Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask DH not to go for promotion?

408 replies

NCforthis235 · 29/11/2023 16:13

Sorry for long thread but there is context and don't want to drip feed.

DH is a teacher and has recently had a "tap" to apply for HOD job at his school for next September.

I am the breadwinner (earning c.5x DH's salary) but there are elements of his job which contribute massively in financial and non-financial ways (huge discount on school fees, DH does all childcare during school holidays).

I am pregnant with DC3, due in the spring and have made big sacrifices for him to pursue his teaching career. I went back to work after 3 months with DC1, and 6 weeks after DC2 because he was doing a degree and teacher training so I needed to earn. I have stayed in my current job longer than I would otherwise have done because the flexibility is amazing, but I have to do a night away a week from the kids and a long commute either end. Whenever the kids are sick during term time, it is me who juggles as his job is less flexible.

We are finally settling into a routine but I am stretched/often struggling. I do school drop off and pick up 2x a week on my WFH days (plus on my day off - I work 80%), spend a couple of hours with the kids then finish my work day once DH is home from school. It's working, but it's not easy.

The HOD job would involve him moving from 80% to full time as well as significantly more admin to do before/after school. Which ultimately would involve us needing a nanny for an extra day (which would more than eat up the pay bump for him) and add significantly more strain on me when I already feel like I'm just getting by.

He also wouldn't be able to take shared parental leave as we had planned for Christmas term next year. I've said I think we should just focus on stability during the early years and spending as much time with the kids as possible, and that the HOD is likely to come up again at some point. Once new baby is at pre-school, I am likely to want to look at different job options which would be made a lot easier if DH just stayed where he was for a few years. He's saying that we both worked hard and sacrificed a lot for his career and that he now wants to climb the ladder and start taking some of the financial load off of me. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
clearspilt · 07/12/2023 11:29

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

sugarandsweetener · 04/12/2023 16:22

i suspect that either the DH has now been squeezed into saying he’s not interested in the promotion OR he’s digging his heels in (and i hope so!) and it’s stalemate. Either way… an update is unlikely

FlipFlop1987 · 04/12/2023 09:26

SecondUsername4me · 30/11/2023 15:50

Is this just one of those "you need to live within your means" situations?

  • you both choose to work part time
  • you both chose to have a third child
  • you both financially support two other households
  • the nanny works 2x 12.5 hour days yet the toddler also goes to nursery on those days
  • you both send your dc to private school

I'm seeing a lot of choice here.

I agree with this, there are glaring options, the two main ones being:

  • The nanny being paid when the preschooler isn’t even at home

  • Two sets of parents taking money from you at a cost of £1000 a month

The preschooler will only get older, most likely going into full time school in the next 12 months or so. It’s a fairly temporary issue.
The baby will obviously need childcare but in a high earning job, surely you get a decent maternity package? I work in public service on a very average £30k a year and get 26 weeks paid maternity. Did you really need to go back to work at 6 weeks with DC2 (assuming that was pre COL crisis so mortgage will have been half what it is now). Again the parents should be seriously reconsidering their setup if you had to leave your newborn to fund them. What on earth have they both done to need that much money a month at retirement age.

DistantSkye · 03/12/2023 16:47

@NCforthis235
Sorry if you've already addressed this but some points of this just seem a bit weird to me. You talk a lot about the sacrifices you've made with short maternity leaves... But was it not a joint decision to conceive or carry on with a pregnancy at the same time as your DH was at uni and training? Like you could have waited a year until PGDE was done. Or with your first pregnancy, it seems unusual that you weren't able to save anything in advance to have longer off? Even on a lowly teachers salary I managed to save enough for 7 months off (and it was unplanned so I didn't have time before!!). So on 5x that I'd imagine it wouldn't be too hard to save more.
I mean it may or may not be the right time for this promotion. But to blame all this on him when some of the decisions could have been yours seems a bit disingenuous.

1mabon · 02/12/2023 22:08

Hear hear, don't be so selfish.

SharSharBinks · 02/12/2023 20:02

If you were to separate down the line, it sounds like you already have a substantial salary. However, your husband may be struggling so I understand why he'd want to take steps to ensure financial independence/progress his career.

EnidSpyton · 02/12/2023 17:59

BIossomtoes · 02/12/2023 16:24

The vacancy is for a January start, it’s now December - where are they going to find a brilliant external candidate with far more experience who can start in the new year at a month’s notice?

