Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

18-Year-Old DD Clubbing alone

233 replies

WagonWheel1234 · 28/11/2023 18:34

DD turns 18 in a couple of weeks and wants to go to an all-female gay club night (it's a once-a-year-thing apparently) in Covent Garden on NYE, then walk back to Waterloo and get the train home in the small hours - no friends want to come so she'd be totally alone.

I'd be OK with her going with a friend but I think alone is a bad idea when she's never been clubbing before and isn't that used to drinking. No gay clubs in our town, so she feels like it's her only opportunity to go and experience this. She'll be at uni next year and I'm sure there will be things like that at uni, but she says all gay clubs are full of men and straight women and this is unique.

AIBU to say no?

OP posts:
Mirrormeback · 29/11/2023 00:07

My friends younger sister used to go to London clubbing on her own age 14

We'd go up in groups or pairs the same age

Sometimes you're just compelled to do these things

WomensRightsRenegade · 28/11/2023 23:46

No way would my daughter be going. I can only assume most people posting have much younger children and think a child magically becomes a fully-formed adult - whose safety you don’t care about anymore - on their 18th birthday.

And sorry, but it does come across as extremely ‘cool mum’ to be so nonchalant about a teenage girl going into a capital city on NYE completely alone. Because the risk of male violence vanishes when a young woman hits 18?! In a utopia without that threat of course she could walk naked through the streets if she wanted and not come to any harm. But we’re light years away from that.

Tbh if my daughter had even suggested this it would be confirmation that she was nowhere near adult enough to make mature decisions. That level of naivety is pretty astonishing. Yes they need to have their independence and learn to navigate the world. But not going 0-60! Not by doing something objectively dangerous.

Wanting my daughter to be safe is not controlling. There is independence and then there is dangerous idiocy.

SurelySmartie · 28/11/2023 23:41

I don’t see why she can’t wait until Uni. She’s wrong about what she imagines it will be like. She’ll meet lots of gay women and it won’t all just revolve around clubbing. Then when she’s got more friends and a bit more savvy she can start going to clubs in London when she’s home from Uni in future.

She has so much time ahead of her for this. I know it doesn’t feel like it at that age though.

FlissyPaps · 28/11/2023 23:31

Slothfully · 28/11/2023 22:51

It's neither if those things. Just the truth.

You be cool mum if you want to.

It’s not about being “cool mum”. It’s about having basic mutual respect and allowing your children to make adult decisions.

ThreeTreeHill · 28/11/2023 23:29

I think this is madness. You can't stop her but it seems a bad idea

Firstly is she used to London? Is she used to the area on a night out?

She's inexperienced with drinking, inexperienced with clubbing. What's she going to do all night? The club will be packed, she's not going to be sitting around chatting with like minded women and I cant image a lone 18yr old is going to spark the attention of many for a hook up.

Will there actually be trains home on NYE/day?

NYE night outs are horrible. Packed, drunks everywhere, very expensive and everyone is in a rowdy/aggressive state. Venues get terrified things are going to kick off. NYE is not a great first time clubbing experience in Central London.

Why does she want to go? I guess that's the key and can she find that elsewhere? Is there anyway she can find a friend to go?

beatrix1234 · 28/11/2023 23:16

waterrat · 28/11/2023 22:23

I grew up in london and was clubbing from about 16. But i dont think this sounds wise.

She could go and do this more safely and with less pressure (and find a friend to go too) any other weekend of the year

Central London will be horrible incredibly crowded and full of drunks on nye. There wont be taxis and she is really going out on the worst night if the year

Could you gently persuade her to go another weekend and look at a hotel room etc

I agree, I live in central London and NYE is a nightmare, the only night of the year where I stay at home. Streets are crowded, there’s no taxis, people driving drunk, crowds everywhere,drunken fights, long queues to enter any venue and the big stations full of drunks waiting for the train and some passed out. To make matters worse it’s usually freezing outside. Any other night is fine but NYE, no thanks, too chaotic.

Slothfully · 28/11/2023 22:51

FlissyPaps · 28/11/2023 22:08

Ridiculous and patronising response.

It's neither if those things. Just the truth.

You be cool mum if you want to.

Delphinium20 · 28/11/2023 22:28

icclemunchy · 28/11/2023 22:18

@thistimenow interesting, where did I say there will be "non-females" there may or may not be those there who were AMAB. Not sure why it's a problem either as long as they are respectful of others boundaries.

