Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL dying, husband angry at me for not being closer to her

644 replies

alicedbr · 28/11/2023 13:02

MIL has a terminal illness and it's looking like she won't be with us for much longer. Understandably DH is beside himself, he is very close to his mum and an only child.

I've never got on with my MIL as I feel like she's always given unsolicited advice, tried to get over involved in my parenting and in our relationship with DH (examples: got very offended that I didn't want to have a C section as she advised, said things like "mummy isn't being very nice" to my DS when I was attempting to put him down for a nap that he was resisting, given cake to DD "because it's what grannies do" when I specifically asked her not to). Because of that I limited the time I spent around her, although I never stopped DH spending time with her and encouraged him to visit solo, but DCs are very clingy to me so never went without me to see MIL.

Now that she's ill my husband keeps getting VERY angry at me that I didn't just tolerate her treatment of me, always saying "she didn't mean it like that", "she just wanted to be a hands on granny", annoyed at me that DC are much closer to my parents than MIL because we saw them more often, blames me for 'time wasted' that she could have spent more time with our DC. In my view I have never been rude to her or restricted her contact with DH or DC, just protected myself from stress and comments that I didn't like.

Unsure how to deal with this. Is he BU? Is this a natural reaction? How should I be responding? I don't feel like my mental health was or is worth sacrificing just because one day she would die earlier than me, but equally I see why he's upset.

OP posts:
PlacidPenelope · 28/11/2023 15:54

Mummy is mean" is a standard response by health visitors, nurses etc to anything which mummy has to do which baby doesn't like. It's just something to say, there's no meaning behind it.

It damn well shouldn't be a standard response. Yes it does have meaning behind it it is painting the mother of that child to the child as being nasty. How about supporting the mother when she has to do things the child/baby doesn't like instead of blaming her and undermining her?

OP should not have had to put up with comments and undermining from her MIL, her husband should have stepped in and told his mother to button it and butt out, if advice or opinion was wanted it would be asked for.

I am sorry you are receiving this unfair backlash from your husband @alicedbr, I think JaziaD's response is fair.

Mariluisa · 28/11/2023 15:52

I think there’s not enough context about her earlier behaviour. If she just did all that out of the blue then yanbu. If your parents were heavily involved and integrated then I think that, along with the culture difference, could have put her on a very erratic and frantic path concerning the ONLY GC she would have

ButterCrackers · 28/11/2023 15:52

He should direct his anger to his mum but he can’t do that so you’re getting this. Tell your dh to stop this aggressive attitude. If he doesn’t stop putting the anger on you tell him to move out and stay with his mother. He could be caring for her 24/7.

Mariposista · 28/11/2023 15:50

Highlyflavouredgravy · 28/11/2023 13:17

It does sound like you have been unpleasant. You say you haven't restricted her access to the children but also say you haven't spent time with her and your children are clingy to you. So you have restricted access.

Instead if just ignoring silliness, you made it an excuse to keep your children away and now your dh is upset which is understandable.

He should have addressed it before now though. Keeping a partner away from their family or making is difficult for them to maintain good relationships is v controlling.

This. And this absolutely doesn't go down well with Spanish families. The grandparent-grandchild bond is sacred ('da igual' if the DIL is awkward).

You should have let DH take the kids to see her without you if she bothered you that much.

Highlyflavouredgravy · 28/11/2023 15:48

The thing you have to remember is that your mother in law made the man you love and choose to spend your life with. And she feels about her son the way you feel about your children.

And he loves her because she is his mum.

That knowledge should inform decision making about behaviour.

Duckingella · 28/11/2023 15:47

Thé short of it is that your DH is a mummies boy who's too afraid to stand up to his mum and puts her on a pedestal;that pedestal has gotten so much higher since she's now dying and your DH is projecting onto you his own regrets.

You married him not his family;nobody is obligated to like or spend time with their partners family if they aren't comfortable in their presence.

ilovesushi · 28/11/2023 15:45

It does sound sad that the children's grandmother hasn't been allowed into her grandchildren's life. It is most likely a regret your DH has felt all along but it has come into sharp focus now that there is no time to make up for it. Of course MILs say annoying things. They are another generation/ culture. They have been through it all before in another time and context. We are finding our own way and don't welcome criticism. But at the same time I think there should be give and take. You MIL hasn't gone along with your prescriptive way of doing things but neither has she tried to cause harm or neglect. My MIL was incredibly annoying but I knew she was good hearted and my children adored her. We all miss her terribly now she is gone and we all have lovely memories of times together. This is most likely what you DH is struggling with.

Allfur · 28/11/2023 15:45

Honestly I've had worse from my mil, but I just 'forgive' and move on, she's part of the family, life is too short

Redebs · 28/11/2023 15:44

Well worth looking up 'anticipatory grief', btw.
It can be devastating

TorroFerney · 28/11/2023 15:43

Forgotmycoat · 28/11/2023 13:34

I would not entertain this nonsense, I would tell him to sod off. I know this ks harsh, but sometimes the only way to make people snap out of shitty behaviour is to let them know in no uncertain terms that you will not accept their twatty behaviour. You can't keep indulging his outburst whether dirven by grief or not. it's always men, i don't know of any women who turn nasty when grief hits.

He has to deal with his grief but he cannot keep being horrible to the mother of his children. Get him told.

Yep. I’d be telling him that I am sympathetic and it’s his grief talking but that does not give him carte Blanche to rewrite history. I assume he wants a relationship with you once shes dead , that’s the relationship he needs to be prioritising.

LimitedBrightSpots · 28/11/2023 15:42

My father has cancer. He may not be with us very much longer (prognosis currently unclear) and is likely to spend a large chunk of his remaining time in hospital receiving treatment. He is immunocompromised and faces a number of months stuck alone in a small isolation room, heavily monitored, with visitors unable to hug him or get close to him.

If it helps, let me give you my two pennies-worth.

A lot of men are emotionally lazy. Many are brought up like that from childhood. They get away with avoiding emotional labour in a way that women usually just don't. They are also often unfairly the beneficiaries of emotional labour on the part of women (their wives, partners, mothers, sisters etc.). So many men are used to receiving all this emotional care from others in their lives but they are not necessarily accustomed to giving it.

When emotional labour is required of men, often they outsource it to other people (their wives/partners/other family members) or they just don't do it at all. Because they're "busy with work", "busy training for this", "busy doing that". They comfort themselves with the thought that there is always more time, that they'll get around to it eventually.

It's quite stark when actually time is running out and you can't ignore it. There are regrets, yes. Looking back, I wish I had seen my dad more often. I wish we had spoken more and done more things together when he was in better health. I wish we had squeezed in just one more family holiday abroad (unlikely to happen now) and I regret all the trips and outings we talked about but never got around to doing. I wish I had got around to booking the steam train day out that he sent me the details of but I was exhausted with a non-sleeping baby and just didn't follow it up.

But these are peripheral regrets. We made a lot of other stuff happen. He was always welcome and I made time for them. I took the children to visit whenever I could. We may not have done as many of the 'big ticket' items as I would have liked together but we visited garden centres, built the sandpit together, shared takeaways, watched DIY shows together and just made each other coffee. During Covid when we weren't allowed to meet indoors, we'd each drive hours and meet and sit on a sodden bench in a rain-drenched park somewhere in the middle. My dad and I would nurse takeaway coffees while my mum played with DC. A lot of these things were done independently of my DH - he is a workaholic and finds my parents a bit much.

When your DH blames you, what he is really blaming you for is failing to take on his emotional work and nurture his and his children's relationship with his mother. When you stepped back, he may not have realised it but he had a choice - either step up or leave the gap unfilled. He chose to leave the gap unfilled and now he probably regrets it. I imagine also, mixed in with the guilt, is a fair amount of bewilderment. Like I said, many men tend to be the recipients of emotional labour. Now he is in a position where he has to provide emotional support to his mother, instead of receiving it from her, and I imagine that is hard as he is not used to this and he is feeling the burden at a time when he is also scared and grieving.

Sorry for the length of this. Just some random thoughts.

Keepinmovin · 28/11/2023 15:39

alicedbr · 28/11/2023 14:25

Yes I would mainly like to know how to respond!
I don't want to lie and say "ah yes all my fault, was so wrong of me to stand up for myself. I should have just listened to the comments, smiled and let the kids hear all the mean things about their mum"
As he's grieving I can't exactly say "listen we both know she's been a btch, I had every right to keep myself away from her for the sake of my mental health"
So what CAN I say?! To de-escalate the argument but also not start saying I'm wrong just for the sake of it (because that also wouldn't de escalate the argument but would just validate him having a go at me when he shouldn't do)

Several PP including me have given suggestions on how to de escalate. Google de escalation of conflicts if you don't like our suggestions but basically it's

  • be calm
  • acknowledge his feelings
  • don't try to argue or solve prob
  • stay present

Try active listening techniques such as paraphrasing "I can see it's really upsetting you that you can never eat that spanish dish your mum loved to cook"

herewegoagain7 · 28/11/2023 15:38

I think it sounds like you have been rather intolerant towards her and he is feeling guilty

There is no kindness in your post, it's all about you, that's the thing death is so final and I am sure your husband will ruminate a long time on your unpleasantness

The woman is dying and it's still all about you isn't it ?

Redebs · 28/11/2023 15:34

How unwell is she now?
Time for the children to spend time with her before she passes?

waterproofed · 28/11/2023 15:34

To me, what’s quite fascinating is that your DH clearly chose a wife very similar to his mother - both strong headed opinionated women, both convinced they are right and unwilling to take anything lying down. Both strangers to compromise and blind to their similarities. It’s quite touching, really.

These can be admirable and compelling qualities (I personally LOVE a strong woman), but they also have consequences. You now have a decision to make on how you want to approach your grieving husband - do you want to comfort him or be right?

Lavenderflower · 28/11/2023 15:34

My mother and grandmother never liked each other; however, we would frequently stay for the weekend and holidays. I don't understand the children never visited her more frequently even if you were not present.

LongLostTeacher · 28/11/2023 15:32

Lou197 · 28/11/2023 15:15

I am sorry you and your husband are going through this, however my MIL was also a bit tricky when I first had kids and said similar things to yours. However I just kept going and we all made regular visits as a family to see my in laws. 15 years down the line we have a good relationship and she knows that I am a good mum (as is she). I just think that the MIL / daughter in law relationship can always be difficult so it just needs a bit of understanding on both sides. Please support your husband as he goes through this.

I hadn’t really considered this in my first response, but I think this is very true and resonates with my experience of having a newborn around my MIL. I had two DC close together and I found her stressful. She spoke to me like she was the expert, even though it was 35 years since she was around a newborn. She found it difficult to accept that best practice had changed and we would be doing some things differently to her. She took this as a judgement on her parenting, instead of her son and DIL trying to do the best for her grandchild. She made a drama out of having two close together. Things got better once the DC were older and we all enjoyed a nice relationship, but she did it again when I had my third 4 years after my second. This time she couldn’t say I didn’t know what I was doing, but she clearly thought we shouldn’t have had another, never congratulated us, suggested other names for the baby once we announced the name at birth, commented on baby’s appearance(!) and made comments about the older two being emotional, left out etc.

Again, once we were past the newborn stage, it was better. I know she’s got it in the locker to be a madam, but generally we get on well. I think it would have been incredibly difficult if she had received a terminal diagnosis at those newborn times as our relationship was strained and DH would have found it heartbreaking as he loves his mother.

I suppose reflecting on that, I think you should just aim to be there for your husband now. There’s no point raking over what’s gone before, just try to support him in making memories and being there with his mother now.

SecretSoul · 28/11/2023 15:31

Lou197 · 28/11/2023 15:15

I am sorry you and your husband are going through this, however my MIL was also a bit tricky when I first had kids and said similar things to yours. However I just kept going and we all made regular visits as a family to see my in laws. 15 years down the line we have a good relationship and she knows that I am a good mum (as is she). I just think that the MIL / daughter in law relationship can always be difficult so it just needs a bit of understanding on both sides. Please support your husband as he goes through this.

I think this and what @theresnolimits said is right - sometimes there just needs to be a bit of flexibility.

I have a DM who can be very clumsy with what she says and often blurts things out without properly thinking them through.

I don’t think any of the examples given sound terrible. But I think once you’ve taken real offence at something, continuing to take offence is much easier than trying to see the alternate view.

If you’re honest with yourself OP, you are well aware that you deprived your MIL of a close and loving relationship with your DC while simultaneously fostering a close and loving relationship with your own parents. No wonder your DH feels resentful. Surely you could have just busied yourself in the house when she visited rather than flouncing out with the DC in tow?!

Certainly her remarks sound a bit blunt at times but she doesn’t sound so awful that it warrants virtually cutting her off. There is a middle ground between being a complete doormat and refusing to see her, knowing that this would mean your DC wouldn’t see her either.

It doesn’t sound as if you were willing to try and develop a good understanding and now that your DH is wrapped up in grief, long-held resentment is understandably coming out.

laclochette · 28/11/2023 15:29

@Comedycook I agree, but this puts me in mind of the classic question about dealing with conflict: "Would you rather be happy, or right?"

SwedeCarrotLimes · 28/11/2023 15:27

Sounds like husband is taking his grief out on you. But also sounds like you have restricted her access to GC. You have enabled your DC 'clingy' behaviour and should have taken steps before now to ensure DC saw their grandmother without you present. DC being clingy to any one person is unhealthy imo.

OutsideLookingOut · 28/11/2023 15:26

I’m glad to see an OP who isn’t a doormat!

laclochette · 28/11/2023 15:26

I'm sure ultimately the truth lies somewhere in the middle, it almost always does. (Not necessarily slap bang in the middle.)

As others have said, he is grieving, scared and regretting things which are no longer possible to make up or do differently. This is making him act in an unreasonable way. It would have been far better for him to raise these issues earlier, and you to reach a happier compromise, but sadly for us all it is very human to think we have infinite time to work things out. Then illness and death come along and confront us with the horrible reality: namely, that that isn't true.

What he's expressing, to me, is a desire we all have but unfortunately an impossible one. He wishes he could turn back the clock and that things could have been different. In his grief I think you have to be as patient as you can with that. What is really important not to do is to see his statements as expressions of support for his mother in some battle of her vs you. It sounds like that, I know, but you can choose not to engage with it like that. Rather, hear the things he says as expressions of grief, fear and regret.

You could try asking something like, Given we are where we are, and we can't turn back the clock, what could we do now that would make you feel better? Would it be to go and visit her with the kids, cook her recipes etc. You don't know whet his response will be till you ask. If you do get a reaction that is pure negativity, you can understand that as his grief at the fact that none of these things achieve what he wants, which is to turn back time and for things to be different, and any anger and frustration is anger at that not being possible.

Ilovelifeverymuch · 28/11/2023 15:25

Highlyflavouredgravy · 28/11/2023 13:17

It does sound like you have been unpleasant. You say you haven't restricted her access to the children but also say you haven't spent time with her and your children are clingy to you. So you have restricted access.

Instead if just ignoring silliness, you made it an excuse to keep your children away and now your dh is upset which is understandable.

He should have addressed it before now though. Keeping a partner away from their family or making is difficult for them to maintain good relationships is v controlling.

How is that being unpleasant? OP is right to take herself away from someone who continues to be mean and undermine her. If she wanted to have a good relationship with her grandchildren all she had to do was be nice not act nasty. Sorry OP was not unpleasant.

If DH wanted a better relationship he could have spoken to his mother not ask OP to pretend his mother is not nasty and mean.

Mommywomb · 28/11/2023 15:24

Comedycook · 28/11/2023 13:37

Sorry but I actually agree with your husband. She sounds mildly annoying but pretty standard behaviour for some grandmothers. I can see why your dh is upset that the kids didn't spend as much time with her as they could have because you were being a bit precious.

I'm sorry! If the children had spent some time with his mother-in-law, why is it the OP's fault? Why didn't the husband keep the kids when she visited? or took them to visit them. I think it's his fault!
I agree that the OP might sometimes be overly sensitive, and some things are typical of a mother-in-law or grandparents. How many times could the mother-in-law have given the OP's daughter cake near bedtime anyway? or how many times would she have said you'll know when they'll grow etc.
(It's typical for every MIL/mom to say), But it's up to the OP if she doesn't want to deal with negative comments for her mental well-being. I also think that she restricted her children's access to their grandmother by taking them away when MIL visited, saying they were too attached or clingy, instead of leaving them with their dad. Even if the kids complained once, she could have tried doing it two or three times so they'd get used to it.
BUT
It was the husband's responsibility to ensure the children could see their grandmother. Even if he had to ask the OP to leave the kids when she went away during her mom's visit, or take them to his mom's house, etc.
He can't just show a lack of effort now and act like it's the wife's fault for not enduring the mean things the mother-in-law says while he sits there silently.

NoraBattysCurlers · 28/11/2023 15:22

LongLostTeacher · 28/11/2023 15:14

Yeah I guess that’s kind of my point. He should have had enough about him to arrange having the kids around MIL without the OP there, either at home or at MIL’s house. Either the OP went along with his laziness, which is not great but ultimately his fault, or she actively discouraged the children from being away from her, which is manipulating the situation and H is probably somewhat justified in his anger towards her.

The H has messed up - he shouldn’t have been lazy about having his own kids on his own, he should have worked at that situation either by practising with the kids or pulling up his wife on the manipulation of the situation. The OP either allowed the consequences of his laziness to play out, or she acted to ensure the children wouldn’t be without her. Only she will know which it was.

This is a very good assessment of the situation.

Sadly, it will be very difficult to move on from this. It will damage the marriage irretrievably.