Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to feel concerned about coming back to live in the U.K.

114 replies

tropicaltailwind · 25/11/2023 17:03

I’m an expat. I left the U.K. in 2011. I go back every year to see family and friends. I keep up with British news and politics. I still think of Britain as my ancestral home. And I’m planning to come back, probably within four years.

I am worried about the Britain I’m bringing my family back to. The NHS under severe strain, crumbling social services, cost of living, shit in the rivers and sea, the rise of hard right politics. Do you think life in Britain has changed significantly in the last dozen years? Am I BU to worry about coming home?

OP posts:
notquitesoyoung · 26/11/2023 01:22

Not dissimilar to you @tropicaltailwind although we have moved around lots. I have seen changes in most countries we've lived in after we've left. No where seems to be immune from many of the issues currently faced by many in the UK. The UK is very very UK centric. Most people have no idea what it's like to live in other countries or the challenges living away can bring. I think you just have to make your own call and have faith that at the time you made the best decision for your circumstances with the facts available at the time. Hindsight is a wonderful thing which sadly none of us possess.

Just a point re your DS - if uni in the UK is in the future the only way to guarantee both home status & student finance is 3 years residency so that means whole family moving back (can't be just child for educational purposes) either to start GCSE's in Y10 or for sixth form but would need a gap year. There are lots of examples of Home Status for expats but it's getting harder and there are no guarantees. Student Finance is a separate process and even those expats who get Home status don't always get loans.

JFT · 26/11/2023 01:17

@tropicaltailwind there was a thread on here the other day = someone wanting to move from London but to a location with a good standard of living, healthy creative vibe and progressive schools etc.

Anyway there was much input but I did notice Norwich recommended many times. I've never been to Norwich (wasn't even sure where it was) but when I researched, it does sound like a lovely place with many great points and also beautiful landscape / geography. Since you mention that you'd maybe relocate to Norwich, then perhaps this is a happy coincidence? Living somewhere affordable in the UK with a decent standard of living and interesting population has got to be better than, say, the increasing drudgery and failings of London.

tropicaltailwind · 26/11/2023 00:32

Thanks for all the messages. Lots of think about and I really appreciate the time taken to share views.
I’m in a British overseas territory but don’t want to say which one as people are terrible gossips and I don’t want folks here to work out that we might be leaving yet.
I don’t read the Mail, lol, it’s awful and getting worse. I keep up with news from BBC, C4, Guardian, and my friends and family in the U.K. Friends and fam want us to come back which is why I wanted to survey unbiased views on MN.

The state of healthcare, democracy, environment in my current location isn’t the post here: DH and I are here to work and as expats, we are guests. Drawing me back to to the U.K. is aging parents, time with siblings and cousins, and DS wanting to take A levels and go to Uni (DS is 13 so still some time but we’d need to move when he’s 16 to access 6th form college).

Life where we are is VERY expensive and not much for teens to do. We are a part of the island community -our friends are mostly locals and long term expats. I want to be clear eyed about what life will be like if we return. Does the country I grew up in and left aged 39 still feel the same or has Brexit, Covid, austerity, etc changed it a lot?

I have lived and worked in other countries before I was married. I left the U.K. a with a newborn baby and would be coming back parent of a teen. I need to think about DS future - he grew up an island child, he has a U.K. passport. I want to think about his future. I appreciate all the insights. Thank you again .

OP posts:
Vinrouge4 · 25/11/2023 23:31

Every country has its pros and cons. It’s easier to think the grass is greener elsewhere. The NHS is variable but not as bad as you read in the papers. I’ve lived all over the world but, despite its shortcomings, I love the UK best.

Copperoliverbear · 25/11/2023 23:22

I wouldn't bother, the whole place is being left to rot, they couldn't care less about us, the streets are rotten, there's illegals sleeping everywhere, people are living in poverty and rents are crazy, more people rely on food banks, hardly any banks on the high street, shops are closing everywhere, I'd stay were I was if I were you.
They couldn't run a country here if their lives depended on it, instead of given millions to France who do nothing for the money, put it into the NHS and back into building up your own economy. You're better off were you are.

drowningfrowning · 25/11/2023 23:12

Nomnomnom66 · 25/11/2023 17:45

Expat - you mean an emigrant

Not if it's temporary. Emigration refers to moving location permanently. Expat is when your right to remain in the new country is dependent on your current job

MotherOfRatios · 25/11/2023 23:02

I think it depends on so many factors. Racism impact is all, but more so if you are a person of colour.
also, if you have a very high and the cost of living might not impact you as much.

it is very varied and depends on each individuals circumstances I think

LadyMacB · 25/11/2023 22:49

To what extent are the issues faced by the UK shared by other countries too? We will all have seen what’s gone on in Ireland the last few days, and the result of the election in the Netherlands.

lljkk · 25/11/2023 22:35

The NHS under severe strain, crumbling social services, cost of living, shit in the rivers and sea, the rise of hard right politics

So.. where OP lives there's no environmental degradation, no social inequality, cheap accessible public services, and great democracy. Right?

Strokethefurrywall · 25/11/2023 22:02

@ChickaboomZoom my family are now in West Sussex (Horsham), but we lived close to Wimbledon 😁

Every time I come back now I am wearing rose tinted glasses. I get to wander through the city doing fun touristy things with my kids, showing my old stomping grounds, going to the theatre and adventure activities like Chessington/Go Ape etc. I miss the Uk immensely although I think it's helped by the fact that I've had amazing weather each time I come (luck of the gods apparently).

It's hard now because the kids are heading into teen years and there's not much here in Cayman to keep them occupied. Whenever we're back in the UK the first thing they want to do is going to a park or a farm. Like toddlers 😂

Cayman is unrecognizable now. I arrived in 2007 and the changes even in the last 5 years have been vast. It has lost so much of its charm, the beach is still beautiful but practically non-existent due to erosion, and there are pretentious Instagram hotels popping up all over the place. But still we love it...

HuntingoftheSnark · 25/11/2023 21:22

I wondered if the OP was in Bermuda. I worked there for 10 years as an expat, back in the UK for 20 years now. For me the move back was "when" not "if", so it was all about timing - and reasons of education for my DD, elderly relatives, buying property rather than renting, getting back into the London workforce in my case. I hated the first year back but I wasn't keen on my first year overseas either, so I guess I'm just not great with change. Wouldn't have it any other way now though.

ChickaboomZoom · 25/11/2023 21:17

Strokethefurrywall · 25/11/2023 20:38

@ChickaboomZoom I'm a Londoner but live in Cayman now! Have been here for over 16 years...

Aww small world! I’ve lived just outside London for the better part of 20 years although I did go home to Cayman between 2007-2011. I miss it so much but I bet it’s unrecognisable to me now…

I do feel for the OP because being an expat can be hard. I miss home but we are fairly settled here in the UK despite the not so great things sometimes, I would still rather be here for now while the kids are finishing school etc. I try not to get lulled into a grass is greener on the other side mentality because I think every country has its issues.

JFT · 25/11/2023 21:09

Torganer · 25/11/2023 19:26

First I would stop reading the Daily Mail!!

It’s not like this where I live in London. I have an NHS dentist, excellent NHS doctor and hospital service, and the Thames will be cleaner than ever when the Thames Tideway Tunnel is finished. Trains run on time, tube and busses are amazing, and my local area has a great sense of community.

@Torganer

Any chance you could hint at where you live?

I live in C Lon and it's a sh*thole nowadays. It's never been so crowded, noisy, hostile, dirty, expensive, the air is filthy. People are miserable, uptight, anxious and self-centred ever since covid. There's an air of constant tension and agitation. Nobody I know can get a dentist for love nor money, our GPs are horrific, all they want to do is 'gatekeep' and I've started to suspect they're on a reward system where they get paid every time a patient leaves the appointment and they've done a flat nothing. The NHS is dire, the hospitals are dire, they're getting bad CQC reports. Crime is ludicrous. Commuting is crap and tense. Homelessness is peak. Oh yeah and dogs, everyone's got dogs now. Even the shops are crap now, half of the high street is kingdom of sweets stores LOL. I want out!

To the OP, if I had the chance I'd be long gone out of this miserable country. Sadly I don't have any choice as I'm British and don't have any other passport or nationality.

LightSpeeds · 25/11/2023 21:03

Yes, things have changed a lot over the last 10-20 years.

Roads are terrible, you can wait almost a day for an ambulance (then have a terrible time in hospital), wait 6 weeks for a GP appointment, lots of people can't get a dentist.

Public transport is pretty bad (unreliable, understaffed and lots of strikes).

Lots of homeless people sleeping in empty shop doorways.

Lots of the big shops have closed down. Police don't bother investigating or turning up for a lot of crime.

The cost of everything is going up and a lot of people can't afford to live!

Everything has gone downhill.

beachcitygirl · 25/11/2023 21:01

If you were coming to Scotland, I wouldn't worry. England, not so much. I'm not saying that to be toady, just much better schooling & NHS (still far from perfect obvs)
Not the same level of anti-immigration rhetoric, much much much less Tories, a more progressive society, more space, free public transport for kids, free uni tuition, bedroom tax not payable, free prescriptions, state schools good. None of these mental schools with hitleresque headteachers.

Money goes a long way in housing market. Gorgeous beaches.
Shit weather tho - that can't be got away from.

DryIce · 25/11/2023 20:57

I'm not from the UK and I moved here 13 years ago. In my view it has massively deteriorated and i don't think I would make the same decision now.

Obviously for me it's different, now I have children and am settled. We are fairly well off and can insulate ourselves from some of the issues.

But it feels like a very different place to me from the one I moved to. The future does not seem optimistic, and if I were in my prior position and had options of places to move, I would not now choose the UK

Crikeyalmighty · 25/11/2023 20:48

@belladonna22 interesting and thoughtful post and I agree with you. To some extent you can be slightly insulated here by simply paying over the odds and living in a nice but expensive area- there is no doubt in my opinion that whilst not perfect these areas have got better resources because other similar people also want to live in those areas - so I was impressed with the quality of the medical staff at our hospital , the schools are good because good teachers want to live there- it's easy to think itsall fine and rosy - just with potholes and not enough social housing - because our small city is busy, vibrant and still has lots going for it. Travel around as we do for work etc when touring and you get to see that some places really are struggling badly, I wouldn't rush to go in at all to very many town centres- many places are bordering on desolate. I also had the misfortune to have to use an A&E in a not great area and it was not good. Dirty,fights in the car park - just felt third world.

It's totally true about young people and trades and this is one area the Tory's have been very poor in defunding FE to such an extent. Look at the Germans and Dutch they have practical skills pathways in schools from about 14 for those who want to go in that direction.

Takenwithtea · 25/11/2023 20:44

It's horrifying. Nothing that wasn't entirely predictable and expected when the Conservatives came in in 2008, but there was hope that it wouldn't get so very bad.

If you're not very rich,life can be very, very frightening right now. If you have alternatives for your child I'd go with those, or at least keep your options open so the move can be temporary or you can travel for healthcare, university, etc. if needed.

Strokethefurrywall · 25/11/2023 20:38

@ChickaboomZoom I'm a Londoner but live in Cayman now! Have been here for over 16 years...

belladonna22 · 25/11/2023 20:32

Short answer: no, you are not being unreasonable to worry about it.

Long answer: it depends. As many people have pointed out, life is certainly better here than many other places in the world. But presumably you're not deciding between the UK and somewhere worse, you might have the choice of different high income countries. We also have the same privilege (husband is British, I am not, we have the ability to live and work multiple places and are therefore weighing up our own options). Most commenters here have probably never lived outside the UK and never will. There's absolutely nothing wrong with that, but their comments that it's fine aren't really helpful to you in your situation.

As others have said, if you have the resources to live in a good area with good schools and nice families, you can have a pleasant existence. If you have private health care, you can insulate yourself from some of the issues with the NHS.

But what I keep thinking about is my children's future, and what this country will look like in 10, 20, 30 years.

