Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how anyone can be a teacher?

134 replies

Howdaretheydisciplinerudekids · 29/11/2023 00:41

I think I am quite an understanding parent when it comes to my kids schools. However, I do contact the schools whenever I have a concern. I am always polite and understanding of school issues but flag things up when necessary.

However, I hear how some parents speak to and about their children’s teachers and I am pretty disgusted and wonder how anyone remains in teaching. I have so many stories from friends about the crap they put up with from headteachers, parents and children. Who else has similar stories?

  1. A friend of mine was told on more than one occasion by a child that he wanted her dead and was going to shoot her. Her headteacher didn’t even ask if she was ok.
  2. The same child regularly used to throw things in the classroom and trash the classroom. The headteacher refused to get involved and instead blamed the teacher for their being equipment on the floor (that the child had thrown) and asked why she hadn’t picked it up. The child was still throwing things (this time aimed at the class teacher) at the time.
  3. I have heard many occasions of friends who have been out on capability plans for the most minor things. It would seem that bullying of staff from leadership is absolutely rife. For example, one teacher friend told me about the staff having a staff training day about a certain way of delivering maths. Part of the day was spent then planning maths in the said way. The headteacher went into maths lessons and then called all of the staff together because she didn’t like how they were teaching maths and told them all off. She said they should have ignored all training. Several friends have given me the same sort of stories.
  4. My teacher friends are always making excuses why they can’t go out. They have too much work to do. They are too stressed. They are off sick. They have marking to do, leSsons to plan, forms to fill in, statements to write, parents to contact, documents to complete, emails to send etc etc. Then when they have done all that, they have to actually teach a class for 7 hours. They get no let up in that time. They have to be physically and mentally involved and face verbal and sometimes physical abuse, with no chance to recover.
  5. Then they have parents to deal with. Parents who complain constantly because their child has been told off. Parents who constantly criticise teachers because their child, who has done something wrong, is then worrying about it. Or they have 2 sets of parents both claiming that their child is being bullied by the other. Or parents who have fallen out, expecting the schools to separate the children because their grown ups can’t resolve their own arguments.
  6. One relative of mine, was put under disciplinary procedures because they dared to speak sternly to a child who had been stealing from them. They did not even raise their voice. However, they now have a safeguarding concern about them because a member of staff heard them telling the child how upset they were to have had their personal items stolen by them, and the member of staff didn’t like their tone of voice. My poor relative was in bits over this accusation because they had taught for nearly 30 years and now felt like they had been blamed for being a victim of crime. My relative had to take early retirement.
  7. Another relative was teaching In A primary school and was filmed by a child on their phone, and it was shared around social media. My relative then told the child how upset they had been about this. However, instead of the child receiving any sort of consequence, instead my friend had to apologise to the child, for telling the child how upset they were. Sadly, another friend tried to commit suicide after all of the constant monitoring and accountability became too much for her. My friends and relatives who work in schools tell me about the lack of funding in their schools.
OP posts:
Cosyblankets · 30/11/2023 06:36

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/11/2023 07:35

It's utter rubbish to make the ridiculous assumption that parents with kids in private schools must care more about their childrens' education because they pay.

I really hope you aren't a teacher.

Statistically there will be more parents of privately educated kids who support their education and i think that is what the poster is getting at.
I worked for many years in a "rough" school on the edge of a borough. Many of the "good" kids went over the border into the other borough. Leaving us with many kids whose parents did not care, did not support the school in terms of discipline, homework etc. Then there were the kids who were often young carers or who had to take their younger siblings to primary school because the parents were in bed either unwell or a lifestyle choice and these kids didn't even have a pen let alone the correct uniform.
This is a battle that private schools do not have. I'm sure they have demanding parents who expect top grades because they're paying. But they don't have, en masse, parents who do not value education themselves, leading to continual low level disruption, leading to more of the "good " kids going to a different school and so the cycle goes on.
that is what i understood the poster to be saying.

Igglepiggleandhisboat · 30/11/2023 06:18

I’m a Primary Teacher and on a daily basis parents shout at me, children are violent towards me, children fight and I need to put myself in the middle and I get spat at A LOT. There’s only so far a love of working with children can go…

MrsMurphyIWish · 30/11/2023 05:45

Tonight I’ve got parents evening. I know I’ll be asked by two sets of parents, “what are YOU going to do to get my child their target grade?”. These pupils have less than 50% attendance. I want to say “you get them to school” I’ll have to make up some polite bullshit. I’ve learned to say what parents want to hear.

Elendel · 30/11/2023 05:12

WhyMeWhyNowWhyNot · 29/11/2023 20:34

@Elendel utter shite that parents who can afford to pay “care more” 🙄. It’s that smug superior attitude that means my kids are at a state school. Vile. Money doesn’t make you caring - fuck me no wonder this country is so fucked.

Nothing smug about it. Mine go to state school; I wish I could afford private.

But apart from the very super-rich, sending your child to private school at a cost of £20k a year is a significant chunk out of parents' pockets, so of course they are often very invested.

I can count on one hand the invested parents for the kids in each of my classes, but it takes two hands to count, for each kid in my classes, the parents who won't answer calls or messages, who tell me their child's behaviour is my problem, who refuse to buy educational equipment (not a pen, ruler or calculator in sight and always no money for this, but new phones every few months), who tell me their child shouldn't do homework after a day in school.
I have sewn torn uniform back together for my students because their parents wouldn't, and wouldn't buy another.

As a proportion, the parents who do this in private school is far lower. I know the difference.

This doesn't knock all state school parents; around 3 in 4 do take some manner of interest, but it's the 1/4 that couldn't give a shiny shit in the schools I have worked in over the last 7 years or so that cause most of the issues.

SingleMum11 · 30/11/2023 00:34

It’s not just teaching, our kids go to these schools!

I know education has always had some schools which were rough or difficult, but it seems like a lot of schools are now stressful for teachers and pupils, with some really out of control behaviour that no one is addressing.

Howdaretheydisciplinerudekids · 30/11/2023 00:28

By the sound of things, you are the odd one. Reading all these replies to my original comment, has made me think of my neighbour, a male primary teacher. Every morning, I hear him say bye to his ifs and then he is outside physically retching loudly before he gets in his car. His wife has told me before that he does this each day through sheer panic at what the day can bring. He always seems to have some sort of observation or monitoring thing of the teachers. And he has 2 kids of his own with autism to parent as well. Well hats off to all you amazing teachers. The kids are lucky to have had you, even those who have left. It does sound like private schools have the right model and this should be reciprocated by Government through funding and SEND provision.

OP posts:
Iceache · 29/11/2023 21:35

DifficultBloodyWoman · 29/11/2023 01:33

Teachers don’t do much teaching any more. It is mostly crowd control and behavior management.

This is false. I’m a teacher and I spend my time in class teaching brilliantly planned lessons. Our school provide a varied and rich curriculum to all children within the best of our ability. We push the Greater Depth, target the SEND, challenge those achieving what they should and analyse the borderlines. We’re state primary.

I also don’t have nearly the problems with parents I read about here. Sure, there is always the odd one but you can get that anywhere!

Covidwoes · 29/11/2023 21:31

@NeedToChangeName this thread isn't about teaching being a harder job than other jobs. It's about the reality of being a teacher.

ASouthPoleElf · 29/11/2023 21:20

I left primary teaching 7 years ago to have my children and recently returned as a TA. The job has changed just in those 7 years. Admittedly I didn’t work through Covid, but to come back into the classroom post-Covid, it’s obvious there’s been a shift. Where there used to be a relatively small number of children with additional needs, now there are so many with issues that I am not trained to deal with. Lots of anger issues, impulse control issues, lack of social skills, and more children than I’ve ever known needing to access speech and language therapy.

Parent expectations are ridiculous. I’m not sure what some of them think we’re here to do. We’re not miracle workers, and we’re not going to parent your children for you. We’re not your personal therapists. We’re not the enemy. We’re people who care about children and want to support them in reaching their full potential. We’re also human.

RudsyFarmer · 29/11/2023 21:19

I’ve recently had a training session and agree the majority of it was about behavioural management. I think the number one problem is parents not having enough time to parent. Two parents out of the home, often in jobs that require long hours. Child care is farmed out or else screens are nannying the kids. It really isn’t too surprising we have so many children unwilling or unable to follow a school structure.

LoopyGremlin · 29/11/2023 21:10

I ask myself this on a daily basis. Used to love my job as a secondary teacher but it's a completely different ball game now. Kids with a reading age of 5, violent and aggressive children, children with significant ASN, all shoved in a class of 30 with no support yet I am asked to meet all their needs and have innovative learning and teaching strategies. Impossible task.

Icedlatteplease · 29/11/2023 20:54

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 29/11/2023 20:31

Because most behaviour problems are genetic and therefore will become more prevalent in each successive generation.

Do you mean inherited ND? Because it’s not that they all have behaviour problems. It is that they are not educated in the right environment, and are expected to conform to being in a NT school. And can’t. And why should they?

There should be enough schools for HF ND. These are the ones that are let down by the current system. Not severe enough for special ed, but can’t cope with a NT environment.

So whilst genetics may be at play, it’s the shit system that’s causing the problems.

Couldn't agree more.

But you can also see severity increase generation to generation. Or it could be that actually everything from the table layouts to the lights to tic tock conspire against kids these days.

twistyizzy · 29/11/2023 20:44

@WhyMeWhyNowWhyNot money doesn't make you care more but it does give schools more clout to deal with bad behaviour. There has been an expulsion in DDs (Yr 7) private school due to persistant disruptive behaviour over the last half term. No discussion, straight to expulsion. If state schools had the same options then I bet behaviour would dramatically improve but the issue is that there is nowhere to send constantly disruptive kids in the state sector. Ultimately it always comes down to the fact that the state sector is woefully underfunded and under-resourced.

WhyMeWhyNowWhyNot · 29/11/2023 20:34

@Elendel utter shite that parents who can afford to pay “care more” 🙄. It’s that smug superior attitude that means my kids are at a state school. Vile. Money doesn’t make you caring - fuck me no wonder this country is so fucked.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 29/11/2023 20:31

Because most behaviour problems are genetic and therefore will become more prevalent in each successive generation.

Do you mean inherited ND? Because it’s not that they all have behaviour problems. It is that they are not educated in the right environment, and are expected to conform to being in a NT school. And can’t. And why should they?

There should be enough schools for HF ND. These are the ones that are let down by the current system. Not severe enough for special ed, but can’t cope with a NT environment.

So whilst genetics may be at play, it’s the shit system that’s causing the problems.

violetcuriosity · 29/11/2023 20:31

It's pretty shit. I could never teach in mainstream education again. You get far more autonomy and appreciation in special Ed.

stayathomer · 29/11/2023 20:27

Tbh I don’t know either- my sons come home telling me of kids being thrown out of class for horrendous stuff- throwing things, smashing stuff, in things like woodwork and home ec things are set on fire etc etc. The worst thing is these things aren’t one off, they’re regular, kids telling teachers to eff off, shut up, that they’re going to get their parents in- and this is a school that wouldn’t be seen to have a bad reputation

Naptrappedmummy · 29/11/2023 20:22

Because most behaviour problems are genetic and therefore will become more prevalent in each successive generation.

Would you mind elaborating on this for me please?

CaptainMyCaptain · 29/11/2023 20:22

I enjoyed teaching for nearly 30 years (primary) and felt supported dealing with difficult children or parents but then a change of Headteacher and move to Academy status changed everything. Fortunately I was near enough to 60 to escape.

Redvelvet24 · 29/11/2023 20:15

You’ve just described my life pretty accurately, OP. I’ve been teaching 25 years. I used to love my job but it’s unmanageable and a thankless task. I’m looking into exit routes.

wonderingwhatlifemeans · 29/11/2023 20:04

What is frustrating is that it could be so different. We have children with needs that need to be met but we have to spend so much time writing about what we are going to do in our plans that we actually run out of time to fully prepare for the actual learning. We also have to change all our planning when the next 'new' teaching idea comes in which seems like every 5 minutes!

The curriculum needs urgent review. It was written in 2014 and we live in a different world now.

I still love actual teaching but not all the rest that drags me down and takes up all of my time. I'm not sure I can do another 20 years of this but it's all I have known and ever wanted to do.

Icedlatteplease · 29/11/2023 19:40

Oh and weed. Weed is a disaster yet still I hear otherwise sensible people saying it is harmless

Icedlatteplease · 29/11/2023 19:26

Naptrappedmummy · 29/11/2023 16:45

Why on Earth are children and teens so violent now? Frightening thinking about them being adults

Because most behaviour problems are genetic and therefore will become more prevalent in each successive generation.

Because many kids, especially boys, with adhd are in the worst possible environment for them in schools. They need to be out doing. Historically they might have left school as early as possible, now they are stuck there until they are 18, often with very little achievement throughout secondary. Worse we tell them how shit they are in virtually every lesson they go to, even if they aren't told they know because they cant do it.

Because 90% of what they learn is utter rubbish and completely unnecessary fof the work place

SiennaMillar · 29/11/2023 18:29

There must be some terribly run schools! I plan all the English and reading from scratch, and several foundation subjects, in a two from entry school. I teach year 6, so it’s very fast-paced and busy. I work 8am - 4pm. I don’t understand what people are doing to start work at 4am, but my goodness, that is an incredibly unreasonable expectation from your HT, and you need to go the Union asap.

Laiste · 29/11/2023 18:16

YANBU

I spent 8 years as a TA and SEN 1:1

By 1 or 2 years in i was damn sure i'd never want to be a teacher and had my eyes opened for how demanding the job was.

By the end i couldn't even hack being a TA any more!