Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how anyone can be a teacher?

134 replies

Howdaretheydisciplinerudekids · 29/11/2023 00:41

I think I am quite an understanding parent when it comes to my kids schools. However, I do contact the schools whenever I have a concern. I am always polite and understanding of school issues but flag things up when necessary.

However, I hear how some parents speak to and about their children’s teachers and I am pretty disgusted and wonder how anyone remains in teaching. I have so many stories from friends about the crap they put up with from headteachers, parents and children. Who else has similar stories?

  1. A friend of mine was told on more than one occasion by a child that he wanted her dead and was going to shoot her. Her headteacher didn’t even ask if she was ok.
  2. The same child regularly used to throw things in the classroom and trash the classroom. The headteacher refused to get involved and instead blamed the teacher for their being equipment on the floor (that the child had thrown) and asked why she hadn’t picked it up. The child was still throwing things (this time aimed at the class teacher) at the time.
  3. I have heard many occasions of friends who have been out on capability plans for the most minor things. It would seem that bullying of staff from leadership is absolutely rife. For example, one teacher friend told me about the staff having a staff training day about a certain way of delivering maths. Part of the day was spent then planning maths in the said way. The headteacher went into maths lessons and then called all of the staff together because she didn’t like how they were teaching maths and told them all off. She said they should have ignored all training. Several friends have given me the same sort of stories.
  4. My teacher friends are always making excuses why they can’t go out. They have too much work to do. They are too stressed. They are off sick. They have marking to do, leSsons to plan, forms to fill in, statements to write, parents to contact, documents to complete, emails to send etc etc. Then when they have done all that, they have to actually teach a class for 7 hours. They get no let up in that time. They have to be physically and mentally involved and face verbal and sometimes physical abuse, with no chance to recover.
  5. Then they have parents to deal with. Parents who complain constantly because their child has been told off. Parents who constantly criticise teachers because their child, who has done something wrong, is then worrying about it. Or they have 2 sets of parents both claiming that their child is being bullied by the other. Or parents who have fallen out, expecting the schools to separate the children because their grown ups can’t resolve their own arguments.
  6. One relative of mine, was put under disciplinary procedures because they dared to speak sternly to a child who had been stealing from them. They did not even raise their voice. However, they now have a safeguarding concern about them because a member of staff heard them telling the child how upset they were to have had their personal items stolen by them, and the member of staff didn’t like their tone of voice. My poor relative was in bits over this accusation because they had taught for nearly 30 years and now felt like they had been blamed for being a victim of crime. My relative had to take early retirement.
  7. Another relative was teaching In A primary school and was filmed by a child on their phone, and it was shared around social media. My relative then told the child how upset they had been about this. However, instead of the child receiving any sort of consequence, instead my friend had to apologise to the child, for telling the child how upset they were. Sadly, another friend tried to commit suicide after all of the constant monitoring and accountability became too much for her. My friends and relatives who work in schools tell me about the lack of funding in their schools.
OP posts:
jellyfrizz · 29/11/2023 08:49

professionalnomad · 29/11/2023 08:02

I left the UK after 3 years of teaching in state schools and have been abroad for the last 15. I love my job, am extremely passionate about teaching and this was the only way I could see that I could keep doing it and make a decent living.

I did this the other way around; teaching abroad and then back to the UK. I loved teaching overseas (in state schools). I lasted a year and a half in England, I didn't enjoy viewing children as data and wanted to be able to spend some time with my family and so left.

It was so frustrating because I knew it doesn't have to be this way.

thirdistheonewiththehairychest · 29/11/2023 08:40

I decided to quit teaching the day a 4-year-old spat in my face and nothing was done about it.
I was lucky that I had a family business to step into; others unfortunately feel trapped.

Maddy70 · 29/11/2023 08:25

It really is the most difficult job. I left I honestly couldn't cope with it mentally and remain a decent teacher

Notellinganyone · 29/11/2023 08:23

I’ve been teaching for 27 years. However, I work in an independent school with, generally, supportive parents. The kids are mostly great and I have a fantastic department and the freedom to teach the texts I choose and to plan my own lessons. Because I’ve been there a long time 8 have built up a good reputation and that helps with relationships and discipline. I also get 17/week’s holiday. It’s no picnic- I worked a 14 hour day yesterday and have a lot of marking but I find it stimulating and satisfying. I couldn’t work in the state sector now.

Roadtomandalay · 29/11/2023 08:08

You've summed it up pretty well OP. Sounds like my typical week!

OfTheNight · 29/11/2023 08:04

It’s an incredibly difficult job and it’s got worse and worse over the last 20 years.

I left mainstream in 2016, but my DP works at a state secondary still. There isn’t a day goes by that he isn’t verbally abused by a student. Last week he had a textbook thrown at him. And he is considered well liked! Lots of his colleagues face even worse.

There is zero support from SLT and zero money to do anything constructive to support the students who need it.

professionalnomad · 29/11/2023 08:02

I left the UK after 3 years of teaching in state schools and have been abroad for the last 15. I love my job, am extremely passionate about teaching and this was the only way I could see that I could keep doing it and make a decent living.

freeandfierce · 29/11/2023 07:58

We have just introduced body cams, sad times that it's come to this to protect teaching staff. It's a daily occurrence for me to be sworn at, something thrown at me, chanted at. On occasion spat at, chairs thrown. Had stuff stolen from me too. I worry for our future workforce and those students who are being denied an education due to the behaviour of their peers. God help me if I seek support from my leaders. I can't see how this is sustainable, out of a team of 6 we are down to 2 covering the same workload. No one is applying to teach anymore. My colleague and I are teaching three classes infilled with one another, today I have a class of 42 in a room that seats 28. I hope I can get to the Christmas break that's all that's keeping me going currently.

daffodilandtulip · 29/11/2023 07:56

I quit a PGCE because I never "taught" a thing. There wasn't enough staff so I was actually given almost a full timetable to teach straight away. I spent hours planning lessons with zero guidance.

But I never taught any of it. What I did do was repeatedly ask children to put their phones away, stop playing games, stop throwing things, sit down. It took them ten minutes to come into the room and sit down and stop being silly. I then taught a sentence, and had to explain it differently and repeatedly to all the SEN children, then again to the children who couldn't be arsed the first/second/third time. Then someone would set the fire alarms off. Then someone would need the loo, so seven people would need the loo. And you've got an hour to teach them how to answer an exam question - because you don't teach knowledge, you teach them how to parrot out an answer to get the points.

And this wasn't because I was inexperienced, this was standard across the school. Oh and I'm talking about GCSE and A Level ages.

Then after school you have to provide a club to meet a certain target, then there would be a department meeting. Once a week there was an evening meeting. Plus parents evenings and open nights. Then home to plan for more lessons that you know you'll never teach.

MrsMurphyIWish · 29/11/2023 07:45

Nellodee · 29/11/2023 07:40

“I hope you aren’t a teacher” - I definitely judge people who say those words.

Edited

Parents need to hope there’s just a competent adult in the room.

Nellodee · 29/11/2023 07:40

“I hope you aren’t a teacher” - I definitely judge people who say those words.

BorisIsACuntWaffle · 29/11/2023 07:36

Howdaretheydisciplinerudekids · 29/11/2023 00:41

I think I am quite an understanding parent when it comes to my kids schools. However, I do contact the schools whenever I have a concern. I am always polite and understanding of school issues but flag things up when necessary.

However, I hear how some parents speak to and about their children’s teachers and I am pretty disgusted and wonder how anyone remains in teaching. I have so many stories from friends about the crap they put up with from headteachers, parents and children. Who else has similar stories?

  1. A friend of mine was told on more than one occasion by a child that he wanted her dead and was going to shoot her. Her headteacher didn’t even ask if she was ok.
  2. The same child regularly used to throw things in the classroom and trash the classroom. The headteacher refused to get involved and instead blamed the teacher for their being equipment on the floor (that the child had thrown) and asked why she hadn’t picked it up. The child was still throwing things (this time aimed at the class teacher) at the time.
  3. I have heard many occasions of friends who have been out on capability plans for the most minor things. It would seem that bullying of staff from leadership is absolutely rife. For example, one teacher friend told me about the staff having a staff training day about a certain way of delivering maths. Part of the day was spent then planning maths in the said way. The headteacher went into maths lessons and then called all of the staff together because she didn’t like how they were teaching maths and told them all off. She said they should have ignored all training. Several friends have given me the same sort of stories.
  4. My teacher friends are always making excuses why they can’t go out. They have too much work to do. They are too stressed. They are off sick. They have marking to do, leSsons to plan, forms to fill in, statements to write, parents to contact, documents to complete, emails to send etc etc. Then when they have done all that, they have to actually teach a class for 7 hours. They get no let up in that time. They have to be physically and mentally involved and face verbal and sometimes physical abuse, with no chance to recover.
  5. Then they have parents to deal with. Parents who complain constantly because their child has been told off. Parents who constantly criticise teachers because their child, who has done something wrong, is then worrying about it. Or they have 2 sets of parents both claiming that their child is being bullied by the other. Or parents who have fallen out, expecting the schools to separate the children because their grown ups can’t resolve their own arguments.
  6. One relative of mine, was put under disciplinary procedures because they dared to speak sternly to a child who had been stealing from them. They did not even raise their voice. However, they now have a safeguarding concern about them because a member of staff heard them telling the child how upset they were to have had their personal items stolen by them, and the member of staff didn’t like their tone of voice. My poor relative was in bits over this accusation because they had taught for nearly 30 years and now felt like they had been blamed for being a victim of crime. My relative had to take early retirement.
  7. Another relative was teaching In A primary school and was filmed by a child on their phone, and it was shared around social media. My relative then told the child how upset they had been about this. However, instead of the child receiving any sort of consequence, instead my friend had to apologise to the child, for telling the child how upset they were. Sadly, another friend tried to commit suicide after all of the constant monitoring and accountability became too much for her. My friends and relatives who work in schools tell me about the lack of funding in their schools.

4 isn't excuses. It's the reality of the job.
It is also why many are leaving

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/11/2023 07:35

Elendel · 29/11/2023 04:38

No, mostly, it's a money and state education system problem.

The kids who assault others, the kids with needs so severe they can't even spell their own name in Y10, the very bright ones and the ones who have no interest in education and whose parents couldn't care less are all in the same room together.

There is no money to exclude, no money to be able to afford an Inadequate rating (to attract the best staff, or provide an education when pupil numbers drop), no money for modern equipment to make teaching remotely relevant. Hell, we currently have no budget for glue sticks or paper, let alone enough servers to deal with new AI-driven systems, devices which may get a child to pay attention to us more than their phones, no money to take kids out of the local area. What we DO have money for is a cheap messaging system allowing parents 24/7 access to us, to increase the "customer experience" (i.e. to tick the box that we allow parents to communicate with staff whenever they want).

Parents in private schools care more about education, hence why they pay out insane amounts of money for the privilege. While you have demanding parents, and parents who think money should buy their child a qualification, they are far less likely to abuse you for fear of exclusion, far less likely to ghost you when you try to discuss issues and far more likely to involve tutors if a child falls behind.

OP, it's shit right now.

Kids don't care, parents care even less.

Money is so tight further up the chain that kids get unconditional college offers and therefore don't give two shits about their GCSEs beyond Maths and English.

There are no teachers and supply is extremely rare for money reasons and because kids get away with far more than 20 years ago, so we end up with at least weekly cover on top of an insane workload. I get up at 3am to work, because there is no time in my actual day to do anything, but lessons are expected to be planned to perfection, regardless.

My practical subject increasingly has no money for pupil equipment, and what little we have often gets wilfully broken.

And worst of all, if a child truants or misbehaves, it is seen as my fault for not making my lessons engaging or refusing to keep Johnny in the room after he repeatedly told me to go fuck myself. I cause trouble for having standards and, as a middle leader, for holding my senior colleagues to account.

It's utter rubbish to make the ridiculous assumption that parents with kids in private schools must care more about their childrens' education because they pay.

I really hope you aren't a teacher.

DuckyShincracker · 29/11/2023 07:26

I chatted to a very committed teacher recently and was frankly shocked by the levels of violence she is facing on a daily basis. Pupils are just no longer listening to staff at all. The job she described made her sound like a night club bouncer. Except she can't actually defend herself or she would lose her job.

Wisenotboring · 29/11/2023 07:09

I thinknit does vary from.school to school. Some are absolutely viscious places with crazed SLT and unreasonable workloads. I now have a lovely job in a private school. I work hard, but it is sustainable and I can have a life. The children are generally lovely and I have freedom to really teach. It's been a while since I worked in a comprehensive setting and I don't think I'll ever go back. I value my health and quality of life too much.

MrsMurphyIWish · 29/11/2023 07:08

Been teaching 25 years and quite apathetic now tbh. I’ll most likely retire a teacher but it’s not the most enjoyable job anymore. Last week I found a letter from DS’ school about purchasing tickets for his Xmas concert. I asked why he didn’t give it to us and he replied, “well, you wouldn’t go anyway would you?”. I don’t think either of my children will follow DH and I into teaching. They see how family life is put on hold during term time and how poor the pay is. They see their friends who have “better” houses, holidays and cars and they WFH. I can’t remember the last time I heard a sixth former even consider teaching as a career. I’m guessing we’re at the point where new teachers “fall into” the career, do a few years and leave.

BusyMum47 · 29/11/2023 07:05

@Howdaretheydisciplinerudekids
It's all that & more, unfortunately! I'm currently looking to get out & I'm fortunate to work in a relatively supportive school. Many of my colleagues feel we should wear body cams, like the Police, so that parents can see their little darlings in action.

Morethanthis71 · 29/11/2023 06:22

I teach. I absolutely love teaching. I love working with young adults. I do not love having to get up by 4 a.m. every morning to mark or plan for 3 hours before I leave for work because there are not enough hours in the school day. The hours in the school day are taken up by teaching but increasingly behaviour management - rarely of my own students, more and more frequently managing issues around school and from other colleagues lessons. Leaving school at 6pm at the earliest each day. I am exhausted. My own children are more than fed up of this. I cancelled a school event last week to attend one of my own children's concerts and I didn't hear the end of this for days.

MrMucker · 29/11/2023 06:12

Certainly parents making things difficult has increased A LOT recently.
You often see parents on here doing it, and there is a common thread, that they will not accept their kids being sanctioned for anything. Usually it's nothing outrageous-a detention, and exclusion, a discussion, a meeting. These are all earned process through less than perfect behaviour in school.
But parents are very quick to state what happened and how it is the teacher's fault It stuns me when I read posts like that on here tbh. How do they know what happened? Why is the teacher vilified? Why would a teacher simply invent a detention out of spite when they have such an impossibly heavy to-do list?
Teachers really just want to teach and to support and work with every kid in their cohort.
Yes, there are teachers who leave because of parents blocking them in that goal.

BCBird · 29/11/2023 05:47

Pension early and a part time job to supplement it. It a job I have enjoyed and do enjoy but I can't sustain the pace and fall out much longer.

BCBird · 29/11/2023 05:41

Some days are good, others not. Yesterday waited 40m for assistance for a fight in my room. It unusual occurrence , but even so. The constant talking questioning staff etc is preventing others from.learnin. The thing is most pupils are pleasant and compliant, It's just an increasing minority as well as some awkward parents who have created little princes and princesses who make life difficult. Added to this the workload and the curriculum.overload, means that that it is virtually impossible to foster relationships with pupils. It's a sad day. I leaving at 56ish.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 29/11/2023 05:40

You're absolutely right. I now work in a girls' grammar school, where the students and staff are great and we have no teacher shortages, but the workload is still ridiculous. I have worked in schools where things are like you describe though.

A family member (in senior leadership, and a good and popular teacher) was essentially forced to leave his school after being suspended for shouting at a 16yo student (with a very long record of misbehaviour including bullying younger students and harrassing staff) for a serious behaviour incident. He then left teaching. The student raised the complaint on the grounds that it had made them 'feel unsafe in school' but was heard laughing and joking about it with friends immediately afterwards.

RheaRend · 29/11/2023 05:34

I know a teacher who killed themselves because of the leadership within the school. Bullying in schools is rife by the staff to staff and by the parents to staff and by the children to staff. I wouldn't recommend it. When there are no teachers left then they will have no one left to blame. We'll end up in the same situation as we are with Drs and then ppl will cry and look shocked why it happened when they are to blame.

ThereItIs1 · 29/11/2023 05:28

You aren't wrong! I teach in a private school so luckily can 'teach' as we don't have behaviour problems that have been described etc. We are also not subject to the rigorous paper trails and bureaucracy the state sector do which is so time consuming and draining. However, the way parents speak to us is shameful. Shameful. The entitlement, the vitriol, the lack of understanding. I had a parent physically shout at me and tell me they were 'aggrieved' when their child lost their jumper on day 2 of being in reception. The jumper... was unnamed. And that's a minor 'funny' story I tell people. It's just horrific and I wish I could leave the profession but my own children's education is so heavily discounted and they're so happy at the school that I'm trapped. But it's awful. As a staff we want parents to be made to sign a contract to agree to abide by the behaviour policy, e.g no swearing, no personal abuse, no finding out private information about us and using that against us (once had a parent ask me how I thought I could be a reception teacher when I was medicated for depression. Don't know how she found out I was medicated). But I doubt that'll change anything. Teachers are leaving in droves and people need to take accountability for why that is. You sound like a very fair, sane and balanced human OP! If only everyone was!!

Elendel · 29/11/2023 04:38

Neodymium · 29/11/2023 04:11

I teach in a private school and have never had any issues like you described. I think that it’s a head teacher problem in a lot of those examples.

No, mostly, it's a money and state education system problem.

The kids who assault others, the kids with needs so severe they can't even spell their own name in Y10, the very bright ones and the ones who have no interest in education and whose parents couldn't care less are all in the same room together.

There is no money to exclude, no money to be able to afford an Inadequate rating (to attract the best staff, or provide an education when pupil numbers drop), no money for modern equipment to make teaching remotely relevant. Hell, we currently have no budget for glue sticks or paper, let alone enough servers to deal with new AI-driven systems, devices which may get a child to pay attention to us more than their phones, no money to take kids out of the local area. What we DO have money for is a cheap messaging system allowing parents 24/7 access to us, to increase the "customer experience" (i.e. to tick the box that we allow parents to communicate with staff whenever they want).

Parents in private schools care more about education, hence why they pay out insane amounts of money for the privilege. While you have demanding parents, and parents who think money should buy their child a qualification, they are far less likely to abuse you for fear of exclusion, far less likely to ghost you when you try to discuss issues and far more likely to involve tutors if a child falls behind.

OP, it's shit right now.

Kids don't care, parents care even less.

Money is so tight further up the chain that kids get unconditional college offers and therefore don't give two shits about their GCSEs beyond Maths and English.

There are no teachers and supply is extremely rare for money reasons and because kids get away with far more than 20 years ago, so we end up with at least weekly cover on top of an insane workload. I get up at 3am to work, because there is no time in my actual day to do anything, but lessons are expected to be planned to perfection, regardless.

My practical subject increasingly has no money for pupil equipment, and what little we have often gets wilfully broken.

And worst of all, if a child truants or misbehaves, it is seen as my fault for not making my lessons engaging or refusing to keep Johnny in the room after he repeatedly told me to go fuck myself. I cause trouble for having standards and, as a middle leader, for holding my senior colleagues to account.