Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL dying, husband angry at me for not being closer to her

644 replies

alicedbr · 28/11/2023 13:02

MIL has a terminal illness and it's looking like she won't be with us for much longer. Understandably DH is beside himself, he is very close to his mum and an only child.

I've never got on with my MIL as I feel like she's always given unsolicited advice, tried to get over involved in my parenting and in our relationship with DH (examples: got very offended that I didn't want to have a C section as she advised, said things like "mummy isn't being very nice" to my DS when I was attempting to put him down for a nap that he was resisting, given cake to DD "because it's what grannies do" when I specifically asked her not to). Because of that I limited the time I spent around her, although I never stopped DH spending time with her and encouraged him to visit solo, but DCs are very clingy to me so never went without me to see MIL.

Now that she's ill my husband keeps getting VERY angry at me that I didn't just tolerate her treatment of me, always saying "she didn't mean it like that", "she just wanted to be a hands on granny", annoyed at me that DC are much closer to my parents than MIL because we saw them more often, blames me for 'time wasted' that she could have spent more time with our DC. In my view I have never been rude to her or restricted her contact with DH or DC, just protected myself from stress and comments that I didn't like.

Unsure how to deal with this. Is he BU? Is this a natural reaction? How should I be responding? I don't feel like my mental health was or is worth sacrificing just because one day she would die earlier than me, but equally I see why he's upset.

OP posts:
PlacidPenelope · 29/11/2023 19:36

If MIL said to me “some women are not natural mothers” or “your babies are crying because they don’t feel loved” I’d take that not as shit but batshit. She’s an idiot and what she says is meaningless. I find it hard to imagine taking that seriously.

If my MIL had said that to me (she never would because she is absolutely wonderful) I would have told her where to go as would my husband - that is the difference here the husband didn't support his wife and tell his mother her fortune.

Mirabai · 29/11/2023 19:35

Panaa · 29/11/2023 19:27

Why can't you conceive that someone else with a strong personality could choose distance? They might simply not be arsed in any way trying to attempt to take control and they just distance themselves and let the other grown adult work out themselves how to behave.

Edited

Where have I said I couldn’t? I simply pointed out there’s more than one way of being strong to the posters who believed the only way was to distance.

CremeEggSupremacy · 29/11/2023 19:32

Panaa · 29/11/2023 19:27

Why can't you conceive that someone else with a strong personality could choose distance? They might simply not be arsed in any way trying to attempt to take control and they just distance themselves and let the other grown adult work out themselves how to behave.

Edited

Exactly this. I refuse to engage or argue with people who I know are not going to communicate with me - saves me the agg. Some people the only option is to distance yourself and IMO that’s ’stronger’ than putting up with a load of nasty comments. Unfortunately the MIL and DH both made their bed with this situation.

Mirabai · 29/11/2023 19:31

Panaa · 29/11/2023 19:24

And many times boundaries do involve distance, and that's perfectly fine.

And even if you don't care you still don't have to have it around you.

No it doesn't indicate that I can't imagine what immunity feels like at all, that's just a weird assumption that you've made. I can know what 'shit' is without it actually negatively affecting me at the moment. I am well able to categorise what is normal nice behaviour and what is shit and negative behaviour even if it's not affecting me.

If someone is saying to a mother "some women are not natural mothers" and "your babies are crying because they don't feel loved" then that is shit, negative behaviour, whether the mother is thick skinned or 'immune' or not.

I'm not sure if the OP did ever try the few sharp words method, but even if she did the outcome now could still be the same with the DH blaming her for the lack of relationship.....and some people choose not to go down that route while protecting their boundaries and just distance themselves instead. Again, that's fine.

Edited

If MIL said to me “some women are not natural mothers” or “your babies are crying because they don’t feel loved” I’d take that not as shit but batshit. She’s an idiot and what she says is meaningless. I find it hard to imagine taking that seriously.

It’s true DH would blame OP regardless but that’s a different matter.

