Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not give up my Saturdays?

593 replies

Frey11 · 27/11/2023 12:07

My husband shares a daughter with his ex who does a hobby. She has practice during the week, which DH and ex take her to depending who's night it is and at the weekend she has a game on a Saturday. The time varies but it's typically around mid day and takes at least a couple of hours.

My husband has always worked Saturday days, he has a day off in the week and works Saturday. We have SD 2 nights a week, one in the week and at the weekend it alternates one week Saturday night with DH collecting on his way home from work and the next weekend it's Sunday night.

SDs mum has just changed jobs which requires her to also work Saturdays. This was never mentioned to us until she'd already taken the job and I'm now being asked to have SD every Saturday and take her to said game. This means my whole day revolves around this as it's always in the middle of the day.

I also have two pre school children and work all week myself. This is my time with them to do things we don't get to do in the week, see friends, soft play etc..

AIBU to not want to do this every Saturday?

OP posts:
Keepinmovin · 27/11/2023 16:43

KingsleyBorder · 27/11/2023 15:25

Oh I see you were saying “you do” as a proposal for the future?

Problem is that the weekend contact was never scheduled to start before 4pm so this would be varying that arrangement, regardless of any sport in the mix.

Sorry was typing too fast and not being clear.
I think it is reasonable for the DH to take some responsibility for this hobby going forward. It seems unfair that ex mum has had to take it on every week until now.
And if OP has agreed that DH should work every Sat then it could be reasonable for her to sort out every other Sat. It's not reasonable for her to take on every week !

GrumpyPanda · 27/11/2023 16:39

@skyeisthelimit

You need to stand your ground and he needs to sort it out. If they are both working then DD comes to you, but doesn't do her thing any more. They need to take the blame for this, not you.

No, just no. The matches are merely a complicating factor. If they're dropped it still isn't OP's obligation to provide unpaid childcare for the two CF parents. She's stated quite clearly she needs her Saturdays at her own disposition to freely plan activities with her own DC. (The same would apply if she were childfree.)

That aside, how refreshing to see an AIBU that doesn't cone down to collective stepmum-bashing. An outbreak of collective kindness or is the DSC mum in this case just a little bit too batshit?

GuinnessBird · 27/11/2023 16:31

It's the mum's problem to resolve, stand firm.

TrashedSofa · 27/11/2023 16:20

TolkiensFallow · 27/11/2023 15:53

This isn’t even about the hobby. The mum seems to have no childcare plan for Saturdays regardless of whether SD goes to the hobby. If DH doesn’t collect her until 4, then the mum needs to make arrangements for her to be looked after???

I wondered if perhaps DSD is old enough to be left for a few hours, but not old enough to be able to reliably get herself to all the matches. Hence OP framing it as the hobby rather than childcare that she's been asked to take on, and another reason why there's no reason to think she'll 'end up' having to look after DSD anyway.

grass67 · 27/11/2023 16:19

@UnremarkableBeasts I had a contact order it stated dad would have Friday 3.30 - Sunday6pm. I still picked them up from school because he couldn't.

Maybe they do have a schedule but dad couldn't do the Sat as he changed his job at some point. Maybe mum said "oh I will have her until 4 then" There's not enough detail from the OP.

wutheringkites · 27/11/2023 16:16

Sounds like one of them needs to change their working hours. If you have a dependent child then it doesn't make sense for both parents to be working Saturdays. Doesn't matter if they're still together or not.

I would not sort this out for them. She shouldn't have taken a new job without discussing this first.

I guess worst case of a court determines contact and I'd assume they would just decide on every other Saturday.

littlebopeepp234 · 27/11/2023 16:13

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 27/11/2023 12:15

Could you do every other weekend? Maybe see if there are any other parents who you could do a rota with?

Why should op have to?? It’s the biological mum’s problem if she took a job knowing it would mean she works Saturdays knowing full well her daughter takes part in a particular hobby where one of the days happens to be on Saturdays. It’s up to the parent to sort it. Either the parents have to sort it or tell the child they can no longer go.

ithinkmyheadiscavingin · 27/11/2023 16:11

Shinyandnew1 · 27/11/2023 12:30

If these two were still married, they wouldn’t have been both able to take jobs necessitating Saturday working without a conversation about childcare, so they can’t do it now.

