you have to make.
Considering how much you will earn combined if your husband gets this job, I assume it’s more than enough to pay for a nanny? For most working parents the issue is they can’t afford not to work but the childcare pretty much eats up any expendable income. It sounds like you’re in an envious position. Once you’ve sorted your childcare out there’s no reason why you can’t both have a career. Oh and if you can afford it, get a cleaner so you don’t have to worry about keeping your house tidy when you should be spending time with your kids. If you want to spend more time with your kids during the week, it’s you that needs to put your career on hold. But then I say this as a mother of two young children who works four days a week and would love to work five days if I could afford the additional childcare. I am happy the time with my children is at weekends 😂

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 30/11/2023 19:57

I commented waaay at the top of the thread, can't believe this is getting heated! It's not that contentious...

Another point to bear in mind, I think, is that it's generally the case that the early years are most demanding on the mother (for obvious reasons). In your case, with a DH who will be teaching at the school your children attend or will attend, I think you can fairly expect the tables to turn.

My experience was thus: it was almost all on my shoulders in years 0-5 for each of our DC. As they grew, developed interests (not mine) and academic needs which DH could help with better than I could, he took over. We're now at a point where, aside from school hours + extra-curricular hours (which doesn't actually leave very many hours during term time), DH does about 60% of what needs to be done and I do 40%. We could change that balance, but this is what works best for each member of the family.

With a DH working at your DCs' school, I would think he will be doing all drop offs and pick ups, doing the bulk of school admin (perhaps not filling in slips and getting sports kit ready, but all the interface with school at least), helping with homework, and all the schoolwork-related support/ pep-talking/ confidence-building/ direction-giving etc, not to mention GCSE, A-Level and University admissions. That's all stuff that will appear once your eldest DC hits about 10/11yo and go on for many years seeing as you have 3 DC. It's not always as time consuming as breast-feeding and nappy changing (although it can be), but it's certainly MUCH more emotionally and intellectually demanding!

All this to say, perhaps take a longer-term view if you're still bristling at it being his turn to compromise. You've got a long, long way to go. It may actually suit you to have a higher-up DH in the DCs' school!

sugarandsweetener · 30/11/2023 19:56

* I said I have ( as in I know people who haven’t compromised or sacrificed in terms of career due to having children). *

because they never actually wanted to progress their career?
or they have achieved career progress regardless of having children and not had to make a single sacrifice or
compromise to do so?

it isn’t clear

MummyJ36 · 30/11/2023 19:50

OP I’m sorry you’re getting a bit of a bashing by certain posters. I think probably if you weren’t pregnant with DC3 this wouldn’t be such a difficult situation. You feel very vulnerable when you’re pregnant and to have the goalposts changed at such a key time is incredibly unsettling so I totally understand where you are coming from.

This isn’t a black and white situation but I wonder what would happen if you sat your husband down and said you really, truly didn’t want him to go for this job. What would his response be? Perhaps he doesn’t realise how much this is impacting you? Also 3 kids will be a different dynamic and perhaps he hasn’t quite thought through the implications of this.

It is natural for him to want to progress in his career but sometimes having kids means Lamont sacrifices. Sometimes you can’t have it all. And maybe he needs to understand that.

You sound like you have a good marriage beyond this so I do think it is worth laying it on the table, telling him how hard you are finding this and asking if he can come up with a genuine solution that works for both of you.

Riverstep · 30/11/2023 19:47

sugarandsweetener · 30/11/2023 19:40

but this latest post of yours directly contradicts your post where you say you’ve known people to make
no career sacrifice or compromise at all?

if they never wanted to progress anyway… then no sacrifice or compromise made by them not progressing

I have no idea what you are talking about. The op said shes not met anyone who hasn’t had to compromise or make sacrifices. I said I have ( as in I know people who haven’t compromised or sacrificed in terms of career due to having children).

sugarandsweetener · 30/11/2023 19:40

Riverstep · 30/11/2023 19:16

Health care. Continuing to work is a requirement of your regulatory body anyway and you just get left behind in terms of promotions unless you put yourself out there. Some people are happy to stay as a lower band whilst their children are young, but others are not. I know quite a few staff members who secured a promotion whilst on six months maternity leave, returning to work in new managerial roles or clinical training posts.

but this latest post of yours directly contradicts your post where you say you’ve known people to make
no career sacrifice or compromise at all?

if they never wanted to progress anyway… then no sacrifice or compromise made by them not progressing

Doone22 · 30/11/2023 19:40

If you're earning 5x his salary then you can clearly afford extra help. His new job isn't just about money is it? It's about career opportunities. Why would you support him all this time but now say no stay in your place. You wouldn't like it if you were told by him to limit yourself when you actually want to start flying.
If you are already stretched and stressed and wanted to spend more time with kids that's on you. He clearly doesn't. Let him do his career but have that whole conversation about the balance you need or want. Why don't you start working fewer days or shorter hours if that's what you want. If you want to concentrate on your career too get a nanny.

socialdilemmawhattodo · 30/11/2023 19:35

Vinrouge4 · 30/11/2023 19:19

I can understand you helping out your parents who are doing childcare but 700 to his each month is a lot. Can they not downsize? It is a lot to rely on your child to keep you in an accustomed manner. Is he an only child? Is there anyone else who can help out?

Reading this thread - this has also been my main Q. Many of your other costs/choices are driven by your actual life with DC. The costs of supporting both sets of parents are not. That really is one to challenge with both sets.

NameChangeBonus · 30/11/2023 19:33

I would encourage him to go for the promotion and make it work as a family. Sounds like he’s worked hard for it.

Vinrouge4 · 30/11/2023 19:19

I can understand you helping out your parents who are doing childcare but 700 to his each month is a lot. Can they not downsize? It is a lot to rely on your child to keep you in an accustomed manner. Is he an only child? Is there anyone else who can help out?

Riverstep · 30/11/2023 19:16

sugarandsweetener · 30/11/2023 18:48

what profession or job?

Health care. Continuing to work is a requirement of your regulatory body anyway and you just get left behind in terms of promotions unless you put yourself out there. Some people are happy to stay as a lower band whilst their children are young, but others are not. I know quite a few staff members who secured a promotion whilst on six months maternity leave, returning to work in new managerial roles or clinical training posts.

sugarandsweetener · 30/11/2023 18:48

Riverstep · 30/11/2023 18:36

That’s interesting , I have.

what profession or job?

Epidote · 30/11/2023 18:44

As soon as you are both happy any arrangements will do. However it seems like he is been getting ready for this and hold that back can do more harm to the relationship that other thing.
You are very hands on and successful, he seems that he finally had found a job he is enjoying after a lot. You know him best. Can he hold resent toward that decision in the future?

Riverstep · 30/11/2023 18:36

NCforthis235 · 30/11/2023 17:34

@Riverstep I have never met a single person IRL who has not made career sacrifices / compromises due to having children.

That’s interesting , I have.

HunterBidensBurnerPhone · 30/11/2023 17:59

NCforthis235 · 29/11/2023 16:31

@BarbaraofSeville I think my point is that he hasn't held his career back. I've been the one making the sacrifices to allow him to retrain and start the new career. Now I feel it's my turn (once I've popped the final baby out!).

Well which do you want? Do you want a third baby or do you want to advance your career? Because it's a total contradiction to try and do both at the same time.

sugarandsweetener · 30/11/2023 17:54

NCforthis235 · 30/11/2023 17:48

I have already agreed my maternity leave. I will have 6 full months, which feels like an eternity (in a good way!). The plan was then for DH to take one term's worth of SPL, then baby will go 2 days/week with the nanny, 1 day a week with grandparents and a day a week with each of us from c.10months. I would rather baby didn't go to 3 days a week with the nanny at 6 months old, but it wouldn't be the end of the world if he did proceed with the HOD job.

bingo

solution

sorted

at 6 months… nanny for an extra day covered very easily by his additional days work

NCforthis235 · 30/11/2023 17:49

@sugarandsweetener yes - more time off with the children during maternity leave. The status quo works well in terms of flexibility and time with the kids. I don't like the travel/night away but it's worth it for the other bits.

OP posts: