Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

new baby - expecting help from visitors? (close family)

213 replies

Sailawaygirl · 26/11/2023 14:42

Just need to get this of my chest. baby is 4 weeks old, i'm managing ok most of the times - a few tears at times which i think is too be expected, but im generally quite laid back and enjoying beautiful baba.

My parents live close by and until this week they have been our only visitors to baby (first grandchild so every one very excited). Mum helped by doing our clothes and towel washing in first week - which really helped. Since then I have gone round to them or asked them to pop over to see baby (who they adore obviously). But.....the timing of their visits is always when baby is asleep - which is fine but my dad keeps commenting that he never opens his eyes!! I've explained that he is always awake (and happy awake) in the morning so if they visits between 10 and 12 or about 2pm there is a good chance he will be awake and they can enjoy him looking around and making cute noises. Understandably this would also be a helpful time for me for them to visit as they can mind him while he is awake and so let me get on with a few things i want to do (like get dressed, shower, just have a bit of house tidy up ect). DH is about and holds baby for me and is good at helping, but an extra pair of arms would be helpful for both of us in the morning!
But they keep timing visits or asking us to go round for when baby is asleep !!!! this is the time when i can get on a do things, especially when we go to them!! My uncle and aunty were visiting them yesterday to see baby and staying with my parents but they didnt get there till 3 so baby slept in everyone's arms from 3 - 5.30. when we got home baby was hungry, I was hungry DH was hungry and between us we juggled feeding and doing our food and dishes ect, it was really stressful evening and i couldnt help feeling resentful that long afternoon nap time had been 'wasted' as we try and prep dinner, get stuff done or have a bit of time to our selves when he is sleeping.
I said they could visit us today and again said morning is best , mum said they were going to have a slow morning - i said no problem just call after b/fast and i will let you if now is a good time for a visit. Any way - no phone call this morning - baby was awake and happy all morning so i called them at 1230 only to find that they were walking round local town!! they arrived at ours literally 10mins after baby was asleep!! i still wasnt dressed, hadn't had time to have lunch ect. they left after 30 mins because looking at a sleeping baby is a bit boring!!! no one offered to help me with anything (apart from washing but we are on top of that now). As soon as they left i just started to cry, im hungry, thirsty, want a wash and would really like to go for walk before it goes dark, but baby is now awake and wants feeding so i wont get my walk in now. I've explained to my mum that baby has the normal 'fuss' period in evening which we have found hard to manage at times, but her response is just - oh bless' and nothing practical that might help or even a more genuine 'there there'. I wish we hadnt arranged to see them or my aunty/uncle this weekend.

OP posts:
diddl · 26/11/2023 19:07

You’re in tears, hungry, thirsty, need to wash and rest. And MNers have the nerve to click the YABU button?! I’m disgusted at that. OP,

It seems though that Op & her husband could manage that between them.

and visitors can naff right off when he arrives.

That is probably more the crux of it for Op.

She might be getting on better if people weren't visiting at inconvenient times.

StarlightLime · 26/11/2023 19:04

SiennaMillar · 26/11/2023 19:02

You’re in tears, hungry, thirsty, need to wash and rest. And MNers have the nerve to click the YABU button?! I’m disgusted at that. OP, you are NOT being unreasonable. You’re going through the hardest thing you’ll possibly ever go through, it would be nice to have a bit of help. Of course YANBU. I’m currently pregnant with second DC, and visitors can naff right off when he arrives.

They were the opposite of helpful with DC1, like you say, they added stress to my day, expecting me to host and feed them, mere days after a CS! Never again will I be that people-pleasing buffoon, next time I know to expect nothing useful from anyone.

Best of luck to you and baby, it’s hard to start with, but you’ll get there ❤️

She needs to get her dh to step up! He's right there, faffing about unable to boil pasta or do a proper shop so they have food in the house.

coxesorangepippin · 26/11/2023 19:04

Doesnt this rather depend on your idea of "help"? I would be happy to make an extra batch of meals and drop it off to make life easier for them

^^

This would have been great. Didn't happen though

WandaWonder · 26/11/2023 19:04

It was your choice to have a baby if you need people that don't live with to help you to do normal things with a baby you are not doing something right

SiennaMillar · 26/11/2023 19:02

You’re in tears, hungry, thirsty, need to wash and rest. And MNers have the nerve to click the YABU button?! I’m disgusted at that. OP, you are NOT being unreasonable. You’re going through the hardest thing you’ll possibly ever go through, it would be nice to have a bit of help. Of course YANBU. I’m currently pregnant with second DC, and visitors can naff right off when he arrives.

They were the opposite of helpful with DC1, like you say, they added stress to my day, expecting me to host and feed them, mere days after a CS! Never again will I be that people-pleasing buffoon, next time I know to expect nothing useful from anyone.

Best of luck to you and baby, it’s hard to start with, but you’ll get there ❤️

ripplingwater · 26/11/2023 18:58

The expectation always falls on women too and that just isn't fair, especially if those expectations are higher than the actual father of the baby

God yes, doesnt it just? I dont think I've ever heard of a man being asked to provide a meal for a family with a new baby or to help clean their house. 🙄

SouthLondonMum22 · 26/11/2023 18:56

ripplingwater · 26/11/2023 18:52

One thing I've learnt, people don't want to help new mothers and their newborns

Doesnt this rather depend on your idea of "help"? I would be happy to make an extra batch of meals and drop it off to make life easier for them (and in fact, have done this in past many times) but I am sorry, I draw the line at cleaning someone else's house from top to bottom or doing all their laundry for them. I have my own family/kids to take care of plus a full time job. Most people have their own family responsibilities to take care of and their own houses to clean etc I simply wouldnt have the time to take that on as well.

The expectation always falls on women too and that just isn't fair, especially if those expectations are higher than the actual father of the baby.

Elfandwellbeing · 26/11/2023 18:55

I don’t get the angst. A baby changes things yes, but your life will never be the same and expecting others to pick up any slack is a sure way to disappoint yourself.

moonlitwalks · 26/11/2023 18:55

You're expecting more of visitors than you are of your own husband. That’s your issue

This. 100%

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 26/11/2023 18:52

Caggers · 26/11/2023 14:54

DH… holds baby for me and is good at helping

You're expecting more of visitors than you are of your own husband. That’s your issue.

Sort out whatever is preventing him from equally parenting the baby, and you’ll be much less stressed.

I agree

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 26/11/2023 18:52

CleverClogg · 26/11/2023 14:48

sorry, but a 4 week old baby cannot prevent you getting washed and dressed and cooking food!

Of course it can!

ripplingwater · 26/11/2023 18:52

One thing I've learnt, people don't want to help new mothers and their newborns

Doesnt this rather depend on your idea of "help"? I would be happy to make an extra batch of meals and drop it off to make life easier for them (and in fact, have done this in past many times) but I am sorry, I draw the line at cleaning someone else's house from top to bottom or doing all their laundry for them. I have my own family/kids to take care of plus a full time job. Most people have their own family responsibilities to take care of and their own houses to clean etc I simply wouldnt have the time to take that on as well.

rainbowunicorn · 26/11/2023 18:51

SouthLondonMum22 · 26/11/2023 18:45

I actually think the difference is that some are willing to let their babies cry when they have a quick shower and some aren't.

Of course mine didn't always just sit in his bouncer or cot happy for 5-10 minutes so he cried and he had to wait because going to the toilet, having a shower, eating etc is essential, I didn't see it as optional.

Exactly this. I just can't get my head round the threads on here where babies literally get held all the time. It seems they can't ever just be left for 5 mins while the parent grabs a 5 min shower, brushes their teeth or has some food. They can be in the same room they don't need held constantly.

SouthLondonMum22 · 26/11/2023 18:45

Pelham678 · 26/11/2023 18:08

Me too. People don't seem to understand that their experience is not universal and that babies, like adults, are not all the same! For instance, my first would start crying if I just put him down. My friend's baby would happily sit on the sofa while she went and had a shower and got dressed without a care in the world.

I actually think the difference is that some are willing to let their babies cry when they have a quick shower and some aren't.

Of course mine didn't always just sit in his bouncer or cot happy for 5-10 minutes so he cried and he had to wait because going to the toilet, having a shower, eating etc is essential, I didn't see it as optional.

coxesorangepippin · 26/11/2023 18:44

One thing I've learnt, people don't want to help new mothers and their newborns

All they want is a photo opportunity and to leave

Mil and fil infamously arrived to 'help' and started making a fucking Banana bread in the kitchen, with our ingredients

Just takes the biscuit (pun intended)

StarlightLime · 26/11/2023 18:43

YouJustDoYou · 26/11/2023 18:41

It does if you have a Hellspawn like I did

Were there two of you?

YouJustDoYou · 26/11/2023 18:41

CleverClogg · 26/11/2023 14:48

sorry, but a 4 week old baby cannot prevent you getting washed and dressed and cooking food!

It does if you have a Hellspawn like I did

LaurieStrode · 26/11/2023 18:41

LimePi · 26/11/2023 18:34

@LaurieStrode

but you are mixing up two different things
someone can totally respect you and feel gratitude for your help
without wanting your opinion and advice on baby-rearing

why is that in your head the only way to feel respect and gratitude is to respectfully listen to unsolicited advice?

Well, that's where we disagree.

"Unsolicited " is an insult when referring to the suggestions of family and friends. They're not some busybody strangers in Tesco.

StarlightLime · 26/11/2023 18:41

Sailawaygirl · 26/11/2023 18:36

I'm going to stop looking at this thread any more but I am not upset or feel DH isn't doing enough. I was upset ( irrationally I now admit) that visitors hadn't taken on board my time preference and stupidly I had then planned things round there visit. In the silly hope that this might bring down some if the barriers between me and parents. I also had this false vision in my head of someone asking if there was anything they could do to help.

I find days soo much eiaser when we don't have to visit anyone and me DH and baby can just do our thing. And I think we are coping really well. And as I have said we have not had many visitors at all just my parents and my uncle and aunty.

I now have to think about how I take a step back from everyone without hurting the family who di want to see baby.

So thank you

I don't think you crying from hunger and thirst while he nipped out to get some milk can be defined as coping really well, op?
How did the food run out?

Nofilteritwonthelp · 26/11/2023 18:40

CleverClogg · 26/11/2023 14:48

sorry, but a 4 week old baby cannot prevent you getting washed and dressed and cooking food!

This. Also its great if people come and help you, but the reality is most people come to play with the baby not to your house work (unfortunately!)

AngelAurora · 26/11/2023 18:40

So basically you expect your visitors to come clean the house etc?

You need to start sorting yourself out, you are an adult fgs

newhaircut · 26/11/2023 18:38

If you are struggling to eat dinner, that is not your parents or uncles fault. That is your DH’s fault

Yes- this is exactly what I cant get my head around. Of all the people I would expect to help me with dinner, it would be my DH- my life partner and father of my baby, not my parents or my uncle. I dont understand how DH popping out to the shop for milk (which cant have taken hours and hours) means noone had anything to eat and ended up hungry.

Sailawaygirl · 26/11/2023 18:36

I'm going to stop looking at this thread any more but I am not upset or feel DH isn't doing enough. I was upset ( irrationally I now admit) that visitors hadn't taken on board my time preference and stupidly I had then planned things round there visit. In the silly hope that this might bring down some if the barriers between me and parents. I also had this false vision in my head of someone asking if there was anything they could do to help.

I find days soo much eiaser when we don't have to visit anyone and me DH and baby can just do our thing. And I think we are coping really well. And as I have said we have not had many visitors at all just my parents and my uncle and aunty.

I now have to think about how I take a step back from everyone without hurting the family who di want to see baby.

So thank you

OP posts:
LimePi · 26/11/2023 18:34

@LaurieStrode

but you are mixing up two different things
someone can totally respect you and feel gratitude for your help
without wanting your opinion and advice on baby-rearing

why is that in your head the only way to feel respect and gratitude is to respectfully listen to unsolicited advice?

Nowherenew · 26/11/2023 18:34

And yes life would be easier without visitors right now!

Put your foot down and tell them not to come round then.
Or say can you come between 12-1 and then plan things for when they come (eg having lunch or washing the dishes).
Its your home.

You also need to stop treating DH like a child.
He’s an adult, just like you.
He’s now a parent, just like you and doesn’t get to not pull his weight just because he’s a man.

You need to rely on your DH more than your parents or other family members.
If they come round and you can have a break then great but you shouldn’t feel angry at them for it.

As a PP said, be open with them and say I’m struggling please can you come over so I can have a shower and clean up or something.

I think you are misdirecting your feelings.
If you are struggling to eat dinner, that is not your parents or uncles fault. That is your DH’s fault.
When there are 2 parents, one of you can make the food and one of you can feed the baby. It shouldn’t have to be difficult.

You have to start putting yourself first.