Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

18-Year-Old DD Clubbing alone

233 replies

WagonWheel1234 · 28/11/2023 18:34

DD turns 18 in a couple of weeks and wants to go to an all-female gay club night (it's a once-a-year-thing apparently) in Covent Garden on NYE, then walk back to Waterloo and get the train home in the small hours - no friends want to come so she'd be totally alone.

I'd be OK with her going with a friend but I think alone is a bad idea when she's never been clubbing before and isn't that used to drinking. No gay clubs in our town, so she feels like it's her only opportunity to go and experience this. She'll be at uni next year and I'm sure there will be things like that at uni, but she says all gay clubs are full of men and straight women and this is unique.

AIBU to say no?

OP posts:
mantyzer · 29/11/2023 12:15

I am a lesbian.
Going clubbing alone as a young lesbian is not unusual. I did it and most of my friends did. Before you know any or many other lesbians you don't have any other choice except to go alone. Or you just wait and wait until you have friends to go with.

I assume she is going to Jewel. She wants to go to this because there are very few lesbian club nights. Unlike her straight friends she can't just go to a club in her local town or City that is lesbian. The vast majority are mixed and mainly men and are less safe than Jewel will be.

She sounds socially confident so will be fine in the club. It may not live up to her expectations, but it will be fine. I assume she already knows about the dangers of spiking. She will be at far less at risk of this in Jewel, but that does not mean there is no risk. Anyone young going out, unless they are pretty naïve, seems far more switched on about these risks and how to avoid it than most older people are.

Pickpocketing is a risk both in the club and outside and I would want to talk to her about how to avoid that and what to do if it happens. I would also talk to her about the risk of being drunk alone and would want her to set a clear amount she will not drink over. But lots of young people do not drink or do not drink much, so that might not be an issue.

The poster talking about being constantly groped and pulled and grabbed in a lesbian club sounds like a male fantasist. The real risk is that she will be pretty much ignored, but if she is confident then she can enjoy dancing and just being in the crowd. That is fun if you are very confident.

My concern would be her journey home. I agree that some posters make it sound like a war zone, which it is not. But there will be groups of drunk men who may harass her or just make her feel unsafe. If I could afford it I would either book somewhere for me and DP to stay and collect her at the end of the evening outside the club. Or collect her outside and accompany her on the train home. It might be a crappy evening for DP and I, but I would feel much happier doing this.

LambriniBobinIsleworth · 29/11/2023 11:44

All these posters worrying about her safety... fine and fair enough, but aside from anything else it will just be bleakly depressing. She will be all on her own, no one to talk to and likely have a shit night. She so clearly doesn't have a clue about what clubbing is.

Daisies12 · 29/11/2023 11:32

You can't say no. She's an adult. Just make sure she knows her limits on alcohol and has a plan to get home. The vast majority of women have safe nights out, don't freak her out with horror stories. You're only going to push her away if you try and stop her.

Westfacing · 29/11/2023 11:25

A couple of things:

I'd be surprised if trains from Waterloo are running until the small hours

As it's NYE it's likely a ticketed event - does she have one?

LardyCakeAgain · 29/11/2023 11:21

That's the point @CagneyAndLazy - there's no safety in numbers for a girl on her own anymore on a busy city street, as no-one will do anything to defend her and the met police are ineffective & understaffed, muggers & rapists know that. Add into that a huge amount of alcohol & drugs on NYE, and you've got a situation that a sheltered 18 year old girl who has never been clubbing before won't be able to handle. I'm the opposite of sheltered - I did what I wanted from a young age and can look after myself in a fight if no weapons are involved - but I still wouldn't risk going clubbing by myself in Covent Garden / Leicester Sq at NYE.

beatrix1234 · 29/11/2023 11:08

@FreshWinterMorning .! We all know your parents did put their foot down with you, they did say 'if you don't like it you can leave,' and you didn't leave!

Careful with those “all or nothing” “my house my rules” statements, my mom said the same thing so I packed my bags on my 18th birthday and left. I had nothing, but “nothing” was better than a narcissistic emotionally abusive mum. I ended up engaged in sex work to survive. To this day I have a stranged relationship with a mom I see once a year. As a mum your actions will have consequences so tread carefully.

WagonWheel1234 · 29/11/2023 11:07

Thanks for your advice everyone x

OP posts:
CagneyAndLazy · 29/11/2023 11:06

LardyCakeAgain · 29/11/2023 10:53

Another one, in another McDonalds - near in mind that this is a naice wealthy area of outer London, during the day, and still no-one does anything...
https://x.com/CrimeLdn/status/1725547907430900200?s=20

What do you want 'someone' to do, given the useless policewoman isn't doing anything either, despite being equipped with pepper spray, baton, etc?

