Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Carrie Bradshaw?

60 replies

smilingontheinsidee · 26/11/2023 17:30

So I know it’s been debated to death of what a toxic person she is and bad friend and this thread is nothing to do with that.

Aibu to think it was really odd that you barely knew anything of her life before NY? She briefly touched on her father leaving but her mother is never mentioned or makes an appearance and whether she has siblings or half siblings,

I just find it odd to have a main character and have no background to them.

OP posts:
Twentypastfour · 26/11/2023 20:09

Yes I found that part of it very believable.

I have parents but I rarely see them - I don’t live remotely close to them. A couple of times a year. I don’t ever have any need to talk about them to friends. If you were to watch all my coffees and lunches and drinks out with friends as single woman I doubt I would have talked about my parents or my childhood once.

I haven’t met the parents of the vast majority of my friends with the exceptions of those that married since I’ve known them, I suppose.

Littlelucas · 26/11/2023 20:02

I loved the show when I was younger but on watching it recently I found Carrie quite shallow and annoying. She isn’t a character you warmed to unlike the others but I think that’s partly to do with SJP being a bit of a crap actress. I do like her but she can’t act for toffee and is the same character in every film!

smilingontheinsidee · 26/11/2023 19:59

Nofilteritwonthelp · 26/11/2023 18:42

I think that was kindof the point, they weren't close to their own families and had formed their own 'family'

I don’t think so, I never got the impression the other three were close with each other.

OP posts:
smilingontheinsidee · 26/11/2023 19:58

Nofilteritwonthelp · 26/11/2023 18:42

I think that was kindof the point, they weren't close to their own families and had formed their own 'family'

I think people are mistaking this for me meaning they had to have close family or have family on the show. That’s not what I mean at all.

I just saying it would have been interesting to know more about her life, why she doesn’t seemingly have a relationship with her mum,

I think it’s unusual to have four women that ALL genuinely seem very removed from their family and that never seem to go visit them etc. But I also don’t remember any episode that showed a holiday like Christmas or Thanks Giving and what each of them do

OP posts:
ChimChimeny · 26/11/2023 18:51

I think its a lot more common in America to be distant from family too because of the sheer size of the country and limited holiday, it's not like they all stayed in the same.place they grew up, they moved away for their careers.
One contestant on master chef a few series ago hadn't seen her little brother for 2 years!

NumberTheory · 26/11/2023 18:48

It was a fun, surface-superficial show. Building significant character backstories would have made it more difficult to write and less relatable.

burnoutbabe · 26/11/2023 18:47

There was an older man who walked Charlotte down the aisle to trey. I assumed that was her dad?

Nofilteritwonthelp · 26/11/2023 18:42

I think that was kindof the point, they weren't close to their own families and had formed their own 'family'

CrushingOnRubies · 26/11/2023 18:39

smilingontheinsidee · 26/11/2023 17:30

So I know it’s been debated to death of what a toxic person she is and bad friend and this thread is nothing to do with that.

Aibu to think it was really odd that you barely knew anything of her life before NY? She briefly touched on her father leaving but her mother is never mentioned or makes an appearance and whether she has siblings or half siblings,

I just find it odd to have a main character and have no background to them.

There was a prequel series about 10 years ago with a young Austin butler from the Elvis movie & Freeman Agyman in it.

It was called something like the Carrie Diaries

NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/11/2023 18:34

BethDuttonsTwin · 26/11/2023 18:26

I said I was in my mid twenties not her 🙄

<<hides extremely controlled thread>>

Ah, I mistook the 'as a mid twenties woman, she was...and I liked her' structure of your paragraph as referring to her, not you, your feelings coming after that without saying you were the person in their mid twenties at the time.

Feel free to unhide the thread.

Didimum · 26/11/2023 18:31

smilingontheinsidee · 26/11/2023 18:06

No we’re not discussing flaws etc - there’s a billion and one threads about this.

I know. You still mentioned it so I wanted to. I first addressed your actual discussion point. Surely a thread on SATC is not supposed to be so highly policed – no one is obligated to agree or disagree with me or even reply. You included.

Gowlett · 26/11/2023 18:28

She was in her 30s. That’s why meeting a guy was more pressing, say in the case of Charlotte where she wants kids.

I think in their 20s they were getting around. And moving away from family, establishing their own lives. Which was great.

BethDuttonsTwin · 26/11/2023 18:26

NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/11/2023 18:24

Mid twenties? Pretty sure she was in her 30s at the start.

I said I was in my mid twenties not her 🙄

<<hides extremely controlled thread>>

EmmaEmerald · 26/11/2023 18:25

The scriptwriters made an active choice to do that.

They felt the episode with Charlotte's brother was a test - I thought that was fun though I can see why more wouldn't work.

I like that the show took this route. There's so many of us for whom family, especially those you live far away from, don't have much impact on our lives.

I miss those days myself! When my friends were my family....nostalgia....

NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/11/2023 18:24

BethDuttonsTwin · 26/11/2023 18:21

I also don’t ever get the criticism against Carrie’s character for whatever problematic thing she did. A protagonist isn’t supposed to be perfect or always do the right thing. It’s better if a character is believable and has flaws, so long as the audience can at least see motivation – in Carrie’s case being young, single and swallowed in some head fuck relationships.

Agree! I’ve never understood the hate she gets. As a mid twenties woman at the time, her self centredness and mistakes pretty typical tbh and I liked her and found her funny. The demands for unrealistic perfection in all people and things is pretty recent though. I watched at the time and nearly everyone loved her and the show. Each of them had human faults but somehow it’s always Carrie that gets the criticism now.

Mid twenties? Pretty sure she was in her 30s at the start.

smilingontheinsidee · 26/11/2023 18:24

BethDuttonsTwin · 26/11/2023 18:22

Oh right. Maybe you should have set out your parameters for the discussion in the OP and then we’d have all known to stick to them…

I said the thread has nothing to do with that. It’s been done to death.

OP posts:
smilingontheinsidee · 26/11/2023 18:23

BethDuttonsTwin · 26/11/2023 18:21

I also don’t ever get the criticism against Carrie’s character for whatever problematic thing she did. A protagonist isn’t supposed to be perfect or always do the right thing. It’s better if a character is believable and has flaws, so long as the audience can at least see motivation – in Carrie’s case being young, single and swallowed in some head fuck relationships.

Agree! I’ve never understood the hate she gets. As a mid twenties woman at the time, her self centredness and mistakes pretty typical tbh and I liked her and found her funny. The demands for unrealistic perfection in all people and things is pretty recent though. I watched at the time and nearly everyone loved her and the show. Each of them had human faults but somehow it’s always Carrie that gets the criticism now.

And this is why I specifically requested the thread to be about the family/background aspect and not derail it. Thanks.

OP posts:
Emi199 · 26/11/2023 18:23

GertrudeSteinsbook · 26/11/2023 17:41

I kind of liked that about it. Carrie was quite free spirited & a good role model for people that maybe don’t have family. I guess not everyone does or is close to theirs. I thought it was refreshing.

I felt like this about her and Sam never having kids.

BethDuttonsTwin · 26/11/2023 18:22

smilingontheinsidee · 26/11/2023 18:06

No we’re not discussing flaws etc - there’s a billion and one threads about this.

Oh right. Maybe you should have set out your parameters for the discussion in the OP and then we’d have all known to stick to them…

BethDuttonsTwin · 26/11/2023 18:21

I also don’t ever get the criticism against Carrie’s character for whatever problematic thing she did. A protagonist isn’t supposed to be perfect or always do the right thing. It’s better if a character is believable and has flaws, so long as the audience can at least see motivation – in Carrie’s case being young, single and swallowed in some head fuck relationships.

Agree! I’ve never understood the hate she gets. As a mid twenties woman at the time, her self centredness and mistakes pretty typical tbh and I liked her and found her funny. The demands for unrealistic perfection in all people and things is pretty recent though. I watched at the time and nearly everyone loved her and the show. Each of them had human faults but somehow it’s always Carrie that gets the criticism now.

Gowlett · 26/11/2023 18:18

Must look up the Carrie Diaries. Is it good? I liked Girls.

Fedupwitheveryone · 26/11/2023 18:17

I think it was just the style of show? and also that we forget how revolutionary it was )back in 2000??) to have female professional, grown characters discussing sex so much. it was a fresh take when it started.

it was also based on a book w very little family background, and for whatever reason the show's creator's carried on the theme. Think the point was to make it about urban life, not family life. By extension, not family background either

VeronicaSawyer89 · 26/11/2023 18:12

Did you never watch the Carrie Diaries? I really enjoyed them when they were on TV. She's a teen living with her dad and younger sister and her mum is dead. https://www.itv.com/watch/the-carrie-diaries/10a2752

smilingontheinsidee · 26/11/2023 18:06

Didimum · 26/11/2023 18:00

I never felt the need to know Carrie’s background to enjoy the show for what it was. As another poster said, it wasn’t particularly relevant to the show.

I also don’t ever get the criticism against Carrie’s character for whatever problematic thing she did. A protagonist isn’t supposed to be perfect or always do the right thing. It’s better if a character is believable and has flaws, so long as the audience can at least see motivation – in Carrie’s case being young, single and swallowed in some head fuck relationships. I also don’t get the criticism of ignorance in its treatment of any now topical themes – homosexuality, promiscuity, etc. It wasn’t produced to be worthy or with a moral compass. It was very much of its time, the same as any show from the 90s.

No we’re not discussing flaws etc - there’s a billion and one threads about this.

OP posts:
LimeCheesecake · 26/11/2023 18:05

I like that we don’t know. It’s often presumed that for women, “family” is the priority, but the point was you had these 4 women with interesting careers, single and childfree (at the start at least) and their families didn’t play much part in their lives. They had families. But they were people who didn’t have much involvement in their lives.

Swipe left for the next trending thread