Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Butter or no butter

111 replies

sweeneytoddsrazor · 26/11/2023 14:52

Not really an AIBU but more a poll. Had one of those random conversations in work about favourite things to spread on toast. Fairly even across the toppings marmite, jam etc. The real difference of opinion was do you use butter/spread when you are having peanut butter on your toast. Roughly half the pb users were insistent you did the others were horrified. So ordinary butter/spread then pb = yabu
Just pb = yanbu

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PianPianPiano · 28/11/2023 19:13

I used to be horrified at the people who put butter under their PB. It seemed so unnecessary and far too many calories/fat.

And then I tried it....

Butter OP, always with butter.

MartyMcFlysPurpleUnderwear · 28/11/2023 19:03

Always butter the toast.

SurelySmartie · 28/11/2023 18:46

Just peanut butter on its own. It’s instead of butter.

LadyEloise1 · 28/11/2023 18:44

I love butter
Irish butter from grass fed cows.
But I'd never use butter and peanut butter together 😮

QuestionableMouse · 28/11/2023 18:41

DustyLee123 · 26/11/2023 15:00

Why would you put two types of fat on the toast?

Because it is delicious.

BrieAndChilli · 28/11/2023 18:39

I always have butter with any spread including peanut butter. However I like lots of butter and a tiny smear of spread, I can’t stand a thick covering of any thing, jam, pb etc. you can barely see the spread on my toast!

bellac11 · 28/11/2023 18:35

Butter with everything. Bread, toast, potatoes, vegetables, pasta, spread on bits of cucumber.
On scones (now thats controversial I believe)

HarpieDuJour · 28/11/2023 18:29

Butter every time. I only occasionally have anything on top of it, and never, ever have hot toast, because it ruins the butter.

Hillarious · 27/11/2023 14:31

No butter with peanut butter, but Marmite and peanut butter every time!

Aroundthewaygirl · 27/11/2023 14:10

Elastica23 · 27/11/2023 05:14

You're not at Weight Watchers in the 1980s now, Pamela.

😂 Some of us have to watch our calories!

MassageForLife · 27/11/2023 05:34

//PEDANTRY MODE ON

Margarine isn't sold in the UK any more. Margarine by definition has over 80% fat, and has not been sold in the UK for a good number of years. What are sold are called 'spreads'.

Interestingly even chefs don't seem to know this. James Martin recently said that margarine shouldn't be sold in the UK.

//PEDANTRY MODE OFF

The issue with the word 'spread' is, it's kind of unclear. People know exactly what you mean when you say margarine. You can spread many things on your toast that aren't that kind of 'spread'.

Elastica23 · 27/11/2023 05:14

Aroundthewaygirl · 26/11/2023 22:55

Adding butter seems too much especially the extra calories.

You're not at Weight Watchers in the 1980s now, Pamela.

Elastica23 · 27/11/2023 05:03

The only topping I don't have butter under is avocado.

I find peanut butter too dry and claggy on its own, and far too sweet with honey.

flowerchild2000 · 27/11/2023 05:00

This is the first I've heard of this! I am a little horrified! 😂 Butter always but never with pb...just why??

The best way to eat pb on toast is to let some honey soak into the toast first, then pb. The honey will crystallize if the bread is the right temperature. It has the most amazing texture and taste!

stayathomer · 27/11/2023 04:55

cardibach
I actually don’t know many people who do put butter with either so I was laughing with her saying same here!! My family all say it’s disgusting when I put butter under jam!!!!

Ittastesvile · 26/11/2023 23:20

theduchessofspork · 26/11/2023 23:05

Now you are completely wrong in the other direction, you absolutely need butter with honey and jam, or where is the lovely fat n salt n sugar experience??? Hmm???

Lol. I really hate the way jam or honey mix in with the butter. So messy, and means I can't enjoy either the butter or the spread. I also put toppings on toast very thickly, maybe that's a factor.

See, cheese or ham do not mix with the butter so that is acceptable to have both!

theduchessofspork · 26/11/2023 23:07

KohlaParasaurus · 26/11/2023 22:07

Depends on the quality of the peanut butter. The expensive stuff that just contains peanuts and a bit of salt needs butter to stop it from tearing the toast, but the cheap stuff that's full of added oil, sugar and emulsifiers spreads just fine and needs cheese on top.

I love lemon curd, and every other fruit curd, but not with peanut butter.

What you need to try is pip and nut, much easier spreading than whole earth, but equally wholesome

theduchessofspork · 26/11/2023 23:05

Ittastesvile · 26/11/2023 22:45

Toast only has one thing on it, unless it's cheese-on-toast or a toasted sandwich.

So toast with EITHER butter, jam, chocolate spread, peanut butter, pate.

My husband mostly agrees with me but he does use butter with jam, which I think is rank.

Now you are completely wrong in the other direction, you absolutely need butter with honey and jam, or where is the lovely fat n salt n sugar experience??? Hmm???

ODFOx · 26/11/2023 23:04

With PB: no. Absolutely not.
With marmite; depends on if you are dieting or not: marmite snd s poached egg on toast without butter is a perfectly lively meal; marmite and butter on hot toast is a deliciousness best eaten when slightly tipsy or slightly sad as it's so good you need a low point to elevate up from.

FreshWinterMorning · 26/11/2023 23:04

Putting butter on and peanut butter on top is batshit. HTH.

theduchessofspork · 26/11/2023 23:03

EnthENd · 26/11/2023 23:00

Peanut butter isn't butter. Toast needs butter (or marg, but butter is nicer) and optionally a topping on top.

The Dutch call it pindakaas, literally translating to peanut cheese. Would you omit the butter if you were having cheese on toast?

No you come to mention is yes, I don’t put butter under cheese either, but I don’t think the two things fought in the same way, just don’t think it needs it.

theduchessofspork · 26/11/2023 23:02

Oooh it’s nearly 50/50

My sister is one of the weirdos that puts butter under peanut butter. I love butter but NO! not under the crunchy stuff. (She also puts butter and cream on a scone mind you, so she is hardcore.)

EnthENd · 26/11/2023 23:00

Peanut butter isn't butter. Toast needs butter (or marg, but butter is nicer) and optionally a topping on top.

The Dutch call it pindakaas, literally translating to peanut cheese. Would you omit the butter if you were having cheese on toast?

OnlyTheCrumbliestFlakiestChocolate · 26/11/2023 22:59

I love butter as a spread but not with peanut butter. Peanut butter is rich and creamy and yummy without it. I was going to say I wouldn't put another butter with it then I remembered I do sometimes put Nutella with PB, and I guess Nutella is a kind of nut butter but with cocoa added.

Raspberry jam with just peanut butter on bread is the height of delish.

Aroundthewaygirl · 26/11/2023 22:55

Adding butter seems too much especially the extra calories.