Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL dying, husband angry at me for not being closer to her

644 replies

alicedbr · 28/11/2023 13:02

MIL has a terminal illness and it's looking like she won't be with us for much longer. Understandably DH is beside himself, he is very close to his mum and an only child.

I've never got on with my MIL as I feel like she's always given unsolicited advice, tried to get over involved in my parenting and in our relationship with DH (examples: got very offended that I didn't want to have a C section as she advised, said things like "mummy isn't being very nice" to my DS when I was attempting to put him down for a nap that he was resisting, given cake to DD "because it's what grannies do" when I specifically asked her not to). Because of that I limited the time I spent around her, although I never stopped DH spending time with her and encouraged him to visit solo, but DCs are very clingy to me so never went without me to see MIL.

Now that she's ill my husband keeps getting VERY angry at me that I didn't just tolerate her treatment of me, always saying "she didn't mean it like that", "she just wanted to be a hands on granny", annoyed at me that DC are much closer to my parents than MIL because we saw them more often, blames me for 'time wasted' that she could have spent more time with our DC. In my view I have never been rude to her or restricted her contact with DH or DC, just protected myself from stress and comments that I didn't like.

Unsure how to deal with this. Is he BU? Is this a natural reaction? How should I be responding? I don't feel like my mental health was or is worth sacrificing just because one day she would die earlier than me, but equally I see why he's upset.

OP posts:
Iwasafool · 28/11/2023 17:24

CremeEggSupremacy · 28/11/2023 15:07

Username checks out if you think that made you stronger, jesus. Also don't think your examples are anything worse than OP's tbh

Edited

Maybe being accused of having an affair is nothing to you, for some of us it is a terrible thing to be accused of. Asking why she's breast feeding compared to smashing dishes and screaming because you have a new GC on the way? Your judgement seems way off.

Of course I didn't have to go away and think up "extra" thing to make it look worse.

SwedeCarrotLimes · 28/11/2023 17:23

WonderLife · 28/11/2023 17:15

If your children didn't want to be left with you, wouldn't you feel some responsibility for working on your relationship?
Yeah, it's harder work to put the effort in rather than just send them out with the other parent, but surely you'd persist with it.

Absolutely. That’s why I said earlier it’s a joint effort and both parent’s responsibilities. Husband should be taking ownership but needs OP to help and encouragement

LimitedBrightSpots · 28/11/2023 17:21

SwedeCarrotLimes · 28/11/2023 17:11

It IS her responsibility to ensure DC aren’t clinging to her and are encouraged to be social and independent. And most likely the only reason OP enjoys her current relationship with DC is she was the primary carer of DC whilst husband was the breadwinner. So it’s a bit harsh to call husband lazy in developing his relationship with DC.

I disagree. You can't change your children's personalities or make them more confident. And you don't increase their confidence by pushing them away from you.

The way you raise socially confident kids is to provide a secure base for your DC, to be a "safe adult" who does not act unpredictably or push them away.

Children know who their "safe adults" are. And it doesn't necessarily correlate with how often they see them either. We live 3-5 hours away from all four of my DC's grandparents and they are all "safe adults" in my DC's eyes because they are very child-centric. Even though we only see them every few months.

The onus is/was on the DH and MIL to put the work in to develop that relationship with the children. Being at work is no excuse.

Cherrysoup · 28/11/2023 17:19

RoseAdagio · 28/11/2023 15:05

In all honesty she sounds like an absolute nightmare of a human being and you were right to avoid her.

The fact she is dying doesn't change the fact she was bloody awful to you.

Here, here! Honest to god, yes, she’s dying (everyone does eventually!) but I don’t see why the OP should therefore change her mind about what a bitch her mil has been to her over the years. Her Dh has not stood up over the years and I bet he’s got very mixed up feelings of guilt and knowing he didn’t defend his wife over the years from the frankly obnoxious comments from his mum.

It’s obviously a difficult time for him, but taking out his anger/mixed feelings is no good for his relationship with his wife. I doubt very much she is telling him how horrible his mum has been at this moment in time. If I were her, I’d keep my counsel, head down and tackle the issues (if she wants) after the fact. Now is hardly the time to speak to him about the comments over the years, but he can’t just take out his feelings on her, so maybe a very measured discussion would be in order.

Butchyrestingface · 28/11/2023 17:17

Never mind the dying mother-in-law's erstwhile behaviour. OP is basically being abused by her husband right now and (some) people seem to think she should lap it up.

OhwhyOY · 28/11/2023 17:16

I'd also give him some time to deal with his emotions around this and accept the verbal pummelling, albeit not agreeing with it ir apologising. Then in time you can have a proper conversation about it. He's grieving the relationship he wanted with his mum and the person he wanted her to be as he knows now that will never be possible.

Amberjane41 · 28/11/2023 17:15

To be honest from reading your posts it sounds like both of you don’t like each other at all.

WonderLife · 28/11/2023 17:15

SwedeCarrotLimes · 28/11/2023 17:11

It IS her responsibility to ensure DC aren’t clinging to her and are encouraged to be social and independent. And most likely the only reason OP enjoys her current relationship with DC is she was the primary carer of DC whilst husband was the breadwinner. So it’s a bit harsh to call husband lazy in developing his relationship with DC.

If your children didn't want to be left with you, wouldn't you feel some responsibility for working on your relationship?
Yeah, it's harder work to put the effort in rather than just send them out with the other parent, but surely you'd persist with it.

OhwhyOY · 28/11/2023 17:14

I think I'd go down the route others have suggested of either saying nothing, or saying 'I love you and I'm so sorry that you have regrets about how things have gone with your mum and our family. We still have time to make memories so let's do that. What would you like to do?' Then make every effort you can to see her with the kids and make memories, rolling your eyes at any negative comments in the knowledge that she's not well and won't be around much longer.

SwedeCarrotLimes · 28/11/2023 17:11

thing47 · 28/11/2023 16:49

Well the moral of that story is that if you are persistently rude to and about your DIL, don't be surprised when you find she is less than enthusiastic about facilitating your relationship with her DCs.

And no, it most definitely is not @alicedbr's responsibility to encourage her very young DCs to have a relationship with somebody who is horrible to her. What a bizarre idea.

It IS her responsibility to ensure DC aren’t clinging to her and are encouraged to be social and independent. And most likely the only reason OP enjoys her current relationship with DC is she was the primary carer of DC whilst husband was the breadwinner. So it’s a bit harsh to call husband lazy in developing his relationship with DC.

WonderLife · 28/11/2023 17:09

This is a good lesson to those of us with sons, that if we want to have access to our young grandchildren we can't be horrible to their mother.

And if we have raised lazy sons, they won't put the effort in to the relationship they have with us.

eardefender · 28/11/2023 17:07

She may have been a great mum to your husband and a nice granny but the truth is she was not a good MIL to you. You had a different relationship with her and she wasn't a saint to you. She sounds like a normal flawed human being and seeing as she is dying i think diplomacy is in order but the fact remains that she wasn't a great MIL. You need to support your DH in his grief but he has no right to berate you for not getting on with her.

Villagetoraiseachild · 28/11/2023 17:05

Sorry you're going through this Op. Sounds like you had a very challenging mother in law relationship there. I feel you made the right choices, to protect your mental health and the harmony of your family.
I can't offer advice as haven't had this experience. Just hope you can keep your head held high and focus on your own happiness and know that this will pass.

diddl · 28/11/2023 17:02

Op maybe could have done more.

Her husband certainly could have.

JFDIYOLO · 28/11/2023 17:01

He's grieving in advance, sad about his failures, contemplating his own mortality, etc etc. which is totally understandable.

And instead of acting like an adult and managing his feelings he's piling it on your head, which is not acceptable.

Tell him you understand he's grieving and you'll support him with that; it's what we do. And that he will stop attempting to guilt trip you for the consequences of her choices.

TrashedSofa · 28/11/2023 17:01

With the DC being so young still, I wonder if DH had a vague idea he might make more effort to take them to his DM himself once they got a bit older and were less hard work. He thought he'd have time. Now he's found out he doesn't, and he's facing the consequences of having delayed.

WonderLife · 28/11/2023 16:59

Sounds like he just feels guilty that he didn't make more of an effort with his mum, didn't take the kids to see her more and it was easier for him to leave the 'clingy' kids with you rather than deal with them whinging.

I'd empathise with him but also not take responsibility 'I understand you feel angry and wish you'd taken the kids to visit more, that must feel really awful'.

Brandyginger · 28/11/2023 16:57

This sounds very hard. When my lovely dad died at 60 I became angry with my FIL for…being alive. 12 years on I still mentally bemoan my selfish and picky FIL and wonder why he’s here and my dad’s not.
completely irrational and I’ve never told my dh much less take it out on him. Grief can make you very angry.

i think the only thing you could do would be to respond minimally to your dh comments as the usual de-escalation tactics as you’ve already tried and as suggested by pp just aren’t working. So just don’t engage. Walk away to another room if you have to…

ANiceBigCupOfTea · 28/11/2023 16:56

To give my two cents, my sister died when I was 26 and she was 21. She had a long term illness but the end was sudden- as in, at home in bed

My DH didn't have the best relationship with her and they didn't always see eye to eye. She had many issues and she could be a challenging person. Had he restricted me seeing her, or refused to visit in what turned out to be the last month's of her life, or went on about how they didn't get on very well, I would have left him. When she was dying and when she passed, his job was to be my loving and supporting husband and allow me my grief, and he did, and he did it very well.
Bringing up the past isn't helping right now. Your priority is supporting your DH in a difficult time. Trust me i know I wasn't easy to be around when she died and the stages of grief were not easy to navigate.

ithinkmyheadiscavingin · 28/11/2023 16:52

OP, you haven't done anything wrong.

Your husband failed you by failing to shut his mother's constant comments down and instead defended her, and as a result, chose to limit his OWN time with his mother because he couldn't be arsed to visit without you and manage the DCs on his own.

You had every right to go limited contact with her yourself.

Your husband should have sorted visiting time with the children if he was concerned about it. He wasn't. Until it was too late. That's on him. Not you.

No where else in MN land would people be telling young mothers with little ones to suck it up and put up with such comments from a MIL ... only here in retrospect because MIl is now sadly dying.

I would make sympathetic noises, but I wouldn't entertain being blamed for your husband's failures.

Anisette · 28/11/2023 16:52

I suspect that this is your DH's guilt talking, because obviously if he wanted the children to see his mother more often he should have taken them or facilitated it.

When he says things like "my mum used to make an amazing one but of course the kids have never tried it because we've barely visited my mum as you were always too precious around her. Could have just realised she never meant any harm and ignored comments you don't like" can you just say something like "Look, I know this is grief and stress talking, but when you think about it you will acknowledge that she did mean harm and you knew it, which is why you didn't insist. Also that you could have taken them yourself if you really wanted to"?

Belichtofalicht · 28/11/2023 16:51

Oh, I see both sides here. I also had an absolutely infuriating MIL who would say things just like you've described. My husband also would have no clue why it was so maddening and why I couldn't just ignore it. I don't think that men understand at all why the interference from another woman in the way you want to raise your kids is so annoying. I don't even really understand it myself. It's just so undermining, somehow. Maybe it's a primal thing? As in, the subconscious, reptilian brain sees a MIL as a possible threat to your relationship with your child? In primitive times she could have taken the child away, especially as she has a blood claim, being the grandmother. There's just something unnatural (to the mother) about a MIL having opinions on how to raise YOUR OWN child. Believe me, I get it. It's one of the most rage-inducing things I've ever experienced.

However, it's also irrational. He's right that those things weren't really a big deal, even though it didn't feel that way to you. And tbh, it does sound as if you didn't make any effort to continue the kids' relationship with her, even if you wanted to limit your own time with her. But....he didn't fix things either. He could have intervened with the DCs clinginess to you and made them visit her. He could have had a quiet word with her about following your instructions as parents (i.e. no cake) and about the C-section thing, which is totally personal! I think both of you are equally at fault in the way you dealt with the situation. Both of you needed to communicate more, you with him about how maddening the interference is, and him to her about dialling back the comments and advice.

So, what to do now? If I were you, in a calm voice I would say that I know he's hurting and you're really sorry. Communicate with him that women do not take it well when other women interfere with their child-rearing, and that it feels like dominance and is utterly maddening. Own your part in not dealing well with the situation and say you wish you had done things differently. Gently point out that he could have taken the steps I mentioned above, and that neither of you dealt with her interference that well. He is really hurting, so maybe ask for his forgiveness in your part? Say that you wish you had done things differently. I really think it will go a long way towards making him feel seen and acknowledging his feelings.

I guess the only thing you can do now is visit her and take the DCs. Try to make your peace with her and your DH.

MILs are FAMOUS for their interference and unwelcome comments. Why, oh why, do they do this? It causes so much upset and they wouldn't have liked it. And men overwhelmingly will not stand up to their mothers. The whole thing is infuriating. I do feel for you!

thing47 · 28/11/2023 16:49

SwedeCarrotLimes · 28/11/2023 16:15

I would say it’s a joint responsibility and since it’s OP they’re clinging to it requires her support in helping to break that clinginess.

Well the moral of that story is that if you are persistently rude to and about your DIL, don't be surprised when you find she is less than enthusiastic about facilitating your relationship with her DCs.

And no, it most definitely is not @alicedbr's responsibility to encourage her very young DCs to have a relationship with somebody who is horrible to her. What a bizarre idea.

NewFriendlyLadybird · 28/11/2023 16:48

WinterNamechange · 28/11/2023 13:55

Ahh most people would have let these comments roll off them. You are coming across as quite a prickly person. Whether you like it or not, you have restricted your MiL's access to your family while being close to your own. And yes your DH could have taken the children on his own, but as you have not allowed that as your children are 'clingy' how could he have? My DC were clingy when young, but absolutely fine when my DH took them out on his own after a few initial whinges. I guess you reap what you sow, and your husband is realising what you have done - although to be fair he allowed it to happen so is as equally to blame.

Agree with this. Nothing you’ve quoted her as saying sounds that horrific to me, and easy to respond to in a good-humoured way while standing up for yourself. Or you and your husband could have worked on it between you. But to get up and leave, while taking the children with you, really does sound downright rude. Not sure what you can do about it now though.

soemptyinside · 28/11/2023 16:47

Well, I think you could have done more. If you're honest with yourself, you know you could have done more.

You chose to go out. You chose to take your kids with you because it was easier. You could have hidden in a different room. You could have left your kids at home. There were ways to facilitate his MIL having a relationship with the kids, but you didn't do this because it involved more effort than you were prepared to spend on her because you didn't like her.

Now, your DH could have done more, too. He could have. Your kids being clingy was a problem for both of you to solve. He didn't put the effort in either. This is not a problem entirely of your making.

But it's easier to take out the guilt on you than it is on himself because he already feels awful and has no capacity left for any more negative feelings towards himself. He's at peak misery.

So yeah, you're unreasonable here. But so is he. The difference is he's the one grieving (and yes, grief, before someone is actually dead, is a thing), so I think you're going to have to be the bigger person here and take some of that blame rather than argue with him.

Arguing isn't going to change the past anyway. You should bite your tongue and facilitate DH and the kids spending as much time as possible with her in her final days. Your DH is in a world of pain right now - this is the "for worse" part of your vows.

I've just lost a parent myself, and even though I know that logically, I did the right thing in being away when I was, I am full of guilt and grief for why I didn't spend more time with my parent before it was too late. I wish I had someone to blame. I don't. I'm sad, I'm angry, I'm tired, I'm everything. Please don't judge someone grieving the same way you would someone normally. Cut him some slack - he is not a human at his best right now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread