Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

He's hesitant about committing to a mortgage with me after years

118 replies

Melindamessenger1 · 26/11/2023 17:20

Lived together for 3 years and together for nearly 4, renting. He's mentioned wanting to own a home many times, not necessarily with me but just wanting to not have to pay rent and to have a place to call your own.
We're in the North and only looking at modest properties, i.e 90k max. We've got enough for a 5% deposit and also have enough for shared ownership schemes we've looked at.
We currently pay £1050 for all rent, utilities and CT so frankly a mortgage would probably be cheaper and for a bigger home.
I started talking earlier about making an appointment on Monday and he started to show hesitation, saying, ahh I just don't know, it's such a huge thing to think about, I just really don't know.
The other issue is area. We could get a lot more for our money in another area but he will not budge. He said he'd move within a 5 mile radius roughly but that's it.
Another issue is a pet. I've wanted a cat for a while, I've owned cats before and I wouldn't even expect him to look after it, but he won't have any sort of pet. I even suggested a goldfish but he wasn't keen.
I ended up telling him I feel that nothing is ever on my terms and he said he's sorry. I also feel sad that even after several years of living together he's clearly hesitant to enter into a mortgage with me.

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 26/11/2023 19:29

Melindamessenger1 · 26/11/2023 18:46

We've got a bit over 5%, he actually has more in me than savings. I only recently changed to a much better paying job so I've only started saving the last couple of months. I'd be happy for it to be mainly in his name if his deposit is higher of course.

You could also write a how-to book entitled "Handing Yourself Over On a Plate, for Dummies".

You need to end this completely one soded relationship and look up 'the sunken costs fallacy'.

organicbox · 26/11/2023 19:26

I spent about a decade waiting for an avoidant man to get on the same page. The tragedy is he loved me and if I'd have said 'fuck this, I want a house/baby/dog/area move and I am doing it without you' he'd have freaked out a bit, but then got with the programme.

Men have infinite time to commit, so they put it off. Unless they think they will lose what is on offer, many men just can't bring themselves to act now.

Get on with your own life, and mean it. It's okay to love him, but you should love you more.

mathanxiety · 26/11/2023 19:26

Melindamessenger1 · 26/11/2023 18:36

No sorry I mean men in general who do this.

Because women believe their future faking.

Deep down, men who do this have a very inflated view of their own worth and attractiveness, and an unrealistically low estimation of the value of women in general. They're not necessarily aware of their outlook, but their behaviour reveals it very clearly.

They have also been brought up to feel entitled to use women. Maybe not by a raging chauvinist in a home where it was explicitly taught that women can be used, but society sends men signals about themselves and about women and about commitment and integrity, and there are men who absorb that and don't question it.

daisychain01 · 26/11/2023 19:23

I'm not sure if I can afford it alone, I'll try and see.

The worst reason to consider buying a property with someone is because you can't afford it, you're setting yourself up to be trapped with the person with no easy escape.

The second worst reason is to stay with someone who is making it clear he doesn't want to commit to you and doesn't care about how you feel. That's abundantly clear from what you've posted.

Probably best to make your own plans and not rely on a reluctant partner for your future happiness.

mathanxiety · 26/11/2023 19:22

Melindamessenger1 · 26/11/2023 17:57

It's the reason we don't have kids yet because he sees his job as not good enough. I do understand of course and can't force him, but we have 49k joint salary, good maternity package, family support.

No, he doesn't want kids because they would tie him down, and tie him to you.

He is placemarking with you.

He has not committed to you in his heart at all. You're nice to have around to share the rent, cook, clean, and share a bed with. For the time being.

mathanxiety · 26/11/2023 19:20

This selfish, entitled man who lives his life on his terms and expects you to give up your own preferences has done you a huge favour here but I fear you are not picking up his very clear hint

He does not see a future with you and will not therefore commit to a mortgage with you.

Leave him.
Get a lovely cat, or four or five of them.

Buy a house yourself in the area where you could afford one.

There are men out there who are ready and willing to live in a relationship where there is mutual respect and love. The one you're in right now is not such a relationship.

HamBone · 26/11/2023 19:17

I agree with @TeeBee , you’re not on the same page. If you’re not after four years together, I doubt that you will be.

I’d tell him that you’re definitely interested in owning your own home and you’ll be working towards that goal, with it without him. Perhaps having that ultimatum will help him decide what he really wants.

if he doesn’t want what you do, he can go.

PaminaMozart · 26/11/2023 19:09

NB:
Proposals are cheap!
A cheap diamond on your finger doesn't mean he'll actually marry you...

HippeePrincess · 26/11/2023 19:05

Buy a shared ownership of your own and get back on the dating scene. You need to get a wiggle on imo. Already been together 4 years and living together 3 at your age but won’t buy a house with you? He won’t have a child with you either he’ll string you along till Mrs right then they’ll be married and pregnant within 18m-2 years.

Toolongtohols · 26/11/2023 19:05

If you’ve just started a new better job maybe you should use the shared costs of this relationship to save more of a deposit in your sole name .. two can play at that game

BeBraveLittlePenguin · 26/11/2023 19:00

You're Miss Right Now I'm afraid.
He doesn't seen you as a long term partner (unless he can't find anyone else).
Buy the.house, get the cats, make your own future.

jolies1 · 26/11/2023 18:57

You need to know the reasons for his hesitation.

5% is not a big deposit especially when looking for properties around £90k and saving ‘several hundred’ a month.

10% deposit minimum would put you in a better position and give you more mortgage options. You may also need savings for renovations, fees etc.

If his hesitation is financial (we are rushing into this without the cash behind us) or because he has genuine reasons why he would prefer to live in current location (better lifestyle, shorter commute, more amenities, family close by) you need to listen to him and think about what you want, those are valid reasons to delay.

If he doesn’t have any valid reasons you need to have a long think about whether this relationship is going anywhere long term and if you are prepared to go it alone, he wouldn’t be the first man to keep someone hanging without really committing.

OhComeOnFFS · 26/11/2023 18:57

I'd give up on this one, OP. You can't make him want to buy a house with you. He sounds too lazy to buy one on his own, so either you can stay with him, renting, or you can separate. Don't waste another year or two and then decide to separate - make a decision now.

muchalover · 26/11/2023 18:57

Of course he gets upset lovely. Splitting up without a woman waiting in the wings means he'll be single, cleaning up after himself, paying all the bills and not having sex. He will have to work at relationships and wine and dine.

It does seem that you are filing the GF space well but not a good fit for partner role. It doesn't make him evil but it doesn't make him good either. I am sure if you make plans to leave he will step up with something along the lines of a commitment but it will be meaningless and forced to get his life back on track, not yours.

WhereYouLeftIt · 26/11/2023 18:56

Melindamessenger1 · 26/11/2023 18:46

We've got a bit over 5%, he actually has more in me than savings. I only recently changed to a much better paying job so I've only started saving the last couple of months. I'd be happy for it to be mainly in his name if his deposit is higher of course.

Dear Christ, are you actually considering staying with this man?

MaryMcI · 26/11/2023 18:54

Melindamessenger1 · 26/11/2023 17:55

I won't force him to have a pet of course. It's just an example, a goldfish is hardly any bother, my point is that he won't compromise on a single thing.

i think a life partner is someone who can compromise, not one who cannot compromise on a single thing. I would save your own money from your new job and look at getting your own place, with a pet.

orangegato · 26/11/2023 18:53

That’s a shit bleak relationship OP and I’m sad that you’re wasting your life with someone who wouldn’t piss on you if you were on fire. It isn’t about home ownership it’s about an uncompromising selfish fucker.

TeeBee · 26/11/2023 18:53

He's not on the same page. Go it alone. With a mortgage of £90k, it won't be difficult.
It's fine for him to not want the same as you but don't waste too much time with this one if you want different things. Buy your own house, get yourself a child if that's what you want. Don't rely on men to deliver. You can afford to be single minded and go after what you want.

GreatGateauxsby · 26/11/2023 18:48

Melindamessenger1 · 26/11/2023 18:15

Thank you. I'm 32, few months off 33.

And you want kids and he has a loads of lame excuses about timing????
You don’t have time to mess about now

honestly… buy alone and force his hand on this.

dont let him move in without a proper proposal and date for a wedding agreed.
when he won’t get out there and find someone decent who wants to build a life with you.

Melindamessenger1 · 26/11/2023 18:47

The thing is when I talk about moving on he gets upset. I know it's probably that he likes having me around and enjoys my company and the benefits of a girlfriend though.

OP posts:
Melindamessenger1 · 26/11/2023 18:46

We've got a bit over 5%, he actually has more in me than savings. I only recently changed to a much better paying job so I've only started saving the last couple of months. I'd be happy for it to be mainly in his name if his deposit is higher of course.

OP posts:
StillWantingADog · 26/11/2023 18:43

Buy without him if you possibly can. If you still really think you have a future (I doubt it tbh) he could become your lodger. That’s what my dh did a year or so before we bought together.

Draconis · 26/11/2023 18:43

Op if you want children then you may need to call a day with this one as he does not want a long term future with you.
If you stay with him, it'll be one of those stories where you hang on to him, hoping he'll change his mind then he'll leave and have a baby with someone else pretty quick.
Honestly, it happens so often.

PaminaMozart · 26/11/2023 18:41

What @Chowtime said.

@Melindamessenger1 - you need to walk away. He is not the right man for you. You are not on the same page, not now, not ever. His needs and wants will always come first.

Don't do it!

BIossomtoes · 26/11/2023 18:41

Melindamessenger1 · 26/11/2023 17:53

All I know is that he's got zero debt and saves several hundred a month. The mortgage and bills would be slightly less than we pay now.

If he saves several hundred a month why have you only got a £4.5k deposit? As a pp says, he doesn’t see you in his future. Time to go it alone with your cat.