And yes anyone being a twat is shut down quickly, the community as a whole is protective of others. We stick up for and look out for each other. Yes there is the odd bad egg, show me an community that doesn't have them. But I've yet to fine one (except maybe the BDSM community) where respecting boundaries is less tolerated

This has NOT been my bi DD's (19 ) experience at all. She's friends with some transwomen who are respectful but she and her lesbian/bi female and just straight female friends frequently discuss the problems with the many transwomen who have aggressive behavior or are being sex pests. The younger generation is actually getting quite fed up with it. I wrote the below as just one example:

My own DD had a transwoman's penis pressed up against her backside while waiting in line at one club (it wasn't a lesbian club, just general dance club). Her girlfriend yelled at him, but my DD was scared because he just laughed at them and didn't leave.

BlackFridayDiscoCunt · 28/11/2023 22:24

Well, one of my DC went to Singapore/Bali/Australia for a gap year on her own at 18, so I wouldn't be worrying about a club in a big, buzzy city on NYE, personally.

waterrat · 28/11/2023 22:23

I grew up in london and was clubbing from about 16. But i dont think this sounds wise.

She could go and do this more safely and with less pressure (and find a friend to go too) any other weekend of the year

Central London will be horrible incredibly crowded and full of drunks on nye. There wont be taxis and she is really going out on the worst night if the year

Could you gently persuade her to go another weekend and look at a hotel room etc

icclemunchy · 28/11/2023 22:18

@thistimenow interesting, where did I say there will be "non-females" there may or may not be those there who were AMAB. Not sure why it's a problem either as long as they are respectful of others boundaries.

And yes anyone being a twat is shut down quickly, the community as a whole is protective of others. We stick up for and look out for each other. Yes there is the odd bad egg, show me an community that doesn't have them. But I've yet to fine one (except maybe the BDSM community) where respecting boundaries is less tolerated

FlissyPaps · 28/11/2023 22:17

FreshWinterMorning · 28/11/2023 20:16

If she's an adult, and insists she can do what she wants, she can pack her bags and take all her stuff out of her parents house, and go live on her own and support herself financially then.

FFS I can't believe some of the posts on here! No she CAN'T do what the F she wants! Not whilst she lives under her parents roof! I despair for humanity reading some posts on here. Confused

I despair for “parents” like you with this utterly archaic attitude.

SGBK4862 · 28/11/2023 22:17

The fireworks tickets are not balloted. You just need to know when they go on sale and choose which area you want to be in. But now is probably too late to get them - can't be bothered to check.

However, how would parents being at the fireworks help their dd stuck inside a lesbian club where most people will apparently be biological males masquerading as women, intent on sexual assault, spiking her drink or both, and no one will talk to her or be friendly but will definitely grab her or treat her badly.

Even if she manages to exit this den of iniquity, how will she meet her parents in the vast crowds trying to get home after midnight? Oh no, wait. Just after midnight is far too early to leave a club so the parents will need to be the ones to push through the crowds, enter the club and rescue their mortified daughter to drag her to an expensive London hotel.

Or maybe she will fall under a bus at 4pm one dark December day, on her way to buy her clubbing gear.

Because if you only think of the possible risks, then no one is safe on any day anywhere.

While there are safety considerations to discuss with this girl, I think many responses on this thread are close to hysteria. London is not that scary or dangerous. Yes, bad things COULD happen but the likelihood is not as high as many seem to think. We all take risks every single day.

caringcarer · 28/11/2023 22:16

I think due to lack.of trains running she might need to book a Premier Inn FC or the night.

Biscottiforever · 28/11/2023 22:11

It would be a no from me unless she has someone to go with who she knows has her back.

Bahhambug · 28/11/2023 22:10

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

FlissyPaps · 28/11/2023 22:08

Slothfully · 28/11/2023 18:50

I don't get these "she's an adult" responses. She's still living under OP's roof and is financially dependent upon her.

Ridiculous and patronising response.

LambriniBobinIsleworth · 28/11/2023 22:06

This whole idea sounds miserable. Clubbing for the first time, alone? Miles from home? On NYE?! "So you go and you stand on your own, and you leave on your own, and you go home and you cry and you want to die" (to quote Morrissey) springs to mind.

I'd suggest that you'd be much better off encouraging her to join some MeetUp groups for young, gay people or lesbians or whatever so that she can find some likeminded new friends to eventually do things like clubbing with. I can't imagine that she will actually get very much out of solo clubbing on NYE aside from a huge dent in her bank balance.

timenowplease · 28/11/2023 22:02

icclemunchy · 28/11/2023 21:46

More out of the loop than you realise apparently 🙄

As someone who currently attends these kinds of events yes we see more trans women as it's become more acceptable to the masses and yes they may be in various stages of transition (it's never occurred to me to ask!) but I have never once been or seen anyone harassed by a "a man in a dress" like some mumsnetters seem to imagine is prolific.

