Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask about being fired from public sector

112 replies

Bringbackspring · 29/11/2023 14:07

This may be very unreasonable to ask, and there isn't much point to it as nothing will come from this. But AIBU to ask if anyone on here has ever known someone lose their job in the higher education (HE) sector? I'm not talking about a fixed term or casual appointment coming to it's natural end and it not being renewed. I'm talking about staff from any of the HE 'job families' (not just lecturing, there are 100's of job types in HE) being given the boot either mid-contract or from a permanent contract.

I have worked in several UK universities over the past 20 years. I have worked with mostly brilliant people who really go above and beyond, and lots of good people who just get on and do their job to the letter. All fine. I love the work and it makes it easy to get about of bed for as it's work that helps a lot of people.

However, I have worked with a handful of absolute waste of space coasters. People who are incompetent (despite being given training, and endless amounts of support), people who are lazy and will seemingly sit back and just let everyone else pick up the slack because everyone else is too conscientious to just let it all fall apart. One person could not follow even the most basic health and safety protocols (think spilling toxic chemicals regularly and just wandering off to let someone else find and sort it) and was generally a walking hazard!

Not once have I ever seen a case of one of these people losing their job. Only once have I seen a line manager escalate someone to HR (following procedure) and the senior dept. leaders turned on the line manager. The useless employee was protected, and apologised to, and the line manager ended up handing her notice in. So we ended up losing a brilliant member of staff in order to keep a useless one.

I am getting a bit fed up of everyone, including very senior people, being very well aware of these people's short comings, and the impact it has on the teams who work with them. But nothing is ever done about it. It's like HE is terrified of firing people because it's not a very 'wellbeing' sort of thing to do. What about the wellbeing of everyone else!!

In the private sector, I get the impression that coasters wouldn't last long. But maybe I am wrong?

OP posts:
Ragwort · 29/11/2023 20:26

I was a school governor & the Head admitted to having sex in the stationery cupboard (yes really Hmm) with another member of staff .... apparently that's not a sackable offence .... ?

Walkingtheplank · 29/11/2023 20:25

Isn't this more a case of it being difficult to sack union members - and there are more of them in the public sector?

starsinthenightskies · 29/11/2023 20:21

I haven’t worked in higher education but did work in the Civil Service for over a decade. I only ever saw people get dismissed for taking too much sick leave (months or years), never for poor performance.

There was no incentive or encouragement for line managers to fire people, it just led to so much hard work and grievances against them and difficult meetings with the unions etc.

It was a running joke in our office that unless you literally walked in and assaulted someone, you could not be fired. And even then it wasn’t a certainty.

ChiaraRimini · 29/11/2023 20:19

I have worked in HE for 2 decades. I have never known anyone sacked. I imagine the process is a legal minefield.
But I have seen a Pro Vice Chancellor (equivalent to board level in a company) be made to resign as he was not up to the job, in a surprisingly short timescale. That saved a lot of future embarrassment for him and everyone else. I was actually surprised how quickly it happened, which shows HE can get rid of even very senior people when they need to although he should never have been appointed in the first place.
We also had a very short lived HR director who apparently spent a lot of time out of the office getting her nails done etc....

Chuffaluffa · 29/11/2023 20:13

My ex within the last two years got a senior leadership position at a university, and shortly after mysteriously disappeared. contacts at the uni had said that the department was ‘trying to rebuild, after some colleagues being scared for their safety’. I contacted him to see what had happened and he said there was an NDA in place so couldn’t say anything. Few weeks later- higher position in an RG uni. The Peter principle is alive and kicking in HE, it would seem.

only ever seen people get paid off to leave in HE, no matter how absolutely incompetent they might be.

neverbeenskiing · 29/11/2023 20:06

No one who works in the public sector (NHS, local authorities or education, for example) ever gets sacked for incompetence, laziness, bad attitude or poor attendance.