Adverts for mid year HoDs usually specify January or April start. Independent school teachers need to give a whole term’s notice. So they will advertise/ be advertising for a Jan or April start, or even September for the right candidate, with an interim in between.

If this school is a top flight indie, which the OP seems to be suggesting, they will want to ensure they get the right person, not just the person who happened to be there at the right time. A key department such as Science needs a strong leader at its helm and someone with a very good grasp of exam board requirements. They are unlikely to parachute an inexperienced classroom teacher who’s been working p/t into the role on anything other than an interim basis. There will have to be a recruitment process as other teachers in the department will have every right to complain if there isn’t. I can’t imagine the OP’s husband is uniquely qualified for the position amongst his colleagues as he has so little experience. A top flight school is not going to have a core department full of newly qualified teachers.

BIossomtoes · 02/12/2023 16:24

The vacancy is for a January start, it’s now December - where are they going to find a brilliant external candidate with far more experience who can start in the new year at a month’s notice?

EnidSpyton · 02/12/2023 15:58

BIossomtoes · 02/12/2023 14:15

And yes, there will be other opportunities.

In this particular school? And, if there are, will they be available to him after refusing promotion? Turning down a promotion is often career suicide.

He hasn’t been offered the job. He’s been tapped to apply for the job. Some schools promote internally without an application/interview process but this isn’t common or best practice and I would be highly surprised if this was the procedure in a top independent boarding school of the type the OP’s husband works in. They need to be seen to be above board in their recruitment procedures as it is a major safeguarding risk if they’re not. He has been asked to go for it with no guarantee he will actually get it. A brilliant external candidate with far more experience may yet turn up which will make this whole situation go away anyway!

It would not be considered to be career suicide in teaching to turn down a HoD opportunity. HoD positions should not really be given to early career teachers - as the OP’s husband is - and I think the OP’s husband has been tapped for promotion because the school are in a tricky wicket with a vacancy for January rather than him being headhunted in the true sense of the term. The OP’s husband is currently a part time classroom teacher who is part time for family reasons. Turning down this opportunity because his wife is about to have a third child and also has a demanding job is a very valid reason to say thanks very much but not now.

And yes, there will be other opportunities in this school. Especially as the OP and her husband have tiny children and they want to send their children to the secondary school at which he works. That’s a commitment for the next 18 or so years! I can say with certainty that plenty of internal promotion opportunities will come up within that time frame. I would imagine every couple of years there will be movement to enable an upwards move of some nature. People don’t stay forever in schools anymore. It’s very rare to find teachers who have been in the same school their whole career.

LuckySantangelo35 · 02/12/2023 15:31

All those people saying there will be other opportunities… they may well not be.

parents do not need to martyr themselves at the alter of “family” all of the time - OP’s DH clearly has ambitions and aspirations and as a person in his own right - not just a parent - he needs to be able to go for it.

Teder · 02/12/2023 14:36

You are a high income family but the amount you pay your parents is significant. I don’t know if there are any cultural expectations in your situation but it does make things difficult for you. If at all possible, I do think this needs reviewing. You have 3 small children who take over the other adults - that’s just my opinion though. I know it’s easier said than done.

You and your husband need to consider whether keeping your children at this particular school is sensible. It ties him to his current job for 18 years which is approx when your youngest will finish secondary school. Of course your salaries may increase but what if he leaves that school with 3 sets of full school fees to pay? If he’s in it for the long haul, I reckon it’s good future planning to go for HOD. That said, your POV is completely valid and understandable as plans have changed. You have some serious financial plans to work out together. It’s not insurmountable but he needs to hear your views too.
Going back to work with a 6 week old is a huge sacrifice if it is your choice. I know you have joint money but you’re allowed to voice your opinions too.

Best of luck with everything, including the new little one.

BIossomtoes · 02/12/2023 14:15

And yes, there will be other opportunities.

In this particular school? And, if there are, will they be available to him after refusing promotion? Turning down a promotion is often career suicide.

TravelInHope · 02/12/2023 12:27

Magenta82 · 30/11/2023 07:26

What a nasty way to think.

Are people on high incomes not allowed to have problems or ask for advice?

Op has already said they have a mortgage, school fees and support family members. They have commitments to go with their income.

The DH agreed to stay stable to facilitate her career because it was his turn, she had done it for him.

Or are high earners not allowed to expect their partners to keep promises?

People on high incomes have the facility to use money to solve their problems.
The rest of us don’t. That’s the significant difference.

Zoomattheinn · 02/12/2023 12:04

Coming a bit late to this but I just wanted to say you sound like you are doing brilliantly. You’ve also spent time planning so whatever conversation you eventually have has a strong basis.
We have 3 kids, 2 careers - husband a doctor so he’s the higher earner though I had a high paid high profile job. (Fully time nanny) Ultimately, my job had to go to keep us on track as a family. (Just our decision) and I carved a freelance career which worked well for the family. I’m now running my own business and DH is semi-retired so I am getting a lot of support back from him. Mine was a big sacrifice at the time but I just parked any resentment as ultimately without DH’s career, my children and I would not enjoy the lifestyle we have.
Your husband is clearly a brilliant teacher or he would not be fast tracked for promotion so quickly. But if he becomes HoD, he will be doing more admin, less teaching. Has he thought of this? He may have more flexibility in negotiating than he thinks. (Saturday mornings, 4.5 day week?) If they really want him as badly as it sounds they do, he should do the interview and negotiate on the terms if he is offered the job. But be prepared to walk away. You sometimes do have to take these opportunities as they arise.
Re your career, you sound like you are working incredibly hard and if you are away from home one night a week and completing the working day after the kids go to bed you are always “on” which is exhausting. Being pregnant won’t help with that either.
Whatever you decide, you need to carve yourself some “you” time, particularly if DH takes the promotion. That should be non-negotiable or you risk burn out.
Be kind to yourself. You are going to have way more money in the future than you realise. That was something I didn’t really factor in when I was at your stage and I wish I hadn’t worried so much about finances and juggling it all at the time. Your future is secure. Could your in-laws take a 6 month mortgage holiday, allowing you to cut their contributions for 6 months too while you are on maternity leave? This could buy you some extra nanny hours without too much more sacrifice. Good luck. I’m in awe of how you’ve managed this so far given the industry you are in.

Runaway1 · 02/12/2023 10:52

EnidSpyton · 01/12/2023 19:02

I'm coming into this just from the perspective of your husband's opportunity to become HoD. I am a secondary teacher, former HoD, currently got my feet up just being back in the classroom 😉

By the sounds of things, he's either Physics or Chemistry, both of which are subjects in huge demand and short supply. If the HoD is for Physics, Chemistry or Science, then he is in a very good bargaining position with the school. If they want a January start for the HoD position, then they are desperate. In a fee paying school, not having a head of such a key department is a problem with presumably many students looking to do Medicine, Engineering etc and parents expecting top grades for the money they are investing. They will want someone they know and trust at the helm. It sounds like they've already made a mistake in the previous person they hired, so they will be inclined to go for an internal candidate. Better the devil you know.

All this considered, I think your husband could go for the job on the basis he can do it on a 0.8 contract. There's no reason why a HoD needs to be full time. Schools don't like managers not being full time, but if there is a strong second in department and the leadership in general is strong, it shouldn't ever be a problem to have one day a week when the HoD isn't in. When I was Head of Faculty, I measured my success by the fact that my department ran as smooth as clockwork whether I was there or not. A department that needs their HoD breathing down their neck or who can't do anything without help is one that is poorly led in the first place.

Your husband would need to build a case. He would have to go to the leadership with a plan for who will deputise for him on his day off, and emphasise how this will develop the expertise and skill within the department, making the department as a whole more successful. He would need to show that working part time as a HoD can work. Then, you can have it all.

That being said, if not now, doesn't mean not ever. In a large private secondary, there are always opportunities for promotion. He doesn't have to go down the academic route to be promoted - he could also become a Head of Year. These positions do come up regularly because people frequently use them as a springboard to promotions elsewhere.

I would also say that going for a HoD position after just three years in the classroom might be a little premature. In order to manage a department successfully on top of everything else means that you need to be able to teach with your eyes shut and be incredibly quick, efficient and expert at planning and marking. There is a lot of time taken up as HoD with meetings and admin he won't have any experience of doing, as well as dealing with parents, managing colleagues, and staying on top of all the examination preparations. The workload is only manageable if you can do the day-to-day with very little effort. I can't imagine after just three years in the job, your husband would be ready. He may be able to do the job, but it will be much harder on him at this stage in his teaching career than it would be in a couple of years' time. I might also add that a HoD needs to be able to support and mentor colleagues - can he really support other teachers with their teaching practice with so little classroom experience? I wouldn't be happy if my HoD only had three years' experience, myself. How would he be able to help me with a tricky class?

That's just my two penn'orth. Hopefully some food for thought. Good luck to you both!

This is great advice - worth seeing if the school are open to compromise. Fully agree with the position the school are in. Some SLT are really against part-time HODs for no good reason, but even so, perhaps tutor group and Saturday mornings could be negotiated. It could be framed as he’d like to apply, but…

And yes, there will be other opportunities.

Chimpandcheese · 02/12/2023 10:00

Sounds like he’s moved the goal posts there…he’s probably panicking that he won’t get another opportunity like that, but assuming he’s got another 20 or 30 years to work he’ll have plenty of time to climb the ladder!

Bean83ts · 02/12/2023 09:53

But why? It’s basically her picking up the flack and having to sacrifice? Her husband wants to develop his career later on and she facilitated that, she’s the one picking up the flack whilst also been the breadwinner and funding his parents by the sounds of it. It sounds like they’ve had an agreement with shared paternity pay etc and now he’s going back on that but not giving a feasible solution?? Why should op be the one having to think about how it all works?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 02/12/2023 09:45

EdgarAllenRaven · 02/12/2023 09:19

I would read your last update, from the voice of a well-earning husband who wants to deny his wife a chance to rise in her career… it is funny how to gender difference changes things!

Agreed. If the OP were a man talking about his wife, she would get torn apart for saying what she has said.

EdgarAllenRaven · 02/12/2023 09:19

I would read your last update, from the voice of a well-earning husband who wants to deny his wife a chance to rise in her career… it is funny how to gender difference changes things!

LookingforMaryPoppins · 02/12/2023 08:59

I understand why you would be thrown by this however do think it would be wrong to ask your husband to step aside for this. The money paid to your parents is in effect a childcare payment, covering their expenses however you are paying a significantly higher sum to your in laws to supplement their income with apparantly nothing in return. Seems to me that a simple solution would be for your in laws to cover the extra childcare needed - if they can't, increase the nanny's hours and use the money you currently pay them.

sugarandsweetener · 02/12/2023 08:53

I'm still struggling to understand DH's desire to take on a tonne more work, for little to no financial benefit and significant cost to me and the kids.

have you asked him? what’s been his response? Presumably career satisfaction? future career prospects? future proofing? sharing the financial burden ib ten event something happens to you?

sugarandsweetener · 02/12/2023 08:52

since you started the thread, have you actually spoken with him?

You had said you were going to support the promotion and get an extra nanny day?

NCforthis235 · 02/12/2023 08:41

I'm in finance. Sold my soul for 7-8 years to get senior enough to have the flexibility I have now and have then stayed constant for 6-7 years. Not unusual at all whilst having children but to stay where I am for another 5+ years would make it a lot more difficult to move in future.

DH's "earnings" taking into account the fee discount once kids reach secondary, plus no childcare costs in the school holidays, are already pretty close to mine.

We have a lovely work life balance and don't struggle financially, although the recent doubling of the mortgage payment has made things tighter. I'm still struggling to understand DH's desire to take on a tonne more work, for little to no financial benefit and significant cost to me and the kids. But ultimately it's his prerogative.

We have never wanted two "high flying" careers and for our kids to spend all their time in childcare. It just wasn't our priority. He had always been happy to be the "secondary" career for want of a better word, but he loves teaching/education in a way that he has never loved another job so it's completely understandable that his head is being turned by the opportunity to move up.

I don't know how realistic it is to switch focuses at this stage and for us to indefinitely prioritise his career progression in an effort to get him into one of the very highest earning parts of the sector. He'd presumably need to put in the hard yards as I did, but at a much greater cost than it was for me in my 20s. Financially, it makes no sense as the earnings potential in my sector is much greater than even the top of his. That's not the be all and end all, but it has to factor.

OP posts:
Whatonearthdidicomeinherefor · 02/12/2023 08:11

If your outgoings are too high to afford more childcare then perhaps you should consider reducing them.

Start with moving child to state school & save the school fees.

Pbs1984 · 02/12/2023 07:44

It’s a really tricky one - I also have three young children so I know the challenges that come with that. I currently work full time, and my husband works part time to make it work, but it’s still tough.
I do think, though, that you do need to recognise the privileged position you are in - you earn a vast salary whilst working part time, partially from home, in a flexible role that allows you to spend time with your children. I know you describe yourself as ‘cruising’ and desiring more but you sound like you have a dream scenario. Are you really going to find something that is better than that while you have young children? It also means you have the money to find an excellent childcare solution so that your husband can pursue his career goals.

On a side note, what field do you work in? I’m a teacher, like your husband, (and so is my husband) and always wonder about these amazing private sector roles that people have! 😂