Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

M and S charging for carriers

308 replies

Sausagenbacon · 27/11/2023 17:28

AIBU to find it cheeky of m&s to charge 10p for a paper carrier bag when I've just spent £50 on a dress? Especially as I got caught in the rain and it disintegrated.
I can understand why you would charge for a plastic bag, but this is ridiculous.

OP posts:
Curlywurlyturly · 28/11/2023 11:35

This !👌

grass67 · 28/11/2023 11:04

@whatkatydid2013

Actually it's outdated advice/theory that packaging reduces food waste.
https://wrap.org.uk/resources/report/reducing-household-food-waste-and-plastic-packaging

Most fresh food deteriorates in plastic, for example potatoes last much better in a paper bag, carrots sweat in plastic, how many times do you see the ends of carrots rotting?

Whilst I agree you will end up with some that no one wants to buy, look at lidl they do boxes of damaged fruit and it sells...fast!

Reducing household food waste and plastic packaging

Ground-breaking research into the relationship between plastic packaging and five fruit and vegetable items frequently wasted at home, as well as the impact of date labels and storage temperatures, reveals significant opportunities to reduce both food...

https://wrap.org.uk/resources/report/reducing-household-food-waste-and-plastic-packaging

Noseylittlemoo · 28/11/2023 11:02

I work in a shop. We don't charge for our paper bags. If I ask someone if they need a bag some people look at me like I've got 2 heads - of course I need a bag! Some people ask for extra bags because they're outraged that other stores do charge for bags and come into the shop juggling all manner of items knowing they'll get a free bag from us. What irritates me the most is people buying eg a lip balm for themselves and asking for a bag when they've got a handbag and various other bags. I wish we charged for the bags as its so wasteful.

melj1213 · 28/11/2023 11:00

I don't always carry bags if I nip in after work! I expect a decent bag to put my shopping in.

But why is it the shops responsibility to provide a bag as opposed to your responsibility to take one with you just because you "nip in after work"? You aren't forced to shop, you are choosing to just like you are choosing to buy a bag rather than have one with you.

I work in a supermarket and occasionally pick up a couple of bits like bread and milk after my shifts, which is why I always have a small shopping bag folded up in its little pouch in the bottom of my bag just in case.

If you know you're a "nip in after work for a couple of bits on a regular basis" type of person then just keep a small reusable bag in your bag/coat for those little trips. If they're happening often enough and you're buying enough that you can't comfortably carry the items then you need to be prepared for them and if they're happening so infrequently that it's not worth the effort of remembering a bag, then accepting the very occasional cost is the consequence of that.

melj1213 · 28/11/2023 10:51

I think a big part of it is intentional vs opportunistic shopping - I try to only shop if/when I have planned it as I have a strict budget every month and can't afford to just "pop into town" on a whim and if I do it is rarely for more than a single item or two, which can usually be carried without a bag of I don't have one. I don't live anywhere near my town centre so I have to actively make a conscious decision to go shopping and therefore also have the opportunity to take a bag with me.

Very, very occasionally I might buy more than I have bags for, or buy something I don't want to put in a bag with my existing purchases, but in those cases I see the bag charge as a consequence of that - I have the option not to buy the item, or of putting it in an existing bag but if I choose not to do that then I am responsible for the consequence of that action by having to buy a bag.

I always try to have a reusable bag on my person when I leave the house, my reusable shopping bags live in the boot of my car for supermarket trips and if I'm going into town to shop and/or am taking public transport then I take my wheeled shopping trolley for my general purchases (We used to live in Madrid where everyone used one and it is so much more convenient, even if it embarrasses the hell out of teen DD) and shove a couple of cotton totes in the front pocket that I exclusively use for clothing/delicate items.

Additionally to the intentional vs opportunistic shopping, it's habit - it took me a long time to get in the habit of replacing bags once I'd used them but now it is second nature as I have little routines - the wheeled shopping trolley lives behind the front door so as soon as I get home it gets unpacked and put away ready for the next shopping trip; the reusable shopping bags that live in the car - as soon as I get home I unpack the shopping and the bags get folded into one bag and then that bag gets hung on the front door handle, so that the next time I leave the house (even if I'm not going shopping or even going out in the car) they are right there for me to grab and put into the boot of the car; the reusable bags that live in my coat/bag - I have a basket on a shelf by the front door with a few reusable bags in the little pouches and as I get in and hang up my coat/bag I shove one of those into my bag/coat to replace the one I've used, then when I unpack the current purchases those bags go into their little pouch and get put into the basket to wait for the next cycle round.

ZiriForGood · 28/11/2023 10:50

Glad to hear they do charge.
Many people have their own bags and the token charge works as an encouragement to actually use it.

whatkatydid2013 · 28/11/2023 10:41

grass67 · 28/11/2023 09:12

As mentioned before, paper is very damaging to the environment. Plastic is also terrible for the environment. I have a few cloth bags, you can wash them and they look so much nicer. For a big food shop I have the Aldi bags for life. Anything else I use my cloth bags. If you leave some in your car, you always have them.

It's not a rip off, it is an incentive. It's a simple concept and really makes a big difference to the environment. Sadly humans are selfish and lazy and don't care the planet is basically dying.

I agree about the ridiculous amounts of packaging on foods, only way to sort that is to tax the supermarkets. Any fruit, veg etc should be in compostable bags or sold loose.

I would like to see a super tax on imported clothing, it's disgraceful how cheap clothes are, that are just going to landfill. British clothes should be exempt from tax.

I think they need to weigh up the cost environmentally of food waste (apparently you get a lot more without packaging) and the packaging. We buy what we can loose but I can acknowledge the supermarkets are likely to have more waste that way. You won’t pick out the bruised apple or the one where a stalk from another apple has taken a chunk out of the skin for example where if you grab a plastic wrapped tray then chances are fruit isn’t damaged in first place but if it is you won’t see it

BIossomtoes · 28/11/2023 10:32

wensleywhale · 28/11/2023 10:28

Thought that was just plastic

It is. Charging for paper bags is a complete piss take

IGotItFromAgnes · 28/11/2023 10:31

Diamonde · 28/11/2023 10:04

No, I’d just be a lot poorer. Or not eat.
Most people don’t deliberately decide not to take bags shopping.

You don't forget your wallet or keys. Because you know there are consequences.

If bags costed more, you'd remember.

I do forget my wallet. I have forgotten my car keys on numerous occasions.

Costing more would make no difference to my ability to remember. ADHD doesn’t work like that, sadly.

wensleywhale · 28/11/2023 10:28

Riverlee · 27/11/2023 17:31

I thought retailers have to charge for bags by law.

Thought that was just plastic

Thatswhy11 · 28/11/2023 10:26

My local M&S have started doing paper bags it's a joke given its a lot of elderly shop there and it might rain. I don't mind 10p but they charge 30p, definitely not 10p where I live. They have got some other bags for life for 60p nice print but you can't get much in.

I don't always carry bags if I nip in after work! I expect a decent bag to put my shopping in.

CharityShopChic · 28/11/2023 10:23

So you get the wee drawstring ones like the one I posted a pic upthread. Nobody has to carry around bulky bags for life in their bag/pocket.

Honestly, some people are just deliberately difficult.

madeinmanc · 28/11/2023 10:22

MsPloddingBottom · 27/11/2023 21:48

I take a spare bag in my handbag

Actually a bag for life fills the whole handbag up unless you're carrying a massive tote bag everywhere 🙄

And while we're on the subject of hypocrisy, why is it somehow OK for me- a public transportation user- to be charged over the odds for a bag but dog owners are free to buy endless wasteful plastic bags, bag up poo and put those into landfill (in the-best case scenario)? Why aren't they forced to use biodegradable bags?

SutWytTi · 28/11/2023 10:15

Mademetoxic · 28/11/2023 08:27

From your pp you make it sound like you can't be bothered. You don't have the time or inclination were your exact words.

Said people are entitled. I think your attitude is entitled and strange. Never have I heard someone say it's entitled to pick up litter. This thread is crazy.

They didn't say you were entitled to pick up litter, they said you are being entitled to demand other people do it just because you yourself choose to do it.

I pick up litter myself. But I don't think other people have to do it.

Your posts have been rather sanctimonious. Lots of people don't have time. They're not to blame for any mess. The people primarily to blame are the government who have cut council budgets so much the streets are a mess. The majority of litter comes from bins, not from being dropped deliberately. That's why councils used to empty them regularly and sweep up.

Tory councillors often blame people for not litter picking - they can get knotted. Restore council budgets.

Those who do actively drop litter are wrong, of course, but the real issue is lack of street cleaning these days.

grass67 · 28/11/2023 10:12

I've stopped using bin bags 😁 I don't put any food waste in my bin, so everything is dry. I just put in in the house bin , then tip it into the wheel bin. it gets tipped by the bin men just the same. To be honest not a lot goes in the landfill bin anymore.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 28/11/2023 10:08

People have very short memories if they can't remember how much litter was caused by single use bags.

