Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tenancy inspection today - can they say anything about a messy house?

286 replies

YorkshirePuddingBelongs · 27/11/2023 10:00

I have a tenancy inspection this afternoon - my landlord is a nasty prick, his DD is doing the inspection. It’s a long story but he’s been awful, sending me harassing emails, making threats and breaking the Tenancy Fees Act as well as his part of the tenancy agreement. I move next month, thank god, but he’s 100% out to get me - and I think he has likely briefed his DD to look for problems.

There is no damage in the house bar a scuff or 2 on the walls (it’s an old house with tiny narrow staircases and this was from carrying the bed up - he’s seen them before and said it’s fine it always gets scuffed). But we’ve been going through some stuff and I haven’t had time to spring clean line I always do. I have a horrible feeling she will comment on the mess. It’s mostly things like the bathtub and shower needs a clean, the kids’ rooms need a hoover etc. but I KNOW they will be looking for problems because they’ve heavily hinted at it, sending me messages about “if there’s damage you haven’t reported you will be liable for the costs” etc.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BrumLandlord2026 · 09/11/2026 09:23

Hi, I am a landlord in Birmingham, and I wanted to add the landlord side of this, because a lot of the replies here are missing the difference between messy and dirty.
Messy is not the same as damage, and messy is not the same as dirty. Toys on the floor, shoes in the hall, laundry baskets, boxes in the living room, that is how a house looks when a 4-year-old lives there, and when life has been hard for a few weeks. No decent landlord is going to say anything about that, and no decent landlord is going to use that against you.
What a landlord is actually looking for during an inspection is damage, damp, and safety. Is there a leak under a sink, is there damp or mould in a bathroom, are the smoke and carbon monoxide alarms working, is the heating working, and is the condition of the property the same as the check-in inventory, with dated photos. The inspection takes 15 to 20 minutes for the first one, then 5 to 10 minutes after that, and it is not a test of how tidy you are.
That said, and I say this kindly, if the house is so messy that the inspector cannot see the floors, or cannot get to the boiler, or cannot see if there is damp behind the boxes, then the mess does become a problem, because the inspector cannot do their job properly. A quick tidy of the worst areas, and a clean kitchen and bathroom, is enough. Nobody expects a show home.
To the OP, I hope the inspection went ok, and I hope things are easier for you now. You are not being unreasonable to expect that your home is your home, and your mess is your mess, as long as the property itself is looked after.

NumberTheory · 02/12/2023 15:28

NigellaAwesome · 02/12/2023 09:32

I think there is a fair amount of misunderstanding about landlord's rights to inspect.

If it is in the contract, it is legally binding. The difference is that the landlord cannot unilaterally enforce this if the tenant does not agree.

In that case, the landlord can apply for a court order to enforce the legally binding contract. ** And they can seek legal costs from the tenant as a result.

While that’s the route landlords need to take to try and enforce a clause that a tenant does not keep to, not everything put in a contract is legally binding. Clauses that are unfair or remove statutory rights, for instance, are not legally binding and will not be enforced by courts.

A court would not enforce an inspection clause if the landlord was trying to use it in a way that the court considered unfair or unreasonable.

NigellaAwesome · 02/12/2023 09:32

I think there is a fair amount of misunderstanding about landlord's rights to inspect.

If it is in the contract, it is legally binding. The difference is that the landlord cannot unilaterally enforce this if the tenant does not agree.

In that case, the landlord can apply for a court order to enforce the legally binding contract. ** And they can seek legal costs from the tenant as a result.

Teder · 01/12/2023 19:00

Landlords can include whatever they want in a contract but it’s not legally binding. They can demand you stand by your bed while they check for dust bunnies behind your sofa and crumbs in the oven. The law overrides it. Any landlords who think they have a right to inspect are automatically bad landlords. They should know better.

I own my home and have no skin in this game. The OP has been treated appallingly by some people on here. She’s not living in filth, she just hasn’t prioritised cleaning in the recent past due to a huge life change. Is it ideal? Nope but life happens. @YorkshirePuddingBelongs I hope you’re doing ok.

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 30/11/2023 15:24

Tenants pay the LL’s mortgage

On this alone you are wrong. You're not doing your LL a favour. Tenants pay to have a roof over their heads, somewhere to live and to call home. That's it. What your landlord does with the rent he or she receives is none of your business. He may not even have a mortgage.

SkySecret · 29/11/2023 22:02

I was completely with you until the carpets, OP. It’s pretty standard to have the carpets properly cleaned as part of end of tenancy. I’ve rented flats 3 times for work 2 x 6 months and 1 x 9 months. Carpet clean was always expected, and as a new tenant I’d expect them to have been cleaned. Just because you can only see one stain doesn’t mean they’re not dirty. It just means whatever else you dropped on them was see through! Shoes walking on them, dead skin, dust, spillages etc.

Clean the carpets.

