Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask DH not to go for promotion?

408 replies

NCforthis235 · 29/11/2023 16:13

Sorry for long thread but there is context and don't want to drip feed.

DH is a teacher and has recently had a "tap" to apply for HOD job at his school for next September.

I am the breadwinner (earning c.5x DH's salary) but there are elements of his job which contribute massively in financial and non-financial ways (huge discount on school fees, DH does all childcare during school holidays).

I am pregnant with DC3, due in the spring and have made big sacrifices for him to pursue his teaching career. I went back to work after 3 months with DC1, and 6 weeks after DC2 because he was doing a degree and teacher training so I needed to earn. I have stayed in my current job longer than I would otherwise have done because the flexibility is amazing, but I have to do a night away a week from the kids and a long commute either end. Whenever the kids are sick during term time, it is me who juggles as his job is less flexible.

We are finally settling into a routine but I am stretched/often struggling. I do school drop off and pick up 2x a week on my WFH days (plus on my day off - I work 80%), spend a couple of hours with the kids then finish my work day once DH is home from school. It's working, but it's not easy.

The HOD job would involve him moving from 80% to full time as well as significantly more admin to do before/after school. Which ultimately would involve us needing a nanny for an extra day (which would more than eat up the pay bump for him) and add significantly more strain on me when I already feel like I'm just getting by.

He also wouldn't be able to take shared parental leave as we had planned for Christmas term next year. I've said I think we should just focus on stability during the early years and spending as much time with the kids as possible, and that the HOD is likely to come up again at some point. Once new baby is at pre-school, I am likely to want to look at different job options which would be made a lot easier if DH just stayed where he was for a few years. He's saying that we both worked hard and sacrificed a lot for his career and that he now wants to climb the ladder and start taking some of the financial load off of me. AIBU?

OP posts:
likethislikethat · 02/12/2023 04:38

Just seen you;re financial breakdown and that you're some way short of £250/300k.

You need to consider swapping out the part time nanny for a live in.

The wrap around additional help does come at a cost of some privacy but if you have space to accommodate then you win massively.

I'd be more concerned about your husband losing the Saturday morning really.

Also, and don't take this the wrong way, you really don't earn enough to have 3 kids in private school and that desire will suck you dry financially for the next 20 years.

I'm just finished paying about £35k fees a year plus the additional £5k to £10k a year for trips and other "essentials" and that is about £67k of pre tax income. Triple that and you're talking about requiring £200k of pretax income just for school.

Invest £100k+ as an alternative and send the kids to a good but free alternative and they have millions each in investments to start their lives.

Just throwing it out there.

Equally, the cost means you are forever tied to work, your pensions and investments of your own are weak (I don't see 2 x £20k into ISAs each year ?) and if your husband wants to move higher up at another school, you are moving house or losing the discounted school fees.

likethislikethat · 02/12/2023 04:24

NCforthis235 · 29/11/2023 16:20

@idontlikealdi sounds like a very similar situation. I do worry that its not "just" HOD - it's very clear that he wants to climb further (which I'd love to fully support) but financially he will never earn enough in education to allow me to take a step properly back from work.

Really ?

The head at our independent school is on more that £250k plus add ons and the head at the non fee paying local school (was best in the country) is on a similar package.

I'm assuming he makes £40k or so and you;re on £200k ?

Mamanyt · 02/12/2023 00:23

I cannot disagree with your reasoning, it is quite sound. My concern is, quite often turning down a promotion, especially one that comes at a crucial junction, may move your husband to the bottom of the list for future promotions. It isn't fair, but it happens far, far too often. So do take that into account, both of you.

ErinBell01 · 01/12/2023 23:40

Exactly the question I was going to ask! Why have a third when things are just beginning to fall into place with your two getting a bit older. Did you not take into account him going for promotion and the impact a new baby would have on all the fine tuned arrangements?

Sometimes it's not about the money though, it's about job satisfaction and if your DH can hack it as a HOD then it seems a shame to stop him going for it. When you're happy for him to go for it in the future who knows where he could have been? Maybe you need to get a live in nanny and use up all the extra cash, and more perhaps, just to make it work. Once Number 3 is at school it will become easier.

ZiriForGood · 01/12/2023 21:30

jolaylasofia · 01/12/2023 17:19

If you are earning 5x teachers salary that 100k+ a year. What on Earth are you doing with it all to need him to work at all?

