Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Doesn't it feel terribly unfair sometimes that..

207 replies

DrowninginMaryBeardsBeard · 29/11/2023 01:46

The kids in primary school who tend to be the clever ones also, unfairly, seem to be attractive and popular too.
Not sure if its just my kids school. Obviously my kid is beyond beautiful to me. But she's not as well put together as these girls, her hair is all over the place due to her inheriting curly hair from me, she's too skinny due to food aversion.
Then there's a group of girls who are just beautiful, they always have neat work, speak several languages, get the best parts in the school play, they look... cool... even at nine. Mums are equally stylish usually European women.
Why is this? Attractive well educated women have attractive clever children. Scatty, hairy mares like me born without beauty and brains have to run around like headless chickens, work more hours for less pay so have less time for taking our kids to the hairdressers and spending hours teaching them Spanish, doing long division or reading the classics?
It's like if you see the line of kids you could almost match them up with the parents without knowing. Slightly overweight child with the overweight parents, messy kid with the messy mum (that's me!), hippie child with the hippie parents, sleek ponytailed outdoorsy child with horse riding mum. I mean this isn't exactly rocket science. But the link between attractiveness, academic ability, class and 'polish' .... that I find fascinating.
Is there also a link with neurodiversity?
For what it's worth my primary school was not middle class at all, kids with parents in prison or addicts who had left them with grandparents to raise, and this was not the case. We were all the same class and so that wasn't a factor. It was more who was 'pretty' and that was only decided by who the boys wanted to kiss, so not a true representation of beauty. I remember there being a sort of 'blonde privilege' where blondeness was a marker of beauty which brunette would never beat, regardless of facial symmetry. That would never fly now and would be rightly challenged in DD's very diverse school.
And these ramblings are why I'm exhausted every day...

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
ManateeFair · 29/11/2023 10:07

Hmm, I dunno. I was one of the cleverest kids at school and I was a complete shambles. I can't really remember what people looked like at primary school, but certainly at secondary school the brightest girls weren't the prettiest and most polished ones. The pretty and polished Queen Bee types were usually good at sport and drama, mid-ranking academically.

mooneigh · 29/11/2023 10:05

To be fair, I have always found and others I know, have said the same. Back when we was at school the 'cool kids' (pretty and popular) are now the ones that are not so pretty and not doing well and the ones that were over weight and not so brushed up on beauty are the ones that are now looking great and actually doing better.
I get what you are saying but my point is, it doesn't really mean anything as people change / children grow up.

I know several people classed as like you say, I hate the school run (usually the scruffy one as I have just come from doing the horses before school run, as have to get to work after) and some parents are so judgemental. Makes me laugh they look down at you and won't speak to you in the playground. Yet they see you out riding your horse and want to be best friends. People are so weird.

Dubbledup · 29/11/2023 10:00

I think it's cyclical. The vaguely pretty or clever ones get praised very early on, they are then confident and enjoy being in the spotlight because they get lots of positive reinforcement from everyone around them, so they are then willing to put themselves forward, hold their head high, dare I say, be a bit bossy.

Other children who have had subtle put downs (not necessarily from parents) start to take a step back, keep their heads down etc.

I think you think the popular smart ones are pretty because they probably hold themselves better, aren't afraid to show off etc.

Bookist · 29/11/2023 09:58

I think it's down to natural selection. If you're born with good looks, intelligence and a pleasant personality then you have the privilege of being able to choose your partner from a similarly blessed cohort. The children you have are highly likely to be genetically blessed, and so it continues.

Goldenbear · 29/11/2023 09:56

I think in the primary/junior years of school you might have a point OP but IME it was more a case of organised, successful parents who made the most of the looks they had, had children that equally appeared well presented and quite intelligent but not super intelligent. I wouldn't say it was inate beauty though. My DS is now in 6th college and personally I think that correlation goes out of the window as the teenagers have individualised their looks and it has nothing to do with parents. Equally, in my DS's sixth form which admittedly is not in a conventional city in England and is pretty bohemian, the notion of popularity changes from the school years so the intelligent teenagers, probably more so girls that are naturally pretty but scruffy are cooler and shine in college when they were probably were overlooked at secondary as they were not polished.

