Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you find this offensive like I do and would you comment on it?

287 replies

Sunandnomoon · 29/11/2023 14:26

Shared by an elderly friend of my mum’s on Facebook. I find it offensive but I’m debating whether it’s worth the hassle of saying so.

It’s certainly not kind, it’s condescending and misogynistic. I’ve known her my whole life and I’ve never seen her be unkind before, actually she did my mum a great kindness many years ago, so I’m not looking to be confrontational or mean.

I just think shit like this being unchallenged makes the world a little bit worse off every day.

Do you find this offensive like I do and would you comment on it?
OP posts:
MrsMarzetti · 29/11/2023 15:49

User13579367337 · 29/11/2023 14:34

Why even give things like this any headspace? You can’t argue with stupid.

So the elderly lady is stupid for holding views that going out showing a great amount of flesh means you don't value yourself highly enough ? They are her views and were from a time that it was socially unacceptable to go out without a lot on. Maybe she doesn't agree with your views just as you don't agree with hers and maybe the time you get to her age your views will be seen as outdated and you will be classed as stupid. Do you class everyone that hold an alternative view to your stupid or just those who are elderly? Because of it is the latter, that makes you ageist.

Butsheisnot · 29/11/2023 15:47

Has she given any context to why she shared it? Ie a comment like 'totally agree!'

I know a couple of older people who would either hit share by mistake and not realise or would post something like this as a commentary on how things used to be - and not realising it comes across as if they agree. I'm not being ageist - for me the 2 people who these scenarios could easily apply to are both 70+.

Anyway. Just a different suggestion that she may not have shared it because it's her view. If she did, it's a really really odd and outdated post. Depends on the type of relationship you have as to whether I'd address or not though.

5YearsLeft · 29/11/2023 15:47

MelsMoneyTree · 29/11/2023 15:21

It's funny how often people want to challenge 'old women' about posts like this but not sexist young men when by my reckoning there are a shit tonne more of the latter on social media than the former.
If you must shout at someone for being sexist on the internet, why not go for Andrew Tate? At least then lots of other sexist arses will see your arguments too.

I have to agree. There are a few people saying that she’s “a product of her generation.” I just don’t believe that - my grandmother, who raised me, was born in 1926 and she couldn’t have been more the opposite. She never told me this shite, and none of her friends would have agreed with it either. She was never racist either, so I never listen to “product of their generation” excuses for that either. I see a lot of people are saying they quit Facebook, and I’m another, but I quit when I lived in America for a while - it seemed like every city everywhere, no matter how “easy-going” according to other Americans, would have several of these mega-churches.

You might not know these people were part of such a church. They would seem nice, seem to have the right values, feed the homeless, give a shite about others, and then you suddenly discover on their Facebook, they’d have bollocks like this, or their opinion of homosexuality would be, “Oh, I hate the sin, not the sinner.” (You fucking what???) But yes, of course, my very favorite were not “old” misogynistic women; I didn’t even run into many older women secretly filled with hate that often. It was, in fact, more middle-aged misogynistic women who would be incredibly into supporting abstinence before marriage and outlawing abortion… almost ALWAYS because they’d had an abortion themselves and they “so deeply regretted it” even though having a child at 15-16 would have ruined their lives (since now they had nice husbands and nice houses and teenage children of their own). It’s all just complete madness.

Anyway, I’ve never gotten back on Facebook, and I’m sad to see that if I did, I’d see these posts on this side of the Atlantic now, too. Or maybe it’s been here just as long. All they’re doing is adding God into the saying about the cow and the free milk; and only arseholes said that to begin with. Sigh.

NaughtyBoyGeorgeMichaelJacksonBrown · 29/11/2023 15:46

Oof, I haven't been mined for a while.

Women in any clothes cannot be compared to objects because WHATEVER they are wearing, everyone knows what is under there. You can't lock your tits away like you'd hide your purse in the glove compartment, you can't leave your fanny at home like you might do with a fancy watch or wad of cash and you can't bury your arse underground for a government approved company to mine. Our bodies are always with us, whether they are covered or not and wearing loose garments does not screen out bad men: they know what is under there anyway.

MissHoollie · 29/11/2023 15:45

My mum once shared something that I and lots of people found offence
In my mum's case her understanding has decreased as she's got older and I felt sorry that she hadn't understood the full meaning .
Maybe this is the case here too

HeraSyndulla · 29/11/2023 15:45

No, I don't find it offensive.

EasternStandard · 29/11/2023 15:43

Just leave it. It’s barmy and I only read a few lines

Sunandnomoon · 29/11/2023 15:42

No-one has commented or liked it so far. I’ve seen photos of her wearing mini skirts when she was younger as someone else suggested. I’d love to add a cheeky comment along the lines of ‘I didn’t know you’d joined the taliban’ but I think it’d go over her head.

I’ll just leave it. I don’t see her often face to face and I’m not going to bring up a Facebook post from months ago.