We spend a lot more on bin bags now than we used to. Not too sure how that makes a huge difference.

Likewise the outcry about single-use plastic bottles that end up in the oceans: any that I use get put in the recycling bin and put out for the council, so if they can't manage to keep the collected waste safely contained until it gets to the processing plant, I don't really see how that's somehow my fault.

Diamonde · 28/11/2023 10:04

No, I’d just be a lot poorer. Or not eat.
Most people don’t deliberately decide not to take bags shopping.

You don't forget your wallet or keys. Because you know there are consequences.

If bags costed more, you'd remember.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 28/11/2023 10:00

I've never heard someone say about picking up litter is entitled.
What is the world coming to when people refuse to make the world look slightly better.

If everyone had your attitude then the local areas would look horrendous.

It is a 2 min job with a litter picker. No excuses.

Every little helps.

Do you not think that the people who wantonly fling their rubbish on to the street might just be the ones to blame - rather than the people who do know how to find a bin for their own waste or take it home with them?

Why are you shaming people who neither drop their own nor want to pick up other people's litter, whilst apparently accepting as a given the truly selfish, entitled people who actually choose to drop it in the first place? Nobody could possibly pick up my litter, even if they desperately wanted to, because, like the majority of people who have a little respect for others, I don't drop any.

RedPony1 · 28/11/2023 09:58

megletthesecond · 28/11/2023 07:26

Doesn't everyone always have a bag on them? It's pretty basic; keys, phone, purse, water, reusable bag etc.

If you have too many bags go litter picking and reduce your stash a bit. Even the useless paper bags will hold some litter.

Nope. Keys & phone. i don't take a purse/handbag anywhere since Applepay was a thing and have never carried water out and about.

i also don't ever wear a coat except at the stables so i don't generally have a pocket i would put anything in

i take bags food shopping as they are in my car, i go from car to shop back to car so i don't have to carry them around.

SutWytTi · 28/11/2023 09:55

Mademetoxic · 28/11/2023 07:48

If everyone picked up litter when they're out and about, the world would look like a completely different place.

Entitled, I've never heard that before about litter picking.
🤣
Don't you want your area to look litter free?

Yes I pick up litter in my immediate area

But bollocks to it being my job to make the nation litter free.

Bloody Tories have cut everything back so much, that's why it looks crap.

grass67 · 28/11/2023 09:44

It is about emissions, every item of cheap clothing is shipped across the world in a plastic bag. Every tube of toothpaste in an unnecessary box, cucumbers wrapped in plastic, tomatoes in plastic boxes.

The emissions from the factory (china pumps out a horrifying amount) the oil burned to ship goods. Polluting the planet because we are lazy and don't want to reuse bags, or not have the convenience of grabbing 3 plastic wrapped peppers. Honestly if you come home from a bag food shop, how much goes straight in the bin?

CharityShopChic · 28/11/2023 09:31

It's not about emissions. It's about LITTER.

People have very short memories if they can't remember how much litter was caused by single use bags.

StopGo · 28/11/2023 09:13

NI, Wales and Scotland have charged by law for 10 plus years.

Government and retailers don't want you to bring your own bags. It's a lucrative passive income for them. First 20% goes to the government as VAT. Retailers can deduct various expenses perfectly legally. Around 1p in every 5p gets donated to 'good causes'.

Tesco donated £30 million last year alone.

grass67 · 28/11/2023 09:12

As mentioned before, paper is very damaging to the environment. Plastic is also terrible for the environment. I have a few cloth bags, you can wash them and they look so much nicer. For a big food shop I have the Aldi bags for life. Anything else I use my cloth bags. If you leave some in your car, you always have them.

It's not a rip off, it is an incentive. It's a simple concept and really makes a big difference to the environment. Sadly humans are selfish and lazy and don't care the planet is basically dying.

I agree about the ridiculous amounts of packaging on foods, only way to sort that is to tax the supermarkets. Any fruit, veg etc should be in compostable bags or sold loose.

I would like to see a super tax on imported clothing, it's disgraceful how cheap clothes are, that are just going to landfill. British clothes should be exempt from tax.

IGotItFromAgnes · 28/11/2023 09:01

CornTheCob · 28/11/2023 08:51

I bet people would remember to take a bag if stores started charging a fiver for one.

No, I’d just be a lot poorer. Or not eat.

Most people don’t deliberately decide not to take bags shopping.