Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Doesn't it feel terribly unfair sometimes that..

207 replies

DrowninginMaryBeardsBeard · 29/11/2023 01:46

The kids in primary school who tend to be the clever ones also, unfairly, seem to be attractive and popular too.
Not sure if its just my kids school. Obviously my kid is beyond beautiful to me. But she's not as well put together as these girls, her hair is all over the place due to her inheriting curly hair from me, she's too skinny due to food aversion.
Then there's a group of girls who are just beautiful, they always have neat work, speak several languages, get the best parts in the school play, they look... cool... even at nine. Mums are equally stylish usually European women.
Why is this? Attractive well educated women have attractive clever children. Scatty, hairy mares like me born without beauty and brains have to run around like headless chickens, work more hours for less pay so have less time for taking our kids to the hairdressers and spending hours teaching them Spanish, doing long division or reading the classics?
It's like if you see the line of kids you could almost match them up with the parents without knowing. Slightly overweight child with the overweight parents, messy kid with the messy mum (that's me!), hippie child with the hippie parents, sleek ponytailed outdoorsy child with horse riding mum. I mean this isn't exactly rocket science. But the link between attractiveness, academic ability, class and 'polish' .... that I find fascinating.
Is there also a link with neurodiversity?
For what it's worth my primary school was not middle class at all, kids with parents in prison or addicts who had left them with grandparents to raise, and this was not the case. We were all the same class and so that wasn't a factor. It was more who was 'pretty' and that was only decided by who the boys wanted to kiss, so not a true representation of beauty. I remember there being a sort of 'blonde privilege' where blondeness was a marker of beauty which brunette would never beat, regardless of facial symmetry. That would never fly now and would be rightly challenged in DD's very diverse school.
And these ramblings are why I'm exhausted every day...

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
DaisyDoor · 29/11/2023 14:21

I think the link is effort (and to a lesser extent money). A lot of good looking people aren’t actually very different from the rest- the difference is grooming, healthy eating, exercise and taking an interest in how you look.

Likewise for the vast majority, academic success is also down to effort. You get a few outliers who succeed without effort or fail even with effort, but most of us are somewhere in the middle and how well we do relates to how hard we work.

People who make an effort and have high standards in one area find it easier to make an effort and have high standards in others.

Ace56 · 29/11/2023 14:08

I’m not sure that brains and beauty is necessarily linked (sometimes it is, sometimes it isn’t), but it’s fair to say that these attractive European women would likely have chosen to breed with attractive European men, which means their offspring are already set up with good genes. Add to this their culture/the way they are brought up (learning languages etc) and it’s no surprise the way their children turn out.

ItsRainingTacos79 · 29/11/2023 14:03

Hmm, not sure if there really is a correlation.

But I do know that conventionally attractive people generally go out with fellow conventionally attractive people and go on to marry/not marry and have conventionally attractive children? How it links with intelligence, I'm not so sure but I often find that what is considered 'conventionally attractive' is in line with beauty standards of the more affluent people, their affluent fashion sense/style/look is 'aspirational'. And affluent people are more likely to have had access to better quality education, leading to higher paid jobs, leading to ability to be groomed and well dressed etc and in turn their children follow?

So, in conclusion, it's do to with money.

HolySkirts · 29/11/2023 13:39

I have four degrees. So do vast numbers of the parents doing drop offs at DS's primary school, because it's near a university and two hospitals, and lots of us are academics/medics etc. Bar one woman (who is an architect) who has a wonderful and eternally neat Louise Brooks bob, I would say the rest of us look perfectly ordinary/permanently slightly bedraggled, as we are mostly on foot or on bikes, damp, and dressed in outdoor clothing and/or cycle helmets over scrubs or work clothes. As do our children.

DH is clever. We have a clever (but lazy) child. Both DH and I are from impoverished WC backgrounds, and are the first in our families to finish school, far less go to university. All of our parents left school at 12/13, and worked in manual, MW jobs all their lives. DH' school was reasonable, but mine was notorious for its truancy, fighting and pregnancies. Lots of my classmates have spent time in prison, and some died young. I feel very lucky I was stubborn enough to manage to get out, with no support or encouragement. We now present as MC, and work in professional jobs, live in a crumbling Victorian pile in an 'old money' part of the city, but we're not.

What I'm trying to say is that people are more various than you're suggesting. I'm certainly clever and high-achieving, but unpolished and not particularly pretty in appearance. I'm not sure I read as being anything in particular.

Usernamen · 29/11/2023 13:29

Honestly it was the exact opposite at my school. The cool, popular kids grew up to have the least interesting lives, while the plain/overweight/geeky ones are doing very well indeed.

To take one example, a girl who was bullied for being fat is now a consultant surgeon and looks stunning (she lost the weight, and has acquired ‘polish’) and the girl who used to bully her quite honestly looks about 10-15 years older than she is, from smoking, drugs and a life of relative deprivation.

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/11/2023 12:56

Dubbledup · 29/11/2023 11:32

Ew your child gets stopped in the street for people to comment on her physical appearance? I would not be pleased with that at all!

Yeah, curse of being a red head lol.

MumblesParty · 29/11/2023 12:36

A friend of mine is stunning, could have been a model when we were younger. Also incredibly clever. Earns a fortune, and happily married. And a lovely kind person, hugely popular, but not arrogant, and treats everyone equally. Just an all-round great person, who on the surface would appear to have everything.

But her Mum was a young single parent, couldn’t cope, and my friend was fostered for years as a young child. My friend never wanted kids, due, I think, to her unstable childhood. She is full of anxieties which she conceals from most people.

Nothing is how it seems OP.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 29/11/2023 12:35

I live in an area with a very high number of graduates.

Most of the kids at our primary look messy and geeky. None of them look beautiful.

The ones at secondary just look like teens.

My daughter is drop dead gorgeous at 17 and really clever. However she has ASD so struggles socially. I don’t buy into your theory.

And from what l remember at school it’s the late bloomers/ weird kids who are the most interesting later in life.

MumblesParty · 29/11/2023 12:29

I think you’re pigeon-holing people too much OP.
Not many kids fit your categories. Most are a mix of features, good and bad.

I came from a very academic background, which was loving and nurturing. I was clever and did well at school. I was also quite pretty as a child and young adult. I always had friends and was socially comfortable. I went to university and became a doctor.

But we were very poor when I grew up, as my Dad left and my Mum struggled to find work. My brother was on the autistic spectrum (undiagnosed - it was the 70s), suffered with depression and killed himself age 20.

I have a good professional job and I’m healthy, but I have zero sense of style and my house hasn’t been decorated for 30 years, so it looks scruffy. I’ve been pretty unlucky in love so I’m a single parent. I have mild OCD and lie awake at night worrying about my kids dying.

My kids are bright, attractive and popular, but they have no father, and my younger child has an anxious nature and some OCD features. We are comfortable but not wealthy.

So you see - in some areas of life I and my family are lucky and truly blessed. But in other areas I have been dealt a pretty shit hand in life. Nothing is black and white.

crackofdoom · 29/11/2023 12:11

😆 at the "messy family" bit, you've got us to a T there! We went to DS1'S careers evening last night, and all 3 of us had significantly more mud stains/ holes in our clothes than the mean! Part of that is down to getting outdoors a lot, part to being poor.

We are also an autistic family. DS2 is by far the cleverest in his class, but certainly doesn't look put together, especially with his terrible lack-of-haircut, due to him not tolerating getting his hair cut....🤷‍♀️

ginandtonicwithlimes · 29/11/2023 11:46

My six year old daughter is very bright, blond and blue eyes yet very rarely gets invited to parties and is often on the periphery of the friendship groups. Obviously it might change as only six but it isn't always the case.

meganorks · 29/11/2023 11:45

I think YABU. I don't see a correlation at all.

Desecratedcoconut · 29/11/2023 11:37

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/11/2023 11:18

Disagree sorry.

Brains and beauty rarely go together in my experience. Indeed if anything the opposite is true.

Also lots of lovely looking children quickly lose their looks with age and others very much grow in to them.

I don't think this is true. This is the type of thing that people want to be true because it suggests that there is some sort of parity and justice in the world. But beautiful people, failing injury, carry that symmetry with them through their whole lives.

Dubbledup · 29/11/2023 11:32

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/11/2023 11:26

I also disagree about the neurodiversity.

DC are neurodiverse but they are the first to be so in my family. They are really good looking kids (not biased she regularly gets stopped in the street and complimented). The are clean, well turned out, popular etc.. they just happen to have significant additional needs. Certainly hasn't impacted on their looks.

Ew your child gets stopped in the street for people to comment on her physical appearance? I would not be pleased with that at all!

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/11/2023 11:26

I also disagree about the neurodiversity.

DC are neurodiverse but they are the first to be so in my family. They are really good looking kids (not biased she regularly gets stopped in the street and complimented). The are clean, well turned out, popular etc.. they just happen to have significant additional needs. Certainly hasn't impacted on their looks.

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/11/2023 11:18

Disagree sorry.

Brains and beauty rarely go together in my experience. Indeed if anything the opposite is true.

Also lots of lovely looking children quickly lose their looks with age and others very much grow in to them.

bugbooosa · 29/11/2023 10:58

Op what really jumps out at me is that you are projecting your own insecurities and world view onto your child. It's not healthy to look a group of kids and compare them through this lens. Kindly, I think it would be a good idea to work on your own self esteem which will benefit your child too.

butterycrispness · 29/11/2023 10:52

Is this a private school?

butterycrispness · 29/11/2023 10:51

They may be absolutely awful people even if they do look good and speak a load of languages, are neat etc. What an incredibly dull world we would live in if everyone was the same and like that.

butterycrispness · 29/11/2023 10:50

DrowninginMaryBeardsBeard · 29/11/2023 01:46

The kids in primary school who tend to be the clever ones also, unfairly, seem to be attractive and popular too.
Not sure if its just my kids school. Obviously my kid is beyond beautiful to me. But she's not as well put together as these girls, her hair is all over the place due to her inheriting curly hair from me, she's too skinny due to food aversion.
Then there's a group of girls who are just beautiful, they always have neat work, speak several languages, get the best parts in the school play, they look... cool... even at nine. Mums are equally stylish usually European women.
Why is this? Attractive well educated women have attractive clever children. Scatty, hairy mares like me born without beauty and brains have to run around like headless chickens, work more hours for less pay so have less time for taking our kids to the hairdressers and spending hours teaching them Spanish, doing long division or reading the classics?
It's like if you see the line of kids you could almost match them up with the parents without knowing. Slightly overweight child with the overweight parents, messy kid with the messy mum (that's me!), hippie child with the hippie parents, sleek ponytailed outdoorsy child with horse riding mum. I mean this isn't exactly rocket science. But the link between attractiveness, academic ability, class and 'polish' .... that I find fascinating.
Is there also a link with neurodiversity?
For what it's worth my primary school was not middle class at all, kids with parents in prison or addicts who had left them with grandparents to raise, and this was not the case. We were all the same class and so that wasn't a factor. It was more who was 'pretty' and that was only decided by who the boys wanted to kiss, so not a true representation of beauty. I remember there being a sort of 'blonde privilege' where blondeness was a marker of beauty which brunette would never beat, regardless of facial symmetry. That would never fly now and would be rightly challenged in DD's very diverse school.
And these ramblings are why I'm exhausted every day...

For God's sake value yourself and your daughter. She's not too of anything and neither are you. Everyone has their pluses and minuses, things they are good and aren't, some are better looking some are worse, some are fashionable, some are not. It's not what people look like it's what inside that counts.

AttentionDeficitAndScrewed · 29/11/2023 10:29

I'm the messy mum with the messy children. :-(

But then dh is super organised and disciplined and somehow he has the same messy children (inspite of being very involved with them)....

LongAndWindingRoads · 29/11/2023 10:27

No, it's not unfair, because neither good looks or intelligence guarantee happiness.
Emotional intelligence is the key to happiness and success.

MrsSkylerWhite · 29/11/2023 10:23

Meh, people grow into themselves.

RantyAnty · 29/11/2023 10:21

LickleLamb · 29/11/2023 08:51

Anyone I've come across who is v attractive, tall, slim, nice voice, etc has also been boring with little sense of humour. Made me wonder if you float through life being admired you don't have to try very hard and hence no funny wit.

Maybe they don't find your type of humor funny.

Goldenbear · 29/11/2023 10:12

OP, you said, 'usually European', is it a cultural thing, a couple of a girls in DD's class whose Mum's were from a country in Europe always had the girl's hair plaited amazingly at 7,8,9 clothes ironed, washed clean coats etc, that said, there is a daughter of a Swedish Mum who wasn't like that and was always in outdoor gear that was quite dirty.