Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Doesn't it feel terribly unfair sometimes that..

207 replies

DrowninginMaryBeardsBeard · 29/11/2023 01:46

The kids in primary school who tend to be the clever ones also, unfairly, seem to be attractive and popular too.
Not sure if its just my kids school. Obviously my kid is beyond beautiful to me. But she's not as well put together as these girls, her hair is all over the place due to her inheriting curly hair from me, she's too skinny due to food aversion.
Then there's a group of girls who are just beautiful, they always have neat work, speak several languages, get the best parts in the school play, they look... cool... even at nine. Mums are equally stylish usually European women.
Why is this? Attractive well educated women have attractive clever children. Scatty, hairy mares like me born without beauty and brains have to run around like headless chickens, work more hours for less pay so have less time for taking our kids to the hairdressers and spending hours teaching them Spanish, doing long division or reading the classics?
It's like if you see the line of kids you could almost match them up with the parents without knowing. Slightly overweight child with the overweight parents, messy kid with the messy mum (that's me!), hippie child with the hippie parents, sleek ponytailed outdoorsy child with horse riding mum. I mean this isn't exactly rocket science. But the link between attractiveness, academic ability, class and 'polish' .... that I find fascinating.
Is there also a link with neurodiversity?
For what it's worth my primary school was not middle class at all, kids with parents in prison or addicts who had left them with grandparents to raise, and this was not the case. We were all the same class and so that wasn't a factor. It was more who was 'pretty' and that was only decided by who the boys wanted to kiss, so not a true representation of beauty. I remember there being a sort of 'blonde privilege' where blondeness was a marker of beauty which brunette would never beat, regardless of facial symmetry. That would never fly now and would be rightly challenged in DD's very diverse school.
And these ramblings are why I'm exhausted every day...

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Peablockfeathers · 29/11/2023 08:41

Slightly overweight child with the overweight parents, messy kid with the messy mum (that's me!), hippie child with the hippie parents, sleek ponytailed outdoorsy child with horse riding mum.

This makes sense though, invariably these things are nurture over nature.

The overweight child with overweight parents will share their diet and activity levels more likely than not; the messy parent won't invest as much time and effort in polishing their child's appearance if it isn't a priority to themselves and/or they don't know how to- no hair is truly unmanageable if you have the time and money which lots don't; the hippie child will be influenced by their parents attitudes and they'll buy clothes they also like; outdoorsy child will no doubt be exposed to their parents outdoorsy hobbies.

There are of course many factors that influence and have an affect, but I don't think it's shocking. I can't say I've paid enough attention to notice the attractiveness thing, but honestly have well maintained hair, skin and clothes etc makes a huge difference to someone's attractiveness- it's not all genetics. Speaking about adults now, but there are few people who if they were a healthy weight, invested time and money into doing their nails, eyebrows, looking after their hair and skin, knowing what style suits them and being good at make up would be ugly still.

Zanatdy · 29/11/2023 08:40

My DD is beautiful, always told by others, a lady stopped me in the petrol station forecourt once to tell me how beautiful she was. She is very clever too. She also suffers from low self esteem and low confidence, she wasn’t the kid who got the best parts in plays, they tend to go to the confident kids

RuledbytheWashingMachine · 29/11/2023 08:38

I don't really know what you mean. I have 4 children at school and each are their own person.

My eldest DD was very neat and was desperate to be popular. She was confident and did every club going. I think her 'try hardness' perhaps put people off.

However my second DD was very popular, athletic, academic but was out spoken and really didn't give a shit.

The third DD always tries her very best and goes out of her way to be friendly. She has lots of friends and is messy.

My boy is fun, popular and just ok at learning. Doesn't give a damn.

None of them are not really like me or dh. Each is individual. We have always encouraged them to be themselves.

YorkshirePuddingBelongs · 29/11/2023 08:33

If it helps OP my 10yo DD is supermodel beautiful, I have been getting comments from strangers since she was a baby - she is absolutely gorgeous, and very popular at school….But she struggles so much. I’m going in for a meeting on what more can be done, she already gets extra support and I have a horrible feeling they may want to hold her back Sad

WrongSwanson · 29/11/2023 08:31

TheaBrandt · 29/11/2023 08:18

Also looks vary over region. Dh and I noticed this starkly when we visited one particular city for a concert the general public looked quite different to the general public where we live!