CremeEggSupremacy · 29/11/2023 19:30

Mirabai · 29/11/2023 19:23

Your idea of strength seems only to be distance. Can you conceive that someone with a strong personality could have MIL under control quite quickly? That someone could simply not give a toss what she comes out with next, take control of the situation, and ensure she doesn’t bore them further with her batty outbursts?

This of course what OP’s DH could and should have done. He could have managed his mother and he chose not to. So OP felt obliged to distance herself.

I haven’t suggested anything of the sort. Of course distance is not the only indication of strength, but it is one indication of it.

CharlieBoo · 29/11/2023 19:30

Only op and her husband know what’s gone on, and how ‘abusive’ MIL was towards op.

The thing is, what matters now is how her DH sees it, and the finger of blame is pointing at you op. You can’t change the past, but how you deal with the coming weeks/months will determine if your marriage will/can survive.

Good luck

Panaa · 29/11/2023 19:27

Mirabai · 29/11/2023 19:23

Your idea of strength seems only to be distance. Can you conceive that someone with a strong personality could have MIL under control quite quickly? That someone could simply not give a toss what she comes out with next, take control of the situation, and ensure she doesn’t bore them further with her batty outbursts?

This of course what OP’s DH could and should have done. He could have managed his mother and he chose not to. So OP felt obliged to distance herself.

Why can't you conceive that someone else with a strong personality could choose distance? They might simply not be arsed in any way trying to attempt to take control and they just distance themselves and let the other grown adult work out themselves how to behave.

PrinceHaz · 29/11/2023 19:26

Sounds like the apple doesn’t fall far from the tree. He also sounds horrible. Do you want to stay with him.

CremeEggSupremacy · 29/11/2023 19:26

AnneValentine · 29/11/2023 19:03

I don’t agree the behaviour described here constitutes abuse and suggesting it does waters down actual abuse.

No it doesn’t, it just shows you up as being someone who is ignorant to the spectrum of abusive behaviour

Panaa · 29/11/2023 19:24

Mirabai · 29/11/2023 19:15

You can have strong boundaries within yourself, they don’t have to involve distance. If you don’t care what someone says because they’re an idiot it doesn’t affect you whether they’re near or far. That’s not pandering it’s just immunity.

Talking about “shit” and “negative effect” indicates you can’t imagine what immunity would feel like.

A few sharp words generally shuts people like MIL up. She’s not a bright woman and she’s very silly.

And many times boundaries do involve distance, and that's perfectly fine.

And even if you don't care you still don't have to have it around you.

No it doesn't indicate that I can't imagine what immunity feels like at all, that's just a weird assumption that you've made. I can know what 'shit' is without it actually negatively affecting me at the moment. I am well able to categorise what is normal nice behaviour and what is shit and negative behaviour even if it's not affecting me.

If someone is saying to a mother "some women are not natural mothers" and "your babies are crying because they don't feel loved" then that is shit, negative behaviour, whether the mother is thick skinned or 'immune' or not.

I'm not sure if the OP did ever try the few sharp words method, but even if she did the outcome now could still be the same with the DH blaming her for the lack of relationship.....and some people choose not to go down that route while protecting their boundaries and just distance themselves instead. Again, that's fine.

IWIllDoItNowInAMinute · 29/11/2023 19:24

Mirabai · 29/11/2023 19:15

You can have strong boundaries within yourself, they don’t have to involve distance. If you don’t care what someone says because they’re an idiot it doesn’t affect you whether they’re near or far. That’s not pandering it’s just immunity.

Talking about “shit” and “negative effect” indicates you can’t imagine what immunity would feel like.

A few sharp words generally shuts people like MIL up. She’s not a bright woman and she’s very silly.

The MIL would have been an awful role model for the DC anyway and I think that’s more important in this scenario really. Imagine if they had grown up thinking it was ok to insult people because Granny does? Doesn’t really matter if the OP had strong internal boundaries and was immune to the comments, the DC would have been exposed to it and could have ended up learning from it. OPs DH should have stopped his mum saying such horrible things to his wife if he wanted to play happy families.

Mirabai · 29/11/2023 19:23

CremeEggSupremacy · 29/11/2023 18:33

Tbh what’s to say OP hasnt been ‘robust’? Shes chosen to distance herself from a horrible woman and taken a stand in doing so. Those who think they’re robust for putting up with such behaviour could be considered the weak ones for not standing up for themselves 🤷🏻‍♀️

Your idea of strength seems only to be distance. Can you conceive that someone with a strong personality could have MIL under control quite quickly? That someone could simply not give a toss what she comes out with next, take control of the situation, and ensure she doesn’t bore them further with her batty outbursts?

This of course what OP’s DH could and should have done. He could have managed his mother and he chose not to. So OP felt obliged to distance herself.

Mirabai · 29/11/2023 19:15

Panaa · 29/11/2023 18:32

And some people are robust enough that even though they could deal with it without taking it personally, they would choose not to, because they have strong boundaries.

No way on this earth would I be letting a MIL tell me my kids were waking in the night because they didn't feel loved because I couldn't give them enough attention because I had them so close together, or that some women just aren't natural mothers.

I wouldn't take that shit from my own family, I wouldn't take it from a friend, I wouldn't take it from a partner, I wouldn't take it from in-laws.

Nothing necessarily very 'robust' about pandering at all anyway. Often pandering and putting up with shit is fine for a while, but catches up on people in the end or else they might have a time where they are feeling less strong and then the behaviour does have a negative effect on them. I would never encourage or expect people to put up with poor treatment just because they can handle it for that reason.

Edited

You can have strong boundaries within yourself, they don’t have to involve distance. If you don’t care what someone says because they’re an idiot it doesn’t affect you whether they’re near or far. That’s not pandering it’s just immunity.

Talking about “shit” and “negative effect” indicates you can’t imagine what immunity would feel like.

A few sharp words generally shuts people like MIL up. She’s not a bright woman and she’s very silly.

Panaa · 29/11/2023 19:13

AnneValentine · 29/11/2023 19:03

I don’t agree the behaviour described here constitutes abuse and suggesting it does waters down actual abuse.

If the husband was the one making those comments to his wife then would you think it was abuse?

Telling her some women just aren't natural mothers?
Telling her that the babies are waking up in the night because she doesn't give them enough attention because they're so close in age so they don't feel loved.
Shouting at her that she didn't get a C-section

PlacidPenelope · 29/11/2023 19:11

As posters here seem to be fixated on the cake example - I have had grandparents, my children have grandparents, I am a grandparent, guess what in all cases grandparents have taken their lead from the parents.

Under no circumstances would my grandparents have fed me cake immediately before bedtime when my mother or father had specifically asked them not to, under no circumstances would my children's grandparents have fed my children cake immediately before bedtime if I or my husband specifically asked them not to under no circumstances would I or my husband feed our grandchildren cake immediately before bedtime when their mother or father had specifically asked us not to. It's called respect, it is the most basic of considerations and undermining the wishes of parents is not just what grandparents do the ones who want to destroy any relationship they have with the mother or father of their grandchildren maybe because it shows they have no respect for them and can't be trusted.

Mind you no set of grandparents in the above would even have thought about feeding a child cake immediately before bedtime.

Coming from a different culture is no excuse for not respecting the mother of your grandchildren, none at all.

CandyLeBonBon · 29/11/2023 19:04

I'll ask again @AnneValentine what do consider to be 'actual' abuse?

AnneValentine · 29/11/2023 19:03

User1789 · 29/11/2023 17:47

I think making light of some very accurate and referenced posts about what counts as abuse, suggests you are either shit stirring, or somebody who's opinions on a complex family situation, involving people who are dying and or/about to be bereaved, shouldn't really be listened to.

I don’t agree the behaviour described here constitutes abuse and suggesting it does waters down actual abuse.

Safxxx · 29/11/2023 18:49

Go with your husband and children and visit your MIL
Life's too short and hers is neary ending...make peace...your husband will be very grateful with your kind gesture....end of the day it's about your peace....atleast he can't say later on you didn't visit her while she was alive...do your bit for him...I'm sure it will help with this current situation of digging at you.

Mariluisa · 29/11/2023 18:43

More in the sense Leanne Morgan means when she says if people knew what having GC would be like, they’d have them first

Mariluisa · 29/11/2023 18:40

CandyLeBonBon · 29/11/2023 18:06

Grandparents go loopy, everyone knows that.

No they fucking don't! How utterly bizarre to think that older people are completely incapable of managing themselves!

My mother became a GM at 39

My comment was nothing to do with older people.

Maybe loopy isn’t the right word, I’ve mostly seen GPs go loopy (for want of a better word) in a really positive way that augers well for their children and grandchildren

User1789 · 29/11/2023 18:40

I think there is also a point to be made here about just how well a more 'robust' personality might have gone down with a MIL like this.

It is a very big assumption indeed to assume that somebody who simply laughed off horrible comments would have been welcomed more than the OP was.

Do you really think the DH would have considered OP to have been making an effort to establish a relationship with his mother if that is what she had done?

Panaa · 29/11/2023 18:37

CremeEggSupremacy · 29/11/2023 18:33

Tbh what’s to say OP hasnt been ‘robust’? Shes chosen to distance herself from a horrible woman and taken a stand in doing so. Those who think they’re robust for putting up with such behaviour could be considered the weak ones for not standing up for themselves 🤷🏻‍♀️

Absolutely.
Having boundaries about what you choose to accept in your life IS robust!
It's sensible, it's mature and it's being a good role model.

CremeEggSupremacy · 29/11/2023 18:33

Tbh what’s to say OP hasnt been ‘robust’? Shes chosen to distance herself from a horrible woman and taken a stand in doing so. Those who think they’re robust for putting up with such behaviour could be considered the weak ones for not standing up for themselves 🤷🏻‍♀️

Panaa · 29/11/2023 18:32

Mirabai · 29/11/2023 18:24

My pp on this thread was to say that DH could have tackled MIL and asked him to treat his wife with more respect, and he could have taken his kids to see her, and now he is punishing OP for his failures.

But the divide on this thread is not actually that some posters are defending abuse but that some posters are genuinely robust enough to deal with MIL’s batshittery without taking it personally, and some are more sensitive like OP and need to distance themselves.

And some people are robust enough that even though they could deal with it without taking it personally, they would choose not to, because they have strong boundaries.

No way on this earth would I be letting a MIL tell me my kids were waking in the night because they didn't feel loved because I couldn't give them enough attention because I had them so close together, or that some women just aren't natural mothers.

I wouldn't take that shit from my own family, I wouldn't take it from a friend, I wouldn't take it from a partner, I wouldn't take it from in-laws.

Nothing necessarily very 'robust' about pandering at all anyway. Often pandering and putting up with shit is fine for a while, but catches up on people in the end or else they might have a time where they are feeling less strong and then the behaviour does have a negative effect on them. I would never encourage or expect people to put up with poor treatment just because they can handle it for that reason.

CremeEggSupremacy · 29/11/2023 18:30

Mirabai · 29/11/2023 18:24

My pp on this thread was to say that DH could have tackled MIL and asked him to treat his wife with more respect, and he could have taken his kids to see her, and now he is punishing OP for his failures.

But the divide on this thread is not actually that some posters are defending abuse but that some posters are genuinely robust enough to deal with MIL’s batshittery without taking it personally, and some are more sensitive like OP and need to distance themselves.

Horrible take. Some people being ‘robust’ enough to put up with abusive behaviour doesn’t make OP ‘more sensitive’. Aside from the cake example, OP’s MIL has been coercive and controlling which is objectively abusive behaviour, whether you wish to put up with it or not does not change the fact