Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how anyone can be a teacher?

134 replies

Howdaretheydisciplinerudekids · 29/11/2023 00:41

I think I am quite an understanding parent when it comes to my kids schools. However, I do contact the schools whenever I have a concern. I am always polite and understanding of school issues but flag things up when necessary.

However, I hear how some parents speak to and about their children’s teachers and I am pretty disgusted and wonder how anyone remains in teaching. I have so many stories from friends about the crap they put up with from headteachers, parents and children. Who else has similar stories?

  1. A friend of mine was told on more than one occasion by a child that he wanted her dead and was going to shoot her. Her headteacher didn’t even ask if she was ok.
  2. The same child regularly used to throw things in the classroom and trash the classroom. The headteacher refused to get involved and instead blamed the teacher for their being equipment on the floor (that the child had thrown) and asked why she hadn’t picked it up. The child was still throwing things (this time aimed at the class teacher) at the time.
  3. I have heard many occasions of friends who have been out on capability plans for the most minor things. It would seem that bullying of staff from leadership is absolutely rife. For example, one teacher friend told me about the staff having a staff training day about a certain way of delivering maths. Part of the day was spent then planning maths in the said way. The headteacher went into maths lessons and then called all of the staff together because she didn’t like how they were teaching maths and told them all off. She said they should have ignored all training. Several friends have given me the same sort of stories.
  4. My teacher friends are always making excuses why they can’t go out. They have too much work to do. They are too stressed. They are off sick. They have marking to do, leSsons to plan, forms to fill in, statements to write, parents to contact, documents to complete, emails to send etc etc. Then when they have done all that, they have to actually teach a class for 7 hours. They get no let up in that time. They have to be physically and mentally involved and face verbal and sometimes physical abuse, with no chance to recover.
  5. Then they have parents to deal with. Parents who complain constantly because their child has been told off. Parents who constantly criticise teachers because their child, who has done something wrong, is then worrying about it. Or they have 2 sets of parents both claiming that their child is being bullied by the other. Or parents who have fallen out, expecting the schools to separate the children because their grown ups can’t resolve their own arguments.
  6. One relative of mine, was put under disciplinary procedures because they dared to speak sternly to a child who had been stealing from them. They did not even raise their voice. However, they now have a safeguarding concern about them because a member of staff heard them telling the child how upset they were to have had their personal items stolen by them, and the member of staff didn’t like their tone of voice. My poor relative was in bits over this accusation because they had taught for nearly 30 years and now felt like they had been blamed for being a victim of crime. My relative had to take early retirement.
  7. Another relative was teaching In A primary school and was filmed by a child on their phone, and it was shared around social media. My relative then told the child how upset they had been about this. However, instead of the child receiving any sort of consequence, instead my friend had to apologise to the child, for telling the child how upset they were. Sadly, another friend tried to commit suicide after all of the constant monitoring and accountability became too much for her. My friends and relatives who work in schools tell me about the lack of funding in their schools.
OP posts:
cassgate · 29/11/2023 17:56

I work in a primary school and the disrespectful behaviour has definitely got worse since covid. The class I have at the moment think they can do as they please with no repercussions. They often say they will tell their mum if you reprimand them. As it happens I am not bothered by such threats and tell them to go right ahead as I would welcome a chat about their behaviour with their parents. I haven’t yet had any parents complain about me but know that other members of staff have. Parents will openly defend their child and try and justify poor behaviour even when faced with evidence (cctv in some cases). There are limited consequences that a school can give out for poor behaviour and those we can use the children are not that bothered about anyway or will get mum and dad on the case as above. It is virtually impossible to exclude a child now as it is always seen as a failure of the school and its policies.

DelphiniumBlue · 29/11/2023 17:34

I'm fortunate to work in a school with very supportive colleagues and caring management. Even so, I would not be a class teacher because of the time demands. I notice there are no mothers of primary aged or younger children working fulltime in my school, although there are some fathers of small children ( with partners who pick up the slack) . Most of the teachers are quite young, ( and therefore energetic)and some of them still live at home with their own parents providing support and running the house. Even so, they don't go out in the week.
Sadly, I've come across more adult bullying in schools than anywhere else I've worked, I was really shocked when I first started working in education, I'd never come cross it before.

Naptrappedmummy · 29/11/2023 16:45

Why on Earth are children and teens so violent now? Frightening thinking about them being adults

Fifthtimelucky · 29/11/2023 13:43

Yes there are plenty of horror stories around, but I don't think it's helpful to suggest that all state schools are awful.

My daughter is in her second year of teaching at a state secondary and absolutely loves it. She is working long hours, but it's manageable, and she's hoping that next year she won't have to spend so much time lesson planning.

She rarely has problems with behaviour. She exclusively teachers sixth formers which no doubt gives her a different perspective, as all her students have chosen to study her subject, but she sometimes has to cover younger classes and she tells me that on the whole behaviour is good in those too (not perfect, but nothing she can't manage)

There are some children, including some she teaches, with difficult/chaotic lives, but in her (admittedly limited) experience, parents are supportive and appreciative and so are SLT.

MigGirl · 29/11/2023 12:42

"TAs are leaving to work in supermarkets because the pay is better and in exchange for dealing with difficult kids, they get awkward adults but cheaper groceries. I don't blame them in the slightest. Buildings are falling down or as in my school, parts are shut down due to RAAC but thanks to our "fucking awesome" Secretary of State, nothing has been done about it, so we are hemmed in to every available space. Kids who struggle with noise suffer."

This time x10, we have so many classrooms closed due to RAAC and the kids are squashed into the rest of the school as we are still waiting on the completion of our temporary classrooms since the start off September. So many kids are going to be affected by this and yet the DofE doesn't want too give any concessions for them. It's also making behaviour worse and more difficult to control.

Actually our SLT have been as supportive as possible but we are at the mercy of DofE in sorting it all out.

toomanyleggings · 29/11/2023 12:36

I taught for fifteen years in secondary schools. Took a tentative step out of it, thinking I could go back if I wanted to. That was four years ago. I’ve never looked back. I get so much praise and recognition for my work now and it’s a fraction of what I was doing as a teacher. It’s a totally different world. The stress, the abuse from kids and parents, the constant monitoring, the feeling of never having done enough, everyone living in fear of inspections and walk rounds. I didn’t realise how totally wrong it all was. Now I can create a to do list and actually tick it all off in a working day! Who knew you could get so much peace from that. A friend of mine has been teaching 25 years. She is hands down the best teacher I’ve ever seen. She’s patient, she’s knowledgeable, she’s creative, she has a wealth of teaching skills and I spoke to her the other day and she’s totally burnt out and wants to leave. It’s a damn shame that someone like that will be lost from the teaching profession

Naptrappedmummy · 29/11/2023 12:27

Nofilteritwonthelp · 29/11/2023 01:36

It's very ironic that parents are going to be the main reason there won't be any teachers left. I'm guessing the don't care as by then their kids will be grown and it won't effect them (although it already is). Much like climate change too I suppose. Feeling quite cynical today but I think society is becoming all about me, me, me and to hell with anyone else and the repercussions.

I agree. I’ve been shocked by the posts in my local mums Facebook group. ‘Please help teacher is harassing my child by telling them off when they throw their books/chair’ type thing. Cue many outraged responses about reporting the teacher to OFSTED or letting the child stay home rather than go into school. It’s utter madness.

I am dreading the current school lot turning into adults, I can’t even imagine how shambolic the workplace will be, if they turn up at all

MigGirl · 29/11/2023 12:25

I work in a support role in a typical high school. It is awful, you couldn't pay me enough to be a teacher. Yet I seriously considered it at one point and thought going into a support role in my subject would give me a good incite as to what it would be like.

It certainly has given me good incite and totally clear that there is no way I will do my teacher training. The kids are so disrespectful and parents often unsupportive. The level pastoral issues schools have to deal with is ridiculous.

The kids break things and don't care and we don't have the budget to replace some equipment. The number of laptops that get damaged and broken is ridiculous. The conversations I've heard teachers having to have with parents is truly terrible. When a parent is supportive of a teachers actions we tend to find out as the teachers are pleasantly surprised by the support.

Yet some of the kids are actually lovely.

fuckityfuckityfuckfuck · 29/11/2023 12:22

Just after covid I decided to move schools (primary) and had to wait until Summer because there were next to no vacancies for Jan or Easter starts other than the odd temp mat cover.

Looking now, 136 primary vacancies within a 10 mile radius desperate for immediate start or Jan start.

I honestly believe state education is going to collapse within the next 2-3 years.

Ohforfox · 29/11/2023 12:05

I thought about going back to re-train as a teacher. Several of my friends are teachers and between them have differing issues with their jobs. However what it mostly boils down to is the lack of appreciation for the education system. I think people forget that state education is a luxury, in comparison to poor countries where children would love to learn & do not have the means to do so. Parents who refuse to reprimand their kids, who can't believe they would misbehave and a lack of respect for other people in general. I know children don't always have good impulse control, or understand the effects of their actions but the threat of your parents finding out you had misbehaved or been rude was off-putting enough in itself. I don't believe we should bring back corporal punishment in schools but relying on children to motivate themselves when their parents can't do it, is a big ask. Further to this the nonsense on my child's group whatsapp class makes me feel sorry for all teachers. Some people really will complain about anything. We have had mostly excellent teachers in primary & feel very lucky but I can see why the passion would go out of it for most.

Malbecfan · 29/11/2023 11:43

I sympathise. I have been a p/t teacher ever since my DDs were born and they are in their 20s. I am in my 29th year of teaching and my 21st in my current school. I have worked in comprehensives in areas of severe deprivation, mixed comps and now work in a lovely state grammar school.

In my opinion, things have got worse but there are layers to this. Firstly, education and the surrounding support services need to be resourced properly. We have relatively few issues, but in many schools there are kids in them who should be in alternative provision, but either there are no places, or no schools. There is certainly no money for this. These youngsters are left in mainstream education to cope. Schools cannot get assessments because the assessments either cost too much or there are not enough Ed Psychs. TAs are leaving to work in supermarkets because the pay is better and in exchange for dealing with difficult kids, they get awkward adults but cheaper groceries. I don't blame them in the slightest. Buildings are falling down or as in my school, parts are shut down due to RAAC but thanks to our "fucking awesome" Secretary of State, nothing has been done about it, so we are hemmed in to every available space. Kids who struggle with noise suffer.

We have a curriculum designed by a megalomaniac, yes looking you odious Gove, which forces all kids through a narrow doorway based on his education from the 1950s. Schools are judged by crap metrics, like how many kids go onto Russell Group universities. It's utter bollocks - our local RG uni shut its Chemistry department in 2003 and doesn't even teach my subject. DH used to work there and does some guest lecturing there - most of the staff can barely speak English - students are paying £9250 pa for this - but they get a big thumbs up for being in the RG club.

My current Head is not liked by everyone, but he has a clear vision and he cares about people. He has been great with my DDs (often asks after them) and he has been very supportive of me with particular issues. My first Head was an arse who promoted people who sucked up to him, regardless of their ability. Another Head in my current school was a covert bully. It has taken years for me to get over it - when my current Head came into my lesson last term "for a quick word", I nearly had a heart attack because it was so triggering. Rather than berating me for some (made up) misdemeanour, he actually wanted to inform me in person that one of his predecessors had sadly died, someone I had done lots of events with although not worked for. I thought that was lovely of him. However, I know how lucky I am because there are so many tools around.

Academisation is not the answer. To me, we need to fund schools properly: buildings, support staff, support services as well as teachers. The curriculum needs to be completely overhauled. Who gives a shiny shit what a fronted adverbial is? However, primary school children have this crap drilled into them. Why? We should be teaching kids to be creative, to learn languages, to play sport, to paint and draw, to sing and play instruments as well as reading and Maths. Parents should actually parent their children instead of expecting schools to do it. There should be an expectation made very clear to parents that if they complain about trivial matters, their kid's place will be taken away and they can educate them themselves.

Sorry, this is so long. More to say but I need to go and teach!

Beebumble2 · 29/11/2023 11:20

I retired after 38 years teaching in inner city Secondary schools, some in London and Birmingham. As things got worse, I got older and promoted to Assistant Principal with responsibilities for Inclusion. I have seen many of the situations in the OP.
In my case it helped that I went grey early and have a resting stern face! Not only were the students wary, but often the parents. The lack of very experienced (long in the tooth) staff on SLTs can result in the poor support for struggling classroom teachers.
Nevertheless, it’s a tough job, Education isn’t valued as it was in the past when parents and grandparents remembered the pre 1945 Education Act, giving free education to all, the abolishment of the 11 plus, giving equal opportunity and the raising of the school leaving age, allowing continued access to education.
In the past many school leavers still valued education and attended night schools to gain qualifications, after a days work.
Would I teach in todays climate, I doubt it.

twistyizzy · 29/11/2023 11:19

gereen · 29/11/2023 01:40

I don't think all state schools are that bad. My dc are in private but I'm always scornfully told that I'm wasting my money and the local state schools would be just as good, and any private school threads are always full of anecdotes about how good their dc's schools are and that they don't have staff or behaviour or funding issues.

Yes quite! According to those posters state schools are the ideal.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 29/11/2023 11:05

DuckyShincracker · 29/11/2023 07:26

I chatted to a very committed teacher recently and was frankly shocked by the levels of violence she is facing on a daily basis. Pupils are just no longer listening to staff at all. The job she described made her sound like a night club bouncer. Except she can't actually defend herself or she would lose her job.

This. I have a few teacher friends, mostly primary. They get hit in the face on a weekly basis. SLT either ignores it or finds a way to blame them (because the parents won't tolerate any criticism of said children). They're all now in the process of leaving as it's simply not worth it.

I have been a teacher abroad (where education was valued and so teachers were teaching respectful and enthusiastic kids) but would never teach here. Those values simply don't exist in any meaningful way anymore.

thirdistheonewiththehairychest · 29/11/2023 10:27

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 29/11/2023 10:10

Have you been threatened as part of your job?
Been held responsible for 30 kids H and S when there’s no support and they are clearly in danger.
Has one of your clients/ customer parents smacked you round the head?
Habe you been spat on and abused as part of your job?
Do you get up at 4.00 am to do the bits of your job that don’t fit in during a normal working day? Then stood up for 8 hours, gone home and done more work?
Are you unable to access a toilet at any time?
Are your customers/clients fighting when you give a presentation and you are told it’s your fault as your presentation is boring?

Thought notHmm

Edited

Most people have no idea @ArseInTheCoOpWindow

Bluevelvetsofa · 29/11/2023 10:22

There was a thread yesterday, about unpleasant and bullying teachers. I had some wonderful teachers, some average and some boring, but no one bullied me or harmed me.

In many years of teaching I had some wonderful experiences, some colleagues who were supportive and true friends, some appreciative parents, some students who were delightful and who I won’t forget, some wonderful lessons and great experiences.

I also experienced as many do, being sworn at, spat at, ignored, barged, kicked, wrestled to the ground, books thrown at me, accusations that were unfounded and untrue.

I also experienced a public castigation from an Ofsted inspector, lies about me and to me from a head teacher, ignoring behaviour from a head teacher and regular criticism. I was also on SLT, so it happens to that group of teachers too.

The negatives were much more prevalent in the years before I gave up teaching and I’m sure it’s even more so now. The tipping point has been reached and it’s sad that it’s come to this.

yoteyak · 29/11/2023 10:12

jellyfrizz · 29/11/2023 08:49

I did this the other way around; teaching abroad and then back to the UK. I loved teaching overseas (in state schools). I lasted a year and a half in England, I didn't enjoy viewing children as data and wanted to be able to spend some time with my family and so left.

It was so frustrating because I knew it doesn't have to be this way.

I'm a long-time retired teacher. Long ago, I left UK, mainly because there existed no real career progression for classroom teachers: to progress past Head of Department status (and get a proper salary increase), you had to move out of the classroom and become a Deputy Head or something similar. I wanted to be a teacher, not an administrator; so I moved my family abroad. (Children were still (just) pre-school.)

I always worked in state-funded schools, essentially I suppose for ideological reasons, but also having seen the damage done to British society by its own brand of private-school organisation (albeit that other countries haven't suffered quite so badly in such regard).

So, anyway, I'm posting here now just to suggest how things could be different for teachers and schools.

An anecdote. Not long after I started in my first job abroad, I was walking along a busy school corridor chatting to a colleague, on the way to the staffroom for coffee-break. Two teenagers started fighting nearby; of course I moved to intervene. My new colleague pulled me away. "What on earth are you doing?" she asked. "You're a teacher, not a police officer!"

Teachers were not required to engage with pupil behaviour; the school employed people (so-called 'educational consultants') specifically to deal with children's behaviour, to supervise (perhaps somewhat harshly to my eyes at the time, at least initially) children who could not, or would not, behave themselves, also during breaks and when a teacher was absent.

Result? Teachers could teach. Any real misbehaviour and a child was removed from class, to spend time being supervised/assisted by the educational consultants. Of course minor matters - inattention in class and so on - could be dealt with by the class teacher; but no classroom teacher had to deal with any severely disruptive pupils, so the majority of children who wanted simply to learn got full-time teaching.

Teachers were better paid by seniority, and for fewer contracted hours, so there was no need to move on to administration to make a career. Also, extra-curricular activities - sport, social, cultural, whatever - were separately staffed; no teacher involvement there either. Class teachers - experts in their subjects - exclusively taught those subjects. (Although this did not preclude getting to know pupils well as children; it was possible to maintain a child-centred teaching manner even given this explicit overall apparent subject-centredness.)

I recommend this system. Of course it costs money. It needs proper recruitment and career-structure for non-teaching staff as well as for teachers.