It is in the first post. As a part time teacher at this specific school, he brings home a significant reduction in school fees, easier way for the children to get in, and having school holidays off. If we give those benefits a monetary value, he is bringing home quite a lot (and counting from this base, the potential pay rise isn't really that significant)

EnidSpyton · 01/12/2023 21:29

In my experience, those claiming HoDs stay in post forever are not quite up to date with how things are in teaching these days.

HoD posts are middle management, not SLT. HoD responsibilities also take up a huge amount of time for not a massive amount of extra pay. It's probably the most thankless and overworked job in middle management and not one you'd want to stay in for too long.

Perhaps ten years ago you'd find HoDs who would stay in the post until retirement. But not anymore. For many people, it's a job they'll do for a few years before moving upwards, going back to the classroom or leaving the profession entirely.

Many of the top independent schools have advertised for HoDs for my subject multiple times over the past few years. HoDs in independent schools are expected to be ambitious and want to move up to Assistant Head within a short amount of time, and it is these sorts of people who are attracted to the role.

I can guarantee that the OP's husband would have the chance to apply again in his current school in two or three years' time and that would probably be the more appropriate time to make the move.

You really can't have it all and acting as if this is the only opportunity the OP's husband will ever have to better his career is both misguided and creating stress at a time when it's not needed in her and her husband's lives. There will be other chances to be promoted. It really doesn't have to be now.

Jolie12345 · 01/12/2023 21:24

You both have a right to pursue your careers. If he earns more, you can earn less so not fair to say he can’t progress because you earn more. If you earn 5 x a teacher salary you should be able to reduce your hours and live off less…would still be more than most.

Lookingatthesunset · 01/12/2023 21:12

whittingtonmum · 01/12/2023 20:20

I think you might want to take a good old look at your own expectations and decide if all this is really feasible. I would look specifically at: the expectation to send family members 1k a month, the expectation to put three kids through private school (assuming that this severely limits DHs workplace options & opportunities to seek promotion elsewhere because of the financial discount) & the expectation that you can have three young children and take a big step up in your career the minute baby is born (both of you). I reckon that you & DH only need to do away with one of the expectations above (family members don't get money while kids are small, kids don't go to private school, one of you delays their next career move) and you're sorted. None of these options are ideal but at least a couple are feasible and not the end of the world for most people ( unless your expectations are too high and you find it impossible to adjust them to changed circumstances).

You make so much sense!

whittingtonmum · 01/12/2023 20:20

I think you might want to take a good old look at your own expectations and decide if all this is really feasible. I would look specifically at: the expectation to send family members 1k a month, the expectation to put three kids through private school (assuming that this severely limits DHs workplace options & opportunities to seek promotion elsewhere because of the financial discount) & the expectation that you can have three young children and take a big step up in your career the minute baby is born (both of you). I reckon that you & DH only need to do away with one of the expectations above (family members don't get money while kids are small, kids don't go to private school, one of you delays their next career move) and you're sorted. None of these options are ideal but at least a couple are feasible and not the end of the world for most people ( unless your expectations are too high and you find it impossible to adjust them to changed circumstances).

Lookingatthesunset · 01/12/2023 20:15

BIossomtoes · 30/11/2023 21:47

which he could take in a few years when your kids are older.

The opportunity may never arise again. It’s a promotion in a school where they get reduced fees for their kids, for three kids from five to 18 that’s a LOT. He needs to stay in that school. If he turns down this promotion the opportunity may never arise again or, if it does he’s unlikely to be offered it again if he’s turned it down once.

^ this!

I imagine he never contemplated the possibility of promotion so early in his career, and this has thrown a curve ball into their previous agreement.

My DC1 is a teacher. Their HoD is early 30s and having a family. There's no way that the HoD is going to leave their post for years to come because it works. That means that there won't be a vacant HoD post in their school for several years, so there won't be another opportunity.

If the new HoD stays in post, for the sake of argument, for 10 years, OP's DH will have missed his chance potentially in that school. That will then impact on the children's education, and her DH will be trapped and unable to move up, even after the OP has moved up her own ladder.

There has got to be a way to manage this that gives both husband and wife opportunities in work, and allows them to parent their children.

It is not beyond the realms of possibility but it will involve a certain amount of sacrifice.

The monthly funds diverted to husband's parents is for me a huge sticking point. Are they helping out in any way in return? I get that there is money going monthly to the OP's parents because they are helping out with childcare. Maybe they could help a little more?

I think some form of compromise needs to be found, otherwise OP or her DH could easily become resentful here, which would have a negative effect on their marriage, and in turn, on their parenting.

As the parent of young adults, I would also say that the early years, while clearly important, and the foundation to their later life, are not actually as challenging as when they reach the teen years. There isn't in fact a time when they need you less - and my three are in their 20s.

MamblingOn · 01/12/2023 19:58

I tend to lurk more than join in on here but I couldn’t resist here because I don’t understand why people are getting on at OP. You earn what you earn and usually have financial commitments to match; it’s pretty unkind to be snide at someone asking for advice/ opinions because they have a good salary and you think money should be able to solve all their problems.

Anyway. I can see the argument from both sides. You’d made an agreement and seems like the third child was thought through together based on your circumstances. The arrangements sound like they’re working well but are clearly finely balanced so it’s not as easy as just “facilitate it” if it only stretches OP further. There’s only so many hours in a day. In most circumstances, I’d say it’s the wrong time and he should look again at HOD in a few years. HOWEVER, presumably all 3 kids will go to the school he teaches at so he’s tied to that school for a significant number of years (assuming you wouldn’t want to move them to follow the staff discount if he moved schools). If there’s only one department, realistically when will the job come up again? The next person might stick at it for decades. Thats what shifts the balance to trying to facilitate it on my opinion. But it shouldn’t be at any cost (OP’s well-being) when the status quo works, provides enough money and a good work/life balance and OP has already facilitated a career change at personal cost.

Jeannie88 · 01/12/2023 19:56

Does he really want to take this role? I can tell you from experience it's much more stressful and time consuming than being 0.8 as a teacher. Yes it's flattering to have a tap but got to look at the reality of it. He will get a couple or more free periods but loads more responsibility and work to do. A lot of people make it work but that involves extra paid care, unless you're lucky to have family to help and tbh the extra money from a responsibility point won't stretch far for this. If it was the other way around what would you think? My personal view is family life and work/home balance is far more important if you can do it, which sounds like you can with your income alone. Xx

Yourcatisnotsorry · 01/12/2023 19:42

The amount you are sending to PIL indefinitely seems insane. If they can’t afford their house they need to downsize.
can you not take a full year maternity leave? If you can pay AVCs into your pension your company may cover them while you are on leave so if you hike it up to 100% or whatever your scheme permits you can get ‘full pay’ though in pension rather than cash. 6 months mat leave is tough especially with 2 other kids.
But to answer your actual question, so long as he can arrange the cover needed extra. Nanny time etc. I would not hold him back from this.

EnidSpyton · 01/12/2023 19:02

I'm coming into this just from the perspective of your husband's opportunity to become HoD. I am a secondary teacher, former HoD, currently got my feet up just being back in the classroom 😉

By the sounds of things, he's either Physics or Chemistry, both of which are subjects in huge demand and short supply. If the HoD is for Physics, Chemistry or Science, then he is in a very good bargaining position with the school. If they want a January start for the HoD position, then they are desperate. In a fee paying school, not having a head of such a key department is a problem with presumably many students looking to do Medicine, Engineering etc and parents expecting top grades for the money they are investing. They will want someone they know and trust at the helm. It sounds like they've already made a mistake in the previous person they hired, so they will be inclined to go for an internal candidate. Better the devil you know.

All this considered, I think your husband could go for the job on the basis he can do it on a 0.8 contract. There's no reason why a HoD needs to be full time. Schools don't like managers not being full time, but if there is a strong second in department and the leadership in general is strong, it shouldn't ever be a problem to have one day a week when the HoD isn't in. When I was Head of Faculty, I measured my success by the fact that my department ran as smooth as clockwork whether I was there or not. A department that needs their HoD breathing down their neck or who can't do anything without help is one that is poorly led in the first place.

Your husband would need to build a case. He would have to go to the leadership with a plan for who will deputise for him on his day off, and emphasise how this will develop the expertise and skill within the department, making the department as a whole more successful. He would need to show that working part time as a HoD can work. Then, you can have it all.

That being said, if not now, doesn't mean not ever. In a large private secondary, there are always opportunities for promotion. He doesn't have to go down the academic route to be promoted - he could also become a Head of Year. These positions do come up regularly because people frequently use them as a springboard to promotions elsewhere.