You know you want to name the city....

User5442525 · 29/11/2023 08:30

Absolutely agree with the neurodiversity issue. Two successful, neurotypical parents are more likely to produce neurotypical kids. These grow up in a healthy, clean environment where chores are (mostly) always done, the home tidy and also observe their parents having a vibrant social life. That in itself is a huge privilege. Neurodiverse kids are more likely to have neurodiverse parents, living in a slightly chaotic and messy home and whose mothers might be overwhelmed by the needs of multiple kids especially if they require extra appointments or therapy for SEN.

It's like living life on hard or easy mode. The neurotypical parents I know never really struggled getting their kids to meet milestones. They were sent off to nursery aged 1-2 and stayed there without any problems or behavioural issues. This frees up enough time for the mum to focus on herself or taking care of younger siblings. Both obviously earn enough to pay for nursery or nannies. Neurotypical kids don't have any sensory issues regarding food so it was a breeze weaning them and they tend to eat healthier. It's easier to get them away from screens. That has another knock-on beneficial effect on health, immunity, appearance and overall well being.

Over the years, these kids tend to be more popular for the same reasons. They are used to being social, charming and interacting with others which they learned easily from their parents. Their parents are also more likely to be proactive and social towards teachers and other parents. In my school, I noticed a strong correlation between the popular kids whose parents all knew each other outside of school, and often the teachers as well, versus kids on the fringes whose parents only showed up to drop off and pick up.

PersephonePomegranate23 · 29/11/2023 08:22

This isn't evident at all at my DC's school, I wonder if it's more prominent depending on the area? We are in the 'burbs and there is a real mix of people and families, from parents who are solicitors and corporates, to self-employed tradesmen or skilled workers, to perpetually unemployed, screaming at your kids in public, drinking cider from a can round the corner just before pick-up...and lots in between.

The kids all just look like kids to me. I couldn't identify whether they're the bright ones or otherwise by looking at them.

The people and things you mention in your OP all sound like the privileges that stem from having money and a SAHP, really.

Being the brightest and/or cleverest at 9 isn't really any guarantee of how the rest of someone's life will pan out though. I don't know if it's even beneficial, really.

TheaBrandt · 29/11/2023 08:18

Also looks vary over region. Dh and I noticed this starkly when we visited one particular city for a concert the general public looked quite different to the general public where we live!

Iwanttowantto · 29/11/2023 08:16

Clever men earn lots of money and marry beautiful women (because that's what men prioritise) and the children get a combo of beauty and brains in the gene pool? Not the most forward looking theory but makes sense to me. Run this over a few generations and both the men and women get both cleverer and more beautiful and there an elite forms.

ZenNudist · 29/11/2023 08:14

You just sound like you're stereotyping. Plus you sound lacking in confidence so everyone else seems more together than you. Don't let this rub off on your dd. Confidence will help her in life.

Mummymummy89 · 29/11/2023 08:08

TheaBrandt · 29/11/2023 07:13

On seeing the supermodel type beauty that dd2 has emerged as at a family wedding recently heard my mum explain to my aunt “well mr Brandt is very tall and elegant” by way of explanation 😀

Woah that's so rude, I'd be furious!

I'm mixed race and my (single) mum's favourite wtf anecdote is how a woman complimented me as a small child and said "what a beautiful child, her father must be so handsome". (My dad has always looked like an ogre. My mum is beautiful although tbf I don't look much like her, being mixed.)

How do people not realise how rude they're being!!

Newsenmum · 29/11/2023 08:00

It’s a bit of everything. And intelligence often brings money and understanding of how to be attractive. And confidence. Confiedencr makes you attractive.

WrongSwanson · 29/11/2023 07:57

gumpf · 29/11/2023 07:50

Your ex gets unsupervised access to a daughter he has traumatised and in a shared house? Christ, what court has allowed that?

Welcome to the UK family court system. This doesn't surprise me in the slightest. The needs /wishes of the abusive parent are generally put higher than the needs/wishes of the child.

