Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is CF and inappropriate and say no?

419 replies

KindaProm · 27/11/2023 11:41

Well actually, I've already said no, and I'm getting a lot of attitude from various folk about my response sadly. So I'm here on AIBU to check myself.

A close family member, Zara has a son, Xander 17 who is at a specialist sixth form.

Every Christmas the school has a Very Fancy Christmas Event for Year 13 that all the children make massive efforts for. Think red carpet, photos, lovely food and entertainment.

They like to arrive in style.

I have a nice car. Zara would like to drive Xander in it to the event.

She's not willing to pay for insurance to drive it, and I'm not willing to fund her, so I've refused. She's not a great maneouverer anyway and I'd be concerned that she'd damage it.

She's having a hissy fit because I've RUINED his evening, they've been plotting this arrival since he joined this College. News to me, I was asked at the weekend for the event at the end of term.

Another close family member, Wilma, has called me several times to cajole, persuade and finally berate me for not allowing Zara to have this pleasure. Yes it's all about Zara, not Xander.

Wilma's DH, Vince, has also started trying to persuade me to let Zara drive it just in the grounds of the event, as its private property and insurance is almost irrelevant at that point.

I'm still saying no. Even if I'd consider it, what would I do whole she drove it on the grounds? Stand at the roadside like a plum while she pootles up the driveway?
How's she going to get to the venue?

I've offered to drive him myself but nope, not good enough; Zara needs to be there.

I'm not being unreasonable am I?

And Wilma and Vince need to stick out of it, don't they?

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 29/11/2023 19:13

Inheritanceconundrum · 29/11/2023 19:11

Of course she doesn't want her expensive car to get damaged.

Why is that unreasonable?

What is unreasonable is the very low chance of it getting damaged versus her relationship further deteriorating with her sister and her parents. It comes across as being precious. The assumption is that it will get damaged, which seems pretty unlikely if her sister just drives it slowly up the venue driveway. I just think that it's unreasonable to put your relationship with possessions above that of close family. But maybe I'm biased because I view cars just as things and not as status symbols and my sibling is currently terminally ill, which really gets you to reassess what is really important in life.

As I said, the sister should pay for insurance and do the leg work, but the OP could still invest a little time in offering to help with this. I recently added a relative as a named driver to my policy and it cost me nothing to do so. It took about 10 minutes to do so.

Did you even read the OP?

THE OP SAID SHE WOULD LET HER SISTER BORROW THE CAR IF HER SISTER SORTED OUT INSURANCE AND THE SISTER IS REFUSING TO DO SO.

Inheritanceconundrum · 29/11/2023 19:11

Of course she doesn't want her expensive car to get damaged.

Why is that unreasonable?

What is unreasonable is the very low chance of it getting damaged versus her relationship further deteriorating with her sister and her parents. It comes across as being precious. The assumption is that it will get damaged, which seems pretty unlikely if her sister just drives it slowly up the venue driveway. I just think that it's unreasonable to put your relationship with possessions above that of close family. But maybe I'm biased because I view cars just as things and not as status symbols and my sibling is currently terminally ill, which really gets you to reassess what is really important in life.

As I said, the sister should pay for insurance and do the leg work, but the OP could still invest a little time in offering to help with this. I recently added a relative as a named driver to my policy and it cost me nothing to do so. It took about 10 minutes to do so.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 29/11/2023 18:52

@Inheritanceconundrum

I don’t think op is being precious at all, yes it’s a lump of metal, an expensive lump of metal and with that comes legal responsibilities.
Driving another car on your own insurance is third party only. Meaning op would lose out if ops sister wrecked it.
Assuming ops sister has insurance that offers this, not all do.

FeeBee73 · 29/11/2023 17:38

If she must be there, she can follow you up in her own car or go early and walk up the drive and wait for him to get out. No way I would let anyone drive my car, especially uninsured.

ironorchids · 29/11/2023 16:27

Ask for an illegal favour in advance of this event and see what they say.

sixteenfurryfeet · 29/11/2023 16:06

they've been plotting this arrival since he joined this college.

Oh really? Then they've had plenty of time to buy their own fancy car, haven't they? But no... they just assumed you'd willingly hand over your car keys so she could drive it.

Merida46 · 29/11/2023 15:59

If you let somebody drive your car knowing that they don't have insurance you will both be breaking the law and liable to get six points on your licence as well as a huge increase in your insurance premium. You should also tell her to Fuck right off!!

GingerNutMe · 29/11/2023 11:59

You are not being unreasonable at all - far from it. I would maybe (and guess you've already done this) reaffirm that you are more than happy to drive him there so that he gets the grand entrance she was looking for and that she should make her own way there in advance so that she can capture the arrival on camera, giving them a lasting memory of the occasion. Yorik and his Mrs can but out!

RantyAnty · 29/11/2023 09:57

She's being a CF.

Too much drama when I reckon you have your own things to do near Christmas.

Tell her to hire a car like any normal person would do but shes a CF and wants one for free.

PuzzledObserver · 29/11/2023 09:21

The cheapest way to insure the car would be to add her as a temporary additional driver to OP’s policy. I did this with my sister for a road trip, it cost less than £7 for 5 days. Not a Jag, though.

The thing is - OP would need to make the change and her sister would need to divulge claims and convictions. Maybe that’s the stumbling block. Getting the quote wouldn’t take long, may well be able to do it on the insurer’s website and would take 5 minutes.

Anyhow - without insurance, it’s a No. It just is.

chaosmaker · 29/11/2023 08:31

Tell them to rent a car for the day, if you haven't already. Then she can drive any fancy thing she likes for no reason at all

MargotBamborough · 29/11/2023 08:16

Inheritanceconundrum · 28/11/2023 20:46

Yes they are being cheeky, but I think that the real reason you don't like it is that you are a bit precious about your car. You just don't want anyone else driving it in case it gets damaged. Most insurance allows occasional use by an unnamed driver with permission. I get the feeling that you would still feel uncomfortable if she drove it, even if she paid for the insurance. You probably give the impression that you consider yourself to be a better driver by refusing to allow her to drive. That said, I really have little understanding for people's obsessions with their cars (or any cars for that matter). It's just a lump of metal that gets you from A to B.

Of course she doesn't want her expensive car to get damaged.

Why is that unreasonable?

MargotBamborough · 29/11/2023 08:13

Inheritanceconundrum · 28/11/2023 21:04

Having found out that it's your sister, I'm afraid that you come across even less well. I don't really understand the whole sibling rivalry thing really. I would at least take the time to check the terms of your policy and then, if she's interested still, get her to look up a short term quote. If you're happy to drive, then drive to the venue, whilst she follows in the car, and then let her take over on private property where it will be quieter. Instead you are both being fairly stubborn here and creating issues that could lead to further resentment. This could easily be resolved if she did the leg work re the insurance quote and you were a bit more accommodating.

How is the OP not coming across well when she's said her sister can borrow the car if she's willing to get herself insured on it? I'm not sure what the point of doing all the work to get a short term quote would be when the sister has already said she isn't willing to pay it.

Driving it uninsured on private land might not be breaking the law but she could still drive it into a ditch or reverse into a fence.

Agreeing to let her drive it if she pays for the short term insurance is way way more generous than I or I expect most people would be.

The sister is asking for a massive favour and if there is any legwork to be done to make it possible, it's very much on her to do it.

Nofilteritwonthelp · 29/11/2023 01:57

Well she doesn't want to pay for the insurance and she doesn't want to be driven, so it's her that's the CF. You can't ask to use something then dictate your own terms!

IShouldntPostBut · 29/11/2023 00:41

For a name that starts with the letter "Y", how about "Yabu"?

JulianFawcettMP · 28/11/2023 23:35

Inheritanceconundrum · 28/11/2023 21:04

Having found out that it's your sister, I'm afraid that you come across even less well. I don't really understand the whole sibling rivalry thing really. I would at least take the time to check the terms of your policy and then, if she's interested still, get her to look up a short term quote. If you're happy to drive, then drive to the venue, whilst she follows in the car, and then let her take over on private property where it will be quieter. Instead you are both being fairly stubborn here and creating issues that could lead to further resentment. This could easily be resolved if she did the leg work re the insurance quote and you were a bit more accommodating.

But she isn't doing the legwork. How is that the fault of the OP in any way? I'm interested to hear your views

dishwasherquestion · 28/11/2023 22:12

Ywain - good solid Welsh Y name there.

TiredCatLady · 28/11/2023 21:30

You mention Zara’s Manoeuvring skills (or lack thereof) and outright refusal to source insurance… I wonder does Zara maybe have a few points on the license and wouldn’t be able to get said insurance… Ho hum.

YANBU - doesn’t matter if it’s a Punto or a Porsche. No insurance, no drive.

KindaProm · 28/11/2023 21:14

Slightly worried about her skills, but still willing to risk it for my nephew and sister**

OP posts:
FiddleLeaf · 28/11/2023 21:13

I’d be conveniently away with my car.

KindaProm · 28/11/2023 21:13

@Inheritanceconundrum I'm really not being stubborn.

What you've suggested is practically what I've suggested. Get yourself insurance, and you're welcome. Though I'm slightly worried about her maneuvering skills.

She's being resolute regarding not needing insurance.

I'm certainly (and have been since it was requested) content for her to do it with a caveat of insurance.

OP posts:
Inheritanceconundrum · 28/11/2023 21:04

Having found out that it's your sister, I'm afraid that you come across even less well. I don't really understand the whole sibling rivalry thing really. I would at least take the time to check the terms of your policy and then, if she's interested still, get her to look up a short term quote. If you're happy to drive, then drive to the venue, whilst she follows in the car, and then let her take over on private property where it will be quieter. Instead you are both being fairly stubborn here and creating issues that could lead to further resentment. This could easily be resolved if she did the leg work re the insurance quote and you were a bit more accommodating.

Inheritanceconundrum · 28/11/2023 20:46

Yes they are being cheeky, but I think that the real reason you don't like it is that you are a bit precious about your car. You just don't want anyone else driving it in case it gets damaged. Most insurance allows occasional use by an unnamed driver with permission. I get the feeling that you would still feel uncomfortable if she drove it, even if she paid for the insurance. You probably give the impression that you consider yourself to be a better driver by refusing to allow her to drive. That said, I really have little understanding for people's obsessions with their cars (or any cars for that matter). It's just a lump of metal that gets you from A to B.

Potaitapotartaproata · 28/11/2023 20:17

Yanis

BellaTheDarkOverlord · 28/11/2023 20:15

Irresponsible to consider allowing her to drive your cat 🐈‍⬛

Swipe left for the next trending thread