Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop paying 50/50 after being fired

261 replies

Copenhagener · 28/11/2023 15:31

I’ve been with my partner for 10 years. We’ve always split things 50/50 (bills, mortgage, food) and then kept the rest of our paychecks to spend as we like. We were both good earners in corporate jobs and took home approximately the same, until this year when he got a new job and a massive raise.

We don’t have children yet (going through IVF).

In October, I was fired from a new job for not being ‘the right cultural fit’. I’ve never been unemployed before.

We live in his country, and I’m not eligible for any benefits, or I will never be able to become a citizen. I have enough from my last pay check to last me until January.

The job market is really rough, and I’m not getting any offers right now despite applying and networking hard. Before, I was fighting off job offers :(

I’ve saved up about £10,000 through freelance work over the past couple of years in an emergency fund. Unfortunately; the freelance work is also drying up.

My partner wants me to use that emergency fund money so we both still pay 50/50, like if I still had a job, and he wouldn’t have to increase his share of the bills/mortgage. I’m happy to put some of my savings into bills/mortgage, but feel he should shoulder more of the burden for now, until I get a new job. He can cover it all using his paycheck alone, and still have some money leftover.

The savings are my emergency fund / IVF fund if our state-funded IVF fails.

He’s from a culture where men and women tend to split everything 50/50.

Who is in the right here?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Cherrysoup · 28/11/2023 17:40

Copenhagener · 28/11/2023 15:47

Quick note: I’ve been on the IVF waitlist for a year, and get 3 rounds paid for by the government: it’s incredibly generous. I won’t be able to get this anywhere else. I’m the infertile one, so if I give this up, there’s no guarantee I’d ever get to try again as I’m 33 soon. I want a baby very badly.

I’m living in a Scandinavian country where childcare is fully funded.

I do envision I’ll get another job, but it could be another few months yet; everything grinds to a halt in December here. The options for temp roles are very few, and typically reserved for students.

What are the plans for when you’re on maternity leave if you don’t get benefits? Will he still expect you to pay 50/50?!

jeaux90 · 28/11/2023 17:38

What is the earnings split between you usually?

Wavyline · 28/11/2023 17:35

Well, obviously you don't have a child with him for a start.

Nowherenew · 28/11/2023 17:35

I think this a tricky one.

If my DP got fired then why should I pick up the slack for him when he’s got thousands sat in the bank?
If he was made redundant or became ill etc then I’d not think twice about paying for him but I’d feel a bit taken advantage of if he’s got thousands in the bank and I’m paying all of the bills.

I’m pretty sure if I started a thread saying my DP has £10,000 in the bank but expects me to pay all of the bills, posters would be telling me that I’m being taken for a mug and he should use his savings.

Your life style is going to be considerably impacted and if I was you I would want to use some of my savings.

You need to use your savings for the first month or 2.
If you are applying for jobs but aren’t being successful then I’d talk to him about him paying for most or all of the bills until you can find something.

I don’t think it’s fair that he should pay them all when you’ve got thousands in the bank.
This is what savings are for, to use when we need them.

Muchof · 28/11/2023 17:34

Copenhagener · 28/11/2023 16:48

Hey guys;

Thanks for all the input. He just got back from work and I’m going to sit down and have a chat with him after he’s cooked dinner about this topic.

I will update you later tonight.

I know everyone is saying LTB - but I will say he’s been the kindest, most understanding partner I’ve ever had. This is the first time we’ve ever not been on the same page.

I have nothing for me back in the U.K. and no family. I will earn my permanent residency in Denmark in August 2024, and then I have no issues with staying here forever regardless of employment status if I want, which I do.

He has just shown you that he is not your partner, quite literally. Partners support each other through hard times, he has just shown that when the chips are down you are on your own.

You need to run a mile from this dreadful relationship. You say he is the kindest partner you have ever had, but you have been with him ten years and are 23, how many partners do you have to compare him too?!

rwalker · 28/11/2023 17:33

Live to see the replies if a woman posted my partner has 10k in savings and wants me to bankroll his bills because I’ve done well for my and earn well
he’d be called the biggest cock lodger going and the overwhelming advice would be kick him to the kerb and LTB

TheSquareMile · 28/11/2023 17:33

Are your job prospects likely to improve next year?

Do you speak Danish to the standard given in the Citizenship list?

Coconutter24 · 28/11/2023 17:31

whatausername · 28/11/2023 17:28

He should already be putting aside his share of the IVF and child-associated costs. The cost should not all be on OP in the first place.

He should be yes but given he expects her to still pay 50/50 whilst out of work I doubt he has planned any savings for IVF

whatausername · 28/11/2023 17:28

Coconutter24 · 28/11/2023 17:07

Can you ask him if you were to use your savings would he be paying for the IVF if you need to pay for it as your savings were planned for the IVF and if you use them you won’t have any money for it.

He should already be putting aside his share of the IVF and child-associated costs. The cost should not all be on OP in the first place.

sillnotseal · 28/11/2023 17:23

cheezncrackers · 28/11/2023 16:56

I think there's a bit of cultural misunderstanding on this thread. Denmark is definitely ahead of the UK in terms of equality between the sexes. Danish women are very independent and proudly so, from what I can see. Having DC without being married is very common, not frowned upon and you aren't disadvantaged if you do that. I wouldn't abandon a whole life with a partner who is otherwise great and a healthcare system that offers three rounds of IVF when you need it, just over one sticky point of principle OP. You're right to discuss it further. Lay out your worries and why you don't want to spend your savings and I would also ask about what happens when/if you're on maternity leave and a reduced income. There needs to be a bit of flexibility, a bit of give and take.

There’s zero cultural misunderstanding. Married to a southern swede and have spent considerable time in Denmark, know lots of danish couples.

50/50 only benefits him. He has out earned her for a while and hasn’t proposed a proportional split. That would truly be ‘fair’

i know no decent scandi bloke who wouldn’t support an out of work partner in this situation. This is NOT a cultural norm.

I definitely know a few bastards who would wax lyrical about feminist Denmark to continue building up their own personal savings at the detriment of the low earning partner though.

Birdcar · 28/11/2023 17:22

user1471556818 · 28/11/2023 17:19

Totally as above I'm afraid .However look at this as a very narrow escape .Time to really rethink this relationship

That hit the nail on the head.

user1471556818 · 28/11/2023 17:19

disappearingfish · 28/11/2023 15:37

You are planning to have a child with a man, that you're not married to, in a country where you have no citizenship rights and no access to benefits. And to top it off you have no joint finances and pay 50% of everything even though he out-earns you.

You are either hopelessly naïve or insane.

Totally as above I'm afraid .However look at this as a very narrow escape .Time to really rethink this relationship

Nofilteritwonthelp · 28/11/2023 17:18

Don't have children with this man

Frasers · 28/11/2023 17:16

Nanny0gg · 28/11/2023 17:11

So marriage in Denmark doesn't confer any protection to the wife (when there are children)?

Don’t you mean spouse? It is not specific to women. It is equal, like in the uk.

ToMissAdventure · 28/11/2023 17:16

I would first have an open conversation with him about how important psychologically and practically your safety net is and that you really hope that during this tricky period you can pull together as a team and he can help support you temporarily. Explain you don’t take it for granted and you being there for each other emotionally and where needed financially at times like this is important.

good luck with the job hunt and do try not to take it personally. The amount of roles that end for this reason is much bigger than most people realise and the sad fact is that it is the senior employee’s personality that is never told to flex.

sillnotseal · 28/11/2023 17:16

Copenhagener · 28/11/2023 16:48

Hey guys;

Thanks for all the input. He just got back from work and I’m going to sit down and have a chat with him after he’s cooked dinner about this topic.

I will update you later tonight.

I know everyone is saying LTB - but I will say he’s been the kindest, most understanding partner I’ve ever had. This is the first time we’ve ever not been on the same page.

I have nothing for me back in the U.K. and no family. I will earn my permanent residency in Denmark in August 2024, and then I have no issues with staying here forever regardless of employment status if I want, which I do.

Good you are having a chat.

He should be understanding that 10k of savings should be saved for your joint life, particularly when you guys are intending on having a family.

He also should understand that he outearns you, and as much as he wants things to be ‘50/50’, it isn’t 50/50. he earns considerably more. The IVF process also won’t be 50/50, I assure you.

Some scandi men use their beardy blokey third wave feminism as a way to rationalise being selfish cheapskates. Even if they perform ‘gender equality’ well by being food good cooks and a dab hand with a mop.

You aren’t ‘lucky’ that he’s a sweet, helpful, good cook. You’ve been financially taken advantage of since he got that huge raise and didn’t propose a proportional split so you wouldn’t be out of pocket. 50/50 for him allows him to profit off you and build his savings whilst you drain yours.

Birdcar · 28/11/2023 17:15

You are not a team in this relationship at the moment. It's survival of the fittest.

What happens if/when your savings run out?

This is not necessarily a temporary situation. It's possible that you might never be on equal incomes again. One of you might have a career that takes off while the others career stagnates. How would that work? This is new territory and it will change your relationship. There is a lot to be ironed out before bringing a baby into the equation.

Rewis · 28/11/2023 17:13

I wouldn't say it is the cultural norm in Scandinavia to go 50/50 even when the other is unemployed or sick etc.

Nanny0gg · 28/11/2023 17:11

cheezncrackers · 28/11/2023 16:56

I think there's a bit of cultural misunderstanding on this thread. Denmark is definitely ahead of the UK in terms of equality between the sexes. Danish women are very independent and proudly so, from what I can see. Having DC without being married is very common, not frowned upon and you aren't disadvantaged if you do that. I wouldn't abandon a whole life with a partner who is otherwise great and a healthcare system that offers three rounds of IVF when you need it, just over one sticky point of principle OP. You're right to discuss it further. Lay out your worries and why you don't want to spend your savings and I would also ask about what happens when/if you're on maternity leave and a reduced income. There needs to be a bit of flexibility, a bit of give and take.

So marriage in Denmark doesn't confer any protection to the wife (when there are children)?

SlightlyJaded · 28/11/2023 17:09

We are going through a hard time at the moment. DH runs a business which - through no fault of his own - is really struggling. I have had to all my smallish inheritance to go in 50/50 on bills for the last three months, as my earnings are less than his - and he needs help.

He has paid the lion's share of everything for over twenty years and is mortified that I am using the only money I have (£20K inheritance) and I know that if he is EVER in a position to pay it back to me, he will.

We are a team and he needs me to help out now until things are better for him. Sometimes it's fine to use your savings to pay your way.

Sometimes it's not.

The massive difference here is that your partner can easily afford to cover it, and is choosing not to.

Nanny0gg · 28/11/2023 17:09

Well I hope you have a successful 'chat'

But whilst I accept why you want to continue IVF think long and hard about your future because if you ever split further down the line don't expect to be treated fairly

Any reason you're not getting married first? I don't know how Scandi countries treat spouses rather than partners but are you making yourself even more vulnerable?

PartTimePartyPooper · 28/11/2023 17:09

if you were on your own in Denmark and unemployed with no access to benefits, then what would you have to pay for? eg if you had ability to cancel all non-essential payments and subscriptions, survive on economy food and keep the heating/lights off until you could downsize to a houseshare in a few months… id suggest you pay that much toward your living expenses with your partner.

it sounds like you’ll have a job again in a few months

i do also question why you’d put yourself in such a precarious living situation AND try to conceive a baby - at least wait for your full citizenship to give you support. Aware there advantages to being married?

EarthSight · 28/11/2023 17:08

Rather than being a couple operating and supporting each other in the same unit, I think he has a different view of relationships. Despite sleeping in the same bed and having sex, his view of what a relationship is, is that you stay firmly on your side, and he stays on his. Inside his head, you might always be kept at a distance.

Some highly selfish, stingy men are like this, and they'll use modern, progressive ideas of relationships to ensure they never have to be supportive, never have to be generous.

When the woman gives birth, she's expected to be back at work full time as fast a possible, like she's a machine. If she doesn't, she risks being called lazy or being accused of being a freeloader, or made to feel like she's SUCH an inconvenience. Such men hate the thought of being generous in any way, even if it's to the mother of their own children.

But, funnily enough, these women seem to often end up working AND doing most of the childcare and housework.....yes.....very progressive.....

Please be careful you don't end up like that.

Coconutter24 · 28/11/2023 17:07

Copenhagener · 28/11/2023 15:47

Quick note: I’ve been on the IVF waitlist for a year, and get 3 rounds paid for by the government: it’s incredibly generous. I won’t be able to get this anywhere else. I’m the infertile one, so if I give this up, there’s no guarantee I’d ever get to try again as I’m 33 soon. I want a baby very badly.

I’m living in a Scandinavian country where childcare is fully funded.

I do envision I’ll get another job, but it could be another few months yet; everything grinds to a halt in December here. The options for temp roles are very few, and typically reserved for students.

Can you ask him if you were to use your savings would he be paying for the IVF if you need to pay for it as your savings were planned for the IVF and if you use them you won’t have any money for it.

disappearingfish · 28/11/2023 17:05

Please, please, please protect yourself financially. Do you understand the financial protections in Denmark for unmarried parents?

I appreciate you don't want to come back to the UK - things aren't great here! - but overwhelmingly women disadvantage themselves career-wise and financially when they have children, so do consider what would happen if this all went wrong.