Is your husband just expecting you will do it, @Frey11 ?

This was my first thought, too.

They wouldn't both be working Saturday if they were still together, as one would have to sort their child out. They still need to sort their child out amongst themselves. It is NOT OP's responsibility to do so.

UnremarkableBeasts · 27/11/2023 16:09

grass67 · 27/11/2023 15:57

@UnremarkableBeasts

oh but....OP hasn't stated they have a contact order...It's an odd set up, which seems to be focused on dads shift.

So what if mum has been accommodating him when he should have the Sat?

There's always an "oh but"

You don’t need a child arrangements order to have agree a clear and definite contact schedule.

If you know that you have contact every Saturday til 4, you organise your life accordingly.

If you need to make a change to that schedule, you agree that change - even just in principle - with the child’s other parent. You don’t just take a job and say ‘can’t have DD in a Saturday’.

Channellingsophistication · 27/11/2023 16:07

No way she has 2 parents already - they need to sort her care. How cheeky!

Crayfishhe · 27/11/2023 16:07

Doesnt look like OP’s coming back which is valid as she’s got an overwhelming YANBU. What her husband and his ex do about his ex deciding to work on her contact time is their problem.

Backagain23 · 27/11/2023 16:07

I feel desperately sorry for kids whose parents have more children with subsequent partners
That's quite the statement.
My DSD is in almost exactly the position of OPs DSD (except my DH doesn't work weekends) and she has actively asked if/when I can have another baby! So it can't be that bad, and she seems to absolutely love and adore her brothers even without me swinging in to pretend to be another Mummy to her. So don't you be feeling sorry for her because two little boys she loves also exist.

grass67 · 27/11/2023 15:57

@UnremarkableBeasts

oh but....OP hasn't stated they have a contact order...It's an odd set up, which seems to be focused on dads shift.

So what if mum has been accommodating him when he should have the Sat?

There's always an "oh but"

BIossomtoes · 27/11/2023 15:57

Reason No. 2,843 that I wouldn't advise having kids with a man who already is a parent. The first daughter must feel like a nuisance to both her parents.

Absolutely. I always said I wouldn’t entertain the idea and being a stepparent was difficult enough without younger children. It’s really sad because it’s always the older child or children who suffer. I put myself out to do stuff I really didn’t want to for that reason but it was relatively easy because the only person it affected was me. I feel desperately sorry for kids whose parents have more children with subsequent partners.

UnremarkableBeasts · 27/11/2023 15:55

TolkiensFallow · 27/11/2023 15:53

This isn’t even about the hobby. The mum seems to have no childcare plan for Saturdays regardless of whether SD goes to the hobby. If DH doesn’t collect her until 4, then the mum needs to make arrangements for her to be looked after???

It’s incredible really.

I cannot imagine committing to something like this without already having a clear plan for who would be looking after my children.

‘my ex’s wife will just have to do it’ is not a plan.

TolkiensFallow · 27/11/2023 15:53

This isn’t even about the hobby. The mum seems to have no childcare plan for Saturdays regardless of whether SD goes to the hobby. If DH doesn’t collect her until 4, then the mum needs to make arrangements for her to be looked after???

UnremarkableBeasts · 27/11/2023 15:51

TrashedSofa · 27/11/2023 15:44

There's really no reason OP should 'end up' looking after DSD, though. So the possibility of lifelong resentment can be migitated against by just.... not. Asserting the boundary and sticking to it.

It’s just ridiculous.

Emotive threats of lifelong resentment to tell the OP that she must do it.

Or that the DH should simply pay more maintenance too.

How about the mother recognises that she is letting her daughter down. She’s the one that decided to get a job working on a Saturday knowing that she’s supposed to have her daughter.

No amount of ‘oh but…’ changes that. If she wanted to discuss changing the contact arrangements, she should have done that before taking a job that meant she couldn’t fulfil her responsibilities within the arrangement.

grass67 · 27/11/2023 15:49

Lifelong resentment goes both ways...how many parties will OP's children miss whilst watching their SS play? My children hated having to wait whilst one of them was at an activity.

