Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that you shouldn’t choose to rent an upstairs 2 bed flat if you have 4 noisy kids

405 replies

shatteredmama · 25/11/2023 14:51

Just after your thoughts. We rent a ground floor flat, we expect to hear some of the usual sounds of upstairs neighbours such as footsteps, doors closing, washing machine, Hoover, the odd thud. Am absolutely fine with that.

A new couple moved into the flat upstairs, normal neighbour noises could be heard. No problem with that. Soon after they told me they had lied to our landlord and that it won’t just be the two of them, their 4 boys from the ages of 2 -11 would be coming over from their home country and living in that flat with them. Theirs is a 2 bedroom flat, no outside space, our flats are converted from 1 house. As she told me this she laughed and her exact words were oh you’ll know when they’ve arrived. Things are going to get very noisy!

Since the kids moved in the noise levels are ridiculous. Constant loud bangs, thuds, shouting, squealing, we can hear them running up and down their flat. It isn’t occasional. It’s all day every day as not all of them attend school.

I know kids make noise. On a couple of occasions I’ve knocked on and as nicely and politely as possible explained how it’s impacting us. For example when my child was crying and couldn’t go to sleep at bedtime because all the kids in the room above were jumping off the sofa onto the floor, our lampshade was swinging from the impact. At other times they’ve all been running and screeching so loud it sounds as though they are actually in our flat with us. The neighbours have then shrugged, argued back and said they’d try to keep the noise down but there’s nothing they can do.

I don’t know what we can do other than move out ourselves, but with the housing crisis the way it is, it wouldn’t be easy. I feel angry that they lied to get the tenancy and moved the family in knowing that it would disturb us and make our lives difficult.

Would any of you say I’m justified in feeling this way, any practical advice you’d give?

OP posts:
FrenchToastLover · 25/11/2023 20:45

shatteredmama · 25/11/2023 20:34

Just to clarify for the few posters sparring for a fight - yes I was shocked and angry at her laughing that it was going to get noisy. That however is not the main thing upsetting me. It is the noise that is the issue. You may have misinterpreted what I was trying to express, which is that her gleeful arrogance was the worst way she could’ve approached this. Also it wasn’t delivered in a kids will be kids type of way, it was done in a fuck you, deal with it, type of way.

"sparring for a fight"

You posted on an aibu thread. People are allowed to take in your words and come to the conclusion that you are in fact bu. Were you hoping everyone would just agree throw sympathy your way?

It's not "looking for a fight" for people to think that based on what you've said that you might not be telling the full story, might be making things personal between you and this woman etc

I didn't realize that disagreeing with your stance wasn't an option 🙄

shatteredmama · 25/11/2023 20:34

Just to clarify for the few posters sparring for a fight - yes I was shocked and angry at her laughing that it was going to get noisy. That however is not the main thing upsetting me. It is the noise that is the issue. You may have misinterpreted what I was trying to express, which is that her gleeful arrogance was the worst way she could’ve approached this. Also it wasn’t delivered in a kids will be kids type of way, it was done in a fuck you, deal with it, type of way.

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 25/11/2023 20:19

Why do people think the local authority will accept they're overcrowded? The youngest child at the very least won't even count as a whole person, all the children are the same sex and <9 years of one another and there's a third room to use as a bedroom (as well as it being a living room).

That's the sort of age and sex distribution that'll have them still deemed as adequately housed with 9 kids, never mind 4.

sollenwir · 25/11/2023 20:15

LaurieStrode · 25/11/2023 19:58

But everyone has an obligation to make sure their feral offspring aren't bothering others. Cramming four kids into one bedroom, never taking them to the park, laughing about the nuisance to the neighbours, etc., is all-around shitty parenting.

And yes, people ARE accountable for how many kids they choose to produce.

Bear in mind we're only hearing how OP has described the situation, and being as she doesn't seem to like them much.......

PinotViogner · 25/11/2023 20:14

Arguing about why the woman in question had so many children is such a useless and stupid argument. The kids are already here, existing. She's hardly going to look at this thread and think "yeah fair enough I do have a lot of kids let me just delete a few". They exist now and need a home is the fact of the matter.

Like a pp mentioned I'm very happy to be called preachy if preachy means not wanting four kids to be homeless because OP didn't like their mums attitude (I'll take this opportunity to remind anyone reading that OP has already said in another response that the women's attitude is her real problem and not the noise).

LaurieStrode · 25/11/2023 19:58

PinotViogner · 25/11/2023 18:51

Always lovely to see the "why have umpteen kids in the first place" lot are alive and kicking on this thread.

Newsflash: children are not a commodity that only the rich and privileged are entitled to. Nobody owes you an explanation for why they have children, how many they have, are choosing childfree etc That's not the issue here.

The use of the word "choose" in the title and ops admittance that she was more bothered by the woman's attitude than the noise itself tells me all i need to know here.

But everyone has an obligation to make sure their feral offspring aren't bothering others. Cramming four kids into one bedroom, never taking them to the park, laughing about the nuisance to the neighbours, etc., is all-around shitty parenting.

And yes, people ARE accountable for how many kids they choose to produce.

sollenwir · 25/11/2023 19:56

TooOldForThisNonsense · 25/11/2023 19:30

It’s also easy to sit behind a screen and make preachy po faced comments when it’s not your life being made a misery by people like this..

Yes, it is depressing when people like the OP’s neighbours break their tenancy agreement and act in such a selfish, entitled way not giving 2 shites about the misery they and their feral brats cause others.

why don’t you pm the OP your address and the family from hell can move in near you?

What an original reply, another typical response from behind a screen.

FrenchToastLover · 25/11/2023 19:54

It's the use of the word CHOOSE for me...

OP might I suggest that you simply choose to go live in a nice, isolated mansion somewhere far from any devilish brats? Seems to me that your CHOICE to live in a rented downstairs flat isn't working out so great.

If it's preachy to think that a family of six shouldn't be made homeless because OP was sad about a lack of apology from the mum then I'm more than happy to be preachy 😁

CornishGem1975 · 25/11/2023 19:40

I think you can choose wherever you bloody well like to live, kids or no kids. You can always move. Don't live on a lower level flat if you don't like noise.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 25/11/2023 19:38

Some of your kids must have been feral as well if this sounds like normal child noise. No my kids weren’t totally silent when they were young but they certainly didn’t scream, shout, run around constantly and repeatedly jump off sofas

Lavender14 · 25/11/2023 19:32

35965a · 25/11/2023 14:56

As you said yourself, with the housing crisis it isn’t easy. Can’t blame them to be honest. It’s a battle getting a new place.

This^
It's understandably frustrating for you but equally with options so limited, expensive and competitive now I can fully understand why they've done what they had to do to be able to have their children live with them. As most parents would want. The noise you are describing is normal household noise for a household with youngish children. They have a right to enjoy their home which for children means playing and being noisy. I'm sure it's not easy for the parents to manage in a 2 bed flat either especially if they've had a period of separation from their children and the kids are adjusting to a new home, country and care providers. That's a lot. You also don't know if the kids have additional needs/ trauma etc.

Your options are to make a noise complaint to your landlord (I personally wouldn't where children are involved but it's your choice to make), or if you don't want to hear your upstairs neighbours- to move. Or you try to make an agreement with your neighbour about noise that reflects your child's bedtime. But as they've said, they won't always be able to keep their kids quiet at a set time.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 25/11/2023 19:30

sollenwir · 25/11/2023 16:23

It's really easy to make statements like that from behind a screen.

What a depressive world we live in.

It’s also easy to sit behind a screen and make preachy po faced comments when it’s not your life being made a misery by people like this..

Yes, it is depressing when people like the OP’s neighbours break their tenancy agreement and act in such a selfish, entitled way not giving 2 shites about the misery they and their feral brats cause others.

why don’t you pm the OP your address and the family from hell can move in near you?

AgnesX · 25/11/2023 19:26

WonderLife · 25/11/2023 14:59

All these people hoping to make 4 children homeless in the middle of winter Shock

Oh please🙄You'd be complaining if you were on the receiving end.

FrenchToastLover · 25/11/2023 19:23

I was with OP for the most part until that comment about the neighbors attitude and lack of apology being the real thing she's angry about it. Makes me wonder if the noise is actually fairly minimal but she feels a personal vendetta at this point.

Either way, the comments suggesting she try to have 4 children evicted, potentially homeless, in the middle of winter because she felt a bit slighted are perfectly modern Britain. Ghoulish.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 25/11/2023 19:14

All the preachy po faced types would no doubt be up in arms if this was their lives being made a misery in this way. These brats sound feral and not just making normal kid noises.

Given how hard it is to evict even the feckless who don’t pay their rent I can’t imagine they’d get chucked out any time soon but why does the fact there’s a housing crisis mean the OP has to tolerate anti social behaviour. They could have 4 kids in the flat and choose to act like decent people, but they aren’t.

As for the kids aren’t the preserve of the wealthy no they aren’t, But it is irresponsible to have more children than you can feasibly support. I always wanted 3 kids. I have 2. Because that was as many as I could comfortably support.

PinotViogner · 25/11/2023 18:51

Always lovely to see the "why have umpteen kids in the first place" lot are alive and kicking on this thread.

Newsflash: children are not a commodity that only the rich and privileged are entitled to. Nobody owes you an explanation for why they have children, how many they have, are choosing childfree etc That's not the issue here.

The use of the word "choose" in the title and ops admittance that she was more bothered by the woman's attitude than the noise itself tells me all i need to know here.

Chartreuse45 · 25/11/2023 18:47

I haven't read the thread nor do I have any legal knowledge about overcrowding etc, so I apologise if this has been said before or my data is incorrect.
Speak to the mother and calmly tell her that in the UK 6 people in a 2 bedroom flat is considered overcrowding and their landlord-tenant contract will be considered null and void. AFAIK and based on various reality TV shows about London housing the landlord will get into trouble if there's any suspicion that he knew.
However that you know finding a flat is hard and therefore you'd like to help them by not escalating the situation especially coming into winter, if she in return makes sure the children are less noisy. You have children yourself so you probably know some hints and tips.
Four young children and their belongings are easily noticed, possibly by neighbours or if any plumbing or heating problems need to fixed by the landlord. If the boiler breaks down they cannot live with no hot water or heating for days or weeks.

Blipeuy · 25/11/2023 18:47

NoSquirrels · 25/11/2023 18:43

Depends on what noise it is. The noises the OP describes being particularly bothered by are thuds, jumping/running etc. That would go away if they swapped flats. Shouting & squeaking wouldn’t, admittedly, but if you’re above a noisy flat it’s easier to soundproof the floor yourself so you hear less. And sometimes you get over sensitised to a particular type of noise (my upstairs neighbours clicky heels on bare floorboards, grr) whereas other noise you’re less bothered by (my downstairs neighbours’ toddler tantrums).

Maybe OP can’t or won’t swap - the flats might not be identical. But it’s at least a possibility if they both rent, and from the same LL, in a way it’s not if you own and you’re completely stuck.

The worst noises from an upstairs flat (for me): kitchen noise, loud cackling/screeching, musical instruments, door slamming.

From a downstairs flat:
Thumping, jumping and humping.

I guess it depends on what you find most annoying out of each list really.

NoSquirrels · 25/11/2023 18:43

Blipeuy · 25/11/2023 17:42

I personally wouldn't. Lower floor noise is far worse.

Depends on what noise it is. The noises the OP describes being particularly bothered by are thuds, jumping/running etc. That would go away if they swapped flats. Shouting & squeaking wouldn’t, admittedly, but if you’re above a noisy flat it’s easier to soundproof the floor yourself so you hear less. And sometimes you get over sensitised to a particular type of noise (my upstairs neighbours clicky heels on bare floorboards, grr) whereas other noise you’re less bothered by (my downstairs neighbours’ toddler tantrums).

Maybe OP can’t or won’t swap - the flats might not be identical. But it’s at least a possibility if they both rent, and from the same LL, in a way it’s not if you own and you’re completely stuck.

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 25/11/2023 18:40

BertieBotts · 25/11/2023 15:02

It's not the best thing ever to lie, but perhaps they found that they were being discriminated against, it's illegal for a landlord to advertise no children, but many of them have this as unofficial criteria all the same.

But surely it's not illegal for a landlord to not want 6 people living in a 2 bedroom flat. They presumably wouldn't rent to 6 adults, so it's not specifically a child issue.

(I know this is an issue generally, and obviously if a landlord won't rent a 2 bedroom flat to, for example, a couple and their one child, that's not ok)

Concannon88 · 25/11/2023 18:38

itsalongwaybackfromsorry · 25/11/2023 18:20

I don’t know what we can do other than move out ourselves, but with the housing crisis the way it is, it wouldn’t be easy. I feel angry that they lied to get the tenancy and moved the family in knowing that it would disturb us and make our lives difficult.

and that's why they lied: it's almost impossible for some people to find rental accommodation in the areas they need to be at prices they can afford.

I also note that you have a 'child' and they have 'kids'. Rather telling what you think of them... but please, go ahead an make their lives even harder than it probably already is. I'm sure they don't like living in an upstairs 2 bedroom flat with 4 children either and would much prefer more space and a private garden for them to play in.

Theres no pecking order when it comes to kids and child, they're interchangeable. It says more about what you assume other people are thinking.

She isnt making their lives harder, shes trying to make her familys comfortable. Its unfortunate they have ended up in a 2 bed, being a family of six. However her laughing about it and the fact she already knew they would be noisy to outsiders shows her lack of empathy for others, so why is it so many posters like yourself are offering them a wealth of empathy. I'm tempted to believe it's to fulfill a need to be the "underdogs hero" when in reality if you were faced with he same dilemma, you wouldnt be so empathic and willing to make excuses.

LaurieStrode · 25/11/2023 18:31

itsalongwaybackfromsorry · 25/11/2023 18:20

I don’t know what we can do other than move out ourselves, but with the housing crisis the way it is, it wouldn’t be easy. I feel angry that they lied to get the tenancy and moved the family in knowing that it would disturb us and make our lives difficult.

and that's why they lied: it's almost impossible for some people to find rental accommodation in the areas they need to be at prices they can afford.

I also note that you have a 'child' and they have 'kids'. Rather telling what you think of them... but please, go ahead an make their lives even harder than it probably already is. I'm sure they don't like living in an upstairs 2 bedroom flat with 4 children either and would much prefer more space and a private garden for them to play in.

Make their lives harder? FFS, they are the ones who chose to have umpteen kids they can't properly house, to move to an area where they can't afford proper housing, and to raise rambunctious, uncontrolled children, and instead of taking them to the park, allow them to jump and leap and scream inappropriately.

None of that is the OP's fault. She is the victim, they are the perps. Soooo fucking tired of shitty parents and their loud obnoxious offspring getting a total pass because "oooh, cost of living..." or "oooh, housing crisis." They wouldn't have a crisis if they had performed any prudent family planning, would they?

herewegoagain7 · 25/11/2023 18:27

You would soon become a nuisance caller if you called 101

JSMill · 25/11/2023 18:22

Also, Op my tenant used to bang their door when it got too much. It sometimes worked.

itsalongwaybackfromsorry · 25/11/2023 18:20

I don’t know what we can do other than move out ourselves, but with the housing crisis the way it is, it wouldn’t be easy. I feel angry that they lied to get the tenancy and moved the family in knowing that it would disturb us and make our lives difficult.

and that's why they lied: it's almost impossible for some people to find rental accommodation in the areas they need to be at prices they can afford.

I also note that you have a 'child' and they have 'kids'. Rather telling what you think of them... but please, go ahead an make their lives even harder than it probably already is. I'm sure they don't like living in an upstairs 2 bedroom flat with 4 children either and would much prefer more space and a private garden for them to play in.