Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy less for older working daughter than younger brother and sister?

107 replies

snuggleswithmygirlies · 28/11/2023 14:19

I have bought the Christmas presents for our younger children who are school aged and we have our older dd in her 20s coming for Xmas and staying a few nights.
I have bought about half the amount for her and dh says that's unfair but my argument is she has had years of opening presents to that value and amount, now she is a working adult she wont get as much as the younger ones.
I don't expect to be buying that much for the younger ones once they're the same age.
Who is being unreasonable?

OP posts:
Iateallllllthepies · 29/11/2023 21:53

I’ve got a 21 year old ds at home as well as a 9 year old and a 3 year old.

I don’t know what to get him. He’s got a good job, he buys what he wants when he wants it.

He doesn’t like random bits of crap. He’s got clothes and shoes and likes to buy his own, so I am stumped and don’t just want to give cash.

I will spend far more on the 9 year old as that’s a prime age for wanting/needing things.

The 3 year olds presents have mostly come second hand from facebook marketplace (wooden kitchen and dolls house which she will be thrilled with).

It can’t always be equal in money terms when you have age gaps.

seagull82 · 29/11/2023 21:51

I have a DS 21 and DSD 14, both here Christmas Day, DSD has a bigger pile of presents (£200 mainly clothes) DS has less to open (aftershave, tool for work and chocolate) but I'll put £100 in a card for him so it's the same amount spent.

MrsMarzetti · 29/11/2023 21:41

FartSock5000 · 29/11/2023 09:40

@snuggleswithmygirlies Your logic is sound but i'd pre-warn her that visually what will be under the tree looks less for her but cost around the same so that she isn't caught unaware and feels as if she matters less.

FGS she is a grown woman not a 10 year old. Why do you think she needs to be pre warned, do you think she is going to have a tantrum ? I wouldn't expect my Mum ( if she was alive) to spend anymore than £20 on me seeing as i am an adult.

Mumoffourkiddos · 29/11/2023 21:35

3 teens ans 1 newly turned 7 Yr old here and they all have had the same money , 7 year old has a mountain but older ones have fewer but they understand they've had the same money they just asked for more expensive items

Pippu · 29/11/2023 21:12

Mine are mid 20s and I have always been scrupulously careful to spend exactly the same on them whether at svhool, uni or working. That might mean a different number of presents if one is more expensive. Stockings are identical.

Ibizamumof4 · 29/11/2023 21:10

I am with you once they have their own money etc I wouldn’t be expecting to spend loads more of a gesture

PissOffJeffrey · 29/11/2023 21:02

I'm with you OP. I have two DSs who are 26 & 22 and both working full time. Both have said that they don't particularly want or need anything for Christmas as if they want something, they buy it. And whilst of course I will buy them gifts, they won't be to the same value as their 12 year old sister who has to wait until Christmas or birthday to get the things she wants.

Findinganewme · 29/11/2023 20:57

no matter how old the children get, they still have feelings, they’re still our children and I think it’s important to maintain equal treatment, for all of the children. The value should be the same, but of course younger children like lots of presents under the tree and if they are of lower price per present, it’s fine.

my eldest is almost 12 and one his gifts is a cookery class at Jamie Oliver’s school. My daughter is 4 and she will be getting stuff like arty sets, dress up stuff…more boxes but not as pricey per item, compared to her brother.

thelonghaul · 29/11/2023 19:09

Not unreasonable at all, particularly since youre only talking volume not value. But probably worth talking it through with her in advance so there's no misunderstanding on the day.

weegiemum · 29/11/2023 18:40

We have an agreement that you get "big" presents until you are 21, and after that you'll get some nice stuff and we Santa will still fill your stocking. We have quite a generous budget for gifts so they're all still getting plenty. Dd2 (youngest) turned 20 yesterday so one more year!

NumberTheory · 29/11/2023 18:25

OrigamiOwl · 29/11/2023 16:39

I think your point about your older one having had years of presents already is a bit of a moot point... Your younger ones have years ahead of them, so it would all even out over time.

It will only even out if you stop giving them piles of presents when they reach a set age. Otherwise the older one will always have more years of it.

At what point do you think it's appropriate to stop giving piles of presents?

NumberTheory · 29/11/2023 18:23

I would not expect to buy for an adult child the way I buy for a younger child. I went to uni at 18 so from then until I graduated, Christmas and Birthdays consisted of money and a small, well considered, token present. Once I was working properly it was just the small present. We're better off than my mum was, so I'd expect to give my grown up kids more financial help, but not piles of presents at Christmas. I think that's totally the wrong focus for a happy life and not the way I'd want my relationships with my adult children to go.

HollyJollyRobin · 29/11/2023 17:24

There's a big age gap between me and my brother (he's younger) and gets more than me...I'd rather that tbh as I can afford to by myself what I want, whereas he can't as is still in uni!

OrigamiOwl · 29/11/2023 16:39

I think your point about your older one having had years of presents already is a bit of a moot point... Your younger ones have years ahead of them, so it would all even out over time.

PianPianPiano · 29/11/2023 16:25

Anderson2018 · 29/11/2023 08:23

if you’ve spent the same on them all that’s fine, but why on earth have you got presents wrapped up under the tree 3 weeks early. Surely you set it all up on Christmas Eve as if santas been?

Presents under the tree come from us in our house - Santa fills the stocking that's left outside the bedroom door. (But yes, I'm amazed people have their presents bought, wrapped, and under the tree already!)

Maray1967 · 29/11/2023 14:16

We’ve always done it the other way. Spent more on a 13 year old than a 5 year old, for example- as better computer equipment is worth paying for but not loads of plastic crap in the form of toys. 5 year old roughly got what the 13 year old did when he was 5. Now ours are early 20s and mid teen - older is working, but at home . We’re spending the same on them.

Kathryn1983 · 29/11/2023 14:14

My mum from when we were 16 moved from just a pile of gifts to just our Christmas Eve boxes (literally pjs, slippers of socks and a book, puzzle box or dvd ) and 3 gifts and money
and it was the same 3 things
perfume (all girls)
a chosen/requested gift (so a bra set or a bag or clothes or some make up or jewelry whatever)
And a small gift bag bag with chocolate and sweets and a silly toy or puzzle

now as adults we obviously no longer get Christmas Eve boxes so now we get
pjs
Perfume
sweets/ chocolate
Mon Christmas Day and that's it

I think she removed stockings when we started secondary school or a year or two after Santa was uncovered

for years my younger sister got loads more and I never recall batting an eye at it and if my eldest was that jealous of a young child Aw a much older child / adult I'd be concerned about my parenting 🤣😂

DietrichandDiMaggio · 29/11/2023 14:11

Do those who talk about always spending the same on 'children' think that their parents should provide them with expensive presents for the rest of their lives? Do you expect to be treated like a child by your parents forever?
It's not about being less valued, but moving into another phase of your life, as an adult, which the younger siblings will as well when they are older.
Hopefully, my son's earnings will exceed ours considerably as his career progresses, but presumably some of you would expect us to continue spending hundreds of pounds on him at Christmas, as he is our child?

Kathryn1983 · 29/11/2023 13:54

I have older and younger siblings with a decent age gap
please don't worry your eldest isn't going to feel undervalued by getting perfume over 10 squishy toys 🤦‍♀️
and of course the tree will look focussed on the littler ones ! Surely any reasonable young adult will see that's fine 🤷‍♀️
i would suggest you talk to her about it in advance and say now she's older you are going to do fewer more significant presents for her and will do the same for the littles when they reach that age too
or you set a financial budget of £x amount per child and that's what's spend if it's 1 gift or 10 or heaven forbid cash 🤪
adult Christmas with family can still be super enjoyable and special and welcoming without stuff and things

Elaina87 · 29/11/2023 13:48

I think you're right. As you say, once they get to the same age they will get less too. It shouldn't be about the sheet amount of gift anyway should it?

StoorieHoose · 29/11/2023 11:55

BarnacleBeasley · 28/11/2023 15:21

I've got a sibling 10 years younger and it would never have occurred to me to expect the same number of presents when I was an adult and they were a child. The individual presents I did get (e.g. perfume) were probably more expensive than their individual toys - but I wouldn't have been adding up the monetary value either.

This. Also have a sibling 10 years younger than me and I wouldn't have dreamed of expecting my parents to spend the same amount on me as them when I wasn't even living with them and earning my own money

pinkspeakers · 29/11/2023 11:51

I think it is perfectly reasonable, provided you treat other kids the same once they reach the same age. I would probably have chat with her beforehand though, so she isn't surprised. I've not really cut back on presents or spending for my two yet as they are still Uni age and financially dependent on us, but I would expect things to gradually change as they get older. At some point, I would expect presents to be more or less reciprocal i.e. an adult child would buy similar gifts for their parent as the parent does for their child. Some families might have a norm where adult children buy multiple presents for their parents and vice versa, but that's not how it works in our family.

curaçao · 29/11/2023 11:45

How old are the ypunger ones

Jayne35 · 29/11/2023 11:21

I always spent the same on my two children but it's spread out differently now my youngest has two children, so his amount is shared out between him and his family.

BogRollBOGOF · 29/11/2023 11:18

My two are younger but their presents are about what they want/ need. DS2 is a cheaper child to please than DS1 and one year, his "Santa present" was a £6 ball, whereas DS1's was a £80 Lego set. It felt odd that there was such a big discrepency, but the children were treated fairly according to their desires that meant more to them than monetary value.

Being identical is not necessarily the same as fair and it can disregard individual circumstances and personality. What matters is meeting practical and emotional needs through life. An adult may "just" get a fancy toiletries set for Christmas, but then need a far more expensive leg-up for a major change like buying a car/ house/ wedding. Dependent children need you to support all their needs all the time.