Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is CF and inappropriate and say no?

419 replies

KindaProm · 27/11/2023 11:41

Well actually, I've already said no, and I'm getting a lot of attitude from various folk about my response sadly. So I'm here on AIBU to check myself.

A close family member, Zara has a son, Xander 17 who is at a specialist sixth form.

Every Christmas the school has a Very Fancy Christmas Event for Year 13 that all the children make massive efforts for. Think red carpet, photos, lovely food and entertainment.

They like to arrive in style.

I have a nice car. Zara would like to drive Xander in it to the event.

She's not willing to pay for insurance to drive it, and I'm not willing to fund her, so I've refused. She's not a great maneouverer anyway and I'd be concerned that she'd damage it.

She's having a hissy fit because I've RUINED his evening, they've been plotting this arrival since he joined this College. News to me, I was asked at the weekend for the event at the end of term.

Another close family member, Wilma, has called me several times to cajole, persuade and finally berate me for not allowing Zara to have this pleasure. Yes it's all about Zara, not Xander.

Wilma's DH, Vince, has also started trying to persuade me to let Zara drive it just in the grounds of the event, as its private property and insurance is almost irrelevant at that point.

I'm still saying no. Even if I'd consider it, what would I do whole she drove it on the grounds? Stand at the roadside like a plum while she pootles up the driveway?
How's she going to get to the venue?

I've offered to drive him myself but nope, not good enough; Zara needs to be there.

I'm not being unreasonable am I?

And Wilma and Vince need to stick out of it, don't they?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RantyAnty · 02/12/2023 20:22

LovelyDaaling · 01/12/2023 14:38

It makes you want to trade your car in this week for a Nissan micra.

Haha have done that.

Imreallytiredandanxioustoday · 02/12/2023 13:18

Inheritanceconundrum · 28/11/2023 20:46

Yes they are being cheeky, but I think that the real reason you don't like it is that you are a bit precious about your car. You just don't want anyone else driving it in case it gets damaged. Most insurance allows occasional use by an unnamed driver with permission. I get the feeling that you would still feel uncomfortable if she drove it, even if she paid for the insurance. You probably give the impression that you consider yourself to be a better driver by refusing to allow her to drive. That said, I really have little understanding for people's obsessions with their cars (or any cars for that matter). It's just a lump of metal that gets you from A to B.

Most insurance certainly do not allow this.
Every driver needs a minimum of third party cover so duster would need a driver other vehicles extension which won't protect OPs car at all. Some policies don't even offer this cover.

Driving with no proper comprehensive cover would be a bad idea for all concerned and as an insurance claims handler I'd never risk it because the costs can be insane.

LovelyDaaling · 01/12/2023 14:38

It makes you want to trade your car in this week for a Nissan micra.

FloydPepper · 01/12/2023 14:31

Mazuslongtoenail · 27/11/2023 11:44

You offered to drive, that’s the reasonable thing to do. So you’ve been more than fair.

This

if it were about the son, your offer would be taken up. As it’s not, and it hasn’t been, not much more you can do.

id happily point this offer out to anyone saying you’re being unfair.

Stellamari · 01/12/2023 14:16

I can’t believe anyone would expect someone to let them drive their car uninsured.

When mine were in the 6th form, it was all the rage to hire a limousine with chauffeur between a few of them and turn up in that. Couldn’t Yves’ mum do that?

Tomelette · 30/11/2023 21:29

sueelleker · 30/11/2023 17:03

Anyone else thinking that Inheritanceconundrum may be Zara?

Yep.

socialdilemmawhattodo · 30/11/2023 20:08

Inheritanceconundrum · 28/11/2023 20:46

Yes they are being cheeky, but I think that the real reason you don't like it is that you are a bit precious about your car. You just don't want anyone else driving it in case it gets damaged. Most insurance allows occasional use by an unnamed driver with permission. I get the feeling that you would still feel uncomfortable if she drove it, even if she paid for the insurance. You probably give the impression that you consider yourself to be a better driver by refusing to allow her to drive. That said, I really have little understanding for people's obsessions with their cars (or any cars for that matter). It's just a lump of metal that gets you from A to B.

I have a very expensive 2nd car. 4 years old - and hasn't dropped a penny in value. So yes I am fucking precious about my car. Mine isnt a lump. It is gorgeous. So gorgeous even I rarely drive it. There are only about 1500 of my cars in the UK. So no way EVER would I be "lending" mine to a CF. My son - driving licence - in the motor trade - keeps asking. The only promise I make is that I will ask the insurance broker to quote. Hysterical - insurance sky high. I am old, clean licence and even my insurance is far too much for how much I drive the car. I truly think you have no real idea as to how much insurance costs on a "fun" car.

TinkerTiger · 30/11/2023 17:54

Can’t decide yet until I hear Ursula and Yvette’s take on this whole affair.

SlowerMovingVehicle · 30/11/2023 17:34

Yabu for not telling your dsis to f right off as soon as she refused to pay the insurance. And the same to the CFs wading in. CF of the year 2023 group award.

sueelleker · 30/11/2023 17:03

Anyone else thinking that Inheritanceconundrum may be Zara?

JoanOfAllTrades · 30/11/2023 14:38

Daffodilsandtuplips · 30/11/2023 14:29

I don’t know where op lives but it’s been snowing overnight here in North East England, it was snowing when I wrote my post at 09.00 am. One road was closed yesterday morning due to ice.

Ah well, in that case, I definitely do not blame OP for refusing to let sister borrow the car! The mind boggles....no insurance and a possibly erratic driver 🙄

Daffodilsandtuplips · 30/11/2023 14:29

JoanOfAllTrades · 30/11/2023 14:17

I'm going to take a stab in the dark (it's the middle of the night here, well early hours of the morning to split a hair, so a pun!), but isn't it snowing, or at least icy on the roads? Or is it too early still?

I don’t know where op lives but it’s been snowing overnight here in North East England, it was snowing when I wrote my post at 09.00 am. One road was closed yesterday morning due to ice.

JoanOfAllTrades · 30/11/2023 14:17

Daffodilsandtuplips · 30/11/2023 09:52

Op mentions the venue is fifteen miles away plus a private drive of one mile in the grounds of said venue. 16 miles return is 32 miles. That is more than a few minutes of driving, it could be 40 minutes to an hour or more, depending on road and weather conditions. Where I live these venues tend to be in big estate Mansion houses converted to Hotels, usually in rural locations and rural usually means narrow unlit roads.

I'm going to take a stab in the dark (it's the middle of the night here, well early hours of the morning to split a hair, so a pun!), but isn't it snowing, or at least icy on the roads? Or is it too early still?

JoanOfAllTrades · 30/11/2023 14:11

Inheritanceconundrum · 29/11/2023 19:11

Of course she doesn't want her expensive car to get damaged.

Why is that unreasonable?

What is unreasonable is the very low chance of it getting damaged versus her relationship further deteriorating with her sister and her parents. It comes across as being precious. The assumption is that it will get damaged, which seems pretty unlikely if her sister just drives it slowly up the venue driveway. I just think that it's unreasonable to put your relationship with possessions above that of close family. But maybe I'm biased because I view cars just as things and not as status symbols and my sibling is currently terminally ill, which really gets you to reassess what is really important in life.

As I said, the sister should pay for insurance and do the leg work, but the OP could still invest a little time in offering to help with this. I recently added a relative as a named driver to my policy and it cost me nothing to do so. It took about 10 minutes to do so.

Do you know OP then? Or her sister? Actually, unless you do know her sister, and you've sited her drivers licence and insurance history, how can possibly know what the chances of the car getting damaged are?

You know nothing of the sister's driving history, the sister has already stated her refusal to get insurance and since you don't know how many other teens are attending the ball, you can't know how busy the venue roads will be, nor can you vouch for the driving skills of the other drivers.

I see absolutely no evidence that the OP views her car as anything other than a nice car that she treated herself too, having worked hard to pay for it; the only person viewing this car as a status symbol is the sister.

This plan has been in the pipeline for at least a year, if not longer! The sister could have easily saved up the money for a rental car, or a chauffeur driven vehicle - she chose not too! It isn't for OP to bail her sister out. OP offered to drive her nephew, this offer was refused.

The sister wants to be seen in the car. For her, the car is a status symbol. She doesn't give a darn if the car is damaged, hence her refusal to get insurance.

The car may only be a vehicle to get from A to B, but it's OP's A to B carrier! And you can bet your life that if something did happen to the car, the sister would refuse to pay for it, instead she would probably blame OP for letting her drive the car, knowing that she doesn't drive performance cars often, if at all!

I'm very sorry about your sibling 🌺

Daffodilsandtuplips · 30/11/2023 09:52

Op mentions the venue is fifteen miles away plus a private drive of one mile in the grounds of said venue. 16 miles return is 32 miles. That is more than a few minutes of driving, it could be 40 minutes to an hour or more, depending on road and weather conditions. Where I live these venues tend to be in big estate Mansion houses converted to Hotels, usually in rural locations and rural usually means narrow unlit roads.

squirrelnutkin10 · 30/11/2023 09:39

'The cat is a jaguar.'

now it has got interesting...😂

T1Dmama · 30/11/2023 09:30

JulianFawcettMP · 28/11/2023 23:35

But she isn't doing the legwork. How is that the fault of the OP in any way? I'm interested to hear your views

I get the impression that @Inheritanceconundrum jasmt read the post properly.
Do people not realise that driving without insurance is illegal? Or that a
crash even on private property is a crash?? The damage isn’t non existent just because it’s on private property!! Cars are expensive, I learnt the hard way NEVER to lend my car out again, to anyone!

T1Dmama · 30/11/2023 09:22

100% not unreasonable!!I leant out a car once to a friend and she crashed it! Never got a penny back from her and the car was practically written off. We lost so much money on it because she was only 3rd party on it!

vernatheraven · 29/11/2023 20:16

OhComeOnFFS · 27/11/2023 12:35

Does she want to pretend the car is hers, then?

I reckon this is the main reason

justagirlmum · 29/11/2023 20:00

YANBU.
I can never understand other people's sense of entitlement with things like this! So weird. You're definitely not in the wrong OP! Stand your ground

Qwertyme · 29/11/2023 19:54

Search FB for "free prom cars and special occasions"

Pass on the link and turn off your notifications from Zara.

MargotBamborough · 29/11/2023 19:39

Inheritanceconundrum · 29/11/2023 19:30

@MargotBamborough

No need to shout dear, I'm not deaf. Nor blind. And yes I did read it. I just wasn't entirely buying the narrative and felt that both parties could have done more to facilitate things. The OP said that she didn't look into the details of her policy after her sister dismissed her stipulation of her paying for insurance. Personally, I would have checked out whether that was absolutely necessary first before stipulating it. I was allowed to temporarily switch named drivers on my policy for no additional charge. Perhaps her sister felt that the OP was being a bit difficult or that her tone was derisery. After all, we know that she refers to her sister as the golden child. I just think that life is too short for disputes like this.

So, the OP said that her sister (whose driving she doesn't entirely trust) COULD borrow her expensive car if she covered the cost of putting herself on the insurance.

The sister said no, she wasn't willing to cover the cost.

Then the OP offered to drive her nephew to prom herself so he could be seen by his mates getting out of the swish car.

The sister said no, she wanted to be the one driving. But not badly enough to pay to get herself put on the insurance, apparently.

Sorry, what exactly do you think the OP should have done to "facilitate" this?

I think she's already bent over backwards actually.

Are you suggesting that she should either pay whatever it costs to put her sister on the insurance or let her drive it uninsured?

Why?

MargotBamborough · 29/11/2023 19:33

Inheritanceconundrum · 29/11/2023 19:23

I also think that responses here have been skewed as a result of the way that the facts have been presented. Firstly through use of the CF term. Everyone knows that mumsnet start frothing at the mouth at the first mention of a CF. Also, the deliberate omission of it being her sister didn't help and caused a biased presentation. The post would have been received slightly differently, in my opinion, had she asked whether she should lend her car to her sister for a few minutes to take her son up the drive to the prom. The OP has presented herself as being reasonable by ensuring that she has said how much she loves her nephew. Meanwhile her sister is dubbed the CF golden child, so cast in a deliberately poor light. She is criticised for wanting to be with her own son at the prom, rather than his auntie taking him (which given the evident hostility between the two, would be disappointing to hear). Posters have described her as pretentious for wanting to borrow a nice car for a special occasion. No one has accused the OP as being pretentious for owning the car in the first place. It just strikes me as a biased narrative and that this boils down to typical sibling rivalry/tensions.

But the question isn't whether she should be willing to lend her sister her very expensive car for a few minutes.

The question is whether she is unreasonable to refuse to let her sister drive her very expensive car for a few minutes without insurance, which would be a driving offence for both of them.

I don't see how pointing out that people might have answered differently if she had asked a completely different question is relevant. Neither is it relevant whether it is her sister asking her to commit a crime or anyone else.

It's also not relevant whether you think the OP is pretentious for owning a nice car. Owning a nice car, unlike driving without insurance, is not a crime.

Inheritanceconundrum · 29/11/2023 19:30

@MargotBamborough

No need to shout dear, I'm not deaf. Nor blind. And yes I did read it. I just wasn't entirely buying the narrative and felt that both parties could have done more to facilitate things. The OP said that she didn't look into the details of her policy after her sister dismissed her stipulation of her paying for insurance. Personally, I would have checked out whether that was absolutely necessary first before stipulating it. I was allowed to temporarily switch named drivers on my policy for no additional charge. Perhaps her sister felt that the OP was being a bit difficult or that her tone was derisery. After all, we know that she refers to her sister as the golden child. I just think that life is too short for disputes like this.

Inheritanceconundrum · 29/11/2023 19:23

I also think that responses here have been skewed as a result of the way that the facts have been presented. Firstly through use of the CF term. Everyone knows that mumsnet start frothing at the mouth at the first mention of a CF. Also, the deliberate omission of it being her sister didn't help and caused a biased presentation. The post would have been received slightly differently, in my opinion, had she asked whether she should lend her car to her sister for a few minutes to take her son up the drive to the prom. The OP has presented herself as being reasonable by ensuring that she has said how much she loves her nephew. Meanwhile her sister is dubbed the CF golden child, so cast in a deliberately poor light. She is criticised for wanting to be with her own son at the prom, rather than his auntie taking him (which given the evident hostility between the two, would be disappointing to hear). Posters have described her as pretentious for wanting to borrow a nice car for a special occasion. No one has accused the OP as being pretentious for owning the car in the first place. It just strikes me as a biased narrative and that this boils down to typical sibling rivalry/tensions.