Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My friend thinks I was assaulted. I don't

136 replies

Bigbirthdaycomingup · 26/11/2023 18:00

A very unpleasant conversation with a friend about a mutual friend took place yesterday. I'd appreciate some help getting my thoughts straight. I feel rattled.

I was having lunch with a gang of old friends yesterday. A mutual friend was mentioned, let's call him Alan. Alan and I were close friends for years since our late teens. We hooked up sometimes during single periods and at one point or another both of us separately broached the topic of giving it a go for real but it was never mutual or the timing was off. I am very fond of him but in recent years haven't seen him in person for various reasons.

In the intervening years my friends at the lunch knew him through different channels. One of them told a shocking story about him. I was utterly horrified and pressed for details. She seems to have the information fourth hand. It's about Alan allegedly having sex with one of her friend's friends when she was too drunk to consent and possibly unconscious (I say possibly as the woman herself is unclear on whether she had blacked out).

To note : I know of this woman and her circle. They are heavy drug users and lead chaotic lives. I've heard a lot of similar stories circling over the years about some of the other men. I've been talking to Alan a good bit online recently and he has stopped drinking completely and hasn't taken drugs in well over a decade. I briefly wondered if this was why.

I was digesting this news and asked who the source was. My friend was unimpressed at my response and asked why I didn't believe it. I said it was hard to absorb, I had never had any indication he could be capable of that. He has always been absolutely lovely to me. We would frequently go out for dinner alone or stay in each others houses.

At that point my friend looked shocked and said he had pretty much done the same to me in our early twenties. I had no idea what she was talking about then I remembered and started to laugh.

Background from twenty odd years ago - I had phoned Alan one day sobbing that I'd been dumped and was heart broken. He said he would be straight out. We went to the local bar and lined up a load of shots on the bar. The usual melodrama of that tine. Neither of us remember finishing them and predictably we woke up in bed together. We were also very embarrassed as we tried to piece together the rest of the evening and kept receiving snippets of info from random people who we had run into.

She said he was preying on me as I was vulnerable. I argued that if anything I took advantage of him and I knew exactly where that night was going to end up. We'd slept together previously. He actually liked me for real as it turned out and had asked me out properly the following week but I turned him down as was pining for my ex. We went back to being friends afterwards and had a couple of flings over the next ten years.

A debate ensued about how we lie to ourselves as we can never accept that we have been a victim. I know this happens but I really don't think I am.

Yabu : he was a predator even then and you are deluded
Yanbu : he may well be a rapist now but that doesn't change what happened in the past - two mates behaving like idiots and no harm done

OP posts:
ocarinaflow · 27/11/2023 10:22

AlwaysForksAndMarbles · 27/11/2023 08:38

  1. You can’t consent to sex if you are blacking out drunk, even if you intended to have sex before the night started. Therefore, if a man has sex with you in that state, where you can’t give enthusiastic and informed consent, it is rape.
  2. If he was genuinely blacking out drunk, rather than putting it on or exaggerating, there’s no way he’d have been able to ‘perform’.
  3. What if you consented to one form of sex, but during this encounter you can’t remember, you said ‘no’ to another, and withdrew your consent? And he carried on? Being as drunk as you were, you can’t remember. Therefore you couldn’t give consent. Do you see how this works?

I was in my twenties in the nineties, and nobody talked properly about consent. But I do know women who were raped under similar circumstances, and we all recognised it as rape even then. It should not be diminished or excused because of drink or drugs or circumstances.

I think you need new friends and a new outlook, though, if you think talking about stuff like this is lunch time catch up fodder. It’s part of the reason why men’s sexual abuse of women is so pervasive and so persistent. It’s clear that still, not everyone takes it seriously.

Hmm? I think the vague terms you use are unhelpful. I'm all for informed, enthusiastic, sober mutual consent– much healthier than drunken sex. But using weasel words to imply rape is not on also.

What is "blacking out drunk"? Are you trying to say "unconscious"? All OP said was that neither of them could remember what happened the next day. She didn't say she had fallen unconscious at any point before sex.

I have often done things in a CONSCIOUS state while very drunk. I've had whole adventures around town I don't remember.

If Person A is clearly drunk while Person B is sober, then yes B is taking advantage of A. If 2 people get very drunk together, and end up sleeping together, I wouldn't call it rape.

Actually, it's far back in the recesses of my memory, but I first slept with my DH at uni through a mutual drunken grope and a night neither of us can really remember, apart from 3rd party testimonies. ;) It's not rape just because 1 of the drunk people has a penis. You or OP's friend don't get to tell me I was raped lol, sorry!

Of course, Alan could have been sober and actually raped OP and be lying about it now but we don't know.

Carmargo · 27/11/2023 10:15

This is why Fwb is for stupid people only.

Have relationships or one night stands. That's what smart people do. Else you get crap like this.

The whole thing is fucking ridiculous. Of course he didn't assault you and, to be frank, you need to get that shit out of your head right now.

Who knows what happened with this other woman, though.
Don't think he assaulted YOU.

honoldbrist · 27/11/2023 09:03

I've never been so drunk that i couldn't remeber anything and then woken up in bed with someone. And i've been really drunk. Are you sure he didn't slip you something?

Maddy70 · 27/11/2023 08:57

You were there. You know ignore your friend

scrambledeggsonrye · 27/11/2023 08:52

If your friend is helping to spread a rumour (based on a third or fourth person account) that Alan is a rapist, she needs to be really careful. People have been sued for less!

I understood what you meant OP. You weren't disputing the woman's account but you were factoring in the possibility that if your friend heard this 'on the grapevine' rather than directly from the woman, there's a possibility it's not true. If we believed every rumour we were told without question, we'd quickly get ourselves in a mess.

As for you, if you're happy the night was a mutually drunken consensual experience then it's not really anyone else's business!

AlwaysForksAndMarbles · 27/11/2023 08:38
  1. You can’t consent to sex if you are blacking out drunk, even if you intended to have sex before the night started. Therefore, if a man has sex with you in that state, where you can’t give enthusiastic and informed consent, it is rape.
  2. If he was genuinely blacking out drunk, rather than putting it on or exaggerating, there’s no way he’d have been able to ‘perform’.
  3. What if you consented to one form of sex, but during this encounter you can’t remember, you said ‘no’ to another, and withdrew your consent? And he carried on? Being as drunk as you were, you can’t remember. Therefore you couldn’t give consent. Do you see how this works?

I was in my twenties in the nineties, and nobody talked properly about consent. But I do know women who were raped under similar circumstances, and we all recognised it as rape even then. It should not be diminished or excused because of drink or drugs or circumstances.

I think you need new friends and a new outlook, though, if you think talking about stuff like this is lunch time catch up fodder. It’s part of the reason why men’s sexual abuse of women is so pervasive and so persistent. It’s clear that still, not everyone takes it seriously.

gannett · 27/11/2023 08:14

Several things to unpack here.

Firstly it bears repeating that even if a woman is a heavy drinker and drug user, she can still be raped. It also bears repeating that even if a man has had consensual sex, drunken or sober, with one woman, he can still have raped another woman.

But the OP's problem isn't really about that. It's about realising that her own consensual sexual experience is not only being used as gossip fodder, but likely being misrepresented as rape/sexual assault. That can feel like a violation in itself - to have your sex life discussed in false terms. And while my position is usually to believe women who say they've been raped, I can see why - in light of hearing this information fourth-hand through the same gossip mill - OP might lean away from doing that.

In terms of what she should do now, I think she should focus on her side of things. Push back in the strongest terms against this "friend" who's telling her she was assaulted when she doesn't feel she was. OP knows what she experienced and how she felt about it better than the friend. I'd also want to know whether the friend had been telling this story to other people, and if she had been gossiping I'd be furious. Honestly, if I found out a friend had been telling people I'd been raped (whether I had been or not) without my knowledge, I'd consider cutting her off.

As for Alan... this depends on how close the OP still feels to him, how close she's likely to be with him in the future and her own instinct about him. I would consider telling him that he's being gossiped about in this manner and I'd want to hear his side of the story.

Geneve82 · 27/11/2023 08:13

these women are heavy substance abusers and less chaotic lives

20 years ago you were heavily heavily under the influence of alcohol and having a very chaotic night “very messy” in your words.

So when you refer to their drug use etc. what are you actually implying if you had to sum up in a sentence

Geneve82 · 27/11/2023 08:07

Bigbirthdaycomingup · 27/11/2023 08:04

@Geneve82 it's no secret at all and yes I've been around them. I wouldn't be there on nights out as late nights are not my vibe anyway but just as one example; I dropped something into my friend's house. Her friend was visiting at the time so she introduced us. Her friend was going to work later. She sat down beside me at the kitchen table chatting away and did a line of cocaine as if it was the most normal thing in the world.

how old are you all op? i’m guessing mid forties of Alan incident happened 20 odd years ago?

LBOCS2 · 27/11/2023 08:05

Is there not also a relevance to the fact that the other group use drink and drugs heavily - in as much as, if someone is saying the OP was assaulted because she was extremely drunk when the sex with Alan took place, then why would they not also be saying that this other sexual encounter is also rape if they were both under the influence then? But not taking into consideration how both of the women came away from the encounter feeling?

Unless you hear it from the person who was involved in the encounter, I think I'd be dubious of this mutual friend's assertion of the situation too.

Bigbirthdaycomingup · 27/11/2023 08:04

@Geneve82 it's no secret at all and yes I've been around them. I wouldn't be there on nights out as late nights are not my vibe anyway but just as one example; I dropped something into my friend's house. Her friend was visiting at the time so she introduced us. Her friend was going to work later. She sat down beside me at the kitchen table chatting away and did a line of cocaine as if it was the most normal thing in the world.

OP posts:
Treaclesandwich · 27/11/2023 08:02

I’m not saying these issues shouldn’t be discussed - they obviously should - but it sounds like a very intense lunchtime catch-up.

Geneve82 · 27/11/2023 07:54

They all heavily abuse drugs and drinks. I don't know them personally beyond the odd chat or have any involvement in that lifestyle.

but you accept this as the truth on the basis of someone telling you

Geneve82 · 27/11/2023 07:46

Bigbirthdaycomingup · 26/11/2023 19:11

They all heavily abuse drugs and drinks. I don't know them personally beyond the odd chat or have any involvement in that lifestyle. The exception is my friend who is a friend from when we were young. We have remained friends despite having different circles.

how do you know they are heavy drug users?

presumably not from actually being around them yourself but someone telling you…. and yet you’ve accepted as gospel

EtiennePalmiere · 27/11/2023 07:41

Whether anyone was assaulted or not both your friend and Alan sound a little gross, I wouldn't contact either of them again.

TellingFriends · 27/11/2023 06:59

I am the woman Alan originally assaulted (obviously I don't know if I am the one OP is referring to as there are a lot of predatory Alans around).

Alan had consensual sexual relationships as well as being a rapist, like pretty much all rapists.

Ger1atricMillennial · 26/11/2023 21:08

Tough one! If you had said no would it have still happened? If Alan had said no, would it have still happened?

With the other person- who knows what the circumstances were specifically but if they feel that were assaulted i.e. they said no or they were too scared to say no.

Does it show a pattern- that would be the question for me? I.e. if I am drinking and around Alan do I need to be aware that he might not be able to distinguish signals?

TravelInHope · 26/11/2023 21:01

Of course he is a predator. He is a man FFS!

Chipsahoyagain · 26/11/2023 20:45

DaizyDee · 26/11/2023 18:08

It's not up to your friend to decide that you've been assaulted. You were there! If you felt OK about it and not traumatised, it sounds like two drunk people ending up in bed, which is not remotely unusual. He may well have assaulted someone else but that's another story. Sounds like your friend wants to create a drama out of this. If you've been relaxed about it up to now I'd trust your instinct.

This. And you are right to actually question the word of someone who uses drugs!

yellowlane · 26/11/2023 20:42

Well Alan sounded very keen to see you when you told him you had just had a break up and were presumably vulnerable. I think a decent person would be supportive but not cross the line. What if you'd regretted it and got back with your bf. Would you have still felt the same?

It's possible that you felt fine with how that night went but someone else in the same situation (very drunk) may not have.

The fact Alan was willing to have sex with a drunk woman (how drunk could he have been to get it up?) means it probably wasn't a one off.

But the 'friend' is wrong for calling out your situation in front of others. It's none of their business and they shouldn't be gossiping about others either.

TempestTost · 26/11/2023 20:39

Grown adults who get drunk together and go to bed together aren't sexually assaulting each other unless there is some kind of coercion or something. People often make stupid decisions under those kinds of circumstances. So no, not assault.

It's very difficult to say what went on with this other woman, assuming the story is even accurate. People can black out without actually being visibly more impaired than anyone else at an event. Especially if they are taking drugs as well as booze, and especially if they do that kind of thing a lot. I've known people to do all kinds of things like cook, wrap presents, etc, and be able to remember none of it the next day.

It's not an unreasonable idea that drunk sex might always be a bad call, because there really is no way to draw a line around it. There are a lot of grey areas, where you can't really know how the other person is, for everyone involved. And that leaves room for predators to have plausible deniability.

There is a good argument that no one should get that impaired and have sex, and that no one should get impaired like that at all. But the fact of the matter is that having risky sex for many people is part and parcel of that whole lifestyle, and there are even lots of more moderate partiers who get drunk specifically in order to have sex, because it helps them lose their inhibitions. And it's legal for adults to make that kind of decision.

There's a good chance that anyone hanging out in that kind of environment a lot, and partaking, will get into bad situations at one time or another, including having sex with someone who is more impaired than they think, or doesn't remember later.

tuttifuckinfruity · 26/11/2023 20:39

Iam4eels · 26/11/2023 18:11

Also rapists and abusers don't rape and abuse everyone they meet, they'd be so much easier to spot if they did. Just because your experience with Alan wasn't what you consider assault doesn't mean that he didn't assault others.

Is that not exactly what she's saying?

"Yabu : he was a predator even then and you are deluded
Yanbu : he may well be a rapist now but that doesn't change what happened in the past - two mates behaving like idiots and no harm done"

She's not saying he did or did not assault the other woman.

She's saying it doesn't mean that he assaulted her 20 years ago just because they were drunk.

JustWhatWeDontNeed · 26/11/2023 20:26

AllAroundMyCat · 26/11/2023 20:20

Did he target her?
If he was off his face with drink and drugs, surely he is vulnerable too? Yes, it's women that get raped but if both parties are off their face with substances, who knows what the real scenario was.

Sometimes you can deduce based on the circumstances you wake up in.

I really think it's gross that this is a lunch time catch up topic. Dissecting a friend of a friend's alleged rape.

AllAroundMyCat · 26/11/2023 20:20

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 26/11/2023 18:06

The fact that your fourth paragraph is textbook victim blaming and rape apology makes me think you dont have the best judgement on this topic tbh.

Why do you consider it relevant that the woman Alan raped was a drug user/chaotic? That makes her more vulnerable, but it certainly doesn't absolve him. Actually it makes it worse, as it shows that he targeted someone very obviously vulnerable, who was unlikely to be believed. Which is exactly what rapists do.

Edited

Did he target her?
If he was off his face with drink and drugs, surely he is vulnerable too? Yes, it's women that get raped but if both parties are off their face with substances, who knows what the real scenario was.

SecreHallmarkXmasAddict · 26/11/2023 20:18

Your friend shouldn’t be gossiping about Alan and the other woman, and she shouldn’t be telling you how to feel about something that happened to you.