Anyone being a twat is shut down pretty damn quick regardless of what may or may not be in their pants.

OP the club wouldn't worry me too much bar the fact that it's likely to be rammed and not a great intro to clubbing/the scene in general but the travelling would make me pause. It's horrificully busy and pick pockets are in abundance. Plus the general fact that people are drunk and stumbling about it would be better if she had someone with her. Is there something smaller outside London she could consider? Places like Liverpool/Norwich/Birmingham have huge queer communities and there might be something she'd enjoy more

Thanks for confirming that the 'all-female' night the OP's kid wants to go to will definitely have non-females attending.

The 'anyone being a twat is shut down pretty damn quick' is one of the stupidest things I've heard anyone say about clubbing in London. You really are quite clueless.

neverbeenskiing · 28/11/2023 21:50

It's unusual for an 18 year old to want to go clubbing alone. OP, is there any chance she has arranged to meet someone and just doesn't want you to know?

Behindyouiam · 28/11/2023 21:47

@BabaBarrio my children are adults, managed to stay alive through teenage years and I never made one responsible for the other!

How are you teaching a woman to be safe, if you make her feel shes only safe if a man is around to ensure her safety? Sure fire way for her to think a man is going to be her saviour and is to be honoured. She'll get into a relationship with a controlling man and think it's all good, because he's "looking after" her by telling her what she can and can't do.

Shocking

icclemunchy · 28/11/2023 21:46

timenowplease · 28/11/2023 19:58

Unfortunately, things have changed hugely in the past 10 years and there are little to no women only spaces left. Apparently, lesbians are now organising their own underground events. I'm out of the loop nowadays but I can pretty much guarantee any mainstream event that's being advertised as lesbian/women only will have a large about of biological men in attendance.

All the other posters who think it's fine to let a young girl out to a gay club on NYE in London are frankly insane.

More out of the loop than you realise apparently 🙄

As someone who currently attends these kinds of events yes we see more trans women as it's become more acceptable to the masses and yes they may be in various stages of transition (it's never occurred to me to ask!) but I have never once been or seen anyone harassed by a "a man in a dress" like some mumsnetters seem to imagine is prolific.

Anyone being a twat is shut down pretty damn quick regardless of what may or may not be in their pants.

OP the club wouldn't worry me too much bar the fact that it's likely to be rammed and not a great intro to clubbing/the scene in general but the travelling would make me pause. It's horrificully busy and pick pockets are in abundance. Plus the general fact that people are drunk and stumbling about it would be better if she had someone with her. Is there something smaller outside London she could consider? Places like Liverpool/Norwich/Birmingham have huge queer communities and there might be something she'd enjoy more

Behindyouiam · 28/11/2023 21:44

haribosmarties · 28/11/2023 21:38

@FreshWinterMorning yes she can go and pack her bags and move out... but I mean that's not good is it if she does that? I imagine op would be even more worried about her? So why would any parent want that outcome?

My parents Said similar to me as a teen and I actually did leave and never went back. At 16.
I will never be making ultimatums Like that to my kids. As they hit 18 you need to be flexible with them or you really do risk losing them or forever damaging your relationship with them as an adult

Don't blame you and well done for not following other footsteps!

BabaBarrio · 28/11/2023 21:43

Behindyouiam · 28/11/2023 21:37

@BabaBarrio which is what it is? How have I twisted it?? You expect an older brother to wait for hours to make sure his sister gets home ok on NYE!

His sister is responsible for her own safety, not him.

Too weird!

I don’t expect it. A suggestion is not an expectation.

Family should look out for each other. I don’t think you should brag about having a thrown to the wolves, survival of the fittest, swim or get stabbed attitude towards teenagers in London.

Do you even have teenagers?
Would you advise your own child that it’s perfectly fine when many posters who know what NYE is like in that exact area are telling you it is not safe and it’s insane to tell your daughter that she will be fine.

haribosmarties · 28/11/2023 21:38

@FreshWinterMorning yes she can go and pack her bags and move out... but I mean that's not good is it if she does that? I imagine op would be even more worried about her? So why would any parent want that outcome?

My parents Said similar to me as a teen and I actually did leave and never went back. At 16.
I will never be making ultimatums Like that to my kids. As they hit 18 you need to be flexible with them or you really do risk losing them or forever damaging your relationship with them as an adult