I worked for the NHS in a former life and now work in education. It is definitely difficult to get rid of people. There is a long and drawn out process that has to be followed. Endless meetings, 'coaching' sessions and action plans have to be completed and a lot of evidence that you have put 'support' to improve their performance is needed before you can sack someone. But it can and does happen. I've personally worked with the following

  • Consultant sacked for gross misconduct
  • Junior doctor sacked for incompetence
  • Nurse sacked due to sickness
  • HCA sacked for sickness
  • 2 TA's sacked due to sickness
  • 1 HLTA sacked for gross misconduct

That's not counting the many NHS managers, and school middle leaders and senior leaders I've come across who have been 'managed out' or quietly demoted. I agree that whistleblowing, or even indications that you might blow the whistle, seems to be the easiest way to find yourself out on your arse.

Irisborn · 29/11/2023 19:57

Yanbu. This is the biggest problem with the public sector, lazy idiots are never fired, merely managed into a different role. Because everyone changes roles so often, managers can never be bothered to deal with it. And because it’s all public money there’s no real accountability.

My civil service job was 9-5. A junior colleague would arrive between 10am and 10.30, immediately go for coffee with her friends aka ‘networking’ then work for an hour or two, take a long lunch, pop out for an afternoon cuppa then leave early. She used to complain about her salary 😂 the little work she did was usually bad. I asked my manager why on earth she hadn’t been fired and he said ‘oh just put down on your appraisal form that she has performance issues and you’re mentoring her, on paper basically the entire department is mentoring her. She’ll move on to a different team in a couple of years, don’t rock the boat.’

In the private sector you’d be fired in days for that kind of behaviour.

FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable · 29/11/2023 19:53

I have a second job working in the private sector and do think public sector employees take the piss comparatively speaking.

TedWilson · 29/11/2023 19:53

It's increasingly hard in the private sector to deal with this as well but at least we do. There's a massive fear of being sued and exploring other avenues first. It takes 6 months plus unless it's an immediate and dangerous gross misconduct.

FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable · 29/11/2023 19:51

I work in the public sector and it is really hard to sack an employee. There was someone who were using public resources to run a side business for ten years plus and they had loads of evidence but it took two years with appeals to sack them. They kept the pension too.

bombastix · 29/11/2023 19:48

Honestly the way to get sacked in the public sector is to be conspicuously dishonest - then they can't get rid of you fast enough.

I had one women accuse me of being a racist once because I challenged her on not doing some work. She hadn't done it and it was a very public embarrassment.

Instead of owning it she wrote two pages to my manager that I was a racist. Impressively she was dismissed nearly instantly for lying and gross misconduct; because she lied wholesale, and enough to destroy my career. She was barred from the office by security.

I did make me pause because in retrospect I wonder if she had done it before. It struck me as a ballsy move.

StillWantingADog · 29/11/2023 19:48

I’m in the private sector and absolutely someone useless will be managed out swiftly. Or at the top of the list when the redundancy lists come out.

daffodilandtulip · 29/11/2023 19:40

I was a low level NHS manager and it was impossible to sack incompetent, lazy staff who did no work and had horrible attitudes.

Then I whistle blew on dangerous prescribing and refused to make up patient records ... and a mysterious allegation was suddenly made against me that would have got me sacked, had I not have walked out there and then.

Private sector wouldn't get away with any of the nonsense that goes on in the public sector.

Changington · 29/11/2023 19:26

The only people I know who have been sacked were fired for gross misconduct (diddling the expenses).

Everyone else goes "off sick with stress" for 6 months (fully paid) and then quietly disappears.

TheWitche · 29/11/2023 19:14

I work in the public sector and completely agree. It’s a long running joke nobody can be sacked.

TizerorFizz · 29/11/2023 19:01

Some of the difference is a robust probationary period and expectations in the private sector. They exist to make money. They don’t exist for cuddly staff policies with years given to improve. A decision is taken on whether staff are let go at the end of the probation period or before redundancy pay is payable. The public sector doesn’t work in the same way and I’ve seen countless people stay in non jobs in local government. They also move people on rather than deal with them.

I heard from two separate unconnected people that a local government employee at my local council took “working from home” to new heights. They moved to Spain. Not sure what happened but the staff member was required to go into work for meetings so the change of address was discovered!