I think the region thing is true and I find that really curious but I don't think that one is better than the other. I live in Brighton but have family in the south midlands and London and I do notice this in the local population. However, many people don't really move around as much as everyone thinks so there are generations of families in certain areas in the UK and there presumably is some correlation looks wise.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 29/11/2023 09:51

Speaking as a person with poker straight hair, those of you with curls ought to be GRATEFUL. And if your children have curls you should be DELIGHTED. I would have killed for the slightest wave or a bit of movement, not just straight straight straight hair every day of my life.

ClemFandango1 · 29/11/2023 09:50

I think neurodiversity is certainly a factor.

My grandma was, and is, incredibly chic and put together. My mum failed to inherit that skillset and so did I! I look like a lumbering troll most days. Now I have a dd with curly hair so the odds are stacked against her ever looking effortlessly cool, poor thing.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 29/11/2023 09:41

(Just to add I did extremely well at school, was always well turned out but also had 'unruly curls'. I also wasn't especially pretty)

RepetitiveMotion · 29/11/2023 09:40

As others have said, it’s often not the most academic that are the most successful after education. It is often the more confident, and those with other skills that aren’t valued at school like persuasion, entrepreneurship and leadership skills that end up doing the “best”.

We all want our DC to be happy. That might mean SAHM or sparkling international well paid career or making a difference to the world. As pp have said, the people that I know that fall into one of those categories and are really happy are not spectacular looking!

DumboHimalayan · 29/11/2023 09:37

IIRC there are measurable statistical correlations between some or all of: attractiveness, IQ, academic success, popularity, height, salary, health, longevity… But they're probably only really measurable on a big statistical population level, so I wouldn't expect any one person's experiences, or any particular school class, to reflect that.

Having said that, I knew an older boy when I was a kid, a family friend, who was academically stellar, tall, good-looking as far as I could tell, a grade 8 clarinettist, popular, and also the nicest person imaginable, the utter bastard 🤣 I think he's a doctor now.

Yants · 29/11/2023 09:33

RantyAnty · 29/11/2023 03:02

Was there something that stopped you from getting a good education?

Are you suggesting that the State education system unquestionably offers every single child the opportunity to achieve their maximum academic potential and doesn't in any way fail children to any degree whatsoever?

GnomeDePlume · 29/11/2023 09:31

Something I noticed when Friends Reunited first started, before it got taken over by SM polish, was how much time averages everything out.

The beautiful/clever people I had been at school with were in their 40s just the same as me (plain/average intelligence). On the whole, they had done okay but ultimately nothing special.

At school they had seemed so amazing but in the end time has averaged it out.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 29/11/2023 09:26

I seems like I'm in the minority but it always kind of baffles me that people notice this sort of stuff? I know the names of some of the kids in my son's class but couldn't pick them out of a line up unless they're his particular friends.

Is this more noticeable with girls than boys?

I will say that I'm an overweight, either completely put together (as come from work) or scruffy AF (as come from WFH so lucky so joggers, jumper and hair scragged up) whereas my children are always very well turned out and are not overweight at all. Two of them have additional needs, one is consistently top of his class in everything.

Thepeopleversuswork · 29/11/2023 09:26

I understand the syndrome….

But there’s an important difference between natural intelligence and natural beauty and the sort of competence and polish which is often bred by affluent, high achieving and confident parents.

Are children from solid middle class backgrounds with parents who know how to burnish their confidence, which books to buy for them, which subjects to buy tutoring in and how to dress them intrinsically more beautiful and intelligent or do they know how to play the game?

There’s probably some genetic natural selection at play; beautiful and intelligent people usually have a greater pool of potential mates open to them than those with less of these traits but a large amount of this is down to people knowing how to make society work for them.

Treaclesandwich · 29/11/2023 09:24

Looks alone get you so far. You’ve ultimately got to walk the walk. Looks won’t pass you an exam, or mean you can do your job to a high standard. In my job, the clients don’t give a shit what you look like, so long as you’re presentable and professional. All they care about is getting the job done to a decent standard.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 29/11/2023 09:21

Iwanttowantto · 29/11/2023 08:16

Clever men earn lots of money and marry beautiful women (because that's what men prioritise) and the children get a combo of beauty and brains in the gene pool? Not the most forward looking theory but makes sense to me. Run this over a few generations and both the men and women get both cleverer and more beautiful and there an elite forms.

