Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is he cheating or have I lost my mind

655 replies

TheFrame · 27/11/2023 01:37

My husband and I have been together for 10 years, he is 34 I'm 32, we have 4 children ( 5, 3, 2 and 6 months).
Lately our life has been upside down. My parents are both ill, my dad has Alzheimers, my mum has cancer. Our eldest has autism and so much more. For DHs work we need to live in London, for the price of a 5 bed up north I'm in a 3 bed terrace with barely enough room to swing a cat, our youngest wasn't planned.
In the spring I noticed something was off with my husband, he seemed detached, I thought maybe it's the new baby? Maybe it's my parents being ill? Who knows. He always went for drinks on a Thursday after work for as long as I've known him, finish work at 5 couple of drinks and home no later than 8. It slowly started changing, 8.30/9/9.30 there's been a few times where it's been as late as 2am usually no later than 10.30 though. He used to want to have sex as soon as he got in from drinks, but that changed too. I spoke to him about it but he said he was tired. At this point I'm thinking fair enough.
Then he started going in on Mondays - he could work from home and there is no flexitime on Mondays so it's a long day 8-5:30 so I didn't think it made sense but the baby was distracting he said.
Then it was one of these Mondays where he message at 4 (so before he could actually finish) and said "tube delays will be late". I looked on the TfL app - only the central line was delayed, he doesn't use it for work ever!!
Now I'm suspicious but say nothing.
A few weeks later he tells me he forgot to tap out at the station could I log in and pay the fare. It showed me when I logged in the stations he is starting and finishing his journey at.
Tuesday and Wednesday are fine, tapping out at Green Park where he works - all good.
But on Mondays he's been tapping out and back in at Russel Square - for those that know London, you'll know this isn't near Green Park where he works. On Thursday he's been tapping in the evening at either Russel Square or Holborn. I'll assume he's walked there or something?
Suddenly I remember he works with a girl who lives around there, I remember as I once said "I don't know any one who lives properly central" he told me a girl he worked with lives between Farringdon and Chancery Lane .... which is near Russell Square and Holborn !!
I asked him about it and he told me he was working from a WeWork space around there on Monday and Thursday evenings as he found the baby distracting but didn't want to be in office? I didn't believe it for a second, bur said whatever. He must have realised I was suspicious and started sending me the confirmation of his booking for the WeWork space. I let it go as really I don't have any more evidence... this was 2/3 months ago.

Fast forward to a month ago, I ask to borrow his bank card, he tells me it's in the front of his work bag, I take out the card and I find a condom in there too!! While we do use them ... why in his work bag? I ask he claims must have been there for a while. Makes me feel a bit crazy for thinking.

Just to be nosey I guess, I try to find the girl who lived around the other area on Instagram. Didn't take long she's barely 23, stupidly beautiful which made me feel inferior!! Accounts on public, I'll be honest I made a fake account to watch her stories, I didn't want her to see me watching and alert DH. Every Monday she posts a story, of DH across from her at the WeWork place, with some stupid caption. When I ask if he works alone on Mondays he says yes?!
Then the last couple of Thursday evenings she has posted on her story something like a picture of two glasses of wine and a caption like "yes wine and dine me honey" never see the guy she is with, but in one you could see his hand, and I swear it was my DHs (the rings and the watch strap) he has quite an obvious ring as it has sand from our honeymoon in it using resin, so I know it off the top of my head.
I told him all this last week and he said yeah she comes for work drinks with us too and thought I was psychotic for checking her instagram. He let me read the messages between them on the phone and all seemed innocent. Went back as far as 2021, on WhatsApp, IMessage and Instagram. He said he's never messaged her on Facebook.
There was nothing untoward just work things occasional meme.
On Thursday before he went to work I checked the front pocket of his bag there were two condoms (swear there was one the last time when I was looking for his card). Looked again when he got home and there was only one!!
Now today he said he was going for lunch with work friends. I asked where he told me whatever. I checked her story again, and from looking at the decor of where she was and where he said they were doing it was the same place, it's also obvious in her post it's a table for 2!!
When he got back I checked the front of his bag again (as he took his work bag to lunch but fair enough he takes it practically everywhere like Dora the bloody explorer) and there were now 0 condoms ?!!!!!
I don't think I can tell him I've been snooping in his bag without knowing for sure I'm right.

But he's having an affair isn't he? Im not unreasonable to think that right? What the heck do I? Feel like a detective trying to figure it all out !!!

OP posts:
LaurieStrode · 30/11/2023 02:41

People need to own the outcomes of their choices. I do, and expect others to, as well.

GodDammitCecil · 30/11/2023 03:06

With all due respect, no-one cares what you expect.

You’re a faceless random on the Internet. I don’t say this to be unkind. I say it as the objective truth.

People are human and flawed. You certainly are. You may well ‘own the outcome of your choices’ but that doesn’t make you a better person than anyone else. Especially when the end result of that is being unkind and unhelpful to a person in need.

Now. Let’s get back to constructively supporting the OP.

UtterlyButterly2048 · 30/11/2023 06:15

RandomForest · 29/11/2023 23:29

Well there we are @LaurieStrode you've just presented your own example how communication can break down through lack of respect.

Yes you were being honest, just as op's husband was, but were you kind ?

I very much doubt op's h was abusive from the day dot, we take things with a pinch of salt, selfish maybe, becoming increasingly worse as each child tied her to him.
Abuse doesn't happen overnight and it's not always about choosing the right partner, in many cases it is luck, many very intellegent women have unfortunately found themselves at the mercy of very cruel men.

It is not a crime to choose someone who turns out to be abusive, that is exactly the type of reasoning, "you've made your bed now lie in it" that needs to be avoided, as it keeps vunerable, exhausted, chrushed with no self esteem women feeling they can never escape or survive on their own, it can make them feel the world is a worse place than the hell they have at home.

Support and kindness goes along way to build confidence.

Op, I hope you come back, your husband is intoxicated by his own power and I can imagine how painful this is for you, the stages are very predictable, he has gone, maybe you are desperate to have him back if only for the rest and support, maybe some trauma bonding.

Whatever, you can come back to this thread and we will support and protect you, we know how vunerable you are feeling at the moment.
Take care Flowers

Agree wholeheartedly with this. And @LaurieStrode if you can honestly say you have never misjudged a person in your life, if you have never had the wool pulled over your eyes by anyone, ever, I suggest you bobby off and polish your halo. Most of us on here have enough self awareness and life experience to understand exactly how we can be, and have been, deceived at times by people we truly believed loved and cared about us. And how utterly devastating that can be. Op, I hope you’ve managed to get some IRL support, that you’ve eaten a bit and slept a bit and are hanging in there. Impossible as it seems, try not to think about him now. Focus on what you and your dc need in this minute, this hour, this day. Step by step you will absolutely rise like a fucking phoenix from this and we are all behind you, cheering you on xxxx

CandyLeBonBon · 30/11/2023 07:06

LaurieStrode · 30/11/2023 02:41

People need to own the outcomes of their choices. I do, and expect others to, as well.

Oh bore off and be a superior sanctimonious arse somewhere else!

jelly79 · 30/11/2023 07:41

LaurieStrode · 30/11/2023 02:41

People need to own the outcomes of their choices. I do, and expect others to, as well.

Does this mean if someone blindsides you? Breaks your heart? Changes? Hurts you and rips your family apart, you are not allowed to be devastated?

Didimum · 30/11/2023 08:08

@LaurieStrode

he's an arrogant man with the belief he does no wrong (not just now always) he always makes it so even when he's fucked up it's not his fault and spews some self-righteous I owned up and it wasn't all my fault so let's move on shit.

Being arrogant doesn’t make you a cheater. Being self-righteous doesn’t make you a cheater. So why does OP need to ‘own her outcome’?

Could you possibly be inferring? Better work on your reading comprehension, ‘dearie’.

Calliopespa · 30/11/2023 08:13

TooTrusting · 30/11/2023 00:34

Just one more thing. Someone said upthread that OP has said she loves her H and we ought to be mindful of that. I know in these situations it's easy to give gung-ho LTB advice along with "send a screenshot to his parents/the OW/ post it on your SM". My very first friend who got divorced (20 years ago) was young and in reactive mode against a cheating H and OW. I could see it going downhill and said that I thought she ought to try to behave in away that when she looked back on it she'd be proud of how dignified she was, not embarrassed or ashamed. She has always told me that this was the best piece of advice she ever received. Don't do anything hasty and try to avoid doing anything out of revenge or a desire to show him up. I know it's hard but you'll be glad later. It's tough enough without having to regret things you wish you'd never done. I tried to apply this to myselc when I divorced several years later and was glad after the initial months had passed that I kept myself in check and didn't feed into his false narrative that it was all my fault.

I do agree with this - even though I was and sort of still am - tempted to let the OW know she is in DH’s mind “ just sex” and “ annoying” with the “crap” she posts . But realistically his parents will support him. If you reread his text, he comes out fighting at the start, refusing to apologise, but at the end he breaks down a bit more. That’s the bit his parents would see. And I think I was one who mentioned OP loved DH and I really do think it’s important not to trash him. Condemn his actions, yes. I have had people I loved treat me badly from time to time but it still hurt to head them criticised too aggressively for what they had done, and the criticism was nothing like the all out tearing apart DH has got on here. Yes, I GET it: he’s been a vile cheat. But OP can’t sever her emotions overnight and I expect this thread just got too noisy for her- with ( occasional) criticism not just of her but plenty of DH too. There are real people behind the thread ( at least I assume so 😳) who just a couple of days ago were saying they loved each other- op in her post and DH in his admittedly rather baffling text. Love is complicated and at times heartbreaking.

Caerulea · 30/11/2023 08:21

LaurieStrode · 30/11/2023 02:41

People need to own the outcomes of their choices. I do, and expect others to, as well.

Oh fuck off

(hope this stays up long enough for you see it)

GreenIsMyFavoriteColour · 30/11/2023 09:16

Am I the only one thinking that with four kids and (presumably) a mortgage a cheating Dad/Husband might be better than no Dad/Husband?

I'm assuming the pair of them aren't having screaming arguments and can manage to be friendly to each other.

The "relationship" with the 23 year old isn't going to last because he's going to be broke for 15 years and he won't want child #5 and #6. Both of which are likely to be a deal breaker for her.

It's not ideal, but neither is the alternative.

Calliopespa · 30/11/2023 09:39

GreenIsMyFavoriteColour · 30/11/2023 09:16

Am I the only one thinking that with four kids and (presumably) a mortgage a cheating Dad/Husband might be better than no Dad/Husband?

I'm assuming the pair of them aren't having screaming arguments and can manage to be friendly to each other.

The "relationship" with the 23 year old isn't going to last because he's going to be broke for 15 years and he won't want child #5 and #6. Both of which are likely to be a deal breaker for her.

It's not ideal, but neither is the alternative.

Buckle down for the onslaught: you are not allowed to say this on MN. It is tantamount to reducing women to voiceless, unthinking, downtrodden objects. Personally I wouldn’t want to persist with a cheating DH BUT I am prepared to accept some might, and I sincerely hope OP is not that way inclined as she will have been browbeaten that there is something defective and weak in her. But the argument is a single, un-nuanced note sounded loudly. There is no allowing for the fact that for some women it may be preferable for financial, practical, emotional, religious reasons or even just plain preference . And there is no space to admit that actually having the courage to choose that might be as much a manifest working out of being a self-determining, strong woman as choosing not to.

LaurieStrode · 30/11/2023 09:48

I've been thinking the same thing all along, @GreenIsMyFavoriteColour

GodDammitCecil · 30/11/2023 09:51

Don’t fancy yours much, @GreenIsMyFavoriteColour … 😕

Calliopespa · 30/11/2023 09:54

Calliopespa · 30/11/2023 09:39

Buckle down for the onslaught: you are not allowed to say this on MN. It is tantamount to reducing women to voiceless, unthinking, downtrodden objects. Personally I wouldn’t want to persist with a cheating DH BUT I am prepared to accept some might, and I sincerely hope OP is not that way inclined as she will have been browbeaten that there is something defective and weak in her. But the argument is a single, un-nuanced note sounded loudly. There is no allowing for the fact that for some women it may be preferable for financial, practical, emotional, religious reasons or even just plain preference . And there is no space to admit that actually having the courage to choose that might be as much a manifest working out of being a self-determining, strong woman as choosing not to.

To my last I would add I think the problem with your suggestion ( at least what provokes the wrath of MN) is that from the outside it looks the same outcome as when women didn’t have the choice snd were pressured by so many forces to put up and shut up. But having now, as we do, the choice to choose outcomes, it doesn’t make sense to take one possible course off the table - especially if that’s what the woman wants. The difference lies in her ability to choose that course.

Calliopespa · 30/11/2023 10:00

@LaurieStrode i think, with respect, @GreenIsMyFavoriteColour mighg be saying something a little different. I think from what you have posted you meant with four small children and having known what DH was like, OP doesn’t have/deserve to choose? At least that’s how it comes across. I think the suggestion here is that she might have and deserve to choose to stay.

Calliopespa · 30/11/2023 10:01

Calliopespa · 30/11/2023 10:00

@LaurieStrode i think, with respect, @GreenIsMyFavoriteColour mighg be saying something a little different. I think from what you have posted you meant with four small children and having known what DH was like, OP doesn’t have/deserve to choose? At least that’s how it comes across. I think the suggestion here is that she might have and deserve to choose to stay.

Sorry “ have the option/deserve”

SurprisedWithAHorse · 30/11/2023 10:05

GreenIsMyFavoriteColour · 30/11/2023 09:16

Am I the only one thinking that with four kids and (presumably) a mortgage a cheating Dad/Husband might be better than no Dad/Husband?

I'm assuming the pair of them aren't having screaming arguments and can manage to be friendly to each other.

The "relationship" with the 23 year old isn't going to last because he's going to be broke for 15 years and he won't want child #5 and #6. Both of which are likely to be a deal breaker for her.

It's not ideal, but neither is the alternative.

Will the husband take on his share of domestic life so that OP can go have a lover of her own?

GreenIsMyFavoriteColour · 30/11/2023 10:22

SurprisedWithAHorse · 30/11/2023 10:05

Will the husband take on his share of domestic life so that OP can go have a lover of her own?

Who knows but the question for the moment is "Is child maintainance or fifty percent custody better than an onsite but cheating Dad/Husband?". There are two valid answers to that question and I'm not sure that's reflected in this thread.

Therealjudgejudy · 30/11/2023 10:28

I hope you are OK op.

Please ignore the nasty poster who is trying to derail this thread

ValerieVomit · 30/11/2023 12:26

SurprisedWithAHorse · 29/11/2023 20:35

Where's Michael Myers when you need him?

Sorry but your comment made my morning!

ValerieVomit · 30/11/2023 12:48

GodDammitCecil · 29/11/2023 22:22

….And here’s you saying she deserves an unfaithful husband.

Again, you’ve been careful not to use the actual words, but it’s crystal clear what you’re implying.

We can all read and get the measure of you.

To be fair, you can't "get the measure" of anyone from a few posts; it's classic Mumsnet to say you can, and common sense and real life to know you can't. It's just used as a stick to beat posters with. You cannot polarise opinions like that if you really measure them.

If people write stuff that you think is against the rules then report them. Simples.

I've said a few things, and @LaurieStrode has said the same as me but more forcefully. I asked the OP directly and also mused that there must have been red flags about this chap in the beginning, because nobody would display this sort of behaviour from left field. I didn't attack or victim blame, but asked the sort of question that a friend or counsellor would ask, let's be right about it.

The OP has clarified this, @LaurieStrode quoted it and emboldened the salient points. We can deduce he is a narcissist. I also pointed out that the OP has had four BABIES to juggle, all very close together and would have no time left over to notice a lot of them.

Maybe when they met, she was young, and who knows, guessing a possible scenario, guy on a fast track graduate scheme, full of chat, dazzled her and she didn't notice how bad he really was, or thought maybe things would work themselves out, but they didn't and she was too busy with the children to notice.

GodDammitCecil · 30/11/2023 14:44

And absolutely none of that is helpful in the moment, @ValerieVomit .

@LaurieStrode has repeatedly come onto this thread to post unhelpful quips, not constructive responses.

She has despaired at the OP. She has even questioned the authenticity of the OP. And yet returns again and again - highly questionable behaviour, if you really think the OP isn’t genuine.

She has said things on this thread that she would never say to someone’s face in real life.

So yes, I do have the measure of her. Very much indeed.

Perhaps, to give her the benefit of the doubt, she is ‘just’ very socially inept. Either that, or she is inherently cruel. Maybe there is some other explanation. Whatever it may be, she has not presented well in any of the posts she has made on this thread.

Unlike many other people on here.

Once again - let’s get back to constructively supporting the OP.

HikingforScenery · 30/11/2023 14:55

Aww OP I’s very sorry to read this. What a shoxk
for you. Take care of yourself.

Penguinfeet24 · 30/11/2023 16:13

GreenIsMyFavoriteColour · 30/11/2023 09:16

Am I the only one thinking that with four kids and (presumably) a mortgage a cheating Dad/Husband might be better than no Dad/Husband?

I'm assuming the pair of them aren't having screaming arguments and can manage to be friendly to each other.

The "relationship" with the 23 year old isn't going to last because he's going to be broke for 15 years and he won't want child #5 and #6. Both of which are likely to be a deal breaker for her.

It's not ideal, but neither is the alternative.

I really hope you are the only one thinking that. Does anyone think that little of themselves that they would stay with a lying, cheating narcissist who thinks the purpose of a wife is to look attractive and provide sex on tap or else they have a green light to go elsewhere? My God, it's archaic. Being single with children isn't a dirty little scandal, there are plenty of successful, single mothers out there with great lives - they don't NEED to be in 'hot demand', they're not fucking cattle, they're human beings. Sorry but no, you cannot allow this to go on and stay with it because it is perpetuating the myth that people can get away with whatever they want and treating the people they are supposed to love the most however they want. What kind of example is that setting to their children? Absolutely not.

JoanOfAllTrades · 30/11/2023 16:18

GodDammitCecil · 29/11/2023 23:03

Or, to be charitable and give you the benefit of the doubt, please do explain how ‘a mum of four under six isn't going to be in hot demand on the dating scene’ means anything other than ‘no other man will want her’.

This should be entertaining.

This particular poster is often unpleasant in threads, to the point that I wonder if she is really a he!

UnRavellingFast · 30/11/2023 16:57

GreenIsMyFavoriteColour · 30/11/2023 09:16

Am I the only one thinking that with four kids and (presumably) a mortgage a cheating Dad/Husband might be better than no Dad/Husband?

I'm assuming the pair of them aren't having screaming arguments and can manage to be friendly to each other.

The "relationship" with the 23 year old isn't going to last because he's going to be broke for 15 years and he won't want child #5 and #6. Both of which are likely to be a deal breaker for her.

It's not ideal, but neither is the alternative.

I am the child of just such a marriage. It was hell on earth. People can’t disguise the scorn they feel for their partner (cheater) or the desperation and destroyed mental health (cheatee) from their kids. The kids will be aware of something wrong and different to their friends’ families from a very early age, and as they grew up, they will know what the something is. They will be hurt by the fact, disgusted by the fact, mentally anguished that they are not enough for the cheater to behave properly for the family. Children always absorb these things. They will lose respect for both parties and they will wish their parents had spit up. Those children’s relationships in the future will be tainted by this mockery of a marriage with distrust and scorn at its heart. You may think that the logistics make it worthwhile, but the pain and long lasting effects on the children do not.