NigellaAwesome · 29/11/2023 17:43

Mrsttcno1 · 29/11/2023 12:50

That is true, but if a tenant repeatedly refuses access despite communication from landlord, adequate notice given etc, then the landlord can apply to the court for an injunction to gain access. Or they can serve an eviction notice.

And the ll can also apply for a costs order. It doesn't really apply in this case as it is the end of the tenancy and the ll sounds unreasonable and harassing, but for other posters who may be considering not permitting reasonable access, it is something to think about.

Crikeyalmighty · 29/11/2023 12:55

@stilldumdedumming I must admit I've not encountered this apart from at move out in all years renting- and that's even with the odd really posh agent like Savills. yep, I do think that's going a bit far

Mrsttcno1 · 29/11/2023 12:50

That is true, but if a tenant repeatedly refuses access despite communication from landlord, adequate notice given etc, then the landlord can apply to the court for an injunction to gain access. Or they can serve an eviction notice.

lactonic · 29/11/2023 12:46

@user1497207191 A tenancy contract does not trump the law. They can choose write whatever they want into a contract, doesn't make it enforceable or lawful.

YorkshirePuddingBelongs · 29/11/2023 12:25

user1497207191 · 29/11/2023 11:47

It depends on what was in the tenancy agreement which the tenant signed. Many expressly make provision for the landlord or their agent to do inspections. If the tenant signs that, then the landlord has the right to inspect!

No, it doesn’t - landlords have no legal right of entry unless in an emergency. The law trumps contracts

OP posts:
user1497207191 · 29/11/2023 11:47

lactonic · 28/11/2023 14:49

Actually that innocrect. Landlords have no legal right to enter or inspect the property, except in the event of an emergency. Landlords are running a business, and as such, have to abide by the law. Luckily.

It depends on what was in the tenancy agreement which the tenant signed. Many expressly make provision for the landlord or their agent to do inspections. If the tenant signs that, then the landlord has the right to inspect!

stilldumdedumming · 28/11/2023 23:11

@Nanny0gg as I say my 3rd modern renter and it always happens! I must just be lucky that way! I assumed they all did it now.

Nanny0gg · 28/11/2023 22:55

stilldumdedumming · 28/11/2023 21:46

No it was my own musing! Sorry I am quite chatty but I definitely don't have OCD. Still my point stands I think. Having to say sorry it's not cleaned to a high standard (as required) and the cleaners are coming etc. That's the conversation I want to avoid. I cook all the time but I don't use the oven every day - often just the hob. The agents are nice but it's a proper stand by your beds moment. It's an actual inspection. This is my 3rd renter in my 40s and 50s and it's always like this.

I rented a lot in my 20s - and I just don't remember it being like this. Anyway sorry for detailing. I just get chatty.

I've never known a landlord inspect an oven.

NumberTheory · 28/11/2023 22:41

stilldumdedumming · 28/11/2023 21:10

@Crikeyalmighty see that's the thing. If you need an oven cleaner, then the oven is presumably dirty So genuinely, what happens if the inspection happens before the oven cleaners come? I'm not being rude but that's what I don't understand. Had my inspection today and they checked the oven (I clean it after every use and take it apart to clean it v regularly - take the glass out, inspect the shelves etc.).

I think I get about 5 days notice. I've never used cleaners- what if they can't fit you in?

If you want your landlord to renew your lease, it's understandable that you want them to think you are looking after the place to their satisfaction, because in some landlords have refused to renew and issued a notice to quit if they don't like the way the tenants are. So keeping them sweet, beyond the letter of the contract is sensible.

But OP is already leaving. She has given notice. She has no reason to go beyond her enforceable, contractual obligations. She does not need to please the landlord. Barring a few extreme examples, the landlord cannot hold OP accountable for keeping the place clean during the tenancy. Only on cleaning or repairing things at the end of the tenancy and, even then, only to a standard the TDS concurs with.

NigellaAwesome · 28/11/2023 21:59

Op you have had a bit of a kicking here by some posters. Poor show, especially in light of what you are going through.

I am a landlord, and yours sounds v unprofessional, especially the comments about getting the regulars to spy on you.

I do think that a pre end of tenancy inspection can be beneficial as it can head off problems and set expectations, but if this is what he intended, he hasn't gone about it well if he is making up bs about checking rain goods (although that is definitely something I check regularly - gutters, downpipes etc as huge amounts of damage can be caused if not cleared).

In terms of scuffs on the hall wall, it depends how bad they are. A couple of minor ones are likely to be classed as wear and tear - huge scuffs going up the length of the stairs are more likely to be classed as damage. I would suggest getting wall erasers, like Doktor Power, and very gently trying to remove. I wouldn't try to touch up with paint as it usually looks awful.

Re the carpets - I don't think it reasonable to suggest you get them cleaned, although if there is a stain, I would suggest you spot clean it.

I was at a recent event held by one of the deposit scheme companies in which they explained their decision making around deposit disputes. They differentiated between reasonable wear and tear (not deductible) and cleaning, which is deductible. I wouldn't give the ll any ammunition to withhold your deposit. Clean thoroughly and take your own photos and video - many more than you think you need. Review what is stated in the tenancy agreement.

It may be worth checking what documents you were provided at the start of the tenancy - EPC, gas certificate, inventory all come to mind. If you haven't been given these it would strengthen your negotiating position if he tries to withhold the deposit. Are you based in England? There are slight variations in legislation if you are in NI, Scotland or Wales.

stilldumdedumming · 28/11/2023 21:46

No it was my own musing! Sorry I am quite chatty but I definitely don't have OCD. Still my point stands I think. Having to say sorry it's not cleaned to a high standard (as required) and the cleaners are coming etc. That's the conversation I want to avoid. I cook all the time but I don't use the oven every day - often just the hob. The agents are nice but it's a proper stand by your beds moment. It's an actual inspection. This is my 3rd renter in my 40s and 50s and it's always like this.

I rented a lot in my 20s - and I just don't remember it being like this. Anyway sorry for detailing. I just get chatty.

Squiggles23 · 28/11/2023 21:34

stilldumdedumming · 28/11/2023 21:10

@Crikeyalmighty see that's the thing. If you need an oven cleaner, then the oven is presumably dirty So genuinely, what happens if the inspection happens before the oven cleaners come? I'm not being rude but that's what I don't understand. Had my inspection today and they checked the oven (I clean it after every use and take it apart to clean it v regularly - take the glass out, inspect the shelves etc.).

I think I get about 5 days notice. I've never used cleaners- what if they can't fit you in?

You are nuts. If you are cleaning your oven every day you have severe OCD or severely need a life. Either way it’s not OPs issue.

stilldumdedumming · 28/11/2023 21:10

@Crikeyalmighty great username btw!

stilldumdedumming · 28/11/2023 21:10

@Crikeyalmighty see that's the thing. If you need an oven cleaner, then the oven is presumably dirty So genuinely, what happens if the inspection happens before the oven cleaners come? I'm not being rude but that's what I don't understand. Had my inspection today and they checked the oven (I clean it after every use and take it apart to clean it v regularly - take the glass out, inspect the shelves etc.).

I think I get about 5 days notice. I've never used cleaners- what if they can't fit you in?

Crikeyalmighty · 28/11/2023 20:25

@Myfabby might suggest my LL gets me some too- I've got the oven cleaners coming next week and between March and early November have a gardener every 3 weeks to keep it straight (big garden) - I've had 2 inspections since November last year and another one due in a few weeks- I have no issue because it's nicely kept and it's a beautiful house in a lovely area. It looks lived in but in order and agent commented how lovely but homely it was .

If it was my house I admit I would be doing the same- consequently we have good references over many many years and are always picked if we are competing. I know it sounds a bit smug but these days it doesn't pay to not play the game a bit- because choice isn't great

I've had a couple of LLs who were not great, one who thought it was ok to just let himself in with no notice when we were 2 days late paying the rent - due to being paid late. I reported him to the agent (he was a very high up public figure too)

Another who was terrible for repairs of any kind and we rented direct (have never done this since)

But asking to do an inspection a couple of times a year I don't personally feel is harassment. If you don't let them do it then they are more likely to hassle you surely

Amchoor · 28/11/2023 20:15

Myfabby · 28/11/2023 18:55

Gonna send my tenants champagne for Christmas. I didn't know how good I have it!

And you're still here. Filthy oven. Scuffs on walls. Gross bathroom. Sigh

Edited

Why do you feel the need to speak to someone like this? What do you gain from posting horrible things to people who are already struggling? Does it make you feel good about yourself? The OP is clearly having a shit time at the moment, her marriage has broken down and her daughter is struggling with her mental health. And you have kept going on at her, being increasingly rude and accusing her of being the aggressive one.

vivainsomnia · 28/11/2023 20:13

I don't understand why 6ou started this thread. Whether they would seem the house messy or not, you've made it clear over the pages that you don't care at all.

And indeed, if as you've gone to insist, that the house is not that bad, then why would you care what they think?

You keep going on about how you don't care what they think, that all that matters is how you return it (which is absolutely correct), so again, why did you post in the first place?

YorkshirePuddingBelongs · 28/11/2023 20:07

Myfabby · 28/11/2023 18:55

Gonna send my tenants champagne for Christmas. I didn't know how good I have it!

And you're still here. Filthy oven. Scuffs on walls. Gross bathroom. Sigh

Edited

Send them my condolences while you’re at it. And perhaps get therapy for your OTT hygiene anxiety

OP posts:
HippyDays · 28/11/2023 20:04

This thread is batshit. OP YANBU and glad you are a) standing up for yourself and b) getting out of there.
Also hope your daughter is ok (or son, I can’t remember and can’t be arsed to check back through batshittery).

I’m a typical MN hygiene clean freak and I still think this is all batshit!