Cumulonimbusincus · 29/11/2023 18:59

I’ve worked in similar roles but a different field. In my experience the really useless ones were promoted up away from the front line to where they could (theoretically) do less harm.

ChocolateCinderToffee · 29/11/2023 18:52

IvorTheEngineDriver · 29/11/2023 17:03

You cannot deny that the public sector does have that reputation though.

Yes, because of people who don't work in it and talk rubbish!

CleanQueen123 · 29/11/2023 18:45

LemonGelato · 29/11/2023 18:33

Well I have seen (and been part of) dismissals in the public sector, including 2 stints in HE . My HR career spans both private sector, public (Local authorities & civil service but not NHS) and third sector/charity. I've advised on lots of cases over many years and supported managers on some very complicated ones.

It's true it can be harder & slower to manage under performance and deal with misconduct in the public sector. Senior management leadership attitude is often the problem as they want an easy life. But this isn't always the case - I've seen good and bad practice everywhere.

In the public sector, some of the reason is it has a culture of giving people 2nd chances for things (which isn't always a bad thing but it can go too far, for too long). There is a grievance culture in the public sector - counter claims against managers of bullying is just par for the course when managing performance and that slows things down too. Some of it is fear by management at all levels of employment tribunals - especially for claims of discrimination which can get a lot of local negative publicity. Local Authorities are very very scared of being accused of racism for example.

It's true there can be long winded and complicated policies and procedures with lots of stages in them. Bearing in mind most public sector organisations are heavily unionised and introducing or changing policies requires consultation with the TU's, who will understandably fight hard against anything that makes it simpler to dismiss people. Some is lack of ability & competence at management levels (often accompanied by risk averse or young/inexperienced HR staff). Also, experienced TU reps can really intimidate line managers who eventually give up trying. And HR as well - I've had local and regional officers be very aggressive in their language and behaviour towards me personally and I'm simultaneously having to deal with that whilst advising and supporting line manager/investigating officer/Chair of a hearing. It's not easy.

And another factor is structural. For example dismissing academics is complicated by Statutes and Articles of association which are legal documents and dictate often archaic procedures and criteria which make it incredibly hard to dismiss them.

But the private sector is not necessarily something to admire either. They can be very toxic cultures and just manage people out through making life miserable. A lot of private sector organisation do not recognise unions and so have simpler, more 'brutal' policies, for example on sickness absence triggers. They use probations more strictly to get rid of people (the opposite of the public sector which tend not to do so when they could/should). They'll dismiss for all sorts of reasons (or none) and rely on the 2 year inability to claim unfair dismissal to get away with it, along with not bothering to properly investigate disciplinary issues and just go straight to dismissal. If something looks a bit risky they will just throw money at it (and it's FAR harder to get SA's signed off in HE/LA's than people think).

So it's all very complicated and hard and difficult and nowhere near as simple as "public sector bad, private sector good" in terms of people management.

@LemonGelato you've explained it far better than I have. It's not a simple comparison at all.

CleanQueen123 · 29/11/2023 18:41

Public sector HR here. We absolutely do dismiss for absence, performance and conduct.

There are robust processes that need to be followed to do it and I will agree in some cases it takes far longer than it ought to.

Agree with the comments about union reps. Delaying tactics seem to be a speciality for some of them.

It's swings and roundabouts really. I'd prefer to follow a full process and make sure everything possible had been done to resolve the issue over sacking someone without one just because it's quicker.

I think line managers need to take responsibility too. It's no good not addressing the problem for months/years on end and then suddenly deciding the person needs to go. By that point it's much harder to exit them, especially for low level performance/conduct matters.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 29/11/2023 18:33

I don't work in the public sector, I work for a high street bank. The only people I've seen fired were for gross misconduct - of the 'stealing from customers' type.

I'm thinking of one guy in particular who was so thick, just transferring money from wealthy customers accounts into his own.

I think once a person gets past the initial 2 years employment it's a lot harder to manage them out. Unless they're women who ask for flexible working around childcare, and they'll just leave Hmm

LemonGelato · 29/11/2023 18:33

Well I have seen (and been part of) dismissals in the public sector, including 2 stints in HE . My HR career spans both private sector, public (Local authorities & civil service but not NHS) and third sector/charity. I've advised on lots of cases over many years and supported managers on some very complicated ones.

It's true it can be harder & slower to manage under performance and deal with misconduct in the public sector. Senior management leadership attitude is often the problem as they want an easy life. But this isn't always the case - I've seen good and bad practice everywhere.

In the public sector, some of the reason is it has a culture of giving people 2nd chances for things (which isn't always a bad thing but it can go too far, for too long). There is a grievance culture in the public sector - counter claims against managers of bullying is just par for the course when managing performance and that slows things down too. Some of it is fear by management at all levels of employment tribunals - especially for claims of discrimination which can get a lot of local negative publicity. Local Authorities are very very scared of being accused of racism for example.

It's true there can be long winded and complicated policies and procedures with lots of stages in them. Bearing in mind most public sector organisations are heavily unionised and introducing or changing policies requires consultation with the TU's, who will understandably fight hard against anything that makes it simpler to dismiss people. Some is lack of ability & competence at management levels (often accompanied by risk averse or young/inexperienced HR staff). Also, experienced TU reps can really intimidate line managers who eventually give up trying. And HR as well - I've had local and regional officers be very aggressive in their language and behaviour towards me personally and I'm simultaneously having to deal with that whilst advising and supporting line manager/investigating officer/Chair of a hearing. It's not easy.

And another factor is structural. For example dismissing academics is complicated by Statutes and Articles of association which are legal documents and dictate often archaic procedures and criteria which make it incredibly hard to dismiss them.

But the private sector is not necessarily something to admire either. They can be very toxic cultures and just manage people out through making life miserable. A lot of private sector organisation do not recognise unions and so have simpler, more 'brutal' policies, for example on sickness absence triggers. They use probations more strictly to get rid of people (the opposite of the public sector which tend not to do so when they could/should). They'll dismiss for all sorts of reasons (or none) and rely on the 2 year inability to claim unfair dismissal to get away with it, along with not bothering to properly investigate disciplinary issues and just go straight to dismissal. If something looks a bit risky they will just throw money at it (and it's FAR harder to get SA's signed off in HE/LA's than people think).

So it's all very complicated and hard and difficult and nowhere near as simple as "public sector bad, private sector good" in terms of people management.

Timeandtune · 29/11/2023 18:27

I worked for decades in local government . In all that time only one person was sacked after years of playing the system supported by the Trade Union and his elected member buddies.
Skivers and under performers were tolerated . I had a colleague who came in in the morning , hung his jacket over the back of his chair and disappeared down to the seaside for the day.

Loobydoobies · 29/11/2023 18:25

In HE it is often easier to restructure or manage people out than go through any processes if they are out of their probation period. The unions are strong and active, and you (rightly) need a watertight case and documentation to progress with any hearings.

That said, I know of cases where people have been sacked on various grounds, though it takes a fair amount of persistence and evidence to do so. These things are often done discreetly and/or are negotiated, so, in many cases, you may not know about them.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 29/11/2023 18:19

NHS here. Was given several people to manage who had proved unmanageable for other managers. Told I had to keep them on track, adhere to work expectations etc etc. When I did, one went straight to my senior manager, who decided to move her to another team behind my back. I hit the roof, insisted on a meeting with all parties and to hash out what was going on. Still resulted in the staff person being moved, but also gave me a chance to point out that she had no grounds for complaining other than being asked to do the job she was employed to do and meet the expectations that all members of the team were expected to meet. And I also pointed out that her behaviour to me contravened my rights at work (shouting, swearing, telling people I was stabbing her in the back) and that I would be taking action if there was any repeat and expected senior management support in that. They were all stunned.

I have to say our union were great. Could see that she was being completely unreasonable and did their best to provide a dose of reality for her.

Swipe left for the next trending thread