Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell DH that MIL has got me a Christmas present i will have to get rid of?

282 replies

haribosmarties · 25/11/2023 14:48

Or does that seem ungrateful? Its only a low cost item. Should I just pretend to like it?
DH told me the ILs were asking about gifts for us so I told him a brand of toiletries I like of which you can buy various gift sets between a tenner and twenty quid.
I borrowed DH phone whilst we were out and as I was using it a txt message came in from MIL saying she had forgotten what he'd said and just bought a Dove body set for me and would that be ok?
I handed back the phone to my DH without mentioning seeing the message.
Issue is I have eczema and altho its not severe it does flair up with random things.. Dove shower cream, soap and body wash are amongst those things. Ive tried using them before.

So now I dont know whether just to pretend to like the gift when I open it or to tell my DH that I saw the text and its not suitable.
I know these seems like a petty issue but my relationship with MIL has never been great... I mean we've never actively fallen out... but basically she doesnt like me anyway I can tell, and we have very little to do with each other.. I get the sense she thinks I'm high maintenance.. saying something about this gift might add to that.
My DH won't have any advice, he'd probably just tell her to change the gift because interpersonal dynamics go over his head quite often unless people are actively shouting at each other. He also hasnt mentioned the text to me which makes me think he's just replied 'that's fine' and forgotten about it

YANBU= just tell your husband to answer the text saying its not ok and she should change it for something else

YABU = dont say anything. It doesnt really matter, just give it away to someone.

Yes I know I probably should have said something as soon as I saw the text but I just didn't. I struggle with being thought of as difficult so my first response to anything like that is to freeze and then think about it carefully.

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 25/11/2023 17:22

If it was high value make a fuss. But for a Dove set? Regift and suck it up. Not worth the agro.

NoraBattysCurlers · 25/11/2023 17:22

SwingTheMonkey · 25/11/2023 14:55

Just accept, say thank you and re gift it or donate it to charity/foodbank.

This. I wouldn't give it a second thought.

The only unreasonable thing is your need to write such a long post. It's not worth the headspace.

Hayliebells · 25/11/2023 17:16

Just accept, and then give it to a charity, a charity that wants toiletries for those who can't buy their own would be glad of it I'm sure. I really don't understand people to approach gift buying in this way. All this waste in unwanted presents. Just get something you KNOW a person will like, or don't get anything at all. All this gift giving out of obligation, exchanging random crap, I just don't get why people still do it.

Crikeyisthatthetime · 25/11/2023 17:14

wited · 25/11/2023 16:17

It's not that deep. Just tell your DH to tell her it's not one you can use, or smile and accept it.

It's every day household soap shit, not a £5000 diamond necklace.

It's not about the soap. It's about OPs relationship with her mil and she's worried about making it worse.
Because when relationships get a bit tense it can be hard not to worry about things that seem quite small on the surface.

TellySavalashairbrush · 25/11/2023 17:11

Definitely accept with thanks and give to the charity shop.

newtlover · 25/11/2023 17:10

@JaneAustensHeroine what is it????

sandyhappypeople · 25/11/2023 17:10

haribosmarties · 25/11/2023 16:43

@Autumnleavesss my DD also has eczema.. altho she could try it I guess.. these things don't always effect everyone the same. I think I will just keep it in its packet and donate it to a shelter as it could be a nice gift for someone struggling if its unopened and still in its fancy packaging

Personally, I would mention in passing to MIL IF it comes up naturally, that you hope what dH told her was okay, as you can only use certain brands of smellies because of your eczema, specifically the body shop ones, then it leaves the ball in her court as to whether she wants to change it or not, if she doesn’t then just say thank you and gift it on. I would try and put it out there though at some point because if they think you like it they’ll buy it forever because it’s ‘safe’.

sollenwir · 25/11/2023 17:07

@JaneAustensHeroine Have a box in the corner labelled 'foodbank' and as they hand said gift to you offer them the foodbank box instead.

JaneAustensHeroine · 25/11/2023 17:02

I empathise OP. Similar situation here. I have told parents in law many times to please not get me one specific thing as I can’t use it. Every year they buy it without fail and say “I know you told us not to get this for you but it’s just a bit of fun…”

It’s beyond my understanding. I feel like telling them outright that it will just go to charity / to the foodbank. It’s not fun for me.

They have bought it again this year apparently. It’s actually getting quite hard to be civil about it but not worth the aggro. I’ll just give them to the foodbank as I do every year.

Eleganz · 25/11/2023 16:59

Your DH can easily pretend that this is information that he knows about you in this instance and just reply "Oh no mum! Her eczema reacts badly to Dove, could you take it back an change it for xxx"

CuboidsAndSpheres · 25/11/2023 16:57

A dove gift set is an absolutely tragic present.

It's a supermarket brand. The body shop is the same stuff you put in your trolley.

Anyway, just accept it, regift. She's not going to be checking the bathroom for it if you don't see each other

CurlewKate · 25/11/2023 16:57

If that's the consensus I disagree with it. Tell dp. He tells his mum . She gets something else for you and gives the Dove to someone else.

Theduchy · 25/11/2023 16:55

Every year I get stuff I don't want or like from my in laws I.e. prosecco related gifts when I haven't drunk alcohol for years now but I just say thank you and it goes in the regift pile.

BashfulClam · 25/11/2023 16:54

The smell of Dove products makes me feel a bit sick. I have told my mum this several times but she always buys me a set. I just stick it in the foodbank donation trolley in Sainsbury’s.

fuckssaaaaake · 25/11/2023 16:52

rookiemere · 25/11/2023 14:53

The message was for your DH so I would let him handle it.
If you do get given the gift on Christmas day, I'd say something like "Oh it's so kind of you to think of me MIL, but unfortunately I get a rash with Dove. It's such a lovely set, can you find someone else to give it to ?"

Normally I'd suggest just sucking it up, but as you will be getting gifts for many more years then it's better in this instance not to do that.

No I would never do that on actually opening. That's quite cruel when the husband had chance to tell her so she will feel shit about it.

newtlover · 25/11/2023 16:52

OP you're getting conflicting replies because some PPs haven't read your OP properly.

All those with the 'donate to charity' or pass-agg suggestions have missed that MIL actually asks if the Dove gift is OK, so she is presumably open to the fact that it isn't. It's not like she's spent loads of money on it and can easily give to someone else or use it herself.

You should tell DP to reply- oh that's a kind thought but I do know that brand will make her eczema worse, and it can be so painful. She can use X brand or you could get her (cheap and foolproof suggestion)

there really is a serious danger of decades of Dove gifts otherwise

NewAgain123 · 25/11/2023 16:52

Why ask for toiletries when you have eczema and can only use specific stuff 🤦‍♀️

melj1213 · 25/11/2023 16:48

haribosmarties · 25/11/2023 15:07

@OhNoOhNo to be fair he woukd if I brought it up. But he's a man to whom all womens toiletries are the same thing so it probably didn't enter his head that it would be an issue

So why didn't you just say "DH, when I borrowed your phone earlier a text came in from your mum about my Christmas present. The brand she has suggested brings me out in a rash, do you want me to give you some other options to send back to her instead?"

That way you a) acknowledge that you saw the message and b) you can address the issue now.

I think as well, whilst you don't want to rock the boat it's better to rock it now than capsize it later - could you imagine your MILs AIBU "I have been buying my DIL Dove toiletries as part of her Christmas gift every year for the last X years as I never know what to buy her and this was suggested only to find out that she can't use them as she's allergic! She's been letting me waste my money for the last X years on stuff she knows she can't use and I feel bad that I haven't actually got her a present. AIBU to think she should have said something sooner so I could get something appropriate?"

neilyoungismyhero · 25/11/2023 16:47

Why can't you just tell your husband you saw her message and say what you've said on here? He can then advise her and she can keep the Dove items or give them to someone else and get you something more usable.

Whataretheodds · 25/11/2023 16:46

haribosmarties · 25/11/2023 14:59

Ok I think the general concensus is to just accept it then donate it. I know its a trivial issue I just overthink these things! I thought well ill just tell him, but then I thought maybe thats rude... so I asked for opinions on here.

I totally disagree with the consensus!
Presumably your OH was fine with you using his phone. I'd say "your mum texted to say XYZ. Do you want to let her know that Dove doesn't work for my skin and makes my eczema flare up, but ABC are fine? "

NovemberShiv · 25/11/2023 16:44

Keep for a raffle or tombola prize. I sympathise. Mine has form for this - buys a bouquet with lilies in for my sister in law KNOWING she's allergic...

haribosmarties · 25/11/2023 16:43

@Autumnleavesss my DD also has eczema.. altho she could try it I guess.. these things don't always effect everyone the same. I think I will just keep it in its packet and donate it to a shelter as it could be a nice gift for someone struggling if its unopened and still in its fancy packaging

OP posts:
sollenwir · 25/11/2023 16:42

I'm not sure tbh, if you don't say anything you might end up with one every year? Might be better to raise it now. Or if you don't really need the gift then just regift/donate (every year).

What is it with Dove stuff too?
I don't have Excema but it set's my itch levels off the scale!

Talktometellmeyourname · 25/11/2023 16:41

As Frustrating as it is, I’d would just keep quiet and give it away.
I do this with my mil every birthday and Christmas as she gives me things that are just useless to me and often repeated from previous years.

Ponderingwindow · 25/11/2023 16:41

My own DH would have texted back that product isn’t on my safe list . Then told her where she can buy an equivalent priced product that is safe. My allergies are severe though and that safe list is sacrosanct.

with your family dynamic, it’s probably a charity donation and a plan to treat yourself.