Any chance of such a system in Britain? Not, at any rate, so long as the country's rulers are so badly - and systematically - miseducated by those expensive private schools. But, well, you have each a vote.

Dweetfidilove · 29/11/2023 10:11

It’s a question I ask often, because I wouldn’t teach some of the children I’ve encountered in schools for anything.

They lack resources, strong and supportive leadership and support staff is ever dwindling. As for the parents and children they have to put up with - no thanks 😔.

Some of those parents post on MN and I just think- you and your precious just need to be put in a barrel and rolled down a hill that has no bottom.

I have enormous respect for teachers, if not for their teaching, at least for the amount of behaviour management they are expected to do. Often with little support as SLT are such wet lettuces too.

Hats off to them 👏🏾

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 29/11/2023 10:10

NeedToChangeName · 29/11/2023 09:45

This keeps coming up, that teachers have the hardest job in the world, nothing else compares to it etc

Reality is, all / most of us, in loads of roles, are struggling to do the best we can with limited resources. There just isn't the same money around as in the past, so employers are increasingly trying to get more output from fewer staff

Have you been threatened as part of your job?
Been held responsible for 30 kids H and S when there’s no support and they are clearly in danger.
Has one of your clients/ customer parents smacked you round the head?
Habe you been spat on and abused as part of your job?
Do you get up at 4.00 am to do the bits of your job that don’t fit in during a normal working day? Then stood up for 8 hours, gone home and done more work?
Are you unable to access a toilet at any time?
Are your customers/clients fighting when you give a presentation and you are told it’s your fault as your presentation is boring?

Thought notHmm

jumperoozles · 29/11/2023 10:01

Definetly varies from school to school. To be honest it’s all about the leadership. Leadership that cares about you and supports you makes the world of difference. You can actually deal with fairly unpleasant parents if you feel you have support.
I find my main frustration with teaching is not the parents or pupils who for the most part are very nice but the lack of funding and resources. Also the huge timetable pressures meaning we have to cram so much in our days leaving me always feeling like I’m not teaching things or supporting to the best of my ability because it’s all such a big rush and tick box exercise.
I feel sorry for my little boy going to school soon and knowing that staff will just not have time to give him much attention with his work and all the rushed work he’ll have to do. I will be trying to find a school with a more chilled out timetable and plenty of time for art - if such a thing exists!!

NeedToChangeName · 29/11/2023 09:45

This keeps coming up, that teachers have the hardest job in the world, nothing else compares to it etc

Reality is, all / most of us, in loads of roles, are struggling to do the best we can with limited resources. There just isn't the same money around as in the past, so employers are increasingly trying to get more output from fewer staff

Hayliebells · 29/11/2023 09:40

It's not like that in all schools ( mine's not), but parents can be very wearing in even the best run schools. There's also lots of very toxic schools, and I really don't understand how they have any teachers. In the current climate teachers always have the option to leave and teach somewhere else. Many decide that even teaching in well run schools isn't worth it, and we have the resulting recruitment and retention crisis. In the really toxic workplaces I dread to think how they're staffed, but I have heard of some local schools doing online learning for part of the week.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 29/11/2023 09:32

I left teaching 3 years ago. The crunch for me was the following:

My school had a visually impaired unit. I taught a subject that used sharp constantly moving equipment. I had kids that were blind with no support. So l had to sit with them all lesson.

This meant that the ones with anger issues got up to all sorts, the emotional ones needed mothering, the ASD ones needed extra support, the naughty ones disrupted the lesson. So do l leave the VI kid as his H and S was my responsibility?

Same in upper school. Except on top of all of that 3 were absconders. Sometimes l spent the entire lesson on calling and no one did any learning.

l’d had enough.

ImNotReallySpartacus · 29/11/2023 09:16

Neodymium · 29/11/2023 04:11

I teach in a private school and have never had any issues like you described. I think that it’s a head teacher problem in a lot of those examples.

Isn't it also partly because private schools can, and will, expel pupils who are consistently disruptive or badly behaved?

jm9138 · 29/11/2023 09:06

Look at the YouGov poll as to what people think are the biggest issues facing the country and you will understand why teaching is hard and underfunded
https://yougov.co.uk/topics/society/trackers/the-most-important-issues-facing-the-country

Interestingly, people cannot seem to understand that if you sort out educating your population nearly all their other concerns will be at least somewhat alleviated.

The most important issues facing the country

Which of the following do you think are the most important issues facing the country at this time? Please tick up to three.

https://yougov.co.uk/topics/society/trackers/the-most-important-issues-facing-the-country

Swipe left for the next trending thread