This is almost certainly true. But then they start to marry within too restricted a circle, and all sorts of problems emerge. Just look at Victoria’s grandchildren, more interbreeding there than at Crufts, and to no good effect. ( see also : Plantagenets and French royalty). Actually, genetics as I hazily understand them seems to indicate that there is a tendency to return to the mean, so the offspring are not necessarily ‘better’ than the two parents. A lot of ‘breeding’ of animals bears this out ( although people try desperately to ignore this as £££)

Probably a good thing that the current POW had a mother from the aristocracy rather than royalty, and has found a middle class wife !

DrowninginMaryBeardsBeard · 29/11/2023 09:13

@TheaBrandt was it Leona Lewis?

OP posts:
TheaBrandt · 29/11/2023 09:13

Lickle I felt that watching a “who do you think you are” program with an absolutely beautiful sexy singer. But my god you could see there was no spark there at all - the sort your heart sinks when you are put next to them in a restaurant.

Honeychickpea · 29/11/2023 09:09

@LickleLamb Your perception has little connection to reality, but if it makes you feel better, go with it. It's not going to harm anyone else.

SnacksToTheMax · 29/11/2023 09:04

violetcuriosity · 29/11/2023 08:47

Two nice neat French plaits with the 'paintbrush' ends for easy chewing?

I know your post isn't about hairstyles 😂 but I'm a teacher of children with ASD, maybe you could replace the hair with other sensory toys? Xx

My daughter is autistic and I can confirm: doing two plaits are a total lifesaver and the only hairstyle she will tolerate! Looks relatively tidy, keeps it out of her face and lasts the whole day.

I’m not good enough at hair to do French braids (and she won’t sit long enough), but simple ones are fine, and she can still play with them (I’m gradually weaning her off chomping on the ends).

She HATES me brushing her hair but it gets too tangled not to - the braids now stay in overnight to minimise knots. I can then re-do them in the morning one side at a time and it’s just all so much easier - for some reason she will tolerate me brushing one half of her hair at a time, but not her whole head!

LickleLamb · 29/11/2023 08:51

Anyone I've come across who is v attractive, tall, slim, nice voice, etc has also been boring with little sense of humour. Made me wonder if you float through life being admired you don't have to try very hard and hence no funny wit.

Gnomegnomegnome · 29/11/2023 08:50

I think that expectations put on to children plays a massive part. Parents are into how they look, being physically active, eating well, history buffs or maths genius’s. They will encourage their children to be into these things.
Parents with a high sense of achievement will encourage their children to become high achieving.

My parents were arty, chaotic and disorganised. They didn’t encourage academic or physical activities because they weren’t on their radar. If I had been really into science or horse riding they wouldn’t have understood it or encouraged me. It wasn’t their thing, we weren’t ‘those people’. Absolutely no interest in how they looked and thought that not drinking one night a week was the key to good health. I was like that as a child (not the alcohol obviously) but as an adult discovered that I was actually quite good at subjects other than art, that I need organisation and calm and that I like to make an effort (for me) and to look nice.

violetcuriosity · 29/11/2023 08:47

DrowninginMaryBeardsBeard · 29/11/2023 07:28

@violetcuriosity that would be ideal but DD has sensory stuff around her hair. In particular she chews it so if I put it up, she would pull it down to chew the ends.

Two nice neat French plaits with the 'paintbrush' ends for easy chewing?

I know your post isn't about hairstyles 😂 but I'm a teacher of children with ASD, maybe you could replace the hair with other sensory toys? Xx

Pomonas · 29/11/2023 08:44

My kids were the most beautiful and clever at school according to me. I would not even check anybody else kids to compare ever. The mother of a very geeky looking girl once said to me. You know the popular group of girls are so and so and bullied other kids. It was news to me they were popular and I was thinking to myself you must be joking. 🤣 As it happened in year 6 I learned of some mothers who were making my DD lives difficult purely because they were jealous and insecure. I felt disgusted that grown up women could do that to a child. Now many years later those daughters are very unpopular and have not friends according to gossip going around. I blamed on the mothers as they projected their insecurities to their children. Hopefully you are wiser and are not doing that. It really affects their confidence.

DrowninginMaryBeardsBeard · 29/11/2023 08:42

@YorkshirePuddingBelongs I feel your pain. I hope the school listen to you. Has she been seen by an educational psychologist?

OP posts: