Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Butter or no butter

111 replies

sweeneytoddsrazor · 26/11/2023 14:52

Not really an AIBU but more a poll. Had one of those random conversations in work about favourite things to spread on toast. Fairly even across the toppings marmite, jam etc. The real difference of opinion was do you use butter/spread when you are having peanut butter on your toast. Roughly half the pb users were insistent you did the others were horrified. So ordinary butter/spread then pb = yabu
Just pb = yanbu

OP posts:
ScremeEggs · 26/11/2023 22:54

I bloody love peanut butter on toast, one of my favourite things ever!
You need a bit of butter on it in my opinion, not too much mind.
If there's no butter it's far too "claggy!"
So I've voted YABU

Ittastesvile · 26/11/2023 22:45

Toast only has one thing on it, unless it's cheese-on-toast or a toasted sandwich.

So toast with EITHER butter, jam, chocolate spread, peanut butter, pate.

My husband mostly agrees with me but he does use butter with jam, which I think is rank.

hobbledyhoy · 26/11/2023 22:40

This is very much dependent on the main topping
Peanut butter - yes
Jam - yes
Marmalade - yes
Basically any fruit based condiment - add butter
Chocolate spread - no
Philadelphia - absolutely fucking not

I can't bear margarine so it has to be butter.

Elvis1956 · 26/11/2023 22:40

Butter life it too short. Like mouse trap cheese on every thing...I've done without to lose wait and just had a smear of jam...But it was like swimming with your socks on. You can but why the fuck would you

Didimum · 26/11/2023 22:29

cardibach · 26/11/2023 22:13

This was my experience too.
Not under chocolate spread, pâté or cream cheese though.
Jam and marmalade also need butter. Though I’m not really a marmalade fan.

Edited

Ooh, I dunno … yes under cream cheese for definite for me. And jam. Not choc spread. Am a vegetarian so not tried pâté – that’s got a butter base anyway hasn’t it?

evtheria · 26/11/2023 22:29

NO butter with PB 🙅‍♀️🙅‍♀️🙅‍♀️

PickAChew · 26/11/2023 22:28

I love butter. Butter hates me so pb does go on neat. Shame, as a little butter means I can spread the pb more generously without it glueing my mouth shut.

sleepD3pr1ived · 26/11/2023 22:22

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 26/11/2023 22:09

Peanut butter requires some actual butter to act as a lubricant. Else it sticks to the top of your mouth and threatens to suffocate you.

This!

sleepD3pr1ived · 26/11/2023 22:21

Definitely butter than peanut butter 💕 NOT 'spread' of any kind ever with or without PB

And you also have to have jam - so butter then peanut butter then jam. BPB&J - food of the gods.

cardibach · 26/11/2023 22:18

stayathomer · 26/11/2023 15:23

I do eat peanut butter but with jam or marmalade I’d eat butter too. Was once at a hotel for a wedding and a woman actually walked over to me and said it was great to see someone eating butter with marmalade, that everyone called her strange😅

This is really odd. I don’t know anyone who doesn’t use butter with jam or marmalade (tell a lie, allegedly my grandad, but he died when I was 3 so it’s just hearsay). They even give you a Pat of butter with the little jam/marmalade pot in cafés. What a strange woman that was…

ThinWomansBrain · 26/11/2023 22:16

If I don't put a thin layer of butter on, I end up using twice as much peanut butter because it doesn't spread well - and I like peanut butter, but means there is too much of it.

Circularargument · 26/11/2023 22:16

CleverClogg · 26/11/2023 14:55

YABU to eat any sort of spread or margarine ever - it messes up all your hormones and metabolism and causes obesity. It should not be classed as fit for human consumption IMO. and no doubt one day soon it wont be.

So anyone who eats margarine ever IBU. And as long as its butter, fine to have it with peanut butter, or not

Pseudo-science alert.

cardibach · 26/11/2023 22:13

Didimum · 26/11/2023 20:58

I never used to, but I went to a cafe once that buttered the toast prior to pb, and it was delicious, so I will occasionally now, but rarely. Both are yummy.

This was my experience too.
Not under chocolate spread, pâté or cream cheese though.
Jam and marmalade also need butter. Though I’m not really a marmalade fan.

feelingalittlehorse · 26/11/2023 22:10

DustyLee123 · 26/11/2023 15:00

Why would you put two types of fat on the toast?

The more the merrier, I say 🙌

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 26/11/2023 22:09

Peanut butter requires some actual butter to act as a lubricant. Else it sticks to the top of your mouth and threatens to suffocate you.

KohlaParasaurus · 26/11/2023 22:07

Depends on the quality of the peanut butter. The expensive stuff that just contains peanuts and a bit of salt needs butter to stop it from tearing the toast, but the cheap stuff that's full of added oil, sugar and emulsifiers spreads just fine and needs cheese on top.

I love lemon curd, and every other fruit curd, but not with peanut butter.

Helenahandkart · 26/11/2023 21:57

With butter and without butter. They’re two entirely different toast/peanut butter experiences, and I like them both equally.

LeakyPipes · 26/11/2023 21:53

DustyLee123 · 26/11/2023 15:00

Why would you put two types of fat on the toast?

For the same reason as we use one type of fat on toast - great taste 👍

SpringIntoChaos · 26/11/2023 21:26

sweeneytoddsrazor · 26/11/2023 16:33

Fairly even split so far then. Wasn't expecting a margarine lecture but this is AIBU so it usually throws up a few random posts. On a side note I was the only one who liked lemon curd on my toast. Some of the younger colleagues had never heard of it. When did it go out of favour?

You've done it now OP!! I'm craving lemon curd! 🤣

Tintackedsea · 26/11/2023 21:21

All toast wants butter. Whatever happens after that is your choice but the toast demands butter.

thankyouforthedayz · 26/11/2023 21:21

No butter under peanut butter on toast, but most definitely in a peanut butter sandwich.

Pinkpinkpink15 · 26/11/2023 21:17

Always butter (proper butter!!) first. Too dry with just PB.

jay55 · 26/11/2023 21:15

No butter with peanut butter, or with marmite.

Sahmto3 · 26/11/2023 21:08

On toast just peanut butter.
In a sandwich then butter first, peanut butter and then cut into squares 😂😂

ganglion · 26/11/2023 21:08

I don't but I have tried it and I completely get why people would do this.