Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask DH not to go for promotion?

408 replies

NCforthis235 · 29/11/2023 16:13

Sorry for long thread but there is context and don't want to drip feed.

DH is a teacher and has recently had a "tap" to apply for HOD job at his school for next September.

I am the breadwinner (earning c.5x DH's salary) but there are elements of his job which contribute massively in financial and non-financial ways (huge discount on school fees, DH does all childcare during school holidays).

I am pregnant with DC3, due in the spring and have made big sacrifices for him to pursue his teaching career. I went back to work after 3 months with DC1, and 6 weeks after DC2 because he was doing a degree and teacher training so I needed to earn. I have stayed in my current job longer than I would otherwise have done because the flexibility is amazing, but I have to do a night away a week from the kids and a long commute either end. Whenever the kids are sick during term time, it is me who juggles as his job is less flexible.

We are finally settling into a routine but I am stretched/often struggling. I do school drop off and pick up 2x a week on my WFH days (plus on my day off - I work 80%), spend a couple of hours with the kids then finish my work day once DH is home from school. It's working, but it's not easy.

The HOD job would involve him moving from 80% to full time as well as significantly more admin to do before/after school. Which ultimately would involve us needing a nanny for an extra day (which would more than eat up the pay bump for him) and add significantly more strain on me when I already feel like I'm just getting by.

He also wouldn't be able to take shared parental leave as we had planned for Christmas term next year. I've said I think we should just focus on stability during the early years and spending as much time with the kids as possible, and that the HOD is likely to come up again at some point. Once new baby is at pre-school, I am likely to want to look at different job options which would be made a lot easier if DH just stayed where he was for a few years. He's saying that we both worked hard and sacrificed a lot for his career and that he now wants to climb the ladder and start taking some of the financial load off of me. AIBU?

OP posts:
justasking111 · 01/12/2023 16:13

At our private school teachers putting three children through school, the benefit in kind is substantial.

Saharafordessert · 01/12/2023 16:10

That type of promotion may not come up often especially in the private sector and if you really are keen for your children to stay at that particular school then I think DH should go for it now.

Grumpystripes · 01/12/2023 14:00

WrongSwanson · 01/12/2023 08:46

If he ever wants to be HOD before the children reach school leaving age then he does need to do it now though, as he is tied to that school apparently so they can get reduced fees, and a HOD could easily stay in post for many years if not the rest of their career. Another chance any time soon isn't guaranteed

(It would be entirely different if he was free to move schools)

This is a really key point imo. The op is thinking about the difficulties of the next year and completely ignoring the fact that this will be her husband's life for the next 20 years plus unless he is allowed to move schools and they pay out of normal income for whichever children are still there. The costs of doing so though are likely to dwarf the costs of a nanny for an extra day a week.

Montelukast · 01/12/2023 13:14

I agree with many of the comments saying you need to outsource - cleaner, nanny, etc. sounds like you have the income to pay for those things. Either that or do it yourself and lose your pay.

cockadoodledandy · 01/12/2023 11:30

Foreverexhausted1 · 29/11/2023 16:33

This is what I was going to say.

I think you should support your husband and find other solutions to childcare and life pressures. This could lead to resentment further down the line especially as you were the driving force for a 3rd child. You want a family and a career, it's not unreasonable for your DH to also want that.

Agree. If it was a man expecting or asking a woman to settle for a lower role there would be feminist uproar. This is what equality looks like.

Just because you earn more doesn’t mean he has to settle for less when a promotion is possible.

Maybe you go up to 80% over 5 days instead of over 4, to give you a bit more flexibility and time each day.

Yes you sacrificed to allow him to train, but did you think he’d be happy to sit in a mid level role forever just because it’s easy?

JFDIYOLO · 01/12/2023 10:07

How old are the parents? Are they working? Are they disabled? Supporting them as well as your growing family looks like a giant burden.

If they can't afford their house they need to downsize and stop expecting you to fund it.

WrongSwanson · 01/12/2023 08:46

ReadingSoManyThreads · 01/12/2023 00:14

100% this @sandyhappypeople !! Well said.

If he ever wants to be HOD before the children reach school leaving age then he does need to do it now though, as he is tied to that school apparently so they can get reduced fees, and a HOD could easily stay in post for many years if not the rest of their career. Another chance any time soon isn't guaranteed

(It would be entirely different if he was free to move schools)

3Tunes · 01/12/2023 08:04

OP DH is in quite a strong negotiating position here. If they advertise now, they won’t get an external candidate for next term. Maybe for the summer? But they would be new and need to learn the ropes.

Or, they could have him for a bit, then him go on SPL knowing he was coming back and had planned in an excellent handover and cover. They already know him and like him. Surely that’s less of a risk for them.

Has he even had that conversation- saying he’d love to apply but the SPL is personally very important, he’s thought of some ways to make it work. He doesn’t have to say it’s a deal breaker, just imply that he may not choose to apply if the SPL is an absolute no. Then go quiet for a bit and see what happens. Seniors will discuss and I suspect come to the conclusion, given they’ve tapped him up, that they will at least negotiate a bit on SPL.

Also, I’ve read the whole thread and YANBU. If you weren’t subsidising DHs parents so heavily this would work. But you are and it doesn’t. And that’s the choice he has made unilaterally, by the sound of it.

User890976 · 01/12/2023 07:59

ZiriForGood · 30/11/2023 23:52

I think this sums up this thread - many posters don't accept the information that OP's career took a slow down for the family just because she earns good money anyway.

Obviously, she managed to get on that level earlier, and remained there, because as a family they didn't wanted to risk changing jobs both in the same time while having small children.

You’ve hit the nail on the head @ZiriForGood

that and also I think people believe because she earns good money she isn’t allowed to want a work life balance and should just be happy with having her young children looked after by a nanny full time 🙄

MrsAzza · 01/12/2023 07:46

Exactly. Why would a family want to put all this financial pressure on one person when both can earn good money? Long term that makes no sense!

ReadingSoManyThreads · 01/12/2023 00:14

sandyhappypeople · 30/11/2023 23:24

You're not wrong, monetary wise it's short term pain for long term gain (not much gain though!), but he'll never get that time back away from the kids, I know people are saying he will resent OP, but if I was OP I think I'd resent him a little for choosing career 'advancement' over what's in the family's best interest.

I work very flexibly , I own my own company and have a toddler, I would NEVER actively choose to go back to full time 5 days a week away from the home + one morning a weekend + admin duties over and above that during home hours. I think lockdown changed a lot of people perspectives on work, it certainly did mine and now with a child, I would never sacrifice time with her unless it was completely necessary.

He doesn't need to do it at this time, or even at all!, He wants to, which is fair enough, but wants don't really trump needs, especially to the detriment to your family life, if his DW can earn 5x his salary working 4 days a week and happily shares all the bounty equally, he'd be mad to rock the boat, they've got a good thing going as it is, why upset everything.

100% this @sandyhappypeople !! Well said.

ZiriForGood · 30/11/2023 23:52

MrsAzza · 30/11/2023 22:30

I don’t think you can really say her career has ever really been on the back burner when she earns over £100k working the equivalent of 4 days a week. Those jobs don’t just land in your lap!

Edited

I think this sums up this thread - many posters don't accept the information that OP's career took a slow down for the family just because she earns good money anyway.

Obviously, she managed to get on that level earlier, and remained there, because as a family they didn't wanted to risk changing jobs both in the same time while having small children.

WrongSwanson · 30/11/2023 23:41

sandyhappypeople · 30/11/2023 23:24

You're not wrong, monetary wise it's short term pain for long term gain (not much gain though!), but he'll never get that time back away from the kids, I know people are saying he will resent OP, but if I was OP I think I'd resent him a little for choosing career 'advancement' over what's in the family's best interest.

I work very flexibly , I own my own company and have a toddler, I would NEVER actively choose to go back to full time 5 days a week away from the home + one morning a weekend + admin duties over and above that during home hours. I think lockdown changed a lot of people perspectives on work, it certainly did mine and now with a child, I would never sacrifice time with her unless it was completely necessary.

He doesn't need to do it at this time, or even at all!, He wants to, which is fair enough, but wants don't really trump needs, especially to the detriment to your family life, if his DW can earn 5x his salary working 4 days a week and happily shares all the bounty equally, he'd be mad to rock the boat, they've got a good thing going as it is, why upset everything.

I'm the main family breadwinner (by some way) and have recently been diagnosed with a complex condition

Thankfully I can work for now, and thankfully we got a house we could afford on the lower income if needed, but it has made me very sure that it is risky for all sorts of reasons not to allow both careers to advance if possible ( DH has progressed in his too thankfully, so we will be ok if I need to stop)

Redundancy/loss of love for the job/mental health etc - one day op might be very glad she let her DH advance his career

My dad worked 5 full days and at least half a day at the weekend, but he made the most of the time with us, and my parents paid for a nanny and a cleaner, and I never felt I missed out. He was probably at least far more present that the dad with a smaller job who spends a day a week watching football /on the golf course. That day and half (plus some bedtimes in the week) he fully focussed on us. The worst bit was when my mum wasn't working when we were tiny and the stress /pressure and fact my mum clearly longed for more. She was a great mum but she was much happier in herself once she was pushing forward in her career again

And OP DH will be around in school holidays too! So overall it would balance out

And if he is stuck with that particular school it's quite likely this promotion might not come up again for a decade or longer.

EdgarAllenRaven · 30/11/2023 23:27

I don’t think it’s fair that you hold him back now, you should get a Nanny and find a new way for the family to work… could you take a longer maternity leave this time to have some kid time? And then start afresh

sandyhappypeople · 30/11/2023 23:24

WrongSwanson · 30/11/2023 23:01

It's short term pain for long term gain though
As they seem committed to him staying at this school to ensure their children get subsidised education, then his choices for career progression are much more constrained. If he was free to move schools it wouldn't be such a "now or never" issue

You're not wrong, monetary wise it's short term pain for long term gain (not much gain though!), but he'll never get that time back away from the kids, I know people are saying he will resent OP, but if I was OP I think I'd resent him a little for choosing career 'advancement' over what's in the family's best interest.

I work very flexibly , I own my own company and have a toddler, I would NEVER actively choose to go back to full time 5 days a week away from the home + one morning a weekend + admin duties over and above that during home hours. I think lockdown changed a lot of people perspectives on work, it certainly did mine and now with a child, I would never sacrifice time with her unless it was completely necessary.

He doesn't need to do it at this time, or even at all!, He wants to, which is fair enough, but wants don't really trump needs, especially to the detriment to your family life, if his DW can earn 5x his salary working 4 days a week and happily shares all the bounty equally, he'd be mad to rock the boat, they've got a good thing going as it is, why upset everything.

RainbowNinja77 · 30/11/2023 23:11

What will he get for it? TLR 1 or 2? It will be around £5000 a year more for a whole lot of pain.

having just quit a job because of the extra management roles driving me to burn out, I say don’t do it. If you earn more, let him stay where he is.

WrongSwanson · 30/11/2023 23:01

sandyhappypeople · 30/11/2023 22:58

It would be interesting to know that but I definitely wouldn't have a different opinion, to me this makes no difference if op was the man or the woman, the ONLY circumstance I would ever form a different opinion is if there was an element of financial abuse with such mismatched earnings.. but that's not the case here, OP and DH seemingly combine into a central 'pot'.

It's not just about the money, DH taking this job, aside from being no more financially better off, would be spending at least 15-20 hours extra a week working, be less present for the children, less present for OP and more of the household responsibility would fall to her, would have to work one morning a weekend so stops any flexibility there, and he'd have to give up his 3 months leave with the baby as the new role won't allow it.

That's a lot of sacrifices for no real reward, there's no benefit to the family at this time, and if this was a man or a woman I'd say they were selfish for pursuing it now, they've chosen to have a young family, he needs to stay stable in his career and hope for advancement in the future.. it's not ideal for him, admittedly, it must be a horrible place to be, but you simply can't sacrifice your family's happiness for no reward.

Unless anyone can see any real benefit to him taking this job, I really don't get it.

It's short term pain for long term gain though
As they seem committed to him staying at this school to ensure their children get subsidised education, then his choices for career progression are much more constrained. If he was free to move schools it wouldn't be such a "now or never" issue

sandyhappypeople · 30/11/2023 22:58

WrongSwanson · 30/11/2023 22:41

I think if this was reversed everyone would be saying they needed to make it work so she didn't have to pass up the opportunity.