WrongSwanson · 29/11/2023 07:53

As others have said, being super bright at school isn't always the gift it seems. Breezing through school can mean you don't learn resilience

I expect the very bright and beautiful ones get noticed. But there are probably brighter but more average looking children there too.

gumpf · 29/11/2023 07:50

Your ex gets unsupervised access to a daughter he has traumatised and in a shared house? Christ, what court has allowed that?

jemenfous37 · 29/11/2023 07:47

Better breeding stock! It's subliminal bias; looking for healthy, shiny and genetically robust mates, happens, and life-style etc is perpetuated.
Yes, it is this basic (with some exceptions, granted). As with any animal breeding lines, certain parameters will breed certain traits. Tall athletic bods are unlikely to be attracted to the short dumpy bods (such as mine), and then the whole social class will raise its ugly head...

TheWayTheLightFalls · 29/11/2023 07:45

At a basic level most parents instil their genes but also their social mores and styles into their kids.

I’m not particularly attractive but always excelled academically. DH likewise. All three kids are shaping up to be multi-lingual academically confident people who lead with their brains (rather than their social successes, iyswim).

Haydug · 29/11/2023 07:45

Can't say it has been my experience. Through school or work! I am average, in both looks and intelligence. The intelligent ones in school weren't the typically good looking ones from what I'm remembering!

DrowninginMaryBeardsBeard · 29/11/2023 07:44

I suppose there's other things at play. I think it's that some things are massive factors in how our children develop and that's most apparent by the end of primary.

So for example, I was one of the clever kids in my primary but only in one or two subjects. I've never been able to study things I don't find interesting, probably down to ADHD. So I didn't leave school with a great overall education, it was A's in the subjects I enjoyed and C's and D's in the ones I didn't. I did a degree but at the end I didn't apply for any grad level jobs but took on an assistant manager role at a coffee shop as I felt more at home around the people there. This is what growing up WC can do, it can make you feel out of your depth and like you don't belong.
So after ten years of minimum wage jobs, I moved into the public sector. I guess this was already shown as a valid option for people like me my whole family had always worked in the council. Then I started working in family support and the rest is history. I chose a career helping people like the families I grew up around. I see families who struggle with addiction and parental mental health.
So for my daughter, she's up against both barriers of class, ableism as she has autism, sexism and being born to a skint single mother who works out of the house 40 hours a week. She's also got trauma from my abusive relationship with her dad. She can't always shower or bath at his as he lives in a shared house. She doesn't always have clean clothes because he can't remember to bring them or take them to his mums to wash.
You only have to look at all these factors to see how many barriers there are to being attractive, well turned out (I'll keep using that phrase as we all know what it means) and be a good student.
Compare that to a two parent household, with both in the private sector, one working from home or part time to do school runs and life admin, good genetics, being NT... the list goes on! Add being confident because you know your parents are reliable, dependable people, not likely to pick you up drunk or take you to the pub until 8pm on a school night!

OP posts:
RitaFromThePitCanteen · 29/11/2023 07:40

Could they just be wealthy? Wealth buys you extra time, extra help, extra polish, better health and less stress.

Didimum · 29/11/2023 07:36

This was not my experience of school (I’m only 30). The ‘pretty and popular’ kids, both boys and girls tended to perform worst across the board in their subjects, be in the lower sets and had poor exam results. They also were less likely to go to university.

gumpf · 29/11/2023 07:36

I have no idea who the bright kids are in my kids' schools, wouldn't have a scooby. But looking back on my school years, that certainly wasn't the case, I'd say the opposite in fact, especially with boys!

TheYearOfSmallThings · 29/11/2023 07:35

I don't think that is true at all.

Partly because I was always one of the smartest kids, and certainly neither beautiful nor cool, and the same applied to my smart friends (they look fantastic now though Grin).

In my son's Y4 class one of the smart kids is also handsome and charismatic, but the others are the usual scruffy looking specimens. Impossible to know what they will all look like in 10 years though. The most beautiful girl is in "tables club".

Karwomannghia · 29/11/2023 07:35

To me that sounds like your dd’s primary school is in a very affluent area and there is quite a lot of showcasing going on.

Supersimkin2 · 29/11/2023 07:33

Life is unfair but it’s what you make of it that matters.

Good hair has its limits as a life skill. Why doesn’t DD eat?