I would also say that going for a HoD position after just three years in the classroom might be a little premature. In order to manage a department successfully on top of everything else means that you need to be able to teach with your eyes shut and be incredibly quick, efficient and expert at planning and marking. There is a lot of time taken up as HoD with meetings and admin he won't have any experience of doing, as well as dealing with parents, managing colleagues, and staying on top of all the examination preparations. The workload is only manageable if you can do the day-to-day with very little effort. I can't imagine after just three years in the job, your husband would be ready. He may be able to do the job, but it will be much harder on him at this stage in his teaching career than it would be in a couple of years' time. I might also add that a HoD needs to be able to support and mentor colleagues - can he really support other teachers with their teaching practice with so little classroom experience? I wouldn't be happy if my HoD only had three years' experience, myself. How would he be able to help me with a tricky class?

That's just my two penn'orth. Hopefully some food for thought. Good luck to you both!

Lookingatthesunset · 01/12/2023 18:28

Blanc4 · 01/12/2023 18:00

I can’t understand why people have kids to then leave them with a childminder or in a nursery or be rich enough to hire a nanny
why have a third !!

That's a lack of empathy and understanding on your part, not an error on the part of the parents!!

I think your post is highly insulting actually. I have three children. I will always have three children. I placed them in carefully chosen childcare to enable me to work.

This in turn enabled me to fund my pension which I am very much looking forward to claiming.

Maybe you should get out a little more...

cestlavielife · 01/12/2023 18:27

Blanc4 · 01/12/2023 18:00

I can’t understand why people have kids to then leave them with a childminder or in a nursery or be rich enough to hire a nanny
why have a third !!

Dont be silly
No one is giving them up or having 24 7 childcare

Shyam35 · 01/12/2023 18:20

If you have three young children in this climate, you will have no choice but to make sacrifices, unless you're a millionaire. He most definitely should go for the promotion, otherwise it will cause problems later down the line.

Gazelda · 01/12/2023 18:14

Blanc4 · 01/12/2023 18:00

I can’t understand why people have kids to then leave them with a childminder or in a nursery or be rich enough to hire a nanny
why have a third !!

Really?!

Blanc4 · 01/12/2023 18:00

I can’t understand why people have kids to then leave them with a childminder or in a nursery or be rich enough to hire a nanny
why have a third !!

pollymere · 01/12/2023 17:59

HOY jobs do seem to go to teachers far too early in my opinion. If he's in his third year, he's only just stopped being ECT. Full-time teachers get put under a whole load more pressure than part-timers. Suddenly you're expected to do double the duty and after-school things. If he doesn't have a tutor group, it strikes me that he won't realise how many bloomin' meetings you end up having before and after school with parents.

Don't make him feel bad that he earns less than you though. It's not his fault teachers should earn three times what they do. And he contributes with discounted fees.

Explain to him that you don't think the renumeration outweighs the work load and responsibilities. He will essentially potentially gain a 30% increase in workload and a 20% decrease in time off/planning time. I doubt he'll get a 30% increase in pay though! It's important he gets to spend time with his kids whilst they're small. There will be other opportunities to be HOY or similar when the kids are older.

masterblaster · 01/12/2023 17:59

Dear god, if this was a man asking about a woman, the unreasonableness would be at 90 %.

jolaylasofia · 01/12/2023 17:19

If you are earning 5x teachers salary that 100k+ a year. What on Earth are you doing with it all to need him to work at all?

Bean83ts · 01/12/2023 17:14

I think the woman’s also worked hard for it. Why is it always the women that make the sacrifices and have to make it work!

If he wants to go ahead Op cut Oh parents money and pay for an extra day nanny! He can’t have it all and expect you to figure it out

NoThanksymm · 01/12/2023 16:49

I think you can’t ask him not to. But you can ask how it’s going to work! You’re already probably pissing your boss off enough being the one always leaving for the kids, he needs to take on more childcare.

he doesn’t want to spend the time with the kids when they are young, that sucks! But sadly his choice.

but overall he sounds selfish, and insecure. And you’re totally allowed to feel that!

littlemousebigcheese · 01/12/2023 16:33

God people are being mean to you, I'm so sorry. From what I understand, you've made a lot of sacrifices such as taking a very short maternity leave, seeing your children less during the week etc for your husband to train in a new career.

If he's science or maths then him being offered HOD this early isn't surprising at all; it's hard to keep teachers and managing those departments is a thankless task that I wouldn't enjoy. As core subjects there is so much pressure from above, especially maths. If he's keen to progress maybe suggest the pastoral route - head of year, instead of the academic route, head of department, the TLR is the same but it's a much 'nicer' progression imo. Being head of smaller departments like sixth form only subjects or humanities is much less hideous than maths and i would seriously consider why they are offering it at this point. im guessing they've struggled to recruit. managing a department that is a core subject for the whole school is not something id ever take on that early in my career.