Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask about being fired from public sector

112 replies

Bringbackspring · 29/11/2023 14:07

This may be very unreasonable to ask, and there isn't much point to it as nothing will come from this. But AIBU to ask if anyone on here has ever known someone lose their job in the higher education (HE) sector? I'm not talking about a fixed term or casual appointment coming to it's natural end and it not being renewed. I'm talking about staff from any of the HE 'job families' (not just lecturing, there are 100's of job types in HE) being given the boot either mid-contract or from a permanent contract.

I have worked in several UK universities over the past 20 years. I have worked with mostly brilliant people who really go above and beyond, and lots of good people who just get on and do their job to the letter. All fine. I love the work and it makes it easy to get about of bed for as it's work that helps a lot of people.

However, I have worked with a handful of absolute waste of space coasters. People who are incompetent (despite being given training, and endless amounts of support), people who are lazy and will seemingly sit back and just let everyone else pick up the slack because everyone else is too conscientious to just let it all fall apart. One person could not follow even the most basic health and safety protocols (think spilling toxic chemicals regularly and just wandering off to let someone else find and sort it) and was generally a walking hazard!

Not once have I ever seen a case of one of these people losing their job. Only once have I seen a line manager escalate someone to HR (following procedure) and the senior dept. leaders turned on the line manager. The useless employee was protected, and apologised to, and the line manager ended up handing her notice in. So we ended up losing a brilliant member of staff in order to keep a useless one.

I am getting a bit fed up of everyone, including very senior people, being very well aware of these people's short comings, and the impact it has on the teams who work with them. But nothing is ever done about it. It's like HE is terrified of firing people because it's not a very 'wellbeing' sort of thing to do. What about the wellbeing of everyone else!!

In the private sector, I get the impression that coasters wouldn't last long. But maybe I am wrong?

OP posts:
StoneTheCrone · 29/11/2023 16:37

I cant comment on higher education but Ive seen the same thing happen in our company and in others and it appears to be a case of the higher ups not wanting to be seen as the bad guy and instead, either passing if off to HR to deal with when its critical or, simply ignoring it completely to avoid confrontation.

People dont seem to want to deal with conflict and people management these days.

EveryKneeShallBow · 29/11/2023 16:35

Meceme · 29/11/2023 15:18

I worked in education and have known a number of people 'managed out' basically a new head/leader wants to impose his/her vision and rapidly imposes 'improvement plans' resulting in resignations, and people leaving under settlement agreements. In two cases they were weaker members of staff who did need to leave but others were experienced women over 50 managed out and replaced with younger/cheaper staff.

This was my experience as well.

FilthyforFirth · 29/11/2023 16:34

I am a line manager in the public sector experiencing this very thing. My useless direct report is protected and somehow I am at fault for following HR policies.

I just got an 'exceeded' on our mid yesr review (to show I am not a waste of space and hopefully valuable to the team) and I am now looking for an internal move.

It is shocking how difficult it is to get rid of someone in the public sector. And I am a raging lefty, fully paid member of my union. I still think it is awful.

PianPianPiano · 29/11/2023 16:31

I'm not sure its much different in the private sector. I think it takes a lot to get somebody fired - there are are so many hoops to jump through when it comes to poor performance rather than gross misconduct that I suspect a lot of managers choose to avoid it, or kick things off but then the employee improves just enough and for just long enough to keep them around until the process has to start again.
I've also definitley heard it said at my work that 'a bum on the seat is better than nobody' which is obviously ridiculous and often not actually true when that 'bum' is creating work for everyone else, and we'd be better off without them... But I suspect there's a worry that if they get rid of the person they might lose the budget and not be able to recruit someone else to fill their place.

PosterBoy · 29/11/2023 16:24

Schools are different ... they can be very cut throat.

Generally public sector though ... yes absolutely.

Things that cause you to lose your job

  • exposing corruption or inefficiency
  • trying to make people who are in a union do some/any work
  • being too good at your job and showing up the rest
Shivermetimbers0112 · 29/11/2023 16:19

I was HRD in three HEIs over a 25 year period before I retired. Dismissed many staff over the years, just didn’t make a song and dance about it. Having said that some HEIs still operate statutes that are very unwieldy and sometimes the effort required to dismiss for under-performance can inhibit line managers from seeing the process through.

Circularargument · 29/11/2023 16:17

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 29/11/2023 16:13

I have extensive experience of both sectors and found that people arriving from the private sector to the public have been quite surprised at the high standards expected. The old public/private argument that the private sector is better/more efficient/better organised is a myth. There are good and bad examples in both sectors, and equally good and bad leaders.

This. And the argument that business methods and the free market should be applied to public services has been responsible for some almighty cockups over the years.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 29/11/2023 16:13

I have extensive experience of both sectors and found that people arriving from the private sector to the public have been quite surprised at the high standards expected. The old public/private argument that the private sector is better/more efficient/better organised is a myth. There are good and bad examples in both sectors, and equally good and bad leaders.

SaveItForTheBirds · 29/11/2023 16:11

I've worked in HE for a long, long time. To get sacked you basically need to murder one of your colleagues and even then, depending on how popular your victim was, you might only get shuffled to a different department...

Genuine answer - in my 20 years of managing staff in HE support roles, I've sacked two people. In both cases, there were incidents of gross misconduct, one involving fraud and one involving violence. Both times, it was a long process between initial suspension and eventual sacking.

As you say, it's very difficult to sack someone for underperformance. Instead we get stuck in a cycle of performance management ending in (usually) a move to a different post. I've also seen voluntary redundancy schemes where we've lost large numbers of excellent staff while all the coasters just cling on for dear life. It's massively frustrating but the whole sector seems terrified of getting caught up in an unfair dismissal case.

I've worked in four different HE institutions and it's the same across the board unfortunately.

suntannedsnowball · 29/11/2023 16:09

One - for violence, and even that took about three years to draw to a conclusion

roarrfeckingroar · 29/11/2023 16:05

It's impossible. The things I saw at Network Rail.

Circularargument · 29/11/2023 16:04

SylvieLaufeydottir · 29/11/2023 15:22

Are you asking if this is a thing in the public sector? Because yes, it is. The public sector is notorious for never firing anyone and consequently tolerating all kinds of underperformance and bad behaviour. It's one reason why I don't work there.

So you don't work there but you know all about it? Hmm.

Circularargument · 29/11/2023 16:01

ScholesPanda · 29/11/2023 15:41

I've known people to be sacked in the civil service, for poor performance, sick absence, gross misconduct and for failing probation.
However, probably more hoops than in (some of) the private sector to get rid.
Generally, I think it's easier to coast or hide in big organisations than in small and the public sector has more big organisations than small, whereas more private sector posts are in SMEs.
Also, private sector tend to use more settlement agreements, often encourages people to go without fuss for the right pay-off and references.

Yup. But they are quick to trumpet how terrible public sector is, they would never get away with it etc etc.

Circularargument · 29/11/2023 15:59

SerenChocolateMuncher · 29/11/2023 15:16

You are absolutely right.

No one who works in the public sector (NHS, local authorities or education, for example) ever gets sacked for incompetence, laziness, bad attitude or poor attendance.

Occasionally, very senior managers are "allowed to go", but they will go with a large pay-off and good references.

The only way to get the sack in the public sector is to blow the whistle on wrongdoing. Do that and you'll be out of the door before you can say "corrupt bastards".

Really. Must have imagined all those people who failed probation, got sacked for being too sick or in one case useless in a LA I worked in.. Also know that HR gave the managers squat help though, they had to prep their case well

Humanlifeform · 29/11/2023 15:56

I work in HE and unfortunately I know EXACTLY what you are talking about from experiences at two different universities.

I have never seen anyone sacked for poor performance in 19 years . I have seen many playing the ' performance management' process, but nothing ever happens.

These people are also adept at abusing the sickness policy, knowing exactly when and for how long to take sick leave.

They care nothing for their colleagues, they are selfish and dishonest and drag teams down to their level.

In the private sector they would be given a verbal warning, a written warning, a final written warning and then dismissed. This doesn't happen in H.E.

NinaGeiger · 29/11/2023 15:53

I have worked in academia and I think there can be a culture of constructive dismissal rather than sacking - making it impossible to stay in the role but technically the person resigns rather than being sacked.

Catza · 29/11/2023 15:49

I know of people in the NHS who were let go but it only happened when they were on extended sick leave (we are talking years with chronic illness) and were effectively let go because there was no hope they would recover and therefore could not perform in their role.
If someone in a public sector is a member of a union, it is very unlikely they will get fired unless there are issues with gross misconduct or they are in breach of professional code of ethics. For example, we once came across a case where a registered pharmacist was administering covert medication and we reported him to the professional body who then revoked their license, hence they could no longer be legally employed.

ScholesPanda · 29/11/2023 15:41

I've known people to be sacked in the civil service, for poor performance, sick absence, gross misconduct and for failing probation.
However, probably more hoops than in (some of) the private sector to get rid.
Generally, I think it's easier to coast or hide in big organisations than in small and the public sector has more big organisations than small, whereas more private sector posts are in SMEs.
Also, private sector tend to use more settlement agreements, often encourages people to go without fuss for the right pay-off and references.

Freakinfraser · 29/11/2023 15:39

Bringbackspring · 29/11/2023 15:02

I won't argue, it is an odd post. I did say that there isn't much point to it as nothing will come from it. I simply was looking to find out if anyone else has shared my experience. I haven't seen any rules stipulating that I cannot ask people about their experiences on this forum.

As for their incompetence being 'my opinion', that is not the case. All of these individuals over the years have been flagged to senior management (not necessarily by me), and in every case it has been acknowledged that the person is a problem. But nothing ever comes of it, nothing ever changes. I am interested in knowing if this is a sector-specific issue or if it happens everywhere.

I am working with one such incompetent person at the moment who is massively letting our team down. It has been flagged at quite a high level, and a performance plan was put in place. But that has been and gone and still nothing has changed. Senior management acknowledge the problem still exists but it seems they are at a loss as to what to do about it.

Fair enough, the answer is yes it happens in private too. Not for things like assault or heath and safety breaches, in my experience, but yes lazy, incompetent, etc often don’t get fired.

they don’t progress, they don’t get big pay rises, but yes, I’d hazard a guess that every company has them, be it private or public.

of course people do get managed out, passed on to another team to avoid the problem, and yes some get on formal pips and fired, but after two years it’s a complex process.

im working with one right now, and quite frankly its driving me fucking potty. I’ve complained long and loud, as has everyone else, but still he’s there, doing fuck all and making everyone’s life a bit harder.

KStockHERO · 29/11/2023 15:38

To add to my post above - DP is also an academic. He did a citizenship role in his department a few years back which had a dedicated administrator for that role.

That lady did nothing. I don't mean she was lazy, I mean she did absolutely nothing. Her and DP used to have a weekly check-in and she'd always have a million excuses for why she hadn't completed the action points from the last week's meeting (action points like "Book a room for a half-day seminar" or "Email Jon and ask about the thing", not rocket science).

DP couldn't get her to actually do her job. No stick. No carrot. To keep things running, DP started doing the action points himself. Then he got pissed off and stopped. Then the whole system started to fall over and the head of department got involved.

DP told the HoD that it was the administrator refusing to do her job. HoD had a word, nothing changed, HoD said "Ah well, what can you do?" and it just went on.

SausageAndEggSandwich · 29/11/2023 15:34

I've seen it in schools. And not just teachers.

We had a member of staff who was successful in interview for a slightly higher grade post. The job was more technical but she persuaded the interviewers that she was up to it. She wasn't.

Long story short - within six months she had handed her notice in. Head teachers don't mess about when they want you gone. Whether that's for good reasons or bad.

popofthetots · 29/11/2023 15:34

I know someone who physically hit a colleague in the face in her public sector job and didn't get terminated.

Meanwhile in the private sector someone doesn't like the colour of your shoes and you're out the door!

KStockHERO · 29/11/2023 15:31

I'm an academic.

Everything you say resonates totally. Universities are absolutely stacked with lazy coasting, incompetent people across all job families and at all levels.

I've only ever known two people who were 'managed out' of the sector:
An academic who somehow failed probation despite the fact that the university made probation almost unfail-able.

Another academic who was kindly encouraged to leave by a brilliant, visionary head of department who recognised his laziness and incompetence. This head of department was subsequently bullied out of the sector by a group of lazy, mediocre, incompetent senior professors.

But, yes, no-one ever fired.

KnittedCardi · 29/11/2023 15:30

Look at senior NHS managers. Even those who were involved at failing hospitals, causing deaths due to negligence, get quietly paid off, spend 6 months on the golf course, then magically pop up in a different trust. It's actually almost criminal.

Bluevelvetsofa · 29/11/2023 15:29

I’ve known people managed out in education too, whether justified or not. Support plans that are anything but, more and more expectation etc.

Ive also seen some who really do take the proverbial.