Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not give up my Saturdays?

593 replies

Frey11 · 27/11/2023 12:07

My husband shares a daughter with his ex who does a hobby. She has practice during the week, which DH and ex take her to depending who's night it is and at the weekend she has a game on a Saturday. The time varies but it's typically around mid day and takes at least a couple of hours.

My husband has always worked Saturday days, he has a day off in the week and works Saturday. We have SD 2 nights a week, one in the week and at the weekend it alternates one week Saturday night with DH collecting on his way home from work and the next weekend it's Sunday night.

SDs mum has just changed jobs which requires her to also work Saturdays. This was never mentioned to us until she'd already taken the job and I'm now being asked to have SD every Saturday and take her to said game. This means my whole day revolves around this as it's always in the middle of the day.

I also have two pre school children and work all week myself. This is my time with them to do things we don't get to do in the week, see friends, soft play etc..

AIBU to not want to do this every Saturday?

OP posts:
Backtomyoldname · 28/11/2023 21:40

Does the SD's Mum have a new partner?

Has this new partner been approached?

If so what was the answer?

This problem really is for the actual parents to sort out.

I imagine that all of us with multiple children (with or without the added complication of blended families, S Children, Exes etc etc) have had problems with clashes of interests, timings, locations etc - and sometimes have had to say no.

This is one of those situations.

BIossomtoes · 28/11/2023 21:38

None of the children are in a situation of their own making.

The children of the second family are living in one home with both their parents. The impact on them is minimal compared with the stepchildren. And I was quite happy to say nothing of the sort.

greyhairnomore · 28/11/2023 21:37

Has the Mum actually had a conversation with you @Frey11 ? What on earth did she think would happen?

Backagain23 · 28/11/2023 21:32

BIossomtoes · 28/11/2023 21:22

Still don't understand what make the step child the most important

Because they’re in a situation not of their making. They’re shunted back and forth between their parents and two homes. They have stepparents who they have no choice in and see relatively little of (usually) their dad unless the arrangement is 50/50. I felt so sorry for my stepchildren.

Let's apply some common sense.
None of the children are in a situation of their own making.
But you were quite happy to say that because OP got with a man who had a child, it's fine for her children to be buffeted about by the whims of some random woman their dad used to go out with.

funinthesun19 · 28/11/2023 21:30

I’m actually a bit concerned about how dismissive you are about how shit the parents are being towards their child. It’s like it’s going over your head because you’re so focused on the stepmum. Really bizarre.

funinthesun19 · 28/11/2023 21:28

beedayuser · 28/11/2023 21:25

But that’s just me. Can’t stand CF parents

Neither can I. I can't really do with other people's children either. Which is one reason I wouldn't have become a step parent!

Thankfully I’m not a stepparent either. But I also don’t think stepmums owe their lives like some sort of martyr.

beedayuser · 28/11/2023 21:27

IGotItFromAgnes · 28/11/2023 21:22

In 15 years' time, the child will be an adult and will remember who did or didn't do what when she was younger.

Yes and hopefully will realise it’s her parents who should have stepped up, not her stepmother

To look at this in another way: if a step parent does a really good job, then the child (when s/he is an adult) might well say: "my parents were crap, but my stepmum was fantastic".

That's what I'd want if I were a step mother of a child whose parents were both a bit rubbish.

Though a man who was a bit rubbish with his child would be a complete turn-off for me.

beedayuser · 28/11/2023 21:25

But that’s just me. Can’t stand CF parents

Neither can I. I can't really do with other people's children either. Which is one reason I wouldn't have become a step parent!

beedayuser · 28/11/2023 21:24

*I’m assuming that poster also believes any firstborn child should be completely prioritised over their siblings if their parents are still together - that’s the only thing that could make this even make vague logical sense

Absolutely not. In a nuclear family, all children have to make concessions, and the parents will work together to juggle things so that all the children get to do a bit of what they want to do.

In a divorced family, the children are making a massive concession in that they are to-ing and fro-ing between houses and (mostly) warring parents. This is not what they would choose to do.

When a step-parent joins the mix, that's a further complication for the child/ren who are already buffeted around by their parents.

funinthesun19 · 28/11/2023 21:23

beedayuser · 28/11/2023 21:21

It does actually make sense. The parents are clearly both failing to communicate properly about their daughter's needs.