Social media does open your eyes to what the people around you truly think. I did comment and challenge someone else I know last year when she suggested a local stabbing was carried out by refugees who’d moved to the town despite no-one else saying this and it not being the truth. And I’m so sick of seeing those foolish ‘stop giving our money to refugees and give it to army veterans instead’ posts.

OP posts:
Shareiscare · 29/11/2023 15:40

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Raffington55 · 29/11/2023 15:38

I'd leave it. The post is just bizarre!!!! I
Jewels, wares on show, mining companies! Talk about warbling on about a load of crap to make even more shite a point !

KatBurglar · 29/11/2023 15:37

What a sexist pile of claptrap. I'd either say that to her, or just the eyeroll emoji if I couldn't be arsed.

beforethecoffeegetscold · 29/11/2023 15:35

Bemyclementine · 29/11/2023 14:39

How does she feel about women from other religions covering up?

This is often the irony.

Ellie1015 · 29/11/2023 15:35

I think it is very dated but not offensive.

The intention is to build up someone's confidence if they are dressing in revealing clothes for attention. It fails to acknowledge women can dress how they like and this is not a sign they don't value themselves.

I absolutely would not discuss on facebook or real life unless she brings it up to me directly.

OtherS · 29/11/2023 15:35

I find it disgusting, essentially suggesting she thinks women should be hidden away in loose robes if men are to consider them 'worthy'? And if they wear revealing clothes nice men won't want them?! This is not an age thing, this is a sexist pig thing. My elderly parents would certainly be horrified by this - the boomers are the generation of mini skirts, bikinis and female sexual liberation after all! I'd find it difficult not to say anything.

CunkEverywhereOnEverything · 29/11/2023 15:33

Well, that’s vomit inducing bullshit. And offensive in a cringe worthy, patronising way.

Would I bother commenting? Depends on my mood. If I was in a bad mood already then yeah I probably would but I wouldn’t expect anything good to come from it- the person who shared this shite will still think they are wise and correct and feel suitably smug.

DearCake · 29/11/2023 15:32

So weird that you would even give this that much headspace. Literally who gives a shit about what some old dear posts on fb. What could you possibly hope to achieve by commenting or discussing it with her?? The picture/text obviously resonated with her on some level, should she check with you before she posts something in the future?

Of course it’s a load of old tripe but meh.

Cheeseywheel · 29/11/2023 15:32

Not worth the hassle. An elderly lady’s opinion is unlikely to be taken seriously or do any damage. Leave her be.

Didimum · 29/11/2023 15:31

Social media is not the place to have this debate.

NumberTheory · 29/11/2023 15:29

Find some equally twee religiously framed spiel about how God made the world to be beautiful and we don’t have to spend a fortune to find his true treasures. He makes the sunrise everyday, all we have to do is get up to see it; flowers bloom even on the side of the road and we can see his glory just by looking; love is all around us in the smile of a friend or the helping hand of a stranger on the street. God’s treasure is not in the precious metals and gems that man covets and can never satisfy, but in the beauty and love that man, in his image, embodies and appreciates.

Or some such guff.

ironorchids · 29/11/2023 15:29

YANBU.

Just point out how illogical it is.

Diamonds are actually found in the lab where you can grow them and they are systematically added to certain tooltips for strength, 100% on display.

Mining diamonds is one of the most immoral things people could do on this planet and those who succeed aren't somehow morally getting something precious, they are usually well funded, in many places corrupt and monopolistically dominating an industry that systematically exploits its workers. They are often the product and subject of violence and the world would be a better place if it was completely free of diamond mining and they were all just grown in labs.

Ask her if she can square that round gaping hole, nay chasm, in her analogy.

39and · 29/11/2023 15:26

Why pay it any attention. My FIL often posts garbage like this on Facebook after a few whiskies.

SophieinParis · 29/11/2023 15:26

It’s a generational thing. I don’t think we can judge different generations by the same standard. Some relativism is appropriate in my opinion. One elderly lady’s post encouraging young girls
to cover up isn’t going to bring down the feminist agenda.

You say yourself she’s a nice person, just leave it.

Nowherenew · 29/11/2023 15:23

Well she’s definitely an MNer.

Tbh it’s not worth saying anything.

I usually get really annoyed with the woman judging other women’s clothes choices on here but I definitely wouldn’t be happy for my DD to walk around like that and I believe the message is trying to be inspiring to young women who feel they need to dress like that for male attention.

As a PP said it’s not offensive but it is a load of shite.

I came off FB but I remember loads of religious posts like this and I didn’t even waste my time reading them.
Most people don’t even read it themselves, they just repost.

GoonieGang · 29/11/2023 15:22

Not offensive, just absolute bollocks.

MelsMoneyTree · 29/11/2023 15:21

It's funny how often people want to challenge 'old women' about posts like this but not sexist young men when by my reckoning there are a shit tonne more of the latter on social media than the former.
If you must shout at someone for being sexist on the internet, why not go for Andrew Tate? At least then lots of other sexist arses will see your arguments too.