Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

M and S charging for carriers

308 replies

Sausagenbacon · 27/11/2023 17:28

AIBU to find it cheeky of m&s to charge 10p for a paper carrier bag when I've just spent £50 on a dress? Especially as I got caught in the rain and it disintegrated.
I can understand why you would charge for a plastic bag, but this is ridiculous.

OP posts:
BlackFridayDiscoCunt · 28/11/2023 19:49

@Sausagenbacon I completely agree. I said upthread that I'm happy to pay for a decent bag that doesn't disintegrate in the rain. If all the well organised people want to take bags out with them, and can predict when they're going to need them, then that's great. But for those of us who can't, there needs to be an alternative. Nobody's quibbling about paying for the alternative - but they are quibbling about paying for a sodding alternative that falls apart after 5 minutes in light rain.

If I randomly buy a dress in M&S for £99 because I have 15 free minutes and am passing M&S, I expect the bag that I also pay for to go with it to keep it dry until I get it home, rather than dump it on a wet pavement along with a load of yoghurt.

However, this thread has at least convinced me to ring M&S and moan at them about their stupid useless bags.

Sidebeforeself · 28/11/2023 19:11

Because it's not just about the money?🤷‍♀️

Mademetoxic · 28/11/2023 18:56

Sausagenbacon · 28/11/2023 16:46

Frankly, all you perpetual bag carriers come across as smug and sanctimonious.
Plus all this bag stuff is disproportionate when the fashion industry is so incredibly wasteful. And it's nothing to do with carrier bags .
M and s (and everywhere else) is full of sequined stuff. People won't be wearing it next year, and it'll all end up in landfill, like all our cheap clothes. A paper bag, which recycled itself while I was still carrying it, is neither here nor there.

If you can afford a £50 dress then why are you whining about a 10p/20p/50p bag. 🤷‍♀️

Q2C4 · 28/11/2023 18:54

Davros · 27/11/2023 23:08

Furthermore, you can no longer use your "bags for life" until they are wrecked and get a replacement, they don't exist. AND how are they so "ethical" by making us pay for bags but my recycling bin is FULL of packaging from supermarket shopping. Grrr

My local Sainsburys takes plastic packaging back for recycling.

Anisette · 28/11/2023 16:54

Jk987 · 27/11/2023 17:40

Environmental reasons not profit making purposes. I think it's crucial to charge for bags.

What is the environmental reason for discouraging use of recyclable paper bags?

Sausagenbacon · 28/11/2023 16:46

Frankly, all you perpetual bag carriers come across as smug and sanctimonious.
Plus all this bag stuff is disproportionate when the fashion industry is so incredibly wasteful. And it's nothing to do with carrier bags .
M and s (and everywhere else) is full of sequined stuff. People won't be wearing it next year, and it'll all end up in landfill, like all our cheap clothes. A paper bag, which recycled itself while I was still carrying it, is neither here nor there.

OP posts:
UnremarkableBeasts · 28/11/2023 16:42

Diamonde · 28/11/2023 10:04

No, I’d just be a lot poorer. Or not eat.
Most people don’t deliberately decide not to take bags shopping.

You don't forget your wallet or keys. Because you know there are consequences.

If bags costed more, you'd remember.

people say this stuff but have absolutely no idea how hard it might be for some people to actually remember their keys and a means to pay every time they leave the house.

It’s not about ‘consequences’ as a ‘motivating factor’.

I’m guessing you’ve never had to call a locksmith to gain access to your own house. Never mind had to do it multiple times.

Nor have you regularly realised you’ve forgotten your phone/purse/card (or even just forgotten your bloody pin) and had to abandon an attempt at shopping.

You might think it’s just a little bag and it’s so easy to make sure you’ve always got one on you. But that doesn’t hold true for everyone. Lots of the people who do find this kind of consistent organisation difficult are covered by the equalities act - and are disproportionately affected by charges for things like carrier bags.

melj1213 · 28/11/2023 16:39

BIossomtoes · 28/11/2023 15:00

What about having a different re-usable cloth bag for clothes.

Because clothes are usually an impulse purchase and I want a nice crisp new paper carrier. It really isn’t much to ask in a shop that’s supposed to be relatively up market.

So your reasoning is "I don't want to" then? Since the stores don't want to give you a carrier bag and you don't want to either pay or come prepared with your own bag you're stuck then aren't you?

I have the big reusable hessian bags for shopping but I also keep a couple of the small foldaway ones that come in their own little pouch (much like the one someone posted a pic of earlier) in the bottom of my bag and in my coat pocket. I have a couple that fold up into a tiny pouch that fits in my palm but unfolds into a decently large bag that can comfortably fit a few items of clothes without having to fold them up to the point of leaving creases and lives in the fabric.

I rarely ever use them for groceries, they're either only for milk and bread after work or on the very rare occasion I pop into town when I'm buying stuff that is not going to leak/stain etc. Any bag that has been used for anything that might have leaked/spilt/left crumbs etc will be wiped out and/or chucked in the wash before it's put back into circulation. It's not a hard habit to get into, and means I dont think I've paid for a bag for about 10 years, except for the odd occasion I haven't had enough bags with me.

KimberleyClark · 28/11/2023 15:02

CharityShopChic · 28/11/2023 10:23

So you get the wee drawstring ones like the one I posted a pic upthread. Nobody has to carry around bulky bags for life in their bag/pocket.

Honestly, some people are just deliberately difficult.

This. Fabric bags folded up take next to no space. And I have a messenger style bag that is itself big enough for small items like toiletries.