LardyCakeAgain · 29/11/2023 10:53

Another one, in another McDonalds - near in mind that this is a naice wealthy area of outer London, during the day, and still no-one does anything...
https://x.com/CrimeLdn/status/1725547907430900200?s=20

https://x.com/CrimeLdn/status/1725547907430900200?s=20%5D%5D

LardyCakeAgain · 29/11/2023 10:48

The idea that the streets are safer if they're more busy is very outdated. If something kicks off now, no-one steps in to help anymore like they used to, because they're afraid of getting stabbed - they're more likely to stand back and film it. Where do you think these videos come from on the news & youtube? There's currently phone footage being shared around of two met coppers getting battered and kicked on the floor by a gang of teenagers in a busy McDonalds, and the only person who steps in is a little old man who couldn't do much. Bouncers only get involved in incidents inside their own clubs, if it's outside you're on your own. Central London isn't a community of helpful local folk like some up north - it's usually selfish, anonymous crowds, who only care about getting to where they're going and ignore anyone else around them.

peachescariad · 29/11/2023 10:37

I can't believe the shitty advice on here considering this young lesbian woman is a totally inexperienced clubber and drinker and some of you think it's ok for her to go to this venue and travel home alone?
I've just shown this thread to a work colleague (lesbian 42) an she said wtaf??? The venue is highly likely to have a mix of queer/non binary and transwomen, she said the level of unwanted attention can be hard to navigate and even more so for someone so very young and totally inexperienced, plus not having a partner/friend to move off with.
This is not a good choice for her introduction to gay club land.

timenowplease · 29/11/2023 10:12

CagneyAndLazy · 29/11/2023 10:07

What a thread!

MN is a bizarre place where underage teenage children must absolutely be able to shag whoever they want at home "because I'd rather they do it under my roof and they'll do it anyway", but an adult woman can also be told what she can and can't do for an evening out whilst "living under OP's roof".

Fucking bonkers! 😂

MN is a swamp of shitty parenting advice. It's like people don't really like their own kids.

CagneyAndLazy · 29/11/2023 10:07

What a thread!

MN is a bizarre place where underage teenage children must absolutely be able to shag whoever they want at home "because I'd rather they do it under my roof and they'll do it anyway", but an adult woman can also be told what she can and can't do for an evening out whilst "living under OP's roof".

Fucking bonkers! 😂

Lovemusic82 · 29/11/2023 10:06

My dd is the same age and would probably do similar to what your dd wants to do. I would suggest she gets an Uber/taxi home rather than the train or if you can collect her? The club itself will probably be fine, I have been to gay clubs and felt extremely safe, as long as she’s streetwise, keeps an eye on her drink and realises there maybe be me in there that identify as women. My dd isn’t very streetwise, I like to keep reminding her of the risks when she goes out. It’s our job to worry but they are adults.

MrsSkylerWhite · 29/11/2023 10:00

In younger years, was out and about in the small hours many a NYE. Lots of people about, most good humoured and never had any problems (not so commuting to/from work!)
Tubes used to be free after midnight on NYE too.

Irisborn · 29/11/2023 09:58

If that’s what she really wants to do for her 18th birthday celebration, book her a hotel room somewhere near the club.

My worry for her is that she’ll be very disappointed. Clubbing is noisy and most people go in groups. Going on your own as a birthday treat sounds incredibly lonely and depressing, and also there’s a risk that she pulls the first person there who shows her any attention.

I symoathise with her point about gay meetups being dominated by men. There must be other, calmer, female-only meetups, particularly if she’s able to get to London. I have heard lesbians on here say that lesbian groups now meet in secret now avoid being harassed by transwomen. A better option might be for your DD to spend some time networking in Facebook until she finds out where the good meetups are.

FreshWinterMorning · 29/11/2023 09:57

Slothfully · 28/11/2023 22:51

It's neither if those things. Just the truth.

You be cool mum if you want to.

Exactly this. I am hoping (praying) that the few posters who are saying 'yeah yeah - just send your inexperienced SCHOOL AGED CHILD on her way to London - on her own on the train, to go to a busy club on New Year's Eve, and be hanging around on her own in the streets at 2am' do not have children. And definitely not daughters!

If they have - I will pray for their safety and welfare. I am shaking my head and facepalming at some of the responses on here, and genuinely worried and sad that anyone would be so irresponsible and cavalier with their own child's safety and welfare..

Thank goodness most posters are sensible and responsible parents and agree it's batshit, and utterly irresponsible to let this girl go. Along with being very questionable parenting! Just a reminder to the 'cool parents.' This girl is still 17 right now. SHE IS STILL AT SCHOOL.

I will just leave that there for you to think about. I am sure you will realise you're so wrong about this soon enough. SO wrong.

Oh and as for the few posters saying 'if my parents had told ME to leave if I refused to take any notice of them, I would have left home,' ...! We all know your parents did put their foot down with you, they did say 'if you don't like it you can leave,' and you didn't leave!

FreshWinterMorning · 29/11/2023 09:41

BabaBarrio · 28/11/2023 21:19

Keeper? She’s not a pet.
It is the responsibility of family to look out for each other’s safety. An older brother would be better for that than a middle aged frumpy woman. Probably less embarrassing for a teenage girl too.

'A middle aged frumpy woman?'

FFS, could you be more rude and offensive?! Hmm

sweetpickle23 · 29/11/2023 09:38

If my parents had tried to tell me what I could and couldn't do when I was an 18 year-old adult they'd have got short shrift. As PP have said, I was at Uni at that age doing all sorts that would make their toes curl.

I think your daughter wanting to do this alone is the bit that is unsafe- I would (and have) gone clubbing alone but I'm twice her age with a lot of experience of the world and of London. If she is inexperienced this is too much for her by herself. The fact that its London or NYE is less of an issue in my opinion, as other have said it will be safer than usual as it's so busy.

However you can only advise her, I don't think you can stop her.

WasRobbed · 29/11/2023 09:31

QuietBear · 29/11/2023 07:01

What world do you live in that wanting to go clubbing on your own is very unusual?

Are young women no longer allowed to grow up?

I live in the real world! The only person I know personally that goes clubbing alone is my friend with Bipolar disorder when she's having a manic episode. And the strange men I remember from my own clubbing days that would try and insert themselves into our group.

But of course in MN world it's completely normal for teenage girls to go clubbing alone from age 14+ and 'crash' at some randoms flat afterwards.

I'm also loving the posts from people claiming that due to their superior parenting, their 17yo DD planning a night out, alone, on NYE in central London would be perfectly safe. HA!

None of my 18y daughter or 19y old son’s friends go clubbing alone. They view it as a social activity so would not enjoy it on their own. Never mind the safety aspect.

Some people really think a magic button gets switched on when a child turns 18. It’s odd. There is a lot of middle ground between locking up your teenager with no freedom and letting them do whatever they want ‘cos they are an ADULT’. Most of us have young adult kids who are getting there gradually and learning useful lessons along the way.

WasRobbed · 29/11/2023 09:25

My daughter turned 18 in the summer. She didn’t miraculously become a mature adult overnight who was suddenly totally independent and sensible. Funnily enough. Maturing to full adulthood is a process.

And sadly we live in a world where young women alone are vulnerable to some vile men. So caution is needed.

Anyway we live in London. My daughter has been clubbing centrally many times with friends. But she has never come home on her own. Always with in friends, and once or twice my husband has gone out to get her when she has been the worse for wear.

The ‘safest’ part of the evening is midnight when the streets will be busy. Give me busy over quiet for personal safety any day. I would not worry so much about the CG to Waterloo walk. It’s what happens after. The journey back home. I would shell out for a central hotel if she insisted on going.

But otherwise I would discourage her going alone to this. There will be other events in her life. At her age she is impatient and this is everything to her right now. But she really needs to go with someone and I would be discouraging her. My daughter would not want to go if I was against it, even though I could not really stop her. We are very close and she would understand my reservations, despite railing against me on the surface.

I think the plans are too ambitious for her age and experience to date.

waterrat · 29/11/2023 08:29

btw while I don't think it's wise I TOTALLY understand the 18 year old desire to get out into the world and meet like minded people. I think that is natural and deserves every support - it sounds like she has put this idea of a night on a pedastal and it just could be pretty shit and disappointing in reality.

I think try to assure her most Londoners would avoid central london on NYE - and if she is willing to chat with you - could you help her find alternatives in the coming months that would be just as fun.

Longma · 29/11/2023 08:02

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

ocarinaflow · 29/11/2023 07:37

@Anotherrname I'm really sorry you went through that. But ah just for clarity I wasn't ever spiked (or at least don't know if I was, my older siblings used to say don't drink that anymore I'll buy you a new drink, and then later on my own I was familiar enough to always cover my drink with my hand, leave drinks that were too old, etc).

I was harassed and followed plenty while alone though. Really really scary even if there are other strangers in a "crowded" or very noisy place – often people don't realise what's going on or purposely turn a blind eye. But especially when you're just walking through places (or waiting like on platforms) with absolutely no one else around. And especially when drunk and incapable but also sober. Well you get the idea, I'm sure all women know :)

Anotherrname · 29/11/2023 07:25

WhatNoUsername · 29/11/2023 05:15

@ocarinaflow @Anotherrname You are missing the point. Firstly, you prepare your children for independence in a general sense - gradually letting the reins on but also discussing dangers and emergencies so they are able to make their own risk based decisions, be aware of dangers and get themselves out of trouble. I thought that was obvious. If you've not started this process by 18, you are way too late as by this point IT IS NOT UP TO THE OP WHAT HER DD DECIDES TO DO. SHE IS AN ADULT (caps for emphasis not shouting). The OP can't "not let her" or tell her no. She can advise and guide and warn. And I agree I wouldn't want my child 18 or not doing that so I would advise them against it strongly and set out the risks. But bottom line is she can't tell her she's not allowed!

Preparing your child for independence doesn't start with allowing them to go clubbing in a big city alone. A good parent would start off with allowing their teen to party in their own town with friends before going to another town or city with friends. Not alone.

OP's dd is 17 and will have only just turned 18 by the time it's this event. You don't wake up on your 18th birthday and automatically become a fully fledged adult that's very streetwise. I'm a bit concerned that she wants to go alone. I bet she's meeting someone.

Also, thanks for ignoring how @ocarinaflow and I were spiked. I was also SA in a horrific way. That's why I don't think it's safe for young women (and OP's dd is barely an adult) to go out alone at night, especially when alcohol is involved.