Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how anyone can be a teacher?

134 replies

Howdaretheydisciplinerudekids · 29/11/2023 00:41

I think I am quite an understanding parent when it comes to my kids schools. However, I do contact the schools whenever I have a concern. I am always polite and understanding of school issues but flag things up when necessary.

However, I hear how some parents speak to and about their children’s teachers and I am pretty disgusted and wonder how anyone remains in teaching. I have so many stories from friends about the crap they put up with from headteachers, parents and children. Who else has similar stories?

  1. A friend of mine was told on more than one occasion by a child that he wanted her dead and was going to shoot her. Her headteacher didn’t even ask if she was ok.
  2. The same child regularly used to throw things in the classroom and trash the classroom. The headteacher refused to get involved and instead blamed the teacher for their being equipment on the floor (that the child had thrown) and asked why she hadn’t picked it up. The child was still throwing things (this time aimed at the class teacher) at the time.
  3. I have heard many occasions of friends who have been out on capability plans for the most minor things. It would seem that bullying of staff from leadership is absolutely rife. For example, one teacher friend told me about the staff having a staff training day about a certain way of delivering maths. Part of the day was spent then planning maths in the said way. The headteacher went into maths lessons and then called all of the staff together because she didn’t like how they were teaching maths and told them all off. She said they should have ignored all training. Several friends have given me the same sort of stories.
  4. My teacher friends are always making excuses why they can’t go out. They have too much work to do. They are too stressed. They are off sick. They have marking to do, leSsons to plan, forms to fill in, statements to write, parents to contact, documents to complete, emails to send etc etc. Then when they have done all that, they have to actually teach a class for 7 hours. They get no let up in that time. They have to be physically and mentally involved and face verbal and sometimes physical abuse, with no chance to recover.
  5. Then they have parents to deal with. Parents who complain constantly because their child has been told off. Parents who constantly criticise teachers because their child, who has done something wrong, is then worrying about it. Or they have 2 sets of parents both claiming that their child is being bullied by the other. Or parents who have fallen out, expecting the schools to separate the children because their grown ups can’t resolve their own arguments.
  6. One relative of mine, was put under disciplinary procedures because they dared to speak sternly to a child who had been stealing from them. They did not even raise their voice. However, they now have a safeguarding concern about them because a member of staff heard them telling the child how upset they were to have had their personal items stolen by them, and the member of staff didn’t like their tone of voice. My poor relative was in bits over this accusation because they had taught for nearly 30 years and now felt like they had been blamed for being a victim of crime. My relative had to take early retirement.
  7. Another relative was teaching In A primary school and was filmed by a child on their phone, and it was shared around social media. My relative then told the child how upset they had been about this. However, instead of the child receiving any sort of consequence, instead my friend had to apologise to the child, for telling the child how upset they were. Sadly, another friend tried to commit suicide after all of the constant monitoring and accountability became too much for her. My friends and relatives who work in schools tell me about the lack of funding in their schools.
OP posts:
Cosyblankets · 30/11/2023 07:58

Benibidibici · 30/11/2023 07:38

I think some of the examples you give are extreme, it isn't like this in well managed schools.

I also think its very divided. There are still lots of schools out there where most pupils are reasonably behaved. My dc go to a small state primary, the children are lovely and we especially notice how kind the older children are to the youngest. The teenagers from the local secondaries seem by and large to be well mannered, hard working and with nice behaviour. However there's a town nearby where the teens seem much more feral, i know teachers from a couple of the schools there who struggle badly with the horrendous behaviour.

This is exactly what I was talking about. There will be nice kids living in the town where you describe the kids as feral whose parents send them to the nice school down the road. So that school is generally seen as nice. So the school where the kids are seen as feral, none of the nice families want their kids to go there so gradually the gap widens and the nice school gets nicer and the the feral school gets worse. It isn't that the nice school is well managed and the other one isn't, it's more likely that the feral school has no support from parents so the hands of the management are tied.

Countdown2023 · 30/11/2023 07:53

None of my dc nor nephews and nieces will ever go into teaching as they suffered from my the commitments first hand.

thepresureofausername · 30/11/2023 07:50

Some teachers are protected from a lot of the really bad stuff by their good headteachers. But those headteachers do it by absorbing it all themselves and eventually burning out.

OneMoreStepAlongTheRoadIGo · 30/11/2023 07:49

I can guarantee as a parent you will not see the half of what goes on even in a "nice" primary and secondary (my background was mn "nice" schools). Children on the whole are lovely. And given the right conditions I think most kids will do well. But the statistics show us that teachers are leaving in droves and there's good reason.

I think most people like to think "their" child is okay/their school is okay. And it's a way of "othering" the problem. It's really a national crisis. Searcg Noblegiraffes threads as she is so clear and puts it better than me.

Benibidibici · 30/11/2023 07:48

Oh and since getting rid of pay band protection, there's definitely an issue with older upper pay scale teachers being put on performance/support plans for utterly spurious reasons to get rid of them and replace them with teachers who are offered much lower banding even when experienced. This is what happens when you don't give schools enough money. 2 expensive experienced teachers on upper pay scales can be replaced with 2 cheaper teachers & a TA - you can see why teachers do it. The teaching budget should be ring fenced - its stupid as in many cases it means teachers can't afford to move job. My dsis is at the top of payscale with responsibility. Moved out of london to a small town due to housing costs.
Her DH also teaches and took a vast pay cut to move to a job nearer their new home - from upper pay scale essentially he lost 10 years worth of pay band progression. As a result they can't afford dsis moving near home until he's gone back up the bands a bit, so she's stuck with an awful commute and never sees her kids.

Benibidibici · 30/11/2023 07:38

I think some of the examples you give are extreme, it isn't like this in well managed schools.

I also think its very divided. There are still lots of schools out there where most pupils are reasonably behaved. My dc go to a small state primary, the children are lovely and we especially notice how kind the older children are to the youngest. The teenagers from the local secondaries seem by and large to be well mannered, hard working and with nice behaviour. However there's a town nearby where the teens seem much more feral, i know teachers from a couple of the schools there who struggle badly with the horrendous behaviour.

OneMoreStepAlongTheRoadIGo · 30/11/2023 07:32

And yes "robot" teachers delivering identikit curriculums is already the wya some academy chains are going.

And with the ability to train their own staff this is what some teachers are expecting. Centralised powerpoint to read odd, standard rules ("slant").

However kids are not cookie cutter kids and this isn't great for many of them. It's unlikely to be good in the long run.

Baneofmyexistence · 30/11/2023 07:32

I left teaching 6 years ago after ten years in state primaries. I had scissors thrown at me, sworn at, called a drunken whore once, taught one child who repeatedly tried to strangle other children. One shoved a table at a pregnant teacher into her tummy. On top of that the observations, marking, constant meetings and planning, clubs, was just too much. I care for my disabled DD but she is 6 now and at school and sometimes I think about going back as we could use the money but the thought makes me feel sick!

Cosyblankets · 30/11/2023 07:30

letstrythatagain · 30/11/2023 07:00

@Cosyblankets good morning to you too!! lol. no need to be so patronising. I'm asking the teachers on here who are clearly still teaching why they stay?

I stayed for long enough because i felt i could make a difference. But gradually over the course of the last few years before i left i saw perfectly capable and experienced teachers on support plans, partly because they were not so easy to mould into the robots the school wanted and partly because they were too expensive. I no longer felt that i was teaching but just delivering a curriculum. Proving what I'd delivered every step of the way, regardless of the fact that they didn't really understand it deep down but they could pass an exam. I felt it was chipping away at my personality.
There are hoards of teachers like me.

BitOutOfPractice · 30/11/2023 07:23

I simply have no idea how any of them carry on going. I admire them immensely for their gumption and stamina because I know I couldn’t do it for a good clock!

OneMoreStepAlongTheRoadIGo · 30/11/2023 07:20

There's also a growing issue around emotionally based school avoidance (Dr Fisher from "Not fine in school" website is good on this.) This is a growing concern and the "alternate provision" of sometimes just a couple of hours a week is not okay. I've supported families where a parent has had to give up work for this reason.

The whole way schools are currently set up and run is difficult for a subset of students. And they are really not catered for.

Specialist schools are like hens teeth too so there's a group of those with additional need that are not being supported well, and can have a knock on effect on the rest of the class too.

Also the increasing numbers of those who are neurodivergent who may struggle to get through a day/year at school and has huge knock on effect on everyone else.

I know of more than one year 7 child who struggles with transitions (autistic) so is late in between classes. And getting detentions. What will likely happen imo is that behaviour/attendance will get worse and really the issue is managing transitions as an autistic kid. They're perfectly able academically to do Gcses.

Then as a teacher to try to manage all this without support. It's hard.

chosenone · 30/11/2023 07:12

I’m in my 25th year and luckily have a very supportive SLT and generally good kids. I’ll never leave this schools because of the crap in so many others!

we still have increasing issues. There just seems to be a huge increase in non compliance and has Amanda Spielman said in her recent report a breakdown of the ‘social contract’. Basically lots of kids can’t be arsed with school and want to mess around, listen to air pods, vape in the toilets and not conform. How can we honestly stop them? If their parents don’t support and they’re quietly just saying ‘no’

Wr can’t drag kids into lessons, force them to engage, be respectful or do the work. They know this, so we’re stuffed!

LolaSmiles · 30/11/2023 07:09

This doesn't knock all state school parents; around 3 in 4 do take some manner of interest, but it's the 1/4 that couldn't give a shiny shit in the schools I have worked in over the last 7 years or so that cause most of the issues
Agree with this. That's true in my experience.

It's not that parents who choose private care more than parents who use state education.It's that in private education you don't have the group of parents who not only don't care about education, but will actively undermine any attempts to give their child an education. This group of parents, and then their children within school, cause issues for staff and pupils.

Different schools find have this group of parents in different amounts. In one school I worked in it was a very small, but loud minority. In another school I worked in it was probably more than half the parents. Unsurprisingly they were very different schools to work at.