The step-parent chose to put herself into this situation, so she therefore has to fill in for the benefit of the child whom she chose to take on as a step child.

If she hadn't chosen to join this family, then obviously she would have no need to take anyone else's needs or feelings into account. But this is a child. Any half decent person would make sure they could facilitate her hobby, especially given that she's good at it.

In 15 years' time, the child will be an adult and will remember who did or didn't do what when she was younger.

Then the parents need to communicate better don’t they? And put their kid first. Problem solved.

BIossomtoes · 28/11/2023 21:22

Still don't understand what make the step child the most important

Because they’re in a situation not of their making. They’re shunted back and forth between their parents and two homes. They have stepparents who they have no choice in and see relatively little of (usually) their dad unless the arrangement is 50/50. I felt so sorry for my stepchildren.

IGotItFromAgnes · 28/11/2023 21:22

In 15 years' time, the child will be an adult and will remember who did or didn't do what when she was younger.

Yes and hopefully will realise it’s her parents who should have stepped up, not her stepmother

funinthesun19 · 28/11/2023 21:22

beedayuser · 28/11/2023 21:17

@funinthesun19 No axe to grind at all (I'm not a step parent, and my children have no step parents) - but after years of parenting and sharing the experiences of friends, I feel very strongly that blended families only work when all the adults are willing to put themselves out 100% for any children who had already been born before they decided to get together.

If you "shack up with" someone with children, you are also taking on their child/ren, with all that this entails. If you're not willing to do this, you shouldn't do it at all.

I personally don’t think there has to be a rule where the stepmum has to do as she’s told and commit to extreme situations for the parents and it be framed as “putting the child first.”

But that’s just me. Can’t stand CF parents.

beedayuser · 28/11/2023 21:21

It does actually make sense. The parents are clearly both failing to communicate properly about their daughter's needs.

The step-parent chose to put herself into this situation, so she therefore has to fill in for the benefit of the child whom she chose to take on as a step child.

If she hadn't chosen to join this family, then obviously she would have no need to take anyone else's needs or feelings into account. But this is a child. Any half decent person would make sure they could facilitate her hobby, especially given that she's good at it.

In 15 years' time, the child will be an adult and will remember who did or didn't do what when she was younger.

IGotItFromAgnes · 28/11/2023 21:21

funinthesun19 · 28/11/2023 21:17

So the stepmum is held to a higher standard because the child existed first? And the parents who caused that existence of the child aren’t held to a higher standard?

That makes so sense whatsoever.

I’m assuming that poster also believes any firstborn child should be completely prioritised over their siblings if their parents are still together - that’s the only thing that could make this even make vague logical sense.

Katej82 · 28/11/2023 21:19

beedayuser · 28/11/2023 21:14

Still don't understand what make the step child the most important and why the step parent is being held to a higher standard

Because that child existed first, and the step parent made the choice to become involved with that child. If the step parent couldn't be arsed with someone else's child (and, again, I am firmly in this camp - other people's children are of no interest to me), then they shouldn't have become a step parent.

If woman don't want to put a child first who already exists, then why not find a man who doesn't already have children? There are plenty of them around.

I would agree if this had been the position from the start but it hasn't SD mum has taken a new job before making prior arrangements. Why should that fall on SM what if she already had classes booked for the other children.. things if arranged in advance would be different but the mum has been completely unreasonable here.

funinthesun19 · 28/11/2023 21:17

beedayuser · 28/11/2023 21:14

Still don't understand what make the step child the most important and why the step parent is being held to a higher standard

Because that child existed first, and the step parent made the choice to become involved with that child. If the step parent couldn't be arsed with someone else's child (and, again, I am firmly in this camp - other people's children are of no interest to me), then they shouldn't have become a step parent.

If woman don't want to put a child first who already exists, then why not find a man who doesn't already have children? There are plenty of them around.

So the stepmum is held to a higher standard because the child existed first? And the parents who caused that existence of the child aren’t held to a higher standard?

That makes so sense whatsoever.

beedayuser · 28/11/2023 21:17

@funinthesun19 No axe to grind at all (I'm not a step parent, and my children have no step parents) - but after years of parenting and sharing the experiences of friends, I feel very strongly that blended families only work when all the adults are willing to put themselves out 100% for any children who had already been born before they decided to get together.

If you "shack up with" someone with children, you are also taking on their child/ren, with all that this entails. If you're not willing to do this, you shouldn't do it at all.

Katej82 · 28/11/2023 21:17

No DH ex is completely unreasonable for not making arrangements prior to accepting the new job! Then if your DH expects you to do it he's wrong too. Do not do it you have to have that time with your own children and friends. I am similar as sometimes DH will ask me to pick up SD on a Saturday as he works until 5 and then has to go back past our home for a further 15 miles. However I have done it a few times thats because if I have plans with my toddler which like you is special time as I work all week I'm not giving it up. Sunday I tend to have to shop, big clean laundry and cook for everyone SD and older children here, DH cannot cook a thing he needs training badly!! Therefore I'm not giving up that special time on a Saturday as my husband changed his job not thinking about the 60 mile round trip! pick up plus it's 30 miles round for me and my car eats fuel so it's a big fat No unless I'm in SD area. DH however does not expect it he will occasionally ask if say he wants to get back earlier or if I'm in SD area. Do not give in! X

FiddleLeaf · 28/11/2023 21:15

YANBU - Your OH could speak with his workplace and change his schedule.

beedayuser · 28/11/2023 21:14

Still don't understand what make the step child the most important and why the step parent is being held to a higher standard

Because that child existed first, and the step parent made the choice to become involved with that child. If the step parent couldn't be arsed with someone else's child (and, again, I am firmly in this camp - other people's children are of no interest to me), then they shouldn't have become a step parent.

If woman don't want to put a child first who already exists, then why not find a man who doesn't already have children? There are plenty of them around.

poetryandwine · 28/11/2023 21:14

@drowninginjelly Mum has been picking up the slack for Dad, so far as we can tell, for some time (picking up DD from the sport and having her at home until he picks her up). Where ideological purity lies, I do not know. But cooperation between the girl’s parents seems the pragmatic choice.

Livelovebehappy · 28/11/2023 21:14

Backagain23 · 28/11/2023 20:59

She's not being asked to step in occasionally. That's the point.
I do lots of stepping in to help DH and his ex with logistics for my SC. But I absolutely would not be running my two small childrens weekends around her every single week. I'm their Mum first and foremost. All other roles in life file in after that.
It's completely unrealistic, unreasonable and downright cheeky to expect this of OP.

I agree, which is why I said ‘occasionally..’

funinthesun19 · 28/11/2023 21:14

beedayuser · 28/11/2023 20:58

@Backagain23 Yet again: if you shack up with a man who already has a child/children, that child has to come first. If you can't accept this, don't get involved with a man who has children. There are plenty of men who don't come with this kind of baggage.

If you choose to get involved with a man who already has a child, and then choose to procreate with him, then you absolutely have to bear in mind the needs of said child, even if both the child's parents are too selfish to do so.

Again, if you don't want to do that: don't get involved with a man who has children.

If you choose to get involved with a man who already has a child, and then choose to procreate with him, then you absolutely have to bear in mind the needs of said child, even if both the child's parents are too selfish to do so.

So the stepmum is held to higher standard then - is that what you’re basically saying?

And I never understand why some people can’t just talk properly when they’re referring to stepmums. They always say things like “Shacked up with a man with children”. If you’re expecting people to take you seriously then maybe stop with the deliberate derogatory language just because it’s something you clearly have an axe to grind about?

Backagain23 · 28/11/2023 21:07

beedayuser · 28/11/2023 20:58

@Backagain23 Yet again: if you shack up with a man who already has a child/children, that child has to come first. If you can't accept this, don't get involved with a man who has children. There are plenty of men who don't come with this kind of baggage.

If you choose to get involved with a man who already has a child, and then choose to procreate with him, then you absolutely have to bear in mind the needs of said child, even if both the child's parents are too selfish to do so.

Again, if you don't want to do that: don't get involved with a man who has children.

You can "bear in mind" the needs of a child without having to accept them being unilaterally foisted upon you.
Love the language there - "shack up" indeed. My husband and I had a right to get married and out children have a right to exist. His ex GF would not have the right to try to make me run about after her child for her, no matter how often you state that she does.
Still don't understand what make the step child the most important and why the step parent is being held to a higher standard.

Swipe left for the next trending thread