Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy less for older working daughter than younger brother and sister?

107 replies

snuggleswithmygirlies · 28/11/2023 14:19

I have bought the Christmas presents for our younger children who are school aged and we have our older dd in her 20s coming for Xmas and staying a few nights.
I have bought about half the amount for her and dh says that's unfair but my argument is she has had years of opening presents to that value and amount, now she is a working adult she wont get as much as the younger ones.
I don't expect to be buying that much for the younger ones once they're the same age.
Who is being unreasonable?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bleakmidwinter1977 · 01/12/2023 17:12

Children do not all need the same, this applies to the value of gifts and the quantity of gifts.
If your children are counting presents, adding up the pennies, and displaying jealousy of other siblings, something is going wrong somewhere.
Set a budget for gift giving, try to give children something they would like, within that budget. Child A may be over the moon with an item costing £50, Child B may ask for something costing £100, Child C may be a working adult and should be happy to sacrifice a portion of "their" budget to accommodate a younger sibling.
If you feel there looks to be "less" for one, add some inexpensive, token gifts.
Christmas is not about how much your children receive, it is about spending time with family. Focus more on encouraging children to select token gifts for family and close friends.
We have raised 9 children, blended family, 2 shared, one adopted.
The children buy each other token gifts to fill each others Christmas stocking.
Ours were just happy to all be home for Christmas, sharing the excitement of gift opening and being happy their siblings were together.
Up until the age of 5, children are generally happy to open presents whatever they may be.
Between 6 and 12, children tend to request more specific gifts, generally more expensive: if these are over-budget, they can be deferred to birthdays where there is only one person to buy for.
Over 13, children should be aware of parents limitations.
16-18 ours had part-time jobs alongside college, the budget for their gifts was generally less than younger siblings.
Over 18 and at uni, we gave cash/voucher gifts and useful gifts.
Working age, budget is considerably lower than younger siblings.
No idea when an adult would be jealous of younger siblings at Christmas.

Islandgirl68 · 30/11/2023 19:07

YANBU, there has to be a cut off age at somepoint. Just say when they reach 25. So as they each reach 25 they get less. Just like I made 18 the cut off for nieces and nephews. Some would get and others wouldn't. That is life if they are adults they should understand. In the end they will all be the same if you have a cut off age.

Dillydelly · 30/11/2023 17:52

From my perspective OP. My parent stopped buying me gifts after the death of my other parent. My sibling still gets gifts, my parent often calls me to ask for gift ideas😂. Said sibling also gets treated to meals out and monetary gifts during the year. We're both adults in professional, well paying jobs.
As long as your gifts for your daughter are meaningful, I'm sure she'll appreciate them.

Manthide · 30/11/2023 16:08

Goodornot · 30/11/2023 14:09

Fair game but just realise there are consequences you won't realise.

My family did this to me as the only working adult in the family (the rest on benefits) they deliberately don't buy me presents as I work and earn decent money and I also catered for Christmas annually because they wanted Christmas Dinner amd all the food and drink for free.

I don't mind the expense but it's the expectation and the ingratitude.

Imagine their surprise when one year I announced I was going away for Christmas and they could sort themselves out. I didnt do presents that year either.

She is only 20. Not much of a working life behind her and she might still need things as presents. She may decide she is skimping on Christmas in years to come for you lot if you skimp on her.

Edited

I do buy my older dds presents and we all go to their GPs for Christmas Dinner- and we host them otherwise whilst they are here ( normally about 3 days). They just don't get the same as their much younger brother and sister. They both earn many multiples of what we earn but I'd never expect them to provide the food. We've never been into extravagant presents and we do not expect them from them. Your family do sound like they're treating you very poorly.

Goodornot · 30/11/2023 14:09

Fair game but just realise there are consequences you won't realise.

My family did this to me as the only working adult in the family (the rest on benefits) they deliberately don't buy me presents as I work and earn decent money and I also catered for Christmas annually because they wanted Christmas Dinner amd all the food and drink for free.

I don't mind the expense but it's the expectation and the ingratitude.

Imagine their surprise when one year I announced I was going away for Christmas and they could sort themselves out. I didnt do presents that year either.

She is only 20. Not much of a working life behind her and she might still need things as presents. She may decide she is skimping on Christmas in years to come for you lot if you skimp on her.

thelonghaul · 30/11/2023 14:03

#jamieKnows well, quite!!

Also, we've never meticulously spent the same of both kids (conveniently only 3 years between) but just sort of "sense checked" that there was a balance. As they're now in late teens and early 20's I'm expecting to start given a smaller (less obscene) amount of pressies. They're realistic/reasonable people. They'll get it.

Kezzy16 · 30/11/2023 12:17

I agree with your hubby it should be the same amount cost wise but each to their own :)

JamieKnows · 30/11/2023 09:59

Can't believe you've got all of your presents under the tree in November 🤪 worlds gone mad.

saraclara · 30/11/2023 08:33

Hang on. Your kids get TWENTY PRESENTS?

Manthide · 30/11/2023 08:27

Lulaloo · 28/11/2023 16:07

We have had the same conversation this year. We will still spend @£200 older two each at least, but they have bought their own homes and earn more than I do!
I don’t want to, but also feel that they have had their time and it needs to slow down at some point.

My spend is £10 -20 on older 2 dds and their dh's and about £50-60 on younger 2dc. Also £20-30 on gs.

Manthide · 30/11/2023 08:16

toomuchfaff · 29/11/2023 11:05

your argument that she has had years is moot... your younger children have years ahead of them.

Personally as an only child I never had this but I did witness it as friends who were siblings constantly getting less attention, less affection and less presents, they always felt it, felt it was unfair, felt the gap, that they got socks and a jumper and the child got a PS5.. it is massive and shows how much they are valued... compared to "the kids"

don't spend different amounts on your children.

Really! I have never even tried to equal out how much I spend/spent on my 4dc either for birthday or Christmas, hopefully none of them feel undervalued - I adore all 4 equally. Dd2 is currently overhauling the house she and her dh bought for well over a million and dd1 has just returned from a babymoon in the South Pacific ( their 4th overseas holiday this year. Me, I work part-time due to disability and we are on universal credit.

Manthide · 30/11/2023 08:04

I definitely spend more on my 2 younger dc (15 and 20) than their 2 married sisters who are in their 30s. They both combined with their dh's earn about 10 times as much as me, second they have dc who I obviously also buy for and thirdly I have never made sure I spent the same on each dc. When they were younger I tried to ensure they had the same number of presents.

BrassOlive · 30/11/2023 07:57

RatherBeRiding · 28/11/2023 14:23

I agree with your husband. Doesn't matter how old she is or whether or not she is working, it is pretty unfair - how on earth do you think she is going to feel? Unvalued?

Christ how old are you, do you seriously think the number of gifts a person gets is a reflection of how much the gift giver values them?

My sibling has a developmental disability and although we're both adults she obviously gets lots more (quite child-like) gifts than me because the day means so much more to her than me (that, and I work full time in a high paying professional role so want for nothing). It doesn't bother me because I'm a grown ass woman and not a spoilt brat.

Splat92 · 30/11/2023 07:50

I'm with you OP, in fact had this discussion with my DH a week or two ago. We have a bit of a gap with our kids - 2 have finished school and one finishing up primary. I'll be doing equalish value presents while they're at uni but when they have a full time job I expect I don't expect to buy as much as they'll probably have more disposable income than we do.

morellamalessdrama · 30/11/2023 07:32

I think a lot of people saying spend the same perhaps don't have children with a big age gap.

Our youngest is 12 and the eldest 25. The eldest is working and has moved out and she certainly let wouldn't expect the same amount of presents as her younger sibling.

When they were all children, then the same amount was spent. When they are all adults, the same amount will be spent. But during the times when one is a child and one is an adult, there will be a bit of a difference.

Anneta · 29/11/2023 22:43

I’m with you OP. This year I am spending less on the grandchildren who are in their 20s and now working than on the young ones who are still at school. However over the past three years I have sent extra money to one granddaughter at university to help her out and I have bought items for a grandson who has moved into his own home. The younger three grandchildren vary in age from 4 to 16 and I’ve bought them the gifts that I ( & their parents ) think that they would really like rather than focusing on exactly matching the costs.

LoveBluey · 29/11/2023 22:38

NewShoes · 29/11/2023 22:11

I’d spend the same amount on each child, no matter their age. The number or size of the gifts wouldn’t matter.

But if you wanted to start spending less on adult children you need to start when they become adults. You can't wait for them all to be adults as then it's not fair on the youngest.

LoveBluey · 29/11/2023 22:37

When there is a big age gap absolutely yes spend less on the fully grown adult children who earn their own money.

Otherwise you'll be spending hundreds on them until they're in their 30s! And when do you stop? If not at a set age / life stage then whenever you do it the youngest is disadvantaged if you decide right this year it's token gifts only for both kids but the older one has had years extra of having more expensive gifts.
The only fair way to do it is stop at say age 21 or once left full time education.

hattie43 · 29/11/2023 22:36

RatherBeRiding · 28/11/2023 14:23

I agree with your husband. Doesn't matter how old she is or whether or not she is working, it is pretty unfair - how on earth do you think she is going to feel? Unvalued?

This
A horrible thing to treat them differently

Bouncyball23 · 29/11/2023 22:30

RatherBeRiding · 28/11/2023 14:23

I agree with your husband. Doesn't matter how old she is or whether or not she is working, it is pretty unfair - how on earth do you think she is going to feel? Unvalued?

I would think being a grown independent woman she would understand!!

Paddleboarder · 29/11/2023 22:14

I think it’s fine, in fact I will be doing the same. My eldest is in his 20s and has double my income and I can’t afford it. Plus, I don’t think he expects it. My youngest, on the other hand, is still at school and has no chance of affording any of his presents otherwise. I honestly don’t think it’s an issue for my eldest, he is at the point where it is really just about spending time with everyone and I’ve still got him a lovely gift anyway. In the end they will both have the same amount of years when they received expensive gifts.

NewShoes · 29/11/2023 22:11

I’d spend the same amount on each child, no matter their age. The number or size of the gifts wouldn’t matter.

Kwasi · 29/11/2023 22:09

I think it’s fine to spend significantly less
on an adult child no matter where they live. In my family, the actual kids always got more than the grown-up kids. We all understood and no one was upset by it.

mrshenny · 29/11/2023 22:07

AuntMarch · 28/11/2023 14:41

I would find it strange if an adult with a job who doesn't live at home expected the same value/amount spent at Christmas as younger siblings that are still children.

I'm with you.

This

TurkeyLurkeyChickenLicken · 29/11/2023 21:59

I'm spending less money on my 19 year old DD than her siblings this year. She has a full time job which pays well.

However last year we did buy her a car which was significantly more so it does balance out (it cost about £2k). DD knows we are spending less and doesn't care, she buys herself whatever she wants now anyway.