I look at how the education system is a mess, how we have lots of graduates with degrees that are not serving them well in the job market, while at the same time there are labour shortages in other critical areas (medicine, engineering) which mean we need to keep bringing in lots of immigrants. Obviously I'm not bothered by immigration, but high levels of immigration have had a materially deleterious effect on this country's politics!

Outside of unis, we seem to be doing a terrible job of getting young people into trades and other non-academic life paths, leaving many of them adrift and resigned to a life of low-quality, low-security, low-wage work.

Underfunding of everything pervades and undercuts all the public services in ways that intersect and multiply. Underfunded councils don't have the resources to put children with SEN into the settings they need, so they end up in underfunded mainstream schools which don't have the resources or staff to support them to learn properly. These kids often end up disrupting the classes (not their fault, mind you!) which then negatively impacts others around them. This happens day in, day out in so many schools across the country, year after year. So we're ending up with one group of kids not receiving the education they deserve because their needs are unmet, and another group also not getting the education they deserve because the limited teacher time and resources are disproportionately spent managing the behavior of a small group.

So I wonder: when these kids are in their 20s, 30s, 40s, what will the workforce look like? Who is going to be doing the high skill jobs of the future? Or will many Brits be consigned to a grim life while immigrants will come in, do the high wage jobs and pay the taxes that native Brits will live off via benefits (which already kind of happens already). Again, I'm very pro-immigration, but it feels so depressing if it's occurring because we're just not educating British children properly to begin with.

Sure, we can privately educate, and live in our middle class enclave, and try to insulate ourselves, but I'd rather live in a society where the median person is successful, rather than a place with high and rising inequality where I waste my children's childhoods worrying whether I've done enough to ensure their future success.

Anyway, as you can see I've thought about this rather a lot 🤣

Best of luck to you!

Peablockfeathers · 25/11/2023 20:24

lkwhjis · 25/11/2023 19:18

Stay away. Most of the UK now looks and feels like a third world hellhole.

No it doesn't, super ignorant.

Bethebest · 25/11/2023 20:21

Hovella which secondary schools would you recommend in Norfolk please? Thanks so much

Wonderlot · 25/11/2023 20:12

Day to day it really isn’t that bad for the majority of people. The press (and mumsnet) like to catastrophize

jfoyo26 · 25/11/2023 20:09

We very recently moved back from the USA. We moved back to a more affluent area than where we are originally from and love it, there is a lot going on in our community but most of it is volunteer lead! The council seems more of a hindrance than a help most the time and are struggling to keep the most basic amenities functioning well - they just removed half the bins in our area and replaced them with giant ones to save money on bin bags 😂! We purposefully moved to an area with good schools, I like the small community feel of the schools here and low gun crime but certainly in our school the tech is WAYYY behind even the underfunded US public schools - other areas of teaching much better though. The NHS has not been as bad as I expected, but we have private health and dental and I would not have been comfortable making the move without it. I think if you are doing ok financially life here is still good, there is so much culturally we are enjoying about being home - after a decade that doesn't feel too different. The US is soooo affluent and the UK definitely feels A LOT poorer though. P.S: we lived somewhere warm and sunny in the States and I would say the winter weather is the most miserable aspect of living here. If you can get over that, the rest will be plain sailing.

Crikeyalmighty · 25/11/2023 19:59

@Crispedia Copenhagen was great thanks- we came back mainly for elderly relative reasons plus partly work - we had to come back to uk regularly and post Brexit, flight prices doubled and availability halved- really liked Copenhagen, efficient, clean, fun vibe- nice in winter and summer, I will say though the Danes are hardball on non EU citizens (despite the fact we moved during withdrawal agreement phase.you need quite a lot of money in your account if you aren't working for a Danish company and it's high on beurocracy - House rental deposits are 3 months- plus no tenancy deposit scheme and you have to hand back in a fully renovated condition (striped floors, newly painted etc) or you will lose most of your deposit- lifestyle great- but other things - er not so much!! Sweden has a much lighter touch by the way and much lower deposits-