I still resent a Saturday waiting in A&E (for five hours) whilst my stupid bother was treated with a broken arm.....you know 35 years ago 😂

uncomfortablydumb53 · 27/11/2023 15:48

No, do not give an inch on this
Weekend are your time with your DC
It's up to DH and ex to sort this

howdoesyourgardengrowinmay · 27/11/2023 15:47

the parents need to organise another family going to the hobby, (or a paid child minder) to ferry and look after the child until one of the parents can collect them.

Even if you were the fully involved full time 3rd parent in this relationship, as neither of the other 2 parents discussed this with you at any stage until it was a fait accompli, it's not your problem to solve.

UnremarkableBeasts · 27/11/2023 15:46

Keepinmovin · 27/11/2023 15:12

You presumably do the Saturday run on the weekends you have the SD? I Think that could be reasonable given she's a part of your family and its your DH weekend so his responsibility (which I guess as a family you've decided it's OK for him to work Sat). For the ex weekend, she needs to sort herself out with relatives or childcarer

Why is it the OP’s responsibility? Being a woman doesn’t make her automatic childcare.

Even if the OP and her DH have agreed he will work in Saturday’s that doesn’t mean she’s required to take on responsibility for his older child too.

The ex is entirely in the wrong here. She’s unilaterally decided that she wants to work during her established contact time. The DH is also in the wrong because both the SD’s parents seem to have just decided that the OP (and the small children) will be spending every Saturday running around after SD for them.

Ridiculous. What MN stepparenting shows repeatedly is quite how selfish and entitled many parents are in their expectations of a stepmum. And also how keen some
MNers are to insist it’s somehow her responsibility to exist as a childcare accessory for an SC’s parents.

TrashedSofa · 27/11/2023 15:44

Halfemptyhalfling · 27/11/2023 13:40

Other options SD s DM and dp could investigate:
Friend takes
Relative takes
Sports coach takes

Other option is your dh increases maintenance so SDs DM does not work Saturdays

If none of these work it occurs to me that you could end up with looking after her on Saturdays anyway resenting you for the rest of her life as you stopped her sport.

It might not last for very long anyway. It could be she gets bored of going and stops going or one of her parents changed jobs again quite quickly. Or she gets dropped from the team.

You can take books or simple crafts or colouring for little ones in the car if wet or go to a nearby playground or short walk and actually have quality time with them or meet a friend at a nearby cafe

Edited

There's really no reason OP should 'end up' looking after DSD, though. So the possibility of lifelong resentment can be migitated against by just.... not. Asserting the boundary and sticking to it.

Sweetglossy · 27/11/2023 15:44

@Frey11 is DH the father of both your pre school children?

LaurieStrode · 27/11/2023 15:39

Some of my friends with young children consciously opted out of football and other sports for their families because they didn't want to be shackled to routines and obligations like this. It's a bit hard on the child now that she is ensconced in it and presumably has mates on the team. But maybe that would be for the best. There are other enrichment activities that could be done.

It does sound as though there is an imbalance in how much care OP's husband provides. Perhaps he should give up his Saturday gigs and have the girl every other weekend.

It's a little cold to say "it's between them, not the OP's problem," when there is a young human being involved; she's not a dog or a piece of luggage being batted forth and back. But the best hours of every Saturday is a grim obligation.

Reason No. 2,843 that I wouldn't advise having kids with a man who already is a parent. The first daughter must feel like a nuisance to both her parents.

skyeisthelimit · 27/11/2023 15:38

This should have been discussed between the mother and your DH when she was considering the job. If he had said sorry I am working, then she would have had to make a decision and tell DD that she could no longer go.

The world doesn't actually revolve around children. It is ok to tell them that as a parent, you can't do something. That was essentially the decision that the mother made when she took the job (unless your DH had told her it was fine for you to have her without discussing it with you).

You need to stand your ground and he needs to sort it out. If they are both working then DD comes to you, but doesn't do her thing any more. They need to take the blame for this, not you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread