Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask my DH to sleep in the caravan when he works these shifts?

362 replies

CaraVann · 29/11/2023 09:01

As a part of (but not compulsory) DH’s job he does the Winter gritting.

The shift patterns are one week on, one off. It starts in October through to late March, sometimes April. They usually don’t start actually gritting until this time of year where we live (SE).

Tbh, it does brings in a good amount of extra income which at anytime is welcome but particularly during this COL crisis.

However, I find it really disruptive.

The times of the shifts change frequently depending on when the frosts/snows are due. Sometimes it could be from say 3pm-7pm and then back again 2-6am the same day or (the best shifts) 7-11pm.

This week has been particularly frosty here so he has been working double shifts - 2-6pm and 2-6am. He will get the next day off work to sleep.

However, the rest of us in the family (myself, DS18 and DD15) do not get the benefit of a lie in. Instead we have a disturbed nights sleep. For the dc this is mainly because our rescue dog (we’ve had him a year), who normally sleeps through will bark the house down when Dh leaves/returns (doesn’t matter which part of the house we put him in, he’s on high alert for ‘intruders’).

DC and dogs aside it wakes me regardless. I’m a light sleeper anyhow but once I’ve been woken that’s it, I’m awake.
We have a spare bedroom but it’s under our bedroom and I’d still hear him creeping about and the dog will still bark so I’d wake anyhow.
Last night I had 3 hours, broken, sleep. I (and the kids) are shattered. Dd has missed her bus to school because we overslept once we got back to sleep.
We are all grouchy and miserable this morning.

This is the AIBU part. We have our touring caravan stored at the bottom of our garden. I’ve suggested to Dh that he sleeps in there during these middle of the night shifts but he’s reluctant. Not because of the actual caravan as it’s lovely with a fixed bed, an en-suite shower room and very warm heater but because a) it would mean leaving his car out on the side road to save coming through the house as we have no side path/entrance (10 year old car, nothing special) and because the caravan will cost a lot to heat.

Who is BU though?

Dc and I really appreciate DH working these crap shifts (although he says he actually enjoys being out on the road at night with heater and radio on and wouldn’t give it up even if I earned more money) but it really affects our lives.
DS has work, DD has mocks and I work part time and care for my dm who has Alzheimer’s. I also have a chronic health condition which is affected by lack of sleep. I have to care for my mum
today and then I have a hospital appointment but all I want to do is crawl back into bed.

What would you suggested in our situation?

OP posts:
Americano75 · 30/11/2023 13:03

SerenChocolateMuncher · 30/11/2023 13:02

Great argument! 👍

Merely pointing that out. 👍

Americano75 · 30/11/2023 13:03

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 30/11/2023 12:49

But surely the most ardent dog hater wouldn't advocate for getting rid of a rescue animal for the sake of an occasional kip in a comfy caravan? Wow.

I think that's unfair. It's not 'occasional' if he's out gritting for several months a year and he doesn't want to sleep in the caravan rather than his own bed in his own house.

I know that rescue animals need stability, but it's not like people who subsequently find they have to give them up are likely to abuse or neglect them in the meantime, in the way that their original owners may have done, leading to them needing to be rescued in the first place.

It really doesn't sound like due care and attention was paid to the family's circumstances here before making the decision to take on a dog - rescue or otherwise.

I used the word occasional because some posters are reacting as though it's every single night when it's not.

No wonder the op hasn't been back, on top of everything else she's an irresponsible pet owner as well.

SerenChocolateMuncher · 30/11/2023 13:02

Americano75 · 30/11/2023 13:01

Not as as astonishing as your hyperbolic language. Good grief.

Great argument! 👍

Americano75 · 30/11/2023 13:01

SerenChocolateMuncher · 30/11/2023 12:54

Your argument is astonishing. You don't have to be "the most ardent dog hater" to put human beings before dogs. Yes, I would get rid of a dog if it was causing the level of disruption to my family that appears to be the case here.

Clearly the husband does not see it as "an occasional kip in a comfy caravan" FFS and neither does his wife seeing as neither of them wants to do it.

I am not an ardent dog hater, but I would get rid of any dog in a heartbeat before treating any human I loved with such disdain.

Not as as astonishing as your hyperbolic language. Good grief.

SerenChocolateMuncher · 30/11/2023 12:54

Americano75 · 30/11/2023 12:42

So based on your choice of vocabulary alone I'm guessing you're not a dog lover. But surely the most ardent dog hater wouldn't advocate for getting rid of a rescue animal for the sake of an occasional kip in a comfy caravan? Wow.

Your argument is astonishing. You don't have to be "the most ardent dog hater" to put human beings before dogs. Yes, I would get rid of a dog if it was causing the level of disruption to my family that appears to be the case here.

Clearly the husband does not see it as "an occasional kip in a comfy caravan" FFS and neither does his wife seeing as neither of them wants to do it.

I am not an ardent dog hater, but I would get rid of any dog in a heartbeat before treating any human I loved with such disdain.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 30/11/2023 12:49

But surely the most ardent dog hater wouldn't advocate for getting rid of a rescue animal for the sake of an occasional kip in a comfy caravan? Wow.

I think that's unfair. It's not 'occasional' if he's out gritting for several months a year and he doesn't want to sleep in the caravan rather than his own bed in his own house.

I know that rescue animals need stability, but it's not like people who subsequently find they have to give them up are likely to abuse or neglect them in the meantime, in the way that their original owners may have done, leading to them needing to be rescued in the first place.

It really doesn't sound like due care and attention was paid to the family's circumstances here before making the decision to take on a dog - rescue or otherwise.

Americano75 · 30/11/2023 12:42

SerenChocolateMuncher · 30/11/2023 12:38

Yes. Absolutely right. The whole family is being disturbed. By the DOG.

The dog is the problem. Not the husband.

So based on your choice of vocabulary alone I'm guessing you're not a dog lover. But surely the most ardent dog hater wouldn't advocate for getting rid of a rescue animal for the sake of an occasional kip in a comfy caravan? Wow.

SerenChocolateMuncher · 30/11/2023 12:38

Americano75 · 30/11/2023 12:35

It's the whole family being disturbed. One child who also works and another with mocks coming up. She's already explained all of that.

Yes. Absolutely right. The whole family is being disturbed. By the DOG.

The dog is the problem. Not the husband.

Americano75 · 30/11/2023 12:35

SerenChocolateMuncher · 30/11/2023 12:31

You say you would do this for your family, but you don't think the OP should? Her husband has said he doesn't want to sleep in the caravan, so why doesn't she step up and offer? I'll tell you why, because - just like her husband - she doesn't want to.

I'm not going to pretend I would offer to sleep in a caravan in these circumstances, because I wouldn't. If my husband expected me to - especially if he was prioritising a dog over my comfort - he wouldn't be my husband for much longer.

Neither would I expect my husband to sleep in a caravan in the garden. In fact, I wouldn't want him to even if he offered. He has every right to enjoy the comfort of the home he is providing for us and he is infinitely more important to me than any bloody dog could possibly be.

The dog barking is the problem, not the husband's entirely understandable refusal to be thrown out of his home. The problem should be resolved by the wife sleeping in the caravan with the dog, or by getting rid of the dog.

Edited

It's the whole family being disturbed. One child who also works and another with mocks coming up. She's already explained all of that.

SALWARP2023 · 30/11/2023 12:34

Sorry but the dog is the problem and that is what needs addressing. How would you feel the other way round?

SerenChocolateMuncher · 30/11/2023 12:31

Americano75 · 30/11/2023 12:05

I think you're reading way too much into this, and being far too hard on the op.

Also, I think the 'poor man out slaving away for his selfish family' narrative is a false one, seeing as the op has said that he enjoys these shifts and happily takes them.

And yes, it is easy for me to say that I'd do it for my family in the circumstances because it's the truth. It's a no brainer for me.

You say you would do this for your family, but you don't think the OP should? Her husband has said he doesn't want to sleep in the caravan, so why doesn't she step up and offer? I'll tell you why, because - just like her husband - she doesn't want to.

I'm not going to pretend I would offer to sleep in a caravan in these circumstances, because I wouldn't. If my husband expected me to - especially if he was prioritising a dog over my comfort - he wouldn't be my husband for much longer.

Neither would I expect my husband to sleep in a caravan in the garden. In fact, I wouldn't want him to even if he offered. He has every right to enjoy the comfort of the home he is providing for us and he is infinitely more important to me than any bloody dog could possibly be.

The dog barking is the problem, not the husband's entirely understandable refusal to be thrown out of his home. The problem should be resolved by the wife sleeping in the caravan with the dog, or by getting rid of the dog.

Americano75 · 30/11/2023 12:28

She said the extra money is 'welcome' which would be the case for the vast majority of people.

It's not a case of the dog ranking higher than the husband either, it's about managing the effects of the dog's barking.

betterangels · 30/11/2023 12:21

Also, I think the 'poor man out slaving away for his selfish family' narrative is a false one, seeing as the op has said that he enjoys these shifts and happily takes them.

She has also repeatedly said that she'll happily take the money. A dog shouldn't rank higher than a husband, especially not a husband who works unsoocialable, extra hours to make a COL crisis more manageable. Priorities are off.

Americano75 · 30/11/2023 12:05

SerenChocolateMuncher · 30/11/2023 11:33

That is easy for you to say. You are not him and you are not being asked to sleep in a caravan after finishing a shift in the freezing cold, making money for the benefit of your family.

He has said he doesn't want to sleep in the caravan, so it is unreasonable to think he should. If his wife thinks it's such a great solution, why isn't she sleeping in the caravan? She could take her rotten dog with her to keep warm and everyone can be happy .

If I was him, I would be hurt and angry that my wife thought my comfort was less important than that of a bloody dog.

I wouldn't blame him if he walked away from this situation. Considering the selfish disdain she treats him with, she might be happy for that to happen. Poor man.

I think you're reading way too much into this, and being far too hard on the op.

Also, I think the 'poor man out slaving away for his selfish family' narrative is a false one, seeing as the op has said that he enjoys these shifts and happily takes them.

And yes, it is easy for me to say that I'd do it for my family in the circumstances because it's the truth. It's a no brainer for me.

SerenChocolateMuncher · 30/11/2023 11:33

Americano75 · 30/11/2023 10:50

Sorry, I don't agree. She's found a solution to what is a fairly big problem, not just for her but their children. She's asking him to occasionally sleep in a well equipped camper home not, not sleep on a park bench. If it was me in his shoes, I'd do it.

That is easy for you to say. You are not him and you are not being asked to sleep in a caravan after finishing a shift in the freezing cold, making money for the benefit of your family.

He has said he doesn't want to sleep in the caravan, so it is unreasonable to think he should. If his wife thinks it's such a great solution, why isn't she sleeping in the caravan? She could take her rotten dog with her to keep warm and everyone can be happy .

If I was him, I would be hurt and angry that my wife thought my comfort was less important than that of a bloody dog.

I wouldn't blame him if he walked away from this situation. Considering the selfish disdain she treats him with, she might be happy for that to happen. Poor man.

Americano75 · 30/11/2023 10:50

SerenChocolateMuncher · 30/11/2023 10:23

That doesn't excuse her treating her hardworking husband as if he's lower down the family pecking order than the dog. Her life would be a whole lot harder if he decides to walk away from his ungrateful wife. She's lucky he hasn't gone already.

Sorry, I don't agree. She's found a solution to what is a fairly big problem, not just for her but their children. She's asking him to occasionally sleep in a well equipped camper home not, not sleep on a park bench. If it was me in his shoes, I'd do it.

LuckySantangelo35 · 30/11/2023 10:43

Dog isn’t more important than husband

dog doesn’t go out to work, husband does

dog can sleep outside not husband

SerenChocolateMuncher · 30/11/2023 10:23

Americano75 · 30/11/2023 09:15

That's pretty harsh given the op cares for her terminally ill mother, on top of working herself and with a chronic health condition. That's a fairly impressive example to set I'd have thought?

That doesn't excuse her treating her hardworking husband as if he's lower down the family pecking order than the dog. Her life would be a whole lot harder if he decides to walk away from his ungrateful wife. She's lucky he hasn't gone already.

Americano75 · 30/11/2023 09:15

Sayitaintso33 · 30/11/2023 06:52

You need to set a better example and teach your children to be proud of and value their hard grafting father.

That's pretty harsh given the op cares for her terminally ill mother, on top of working herself and with a chronic health condition. That's a fairly impressive example to set I'd have thought?

lemmein · 30/11/2023 08:39

I don't think it's an insane (or cruel!) idea like some posters seem to think, however, he doesn't want to so that's that, you'll both have to find another solution.

My DDs dog is staying with us at the minute and barks at the slightest noise so I get your frustration. If your dogs anything like my DDs I don't think your DH in the caravan would solve the barking issue anyway because she'll still hear him creeping about outside. It might actually make it worse if she's barking out of fear!

If the dog would settle in the caravan I'd do that, or if you can afford it ask DH to give up the shifts - it's not sustainable surviving on so little sleep.

It sounds like you've got a lot on @CaraVann -I hope you find a solution.

Scirocco · 30/11/2023 08:21

Asking someone to sleep in a caravan rather than in their home, where there's even a spare bedroom, is unreasonable. He's working demanding shifts, helping keep roads safe, bringing in extra money for the family... I doubt he's doing it because of some great love for his job - he's doing it for you all. Telling him he can't sleep in his own home because he's bothering the very people he's working to support just feels unappreciative.

It sounds like you all need to be able to get some rest, so if DH sleeps in the spare room or the living room you could try:

  • dampening sound with thicker rugs/carpets
  • white noise
  • training your dog not to bark when DH comes home
  • gradually training yourself to be able to sleep through normal sounds of a person moving around downstairs
  • earplugs for your children
  • over-ear noise cancelling headphones for you if you can get comfortable with them on
  • melatonin
  • if all else fails, you could ask your GP if they'd consider a short course of sleeping tablets for you
ElevenSeven · 30/11/2023 07:29

Yabu, sort your dog out

JurassicFantastic · 30/11/2023 07:14

I think everyone's got a bit lost on this one.

From the shift patterns the only problematic time is when DH LEAVES at 2am - all other times are when they would be awake or its not too unreasonable for them to be awake (11pm/6am).

Surely the dog can be trained not to bark when DH LEAVES the house (as opposed to coming into the house)?

You say DH doesn't work the day after a night shift so can sleep then, so there is no need for DH to use the spare room at all - he could just stay up, watch some TV, doze on the sofa until he leaves at 2am and the dog could be with him.

Surely the dog doesn't bark everytime someone who is is in the same room as leaves the house? And if it does, yes it needs some sort of training/changed routine for the dog to stop this more generally.

Sayitaintso33 · 30/11/2023 06:52

You need to set a better example and teach your children to be proud of and value their hard grafting father.

Doingmybest12 · 30/11/2023 06:47

It's not working for you as a family. I think he should give up the shifts.

Swipe left for the next trending thread