BIossomtoes · 28/11/2023 15:00

What about having a different re-usable cloth bag for clothes.

Because clothes are usually an impulse purchase and I want a nice crisp new paper carrier. It really isn’t much to ask in a shop that’s supposed to be relatively up market.

DonnaBanana · 28/11/2023 15:00

I mean a decent shop would give an automatic discount of the 10p on a big purchase like that so as to meet the law but also be good to customers. But I use a different trick. I buy some uncooked fish or meat in the food hall bit and they legally have to give you a free bag then I put the clothes I buy in there.

Noseylittlemoo · 28/11/2023 14:53

What about having a different re-usable cloth bag for clothes. We have loads of hessian and cloth bags for supermarket /food shopping. They sometimes have old receipts/dirt from potatoes/ a bit of onion skin etc . But I do wash them and also use a different non food bag for other types of purchase. Surely its OK to use a bag that's had other clothing in - you don't need a new bag per item/shopping trip.

BIossomtoes · 28/11/2023 14:27

Am I the only person who doesn’t want to put a brand new, expensive garment into the bag that I use to carry my groceries? I want a nice new paper carrier preferably lined with tissue. If the little shop in my local town can do it wtf can’t bloody John Lewis? JL is haemorrhaging customers and that has to be a factor.

Sidebeforeself · 28/11/2023 13:37

sometimes people forget to take a bag! It’s not that difficult to comprehend. When I forget I expect to be charged for a plastic one cos that’s the law but not for a paper one

MsPloddingBottom · 28/11/2023 13:29

madeinmanc · 28/11/2023 12:45

@MsPloddingBottom Clearly, I have heard of a tote bag because I mention them in the bit of my post that you quoted in your post.

So... what's your problem then? Bearing in mind I use public transport so I'm not some Range Rover driver with five servants and without a clue?

Mademetoxic · 28/11/2023 13:11

SutWytTi · 28/11/2023 10:15

They didn't say you were entitled to pick up litter, they said you are being entitled to demand other people do it just because you yourself choose to do it.

I pick up litter myself. But I don't think other people have to do it.

Your posts have been rather sanctimonious. Lots of people don't have time. They're not to blame for any mess. The people primarily to blame are the government who have cut council budgets so much the streets are a mess. The majority of litter comes from bins, not from being dropped deliberately. That's why councils used to empty them regularly and sweep up.

Tory councillors often blame people for not litter picking - they can get knotted. Restore council budgets.

Those who do actively drop litter are wrong, of course, but the real issue is lack of street cleaning these days.

I just don't get how people wouldn't want their area to look nice. 🤷‍♀️ Hence to pick up a bit of litter if they see it.
It doesn't take 2 mins. 30 second job. The poster was just making excuses.

Mademetoxic · 28/11/2023 13:09

madeinmanc · 28/11/2023 12:42

If I'm planning on shopping then obviously I do, but sometimes -the horror!- I go shopping SPONTANEOUSLY! 😮

If you can remember to take your purse/phone etc out with you I'm sure you can remember to bring a fold away bag with you.

Ocani · 28/11/2023 13:09

Q2C4 · 28/11/2023 12:34

@madeinmanc @Ocani genuine question - why can't you take some fold up bags with you?

I'm not talking about myself. I'm talking about what supermarkets are doing.

Q2C4 · 28/11/2023 13:04

BlackFridayDiscoCunt · 27/11/2023 22:07

If you’re going shopping take a bag; pretty basic

And what if you're not going shopping, but find yourself with a 15 minute window during a working day? Are you supposed to be Mystic Meg and know that you're going to find yourself passing M&S (or wherever) at lunch time, when you're normally nowhere near it?

I keep a fold up bag in my handbag for just such occasions.

madeinmanc · 28/11/2023 12:45

@MsPloddingBottom Clearly, I have heard of a tote bag because I mention them in the bit of my post that you quoted in your post.

madeinmanc · 28/11/2023 12:42

If I'm planning on shopping then obviously I do, but sometimes -the horror!- I go shopping SPONTANEOUSLY! 😮

Q2C4 · 28/11/2023 12:34

@madeinmanc @Ocani genuine question - why can't you take some fold up bags with you?

RedToothBrush · 28/11/2023 12:22

What's stopping you from carrying your own bag? Get into the habit.

MsPloddingBottom · 28/11/2023 11:54

Actually a bag for life fills the whole handbag up unless you're carrying a massive tote bag everywhere 🙄

@madeinmanc

You're how old and have never heard of a rucksack or tote bag?

No idea what the rest of your post is about.

Ocani · 28/11/2023 11:50

Ofc there's been a massive reduction in single use bags since all this started. That's because supermarkets don't provide them any more. There's only reusable bags.

Millions more of them get produced than previously - numbers aren't clear because not all shops report how many they get through, plus many more are produced than are sold because customers use them without paying if they can. They are more environmentally damaging than the little flimsy bags we used to have and cost 50p-£1. Because they're not single use plastic they're not part of the bag charge scheme so the money can legitimately just stay with the shop.

And in all of this the original purpose of the 5p charge has become completely lost. It's not about the environment. Bags are now just another item that supermarkets can charge as they please for. The numbers produced aren't monitored and money doesn't go to charity - it's just a way for shops to add an extra couple of quid onto what they charge which is already now massively opportunistically inflated.

And ofc there is a seemingly endless supply of useful idiots ready to support this because anything that appears greenwashed taps into the whole "omg, why don't you care about the planet as much as I do?" puritanical self righteous one-upmanship that characterises so much of environmental debate.

Swipe left for the next trending thread