They sound bound to this school so his scope for promotion is going to be very constrained already.

They could make it work if they had a sensible budget and weren't subsidising family

It would be interesting to know that but I definitely wouldn't have a different opinion, to me this makes no difference if op was the man or the woman, the ONLY circumstance I would ever form a different opinion is if there was an element of financial abuse with such mismatched earnings.. but that's not the case here, OP and DH seemingly combine into a central 'pot'.

It's not just about the money, DH taking this job, aside from being no more financially better off, would be spending at least 15-20 hours extra a week working, be less present for the children, less present for OP and more of the household responsibility would fall to her, would have to work one morning a weekend so stops any flexibility there, and he'd have to give up his 3 months leave with the baby as the new role won't allow it.

That's a lot of sacrifices for no real reward, there's no benefit to the family at this time, and if this was a man or a woman I'd say they were selfish for pursuing it now, they've chosen to have a young family, he needs to stay stable in his career and hope for advancement in the future.. it's not ideal for him, admittedly, it must be a horrible place to be, but you simply can't sacrifice your family's happiness for no reward.

Unless anyone can see any real benefit to him taking this job, I really don't get it.

DistantSkye · 30/11/2023 22:58

This seems somewhat melodramatic in places. It's teaching, not running the international space station! People manage to teach and have families fine.

I hope you manage to get the resolution you want. If it were me I don't think I'd hold back on the promoted post. He'll resent you in the long run.
I'll be totally honest though, I don't get all your posts about the "sacrifices" you made with a short maternity leave. Surely that was just questionable family planning? Given that a degree is 3/4 years and teacher training is only a year, it seems odd to actively plan your family around that and not just hold off for a year or so? And also seems unusual that with an income 5x a teachers salary, knowing you were planning for a baby, you didn't manage to save anything at all to allow you to take more than 6 weeks off? Something feels a bit off with all this...

MrsAzza · 30/11/2023 22:50

Also, as we all know childcare costs are short term, as painful as they are at the time. But the career is long term…

Justanothermum42 · 30/11/2023 22:50

Support your husband. It’s that simple.

MrsAzza · 30/11/2023 22:43

They already pay £1500 a month for a nanny so if they stopped giving away money unnecessarily to parents that’s £2500 a month to childcare. If DH wants a career he’ll have to stop paying his parents…

MrsAzza · 30/11/2023 22:42

Exactly this. There is no reason with their financial situation they can’t both have the career they want. They are extremely lucky. No one person in a marriage is more important than the other.

sandyhappypeople · 30/11/2023 22:41

MrsAzza · 30/11/2023 22:13

Also for those saying they can’t afford a nanny. Think they need to look at their outgoings…

£1200pcm essential bills
£700pcm support for DH parents
£250pcm support for my parents

Dont know many essential bills that come to £1200 (unless this includes shopping)
Wouldn’t need to pay parents £1000 if you had a full time nanny. Including what is already paid to a nanny this would be £2500 a month for a nanny/childcare..

Why don't you just read the thread instead of trying to cherry pick information like a 'gotcha'.. it won't take you very long to read OPs posts. She explains the nanny costs (£1000 a month for a full time nanny wouldn't even scratch the surface) and parental support payment for DH parents are inflexible and not for childcare.

We live in a very modest 3 bed semi with one child and our essential bills are at least £800, that includes food and dog food.. you know.. essentials.

WrongSwanson · 30/11/2023 22:41

sandyhappypeople · 30/11/2023 22:35

absolutely, I wholeheartedly agree, but only if it fits in with the rest of the family's needs at that time. OP isn't saying she will never support him advancing his career, in fact for the last 5 years she's done nothing but. A career advancement is only worth doing if it brings in benefits for everyone involved, if it's actually making you worse off from a time with family and from a financial standpoint.. it ain't much of an advancement.

It would be once the kids are older, it's just the wrong time right now.

I think if this was reversed everyone would be saying they needed to make it work so she didn't have to pass up the opportunity.

They sound bound to this school so his scope for promotion is going to be very constrained already.

They could make it work if they had a sensible budget and weren't subsidising family