Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to feel a bit nervous about Chinese pneumonia?

136 replies

CleverClogg · 26/11/2023 10:09

Lets hope it is nothing. But I have a lot of respect for the Chinese health system, and think they are far more likely to pick up on something untoward in its early stages... maybe that is why they picked up on Covid first, as there seems to be no doubt now it had gone all the way around the world before it was noticed. I am not implying this has originated in China, just that they are picking up on anomalies, the same way Spanish flu didn't originate in Spain, it was just that the Spanish health system was the first to pick up on anomalies then.

I know there will be other pandemics, obviously, and the most unusual thing about covid was the long time before hand without a major infectious pandemic. But I think we would be very unlucky to see another one so soon. Just a depressing thought. AIBU to feel a bit nervous?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
WrongSwanson · 26/11/2023 11:02

OnGoldenPond · 26/11/2023 10:59

On the lion analogy:

COVID 19 was a novel coronavirus that had not been seen anywhere else before emerging from Wuhan, whether from a wet market or a lab. It is therefore entirely correct to refer to Wuhan as the original source of COVID19 as it was created there.

Lions evolved millions of years ago and have been established in several places around the world since before modern humans evolved. So obviously London Zoo having some individuals of a species that has been established around the world for that long would not justify calling it the source of all lions.

However, if London Zoo ran a scientific experiment involving genetic modification and produced an entirely new species of purple lions, it would be entirely correct to refer to London Zoo as the source of all purple lions.

Exactly.

CleverClogg · 26/11/2023 11:01

WrongSwanson · 26/11/2023 10:49

Agreed.

I don't think anyone sensible doubts whether it originated in china.

Baffled by @CleverClogg agenda here tbh

what agenda? Why would I have an agenda? I am simply chatting about my worries, and hoping for some reassurances, as an impartial biologist (specifically a pathologist- but some decades ago, I am a teacher now)

OP posts:
WrongSwanson · 26/11/2023 11:01

CleverClogg · 26/11/2023 10:58

Again, not a biologist ay?

Novel viruses arise continually - nothing at all remarkable about that

I know novel viruses arise continually.
Why are you so keen to advance the idea it wasn't the lab 🤔

vodkaredbullgirl · 26/11/2023 11:01

I'm going to be thinking of purple coloured lions now 😆

IClaudine · 26/11/2023 11:01

Maybe it is stupid of ne, but I must admit I got a little chill down my spine when I first heard about this, but I am sure the chances of it developing into something for the rest of the world to worry about are very low.🤞 I hope the children all recover OK.

Might go and buy some extra loo roll though 😁

OnGoldenPond · 26/11/2023 10:59

On the lion analogy:

COVID 19 was a novel coronavirus that had not been seen anywhere else before emerging from Wuhan, whether from a wet market or a lab. It is therefore entirely correct to refer to Wuhan as the original source of COVID19 as it was created there.

Lions evolved millions of years ago and have been established in several places around the world since before modern humans evolved. So obviously London Zoo having some individuals of a species that has been established around the world for that long would not justify calling it the source of all lions.

However, if London Zoo ran a scientific experiment involving genetic modification and produced an entirely new species of purple lions, it would be entirely correct to refer to London Zoo as the source of all purple lions.

CleverClogg · 26/11/2023 10:58

WrongSwanson · 26/11/2023 10:39

What a bizarre and nonsensical analogy.

COVID was a novel virus.

A better analogy would be if a zoo bred a lion with a an elephant and created a new monster beast and that escaped

Again, not a biologist ay?

Novel viruses arise continually - nothing at all remarkable about that

OP posts:
Notmetoo · 26/11/2023 10:57

I agree, we ignored it for too long last time and this version affects children so is even more frightening.
The fact that s many people on this thread haven't heard about it shows we are in danger if down playing it's danger again

ThisUsernameIsNotAvailablePlsTryAnother · 26/11/2023 10:57

hellsBells246 · 26/11/2023 10:46

But I have a lot of respect for the Chinese health system, and think they are far more likely to pick up on something untoward in its early stages... maybe that is why they picked up on Covid first, as there seems to be no doubt now it had gone all the way around the world before it was noticed

Are you kidding? Or being ironic?

What proof is there for that? If China had been open and honest about the mysterious new illness for which they had to build several new hospitals, then the pandemic wouldn't have been nearly as bad as it was, and millions of lives could have been saved.

I actually went to 'like' your post there..then remembered I was on Mumsnet 😂

Elastica23 · 26/11/2023 10:57

If anyone was surprised by Covid, then they just weren't paying attention.

But why would anyone be paying attention?Unless it's your job to, or your hobby is worrying yourself to death.

I’d keep an eye on it because I find it news- worthy and do not want a repeat of 2020

It won't change anything whether or not you keep an eye on it. Unless your job is Chief Medical Officer or the like.

BungleandGeorge · 26/11/2023 10:57

I think you’re going to have to provide some evidence that Covid ‘had been all around the world’ until the amazing Chinese health service (or that poor doctor who disappeared) picked up on it?

Seaglass7 · 26/11/2023 10:56

DyslexicPoster · 26/11/2023 10:52

Because I'm a biologist and it's fascinating. I was also fascinated in February 2020 how people didn't think it would reach the UK.

Don't mistake watching with being alarmed. I'm also very interested in the South Sea anomaly but I'm not doing anything about either.

What is the South Sea anomaly?

ThisUsernameIsNotAvailablePlsTryAnother · 26/11/2023 10:55

"If a lion escapes from London zoo that does not make London zoo the origin of all lions, does it"

Eh? If the lion escaped then the the danger posed from that lion originates from London zoo. It doesn't really matter that lions dont originally come from London.
And in the same way the Covid outbreak originated from China so the origins of the pandemic are from China.

Chersfrozenface · 26/11/2023 10:54

..the same way Spanish flu didn't originate in Spain, it was just that the Spanish health system was the first to pick up on anomalies then.

This is not true.

It was called "the Spanish flu" because other countries in Europe and beyond where the flu pandemic had taken hold were fighting World War I and wartime censors suppressed bad news to maintain morale, but Spain was neutral and its newspapers were free to report the outbreak, creating a false impression of Spain as the origin or epicentre.

CleverClogg · 26/11/2023 10:53

VickyEadieofThigh · 26/11/2023 10:46

Covid - I remember vividly the following:

  • News reports of an outbreak of a virus in Wuhan, followed swiftly by action to try to contain it.
  • It spreading across Europe, with especially bad results in Italy
  • Us in the UK watching other countries locking their borders (especially to China) and us not bothering until it was far too late.
  • Us in the UK watching other countries locking down and us not bothering until a lit later.

I certainly don't recognise the scenario you describe. We watched it explode in China and then travel to us. The numbers of cases were given on TV news even before we had our first.

It was retrospectively diagnosed in the Uk in November/December 2019. UK Health services hadn't picked up on the anomalies. Ditto many other western heath services. It was already here and already killing months before the first officially diagnosed case. Of course it was -that is always the way - but pretty shameful how many months out many health services were

OP posts:
Greenshake · 26/11/2023 10:52

LittleStringOfFairyLights · 26/11/2023 10:43

To those of you 'keeping an eye' on things, why?
What will you/can you do about it?

Forewarned is forearmed. This would allow for arrangements to be made re work, supplies to be sorted and so forth. COVID caught a lot of people (general public) on the hop and that was part of the problem.

LardoBurrows · 26/11/2023 10:52

The reason why the Chinese picked up on Covid first was because it started in China, and was possibly manufactured in the Wuhan Institute of Virology, not because of their superior health system.

DyslexicPoster · 26/11/2023 10:52

LittleStringOfFairyLights · 26/11/2023 10:43

To those of you 'keeping an eye' on things, why?
What will you/can you do about it?

Because I'm a biologist and it's fascinating. I was also fascinated in February 2020 how people didn't think it would reach the UK.

Don't mistake watching with being alarmed. I'm also very interested in the South Sea anomaly but I'm not doing anything about either.

WrongSwanson · 26/11/2023 10:51

LittleStringOfFairyLights · 26/11/2023 10:43

To those of you 'keeping an eye' on things, why?
What will you/can you do about it?

I mean, we were well prepared at home with good supplies of non perishables and all the family medications etc by the end of Jan 2020, well before everyone started panic buying. And I'd at least tried to get work to make emergency plans.

Bluesea123 · 26/11/2023 10:50

I’d keep an eye on it because I find it news- worthy and do not want a repeat of 2020

WrongSwanson · 26/11/2023 10:49

VickyEadieofThigh · 26/11/2023 10:46

Covid - I remember vividly the following:

  • News reports of an outbreak of a virus in Wuhan, followed swiftly by action to try to contain it.
  • It spreading across Europe, with especially bad results in Italy
  • Us in the UK watching other countries locking their borders (especially to China) and us not bothering until it was far too late.
  • Us in the UK watching other countries locking down and us not bothering until a lit later.

I certainly don't recognise the scenario you describe. We watched it explode in China and then travel to us. The numbers of cases were given on TV news even before we had our first.

Agreed.

I don't think anyone sensible doubts whether it originated in china.

Baffled by @CleverClogg agenda here tbh

VickyEadieofThigh · 26/11/2023 10:46

CleverClogg · 26/11/2023 10:09

Lets hope it is nothing. But I have a lot of respect for the Chinese health system, and think they are far more likely to pick up on something untoward in its early stages... maybe that is why they picked up on Covid first, as there seems to be no doubt now it had gone all the way around the world before it was noticed. I am not implying this has originated in China, just that they are picking up on anomalies, the same way Spanish flu didn't originate in Spain, it was just that the Spanish health system was the first to pick up on anomalies then.

I know there will be other pandemics, obviously, and the most unusual thing about covid was the long time before hand without a major infectious pandemic. But I think we would be very unlucky to see another one so soon. Just a depressing thought. AIBU to feel a bit nervous?

Covid - I remember vividly the following:

  • News reports of an outbreak of a virus in Wuhan, followed swiftly by action to try to contain it.
  • It spreading across Europe, with especially bad results in Italy
  • Us in the UK watching other countries locking their borders (especially to China) and us not bothering until it was far too late.
  • Us in the UK watching other countries locking down and us not bothering until a lit later.

I certainly don't recognise the scenario you describe. We watched it explode in China and then travel to us. The numbers of cases were given on TV news even before we had our first.

Hbh17 · 26/11/2023 10:46

Worrying about stuff like this is pointless. The last pandemic showed that, because public hysteria pushed Governments around the world into unnecessary restrictions, which ended up causing up more problems than they solved.
Just live your life.... and what will be, will be.

hellsBells246 · 26/11/2023 10:46

But I have a lot of respect for the Chinese health system, and think they are far more likely to pick up on something untoward in its early stages... maybe that is why they picked up on Covid first, as there seems to be no doubt now it had gone all the way around the world before it was noticed

Are you kidding? Or being ironic?

What proof is there for that? If China had been open and honest about the mysterious new illness for which they had to build several new hospitals, then the pandemic wouldn't have been nearly as bad as it was, and millions of lives could have been saved.

Swipe left for the next trending thread