OneMoreStepAlongTheRoadIGo · 30/11/2023 07:09

Tarbert- but noone listens. We had the strikes but that didn't paint teachers in a good light.

Parents on here are regularly anti teachers. Noblegiraffe does an amazing job of highlighting what teaching is like and what every day school is like for our kids.

Noone listens. Noone cares tbh. Then act surprised when their kids class is out of control as they dont have the resources to support kids with additional needs, the teachers go part time or leave, they haven't got time to go the extra mile etc.

OneMoreStepAlongTheRoadIGo · 30/11/2023 07:06

There's a huge crisis in retention and we are losing so many good teachers.

Really we need to look at a national level at what we are doing. Why teaching is such an awful career now and why schools are not functioning well.

What will happen instead is sticking plasters until we end up with low paid people "delivering content" and the teachers creating resources just supervising a team of these.

It's so sad. So many don't want to leave teaching as they're passionate about teaching and get a buzz from supporting learners but the job is unmanageable. The system were working in is unmanageable and not great for the kids.

As for plenty of transferable skills. I'm now working in adult ed and earn a small fraction of my teacher salary. I regularly wish I'd started in a different profession. Or retrained before kids.

Tarbert12 · 30/11/2023 07:05

The promotion process in schools, as in other areas of the public sector, works to promote the wrong people. So you get managers who are dab hands at running competency based questions through chatgpt but are bullies, not very bright, cowards.

But to me the bigger question is how the unions got so rubbish. They've got the government over a barrel. Why aren't they taking action over mistreatment of staff? Is it because officeholders are only doing it to pad their own cases for promotion?

letstrythatagain · 30/11/2023 07:02

@Igglepiggleandhisboat that's exactly how my mother saw it. As much as she hated parts of it in the end (just VERY happily retired) teaching was very much in her blood.

letstrythatagain · 30/11/2023 07:00

@Cosyblankets good morning to you too!! lol. no need to be so patronising. I'm asking the teachers on here who are clearly still teaching why they stay?

cassgate · 30/11/2023 06:59

I am not blaming teachers by the way, just the system that denies teachers the right to tell parents the truth.

Igglepiggleandhisboat · 30/11/2023 06:57

letstrythatagain · 30/11/2023 06:53

If teaching is so bad, and I agree that it (mother and sister are teachers), why stay in it? I see sooo many posts like this so why not just leave and do something else? If you're a qualified teacher then you have huge transferable skills.

I certainly feel as though being a teacher is who I am. I also live for the moments when I’ve made a significant difference to a child. There’s enough of those moments to keep me going (for now!).

cassgate · 30/11/2023 06:57

MrsMurphyIWish · 30/11/2023 05:45

Tonight I’ve got parents evening. I know I’ll be asked by two sets of parents, “what are YOU going to do to get my child their target grade?”. These pupils have less than 50% attendance. I want to say “you get them to school” I’ll have to make up some polite bullshit. I’ve learned to say what parents want to hear.

Yep. I am a TA and have often voiced exasperation at the fact that schools pussy foot around parents. A few home truths is what these people need. Same with social workers, meeting after meeting with inadequate parents going round in circles and not one person has the balls to tell them the plain truth that they are the problem. Glad I am not a teacher as I would probably have been sacked a long time ago.

Cosyblankets · 30/11/2023 06:56

letstrythatagain · 30/11/2023 06:53

If teaching is so bad, and I agree that it (mother and sister are teachers), why stay in it? I see sooo many posts like this so why not just leave and do something else? If you're a qualified teacher then you have huge transferable skills.

Has it escaped your notice that there is a recruitment and retention crisis? Did the strikes pass you by?

letstrythatagain · 30/11/2023 06:53

If teaching is so bad, and I agree that it (mother and sister are teachers), why stay in it? I see sooo many posts like this so why not just leave and do something else? If you're a qualified teacher then you have huge transferable skills.

SusanKennedyshouldLTB · 30/11/2023 06:49

MrsMurphyIWish · 30/11/2023 05:45

Tonight I’ve got parents evening. I know I’ll be asked by two sets of parents, “what are YOU going to do to get my child their target grade?”. These pupils have less than 50% attendance. I want to say “you get them to school” I’ll have to make up some polite bullshit. I’ve learned to say what parents want to hear.

I wouldnt have let the attendance go here. Statistically, they have no chance if passing on that attendance figure. Theyd struggle on 90%. I would absolutely have said they need to be in school.

Then when they have done all that, they have to actually teach a class for 7 hours.
that has been my week. Teaching classes has fallen very low down on the list of demands this week.

Cosyblankets · 30/11/2023 06:42

Iceache · 29/11/2023 21:35

This is false. I’m a teacher and I spend my time in class teaching brilliantly planned lessons. Our school provide a varied and rich curriculum to all children within the best of our ability. We push the Greater Depth, target the SEND, challenge those achieving what they should and analyse the borderlines. We’re state primary.

I also don’t have nearly the problems with parents I read about here. Sure, there is always the odd one but you can get that anywhere!

The reason your school is able to provide such an education is because you don't experience the kind of parents that other posters are talking about.