Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that my partner should attend birth?

137 replies

Allthatglittersisntart · 29/11/2023 11:42

My DP doesn’t want to be in the room for birth as he thinks this puts men off women physically and he doesn't want to witness the pain. He is not from a western culture and back home only
women have anything to do with birth. However, he is the only person I want in the room.

I suppose a risk is that he could have a seizure, which he occasionally gets and seem to be triggered by stress/anger/strong emotion but he does seem to be able to control/predict to an extent(never had one during interview , exam, gym for example).

OP posts:
35965a · 29/11/2023 14:04

Im sure many men don’t want to be there but they go to support their partner if she wants them to. I do find it pathetic. I hate hospitals and seeing my family in pain but if they ever want me there to hold their hand I go and I do what they need because that’s what decent people do. I wouldn’t just say ‘no, sorry I can’t come even though you’re scared and need some emotional support, I’m worried about my own feelings.’ That is pathetic.

Mummymummy89 · 29/11/2023 13:59

Hmm lots of comments calling the man out for being “pathetic” etc but this is the culture he comes from and what he will have been socialised with his whole life.

It's no secret that some cultures or subcultures are more misogynistic than others. And here in the UK, it used to be a less equal society even 40-50y ago. It's ok to call that out.

But I bet even in op's dp's culture, whichever that is, there are men who are less cowardly and useless than -op's dp- others.

Ace56 · 29/11/2023 13:58

Lots of cultures think like this, but they also tend to be cultures where men’s and women’s roles are very divided. Are you ok with this OP? I guess too late now if you’re not, as you’re about to have a baby with someone who I’m willing to bet will also never get up in the night, change nappies or look after a sick child as it’s ‘women’s work.’ Out of interest, do you do all the cooking and cleaning too?

Consideringachange2023 · 29/11/2023 13:55

Hmm lots of comments calling the man out for being “pathetic” etc but this is the culture he comes from and what he will have been socialised with his whole life.

its extremely problematic to present our (western / European etc) cultural norms as the overall definitive “normal”.

that aside, you need to find a place you are both comfortable with. Perhaps he is there for you in the lead up and just sees how it goes. Or maybe you have to find another birthing partner totally or one who will swap in when you get towards pushing stage.

this is just one of the cultural differences and you’ll both have to compromise, hopefully you both can!

Mummymummy89 · 29/11/2023 13:54

My DH had to have a broken and dislocated finger popped back in and wanted me to come with him… I wasn’t there “to have an experience”, I was there to support him. I didn’t say, no I don’t think I’ll enjoy it so I won’t

Hear, hear, @DuploTrain . I have had to do similar when dh had a leg injury a few years back. And short term I had to help him with intimate care like washing himself. He would absolutely do the same sort of thing for me, and did, when I was recovering from my c section.

That's what spouses do.

Why are expectations so low of men, honestly!

guinnesschocolatecake · 29/11/2023 13:53

Tbh, I thought my DP's support was negligible during labour. I was focused on my midwife and doctor. They were the ones I was listening to and who got it (complicated labours). My DP, an introvert, mostly sat in the corner unsure what to do with himself, giving me the odd glass of water and back rub. I would 100% have preferred a more proactive female family member to have been there. So, it wouldn't have bothered me, personally.

Mummymummy89 · 29/11/2023 13:51

I'm astonished by these responses honestly- I've usually found mumsnet to be quite tough on the menz. But in this thread we seem to require far far less of fathers than mothers.

A pp said no one should be forced to assist at a birth - ok, I wouldn't have "forced" my husband but I'd have lost all respect and tbh he'd probably no longer be my husband, if he simply wrung his hands and suggested I get a woman to help me in his place.

As for suggesting he "stay at the head end"... give me strength. Can op "stay at the head end" and dissociate from the bottom half of her body?! And no, I don't mean have an epidural - op's dp won't feel any pain anyway.

Having a baby is messy and painful and often dangerous. If op's dp willingly partook in the conception, he should bloody well help out with the rest of it.

And if this is "society putting pressure on fathers" as per a pp - well, fine. They shouldn't be so spineless as to need any pressure exerted.

StrawberryLemonade2 · 29/11/2023 13:47

First he was there for the labour however I ended up in theatre due to assisted birth/potential csection so I was on my own.

2nd he waited outside the room and 3rd I sent him home with our other two children. I much preferred being on my own as he can't cope seeing me like that and he would've been absolutely useless.

It has to be an agreed choice though. Could he at least be there whilst your labour?

DuploTrain · 29/11/2023 13:41

He may be a good father once the baby is here, but it doesn’t mean he wants to watch the birth and I don’t know that it’s worth forcing him to.

He’s not there to “watch” though. It’s not a spectator sport… he’s there to support. And he should be prioritising OP’s needs above his own comfort in this situation.

My DH had to have a broken and dislocated finger popped back in and wanted me to come with him… I wasn’t there “to have an experience”, I was there to support him. I didn’t say, no I don’t think I’ll enjoy it so I won’t.

Personally I’d be concerned about what else he considers “women’s things”… changing nappies, getting up in the night, taking poorly children to the doctors, I could go on..

The not finding you attractive thing is ridiculous, and I’d also be concerned about his expectations of finding you attractive post-birth. He knows you possibly won’t fancy having sex for a while after doesn’t he?

Wishitsnows · 29/11/2023 13:32

How pathetic and his reasoning that he may not find you attractive afterward is frankly insulting. Shame you don’t get to choose not to be there and be the one actually suffering the pain. I hope you have some good support.

Coffeerum · 29/11/2023 13:29

And this is the man you chose to procreate with?

Dweetfidilove · 29/11/2023 13:26

I never understand these disagreements.

By line 2 in some threads, you can guess the OP’s partner is not from a ‘Western culture’, yet OP is surprised he has certain attitudes.

There are men and women who think this is a ‘woman thing’. It may go against sensibilities, but it’s who he is. He may be a good father once the baby is here, but it doesn’t mean he wants to watch the birth and I don’t know that it’s worth forcing him to.

If you hadn’t noticed you had different views on these things before, now is the time to discuss your expectations going forward and hope for a good outcome.

Everydayisanewday · 29/11/2023 13:20

My husband was at the first and as a result not at the second. I was fine with it. Had no one else and midwife was great.
I honestly think the couple need to agree jointly. A lot of pressure is put on the dad by society.

Mummymummy89 · 29/11/2023 13:09

I would be so, so disappointed in my dh if he came up with something like this. I'd lose all respect.

Tbf my dh was there throughout my traumatic labour, birth and pph/sepsis after the birth. He only finally left when they kicked him out of the postnatal ward (covid times) - I've always said, the midwives took shifts (of course) but my dh was there for all the shifts. He didn't sleep and barely ate for three days (as neither did I). I needed him there.

So bollocks is it a woman thing.

Men have endured and witnessed way worse in war-time than simply assisting at his wife's birth ffs.

You tell him, op. It's at times like this that a man's courage and manliness get tested and if he chickens out, he (and you) will forever remember he was found wanting. How could he look at himself in the mirror for the rest of his life, honestly.

pinkyredrose · 29/11/2023 12:59

He's being honest Op, don't force him to be there if he doesn’t want to. Or if he does go maybe he could stay at the head end not the business end?

pinkyredrose · 29/11/2023 12:56

PhotographTheLights · 29/11/2023 12:06

Funny he has such old fashioned views but is ok with sex outside of marriage. What a Prince!

So what?

ColleenDonaghy · 29/11/2023 12:56

@AnneLovesGilbert has it nailed. Look out for yourself and make sure you have enough support. And have some very frank discussions now about your expectations for each other as parents.

Allthatglittersisntart · 29/11/2023 12:53

My Dad was there was but my sibling’s father wasn’t (a decade before)

OP posts:
SirenSays · 29/11/2023 12:52

he thinks this puts men off women physically.
What a horrible attitude, I wouldn't want him there or near me ever again.

flowerygloves · 29/11/2023 12:20

I think no one should be forced to attend a birth unless it is their job or they are the birther.

Rosiiee · 29/11/2023 12:19

@SOBplus oh my god! That’s so unbelievably sad!! That poor family 😞

SOBplus · 29/11/2023 12:17

Our hospital gave strong warnings about what will be experienced as just before our child's birth a dad fainted in the delivery room hitting his head and died - extreme and remote possibility but you should consider his ability to cope. At least he is open about his weaknesses and strengths?

Nicole1111 · 29/11/2023 12:17

I think he’s right. If he comes in he would have to stop prioritising his dick and future sex life over his partner and unborn child. Seems unreasonable to expect him to support you with one of the most important days of your life to me.
On a serious note though if it was for any other reason (such as the seizures) i’d probably be a lot more accepting, but he didn’t lead with that did he …..

Daphnis156 · 29/11/2023 12:13

It wasn't that long ago that men or any sort of partner just did not witness the birth.
If they don't want to, it might be better not force the issue.

WasRobbed · 29/11/2023 12:09

Tell him the delivery isn’t all about him.

His ‘rationale’ is gross.

I